$817,379Average Value$325Average Price per Sq Ft15Homes For Sale
A lakeside community
Middleton Coastline is a popular neighborhood on the western banks of Wisconsin’s Lake Mendota. “The people here really enjoy being outside, especially in the summer,” says Realtor Laura Callahan of First Weber Real Estate. “Recreation on the lake is huge in the area. Boating, fishing — if it’s on the water, people want to do it.” With excellent schools, a good deal of local shops and restaurants, and a convenient 6-mile commute to downtown Madison, it’s clear why the neighborhood’s housing market is highly competitive.
A mixed bag of home sizes and styles
Prices and housing styles vary greatly on the coastline. Single-family homes in a variety of architectural styles typically range from $300,000 to more than $5 million, with waterfront properties generally starting around the $725,000 mark. Condos are also available from around $150,000 to $750,000, some with amenities like boat piers and kayak racks. Mature trees flank most neighborhood streets, making lots feel secluded. Detached homes feature spacious yards, and homes on the lake have dock access. The market is competitive in this neighborhood, according to Melissa LeGrand, Owner-Broker of LeGrand Real Estate. “There’s been very limited inventory on the lake — I would say in the last two years, there’s only been a handful of properties that have changed hands,” says LeGrand. “I think it’s aspirational to get on the water, and once people are out there, they tend not to leave — they tend to do remodels and things like that. There was one that sold for $1.5 million last year, and it was a complete teardown, so people will pay whatever they have to to get on the water.”
Lake access for all and plenty of neighborhood parks
There is no shortage of recreation in the neighborhood. One spot from which to get on the lake is Marshall Park there’s a public boat ramp, and the park also provides boat and kayak rentals. Volleyball is a popular activity with the adults, and kids love making sandcastles at the small beach. On the neighborhood’s north end, Mendota County Park offers a campground and outdoor basketball courts. For tennis and soccer, Lakeview Park is the spot to go. The park also offers three playgrounds and a splash pad for children, along with a stocked pond with fishing piers. Golfers can hit Bishops Bay Country Club for 18 holes, and during the winter months, residents can use Harbor Athletic Club for indoor workouts.
Great shopping and dining options close to home
Middleton Coastline is home to several local restaurants just minutes from home. Mid Town Pub is a great local spot to become a regular for a Friday fish fry or happy hour specials any day of the week. For a morning pick-me-up, Scooters Coffee gets residents going with hot and cold coffee drinks, smoothies and more. All the necessities can be acquired at various retailers within about 3 miles of home. For groceries, Willy Street Co-Op provides local specialties, while Metro Market has homeowners covered for a more expansive shop to stock up for the week ahead. Anything needed for the home can be found at the nearby Target, and shoppers will love the multitude of stores, from boutiques to national chains, at Greenway Station.
Highly-rated local schools
Most students in the neighborhood attend schools in the Middleton-Cross Plains Area School District, which earns an A-plus grade from Niche. Students often start at Northside Elementary School, graded A by Niche, before heading on to Kromrey Middle School, also graded A, and Middleton High School, graded A-plus. Middleton High was ranked the top public school in Madison and in the top 10 among all Wisconsin schools by U.S. News and World Report in 2024.
Getting around the greater area
Most Middleton Coastline residents will need a car to get around the greater area, as public transportation in the area is limited to bus stops along Century Ave. Getting to downtown Middleton is a matter of minutes, and downtown Madison is an easy drive of about 6 miles along University Ave. The Dane County Regional Airport is within about 12 miles of home.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Middleton Coastline neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Middleton Coastline
US
Homicide
4
4
Sexual Assault
3
4
Assault with Weapon
3
4
Robbery
2
4
Burglary
4
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
4
4
Larceny
4
4
Crime Score
3
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Middleton Coastline Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Middleton Coastline, Middleton sell after 42 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Middleton Coastline, Middleton over the last 12 months is $463,250, down 21% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Beautiful ranch home in a quiet neighborhood in the highly desirable Middleton School District. Great location just a short walk from Lake Mendota, local parks, and Pheasant Branch Trails. Conveniently located near restaurants, local shopping, and athletic club. Main level features kitchen with breakfast bar and pantry, a spacious great room with pass-through to kitchen and dinette. Basement
Waunakee Schools with Middleton Convenience! Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac in highly sought-after Fox Bluff, this beautiful home offers privacy, space, and an unbeatable location. Surrounded by mature trees and tons of green space, the property sits on a huge lot just outside of town. Residents of the Town of Westport enjoy notably lower property taxes while benefiting from an A+ location
Recent Price Reduction! Enjoy affordable, low-maintenance living just minutes from Lake Mendota, parks, beaches, the bus line, UW–Madison, and downtown Madison. This updated multi-level condo features vinyl wood plank flooring, a refreshed full bath, and a functional layout with lower-level bedrooms for added privacy. Multiple patio doors flood the home with natural light while overlooking mature
Lake Mendota and Middleton Schools! Breathtaking lake views paired with an unbeatable location. Expansive windows showcase pristine Lake Mendota frontage and fill the home with natural light. Well appointed house with numerous updates. Updated kitchen w/Wolf range, walnut island, marble counter tops and walk in pantry. Beautiful white oak flooring and impressive two story great room. Private
Set on nearly an acre of wooded privacy in Fox Bluff, this thoughtfully renovated home blends timeless design with exceptional everyday livability. A beautifully remodeled kitchen anchors the main level with custom Denise Quade cabinetry, Sub-Zero/Wolf/Cove appliances, updated laundry, and a gas fireplace that connects seamlessly to the inviting family room with wet bar. Formal living and dining
0.995 Acre Infill Development Site 230 feet along University Avenue +/- 50 Units On the busline Highly Desirable Middleton Location Low Vacancy Rates Residential dwelling on property is being sold "as is where is" and the Seller makes no representation as to habitability or warrants any condition.
One-bedroom condo with an attached one car garage, outside private patio and private main entrance. This condo is centrally located to restaurant's, Coffee Shop, Fitness center, Hardware Store, Pheasant Branch Trail, and Lake Mendota. This end unit condo offers an open floor plan with the kitchen, living room, dining area all overlooking the private patio. nice size bedroom with a large closet,
Nestled on 1.30 acres in the gated lake-side community of Bishops Woods w/ golf cart access to Bishops Bay Country Club, this exceptional home blends luxury, comfort & resort-style living. A dramatic 2-story foyer opens to a stunning great room w/ floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace & wall of windows overlooking the beautifully landscaped yard. The remodeled gourmet kitchen features Wolf appliances,
LOT 333: This homesite is located in The Prairie Estates Neighborhood in The Community of Bishops Bay. The lot backs to the Dane County North Mendota Wildlife Area & Prairie, with the front of the lot providing golf course views of Hole 7 on The Bishops Bay Country Club Golf Course. An exceptional large lot at .72 acres with a tremendous amount of green space, the lot offers many home design
Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 1-bath condo in an unbeatable Middleton location. The refreshed kitchen features quartz countertops, white cabinetry and stainless steel appliances, flowing seamlessly into a bright and comfortable living space. Enjoy a quiet, private setting from your balcony that feels like you’re nestled in the trees, perfect for morning coffee or evening
LOT 298: This homesite is available in the second phase of The Prairie Estates Neighborhood in The Community of Bishops Bay. The lot backs to holes 7 and 8 on The Bishops Bay Country Club Golf Course and has beautiful views west across the course to The Woods Neighborhood. The front of the lot faces the Holy Wisdom Monastery Prairie Restoration area and woodlands. At 1.30 acres, the lot offers
Cozy first floor 2bd/1bth garden condo features a easy access to downtown Middleton, beautiful cottonwood filled green space, and a patio view of Lake Mendota! Complex just had all roofs replaced! Condo fee includes heat, water/sewer, and hot water! Affordable and convenient, this cute condo is waiting for you.
Lake where you live.Welcome to Allen Bay, located just steps from Lake Mendota. Two intimate 31-residence buildings offer thoughtfully designed one-bedroom apartments, spacious two-bedrooms, and elegant three-bedroom townhomes. Gather with friends in the inviting club room, stay active in the fully equipped fitness center, and unwind on the lakeview deck. Step outside to parks,
If you’re looking for an apartment with high-end amenities, top-notch finishes, and creative floorplans and designs, look no further than Cariad. These luxury apartment homes feature floor to ceiling windows, private balconies, and views that bring a smile to your face no matter the time of year with many views of Marshall Park and Lake Mendota. And that’s just for starters. Add quartz
Welcome to Springtree Apartments, a gem nestled in the heart of Middleton, WI. Our apartments offer a variety of deluxe options, including one, two, and three-bedroom units, each designed with your comfort in mind. Enjoy the stunning courtyard view from your new windows, or step out onto your private ST balcony or patio door to soak in the serene surroundings. Each apartment is equipped with a
Welcome to Middleton Shores Apartments, where convenience, comfort, and outdoor living come together in the heart of Middleton.Located at Allen Boulevard and Century Avenue, our community offers quick access to Madison, major commuting routes, restaurants, shopping, fitness centers, and everyday essentials. With three classic buildings and one modern addition, Middleton Shores features a
Smoke Free Apartments Overlook Pointe, perfectly situated in the Middleton Neighborhood. In our community, Pheasant Branch Conservancy, local parks, beaches, bicycle and hiking trails. Downtown Middleton offers cafes, farmers markets, and locally owned shops. You will find our apartments a short distance from the cultural centers of Madison. Choose from a variety of spacious floor
Nestled in a peaceful residential neighborhood, away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life, Middleton Lakeview Apartments are steps from Marshall Park, Lake Mendota, Lakeview Park, and tons of bike and walking paths. Hop on University and you’ll be in downtown Madison in a short 10 minutes. These apartments are perfect for families with two and three bedroom layouts in a wonderful
Discover your new apartment home at Heritage Middleton, for seniors 55 and better! Located at 6206 Maywood Ave in Middleton!Give us a call today to schedule your tour!
Nice remodeled one bedroom apartment with a beautiful view of Lake Mendota and a nice yard to barbeque in. ALL UTILITIES INCLUDED. FREE PARKING. Available August 1.
Rent this spacious 4 bedroom house in Middleton, located off of University Avenue near Allen Boulevard, offering quick access to the Beltline and downtown Madison.This home opens with a bright living room featuring hardwood floors. This leads to a dining room with a walkout to the back deck and a fully equipped kitchen with a breakfast bar off the back. A half bath is also on the
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
