$422,355Average Value$188Average Price per Sq Ft2Homes For Sale
Marilla’s active, small-town community in the countryside
Set 20 miles east of Buffalo, Marilla is a small town offering an escape from the urban hustle. “A lot of working families want to get out of the city,” says Helen Bourgeois, a resident of over 50 years. The town is primarily farmland, with acres of corn and soy, bright pumpkin patches and cows roaming the meadows. Shopping and dining are limited, with most businesses set within the hamlet of the same name. Community events, like Ag Day, and the historic Marilla Country Store are tourist draws. “We get so many people from out of town coming to see what we’re all about,” Bourgeois says. “We try to be an active town and get people involved.”
Marilla is a quiet but charming New York town.
Marilla has manufactured home communities for more affordable options.
1/2
Wide range of housing styles in a fast-moving market
Marilla’s housing ranges widely, with single-family homes built from the mid-19th century to today. “We have a lot of older homes, and usually the lots are three-fourths of an acre or more,” Bourgeois says. No two houses are alike. In the hamlet, historic farmhouses and Colonial Revivals stand beside late 20th-century ranch and split-level homes. Many share rustic features, like painted wood siding, covered porches and exposed wooden beams, contributing to the town’s rural charm. Lawns are shaded by mature trees and dotted with traditional mailboxes, while cars are often tucked into detached garages.
Outside the hamlet, 21st-century custom-built homes sit along quiet country roads, offering privacy, pastoral views and acreage with the occasional outbuilding such as a workshop or stables. Single-family homes typically sell for $200,000 to $500,000, while custom builds or larger estates range from $500,000 to $840,000, depending on size and amenities. Marilla also has a few manufactured home communities, including the 55-plus Marilla Country Village. Most units date to the late 20th century and feature attached carports and vinyl siding. These homes are listed between $15,000 and $90,000. Homes in Marilla spend an average of 25 days on the market, faster than the national average of 53 days.
Single-family homes in Marilla sell between $200,000 and $500,000.
Historic Colonial Revivals can be found near downtown Marilla.
1/2
Marilla schools offer dual-enrollment credit at nearby universities
Marilla is part of multiple school districts, including the Iroquois Central School District, which is rated B overall by Niche. Marilla Primary teaches prekindergarten through fourth grade and earns a B. Students can move on to Iroquois Intermediate for fifth grade before attending Iroquois Middle and Iroquois High — all are rated B. The latter offers dual-enrollment courses for credit at Syracuse University, Niagara University and SUNY Erie.
Iroquois Middle School is a well rated public school in Elma, NY with about 473 students.
Iroquois High School is a well rated public school in Elma with a student teacher ratio of 11-1.
1/2
Fishing, picnicking at Marilla Town Park
Marilla Memorial Park is the pocket-sized go-to for a picnic, featuring a gazebo and the Marilla Veterans Memorial. Nearby, the 1-mile Creation Walk Nature Trail provides a scenic escape into nature with tree-lined views and the gentle sounds of Little Buffalo Creek. Marilla Town Park offers a larger setting for a day out, with a basketball court, picnic pavilions with grills and playing fields. “It’s a nice, big town park,” Bourgeois says. “There’s a pond for kids to go fishing … small playgrounds — it’s country.” Other highlights include Wood Spring Club, a family-friendly campsite with kayaks available to rent, and the public 18-hole Elma Meadows Golf Course, 5 miles away.
Marilla Town Park is a couple miles outside of the village.
Creation Walk Nature Trail is a great place to enjoy the fresh air.
1/2
Farm-fresh groceries, Eggs Marilla and old-fashioned sweets
Marilla’s rural setting means residents can buy groceries straight from local farms. “There are a lot of farmstands around with corn, tomatoes, beans, squash — all types of vegetables,” Bourgeois says. Horizon Ridge Farms operates a farm store/restaurant with fresh produce, butcher cuts and desserts like blueberry coffee cake. Another town favorite, The Farmer’s Daughters’ Diner, serves classic breakfast fare, including Eggs Marilla — hash browns topped with poached eggs and a special sauce.
The 170-year-old Marilla Country Store sells everything from birdhouses and bracelets to souvenir soaps and snow globes. Alongside a modest grocery section and deli counter, the store’s best known for its old-fashioned sweets, such as raspberry jelly sticks and French silk truffles. For dinner or drinks, Barn Dog Distillery is a popular spot featuring craft cocktails, pulled pork sandwiches and occasional live music. Seven miles away, Alden provides additional shopping and dining options, including a Tops.
The Farmer's Daughters' Diner has a special dish named after the town, Eggs Marilla.
Alden Bakery & Café, located near Marilla, serves fresh baked goods and coffee in a charming interior.
1/2
Ag Day, concerts and Christmas in Marilla
Marilla has an active events calendar. The Marilla Gazebo Summer Concert Series kicks off in June, where residents set up chairs and coolers and enjoy live music, including jazz and country. In September, Ag Day celebrates the town’s agricultural roots with food, games and a tractor parade. “We had 150 tractors — big and small,” Bourgeois says. “Little kids drove their toy tractors … it was great.” Christmas in Marilla celebrates the holiday season with everything from caroling and cider to hay rides and hot chocolate. “We have Santa Claus come, and I’m Mrs. Claus,” Bourgeois says. “Kids make cards for the soldiers, cookies and all kinds of games.”
Car-dependent community 20 miles from Buffalo
While some parts of the hamlet are sidewalk-lined, residents typically drive to get around town. State Route 354 provides connecting access to Buffalo. Buffalo Niagara International Airport is 15 miles away, and the ECMC Health Campus is a 22-mile drive.
Marilla is located about 20 miles east of Buffalo.
The Buffalo Niagara International Airport is about 15 miles away from Marilla.
1/2
Written By
Travis Rocha
Photography Contributed By
Jacob Branchaud
Video By
Kyo Nguyen
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Shannon Sherman,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Marilla, NY sell after 15 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Marilla, NY over the last 12 months is $370,000, up 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Affordable living just 5 minutes from the highly desirable Village of East Aurora and located in the top-rated Iroquois School District! This 2-bedroom mobile home offers a great opportunity to add your own updates and personal touches while enjoying a convenient location. This home features 2 bedrooms, baseboard heat, durable metal roof, aluminum siding, 100-amp electrical service, and a
Nestled on 16.26 beautiful acres, this spacious ranch offers the privacy, tranquility & outdoor lifestyle you've been searching for! Enjoy a beautiful backyard overlooking your own pond, while the wooded acreage beyond is ideal for hunting, hiking, ATV trails & exploring nature right outside your door. Inside, you'll find a home filled with character & opportunity. The spacious family room (25' x
MUST SEE!!! SPACIOUS & beautifully appointed farmhouse colonial comfortably set on 2.23 gorgeous acres in the Town of Marilla; move-in ready with highly rated Iroquois schools & captivating countryside views with incredible privacy. Step through the elegant covered front door entryway and into the cozy formal living room with a built-in wood stove insert with brick surround and Bamboo hardwood
Very nice 1.5 acre building lot in the wonderful town of Marilla, this lot has a slight slope that could be ideal for building your dream home, use the slope for excellent drainage and the possibility of not needing a sump pump and perfect for a walk out basement with numerous possibilities, great views and no close neighbors offers generous privacy, electric/gas/water/internet/telephone and
Build your dream home on this beautiful 1.6 acre building lot in the Town of Marilla! Offering approximately 225' of road frontage and 311' of depth (per tax records), this spacious parcel provides the perfect setting for your custom home with plenty of room for a garage, outdoor living space, gardens or more. Located within the highly desirable Iroquois Central School District, you'll enjoy the
2 Acres on Buffalo Creek!Discover the possibilities with this spacious 4-bedroom, 2-full-bath home nestled on approximately 2 acres along Buffalo Creek. Offering over 2,800 square feet, this property features a dynamite-sized great room with a wood-burning stove and windows galore, bringing in beautiful views of the picturesque grounds.The layout offers two bedrooms on the first floor and
Sitting on over four acres of picturesque property, this wonderful home offers an incredible amount of living space, inside & out. With multiple gathering areas, four bedrooms & a barn ready for all the extras, there is room here to truly spread out.Inside, the open-concept living & dining area creates a bright, welcoming space for everyday life with cathedral ceilings and skylights,
Welcome to 11411 Stolle Road, an exceptional 10-acre private estate offering space, privacy, efficiency and resort-style amenities just outside East Aurora. Built in 2003, this distinctive 5-bedroom, 6-bath home offers 5,434 sq. ft. and was operated by a previous owner as a B&B for more than 20 years.At the heart of the home is a chef's dream kitchen with a large walk-in pantry. Generous
Welcome home to this recently updated property, offering spacious rooms, thoughtful updates, and plenty of versatility! Step inside to a generously sized mudroom complete with laundry, providing the perfect spot to keep everyday life organized.The main level features a lovely kitchen with an adjoining bedroom that could also make an ideal home office or flex space. A large bathroom boasts
Welcome to this well-maintained, move-in ready 2-bedroom, 1-bath manufactured home, ideally located in the Alden School District! This home offers a comfortable and functional open-concept layout with a bright, spacious living room that provides plenty of room to relax and entertain. The living area flows nicely into the kitchen and dining space, creating an inviting atmosphere and making the
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
