$297,831Average Value$183Average Price per Sq Ft3Homes For Sale
A small town with easy access to nature
As one of the many well-established Cumberland County boroughs near Carlile, Mount Holly Springs is a notoriously rural area with lots of lakes and trails that provide plenty of outdoor recreation. Residents can enjoy the area's natural beauty without living too far from retail amenities. “It’s a good place to be, especially if you love that small-town feel. You end up getting to personally know a lot of people,” says Ysmaine Dominiciano, a Realtor with EXP Realty who has 8 years of experience and lives in the area.
Mt. Holly Springs is home to many architectural styles.
Single family homes are plentiful in Mt. Holly Springs.
1/2
Victorians and modest ranches
Most properties in Mount Holly Springs are conveniently priced with a good amount of space. Brightly colored townhouses with three bedrooms and 1,500 to 2,000 square feet can be found for anywhere between $140,000 to $210,000. Since a lot of the homes are older, it’s easy to find Victorian-styled houses with large front porches on the market too. For those who want something smaller, ranch-style homes go for $65,000 to $135,000. Most of these properties are located close to South Baltimore Avenue since it cuts through the neighborhood.
You'll find several architectural styles throughout Mt. Holly Springs.
Single family homes line the streets of Mt. Holly Springs.
1/2
Miles of wooded trails
Mount Holly Springs is perfectly located for its residents to enjoy outdoor recreational activities. “The neighborhood as a whole is a very wooded area surrounded by nature,” Dominiciano says. Mount Holly Marsh Preserve is a little outside the neighborhood but has roughly 900 acres of forestry and marshes for people to explore. Visitors can admire the area's beauty along six different hiking trails, go hunting or fish along Mountain Creek. For something more traditional, Tichy Park is an open green space on East Street with a playground for little ones to climb on. Residents can also enjoy the park amenities of Mount Holly Park and Trine Park, with their basketball courts and enclosed dog parks.
Walk along the creek at Mount Holly Springs Park in Mt. Holly Springs.
Enjoy the fresh air at Titchy Park in Mt. Holly Springs.
1/2
Small-town eateries and and old fashioned candy store
When residents of Mount Holly Springs want to go shopping, there are plenty of options along South Baltimore Avenue – the town’s main road. They can browse the many clothing stores like GreenLife thrift store, or treat themselves to some freeze-dried sweets at Deibler Family Adventures candy store. There’s also a Dollar General for daily essentials. When residents are hungry, there are a few local joints where they can grab a bite to eat. Cassells Grille is a typical bar scene with burgers, though their prime rib is also a favorite. For something more casual, Italian Taxi serves pasta dishes, subs and pizza slices. Residents often travel outside the neighborhood to explore options in nearby towns – a trip to Boiling Springs can take them to Karns Foods for groceries. “Carlile is the next bigger city nearby when people need a franchise like Walmart,” Dominiciano says.
Satisfy hunger cravings at Italian Taxi in Mt. Holly Springs.
Shop fresh at Karns in Mt. Holly Springs.
1/2
A highly rated public high school
Families living in Mount Holly Springs have a few schools they can send their children to for their education. Mount Holly Springs Elementary School may have a C-plus grade on Niche, but it’s in the neighborhood and has multiple reading initiatives. Yellow Breeches Middle School has a B Niche grade and maintains above-average test scores. From there, students can attend Boiling Springs High School. Rated No. 5 in Best Public High Schools in Cumberland County by Niche, the school boasts a B grade and has high athletic participation among its students.
Staff at Boiling Springs High School want to create the best environment they can for students.
School Sign
1/2
Drive to work or walk to local shops
Since Mount Holly Springs is a mostly rural area, residents depend on their own vehicles to get around. However, everything along South Baltimore Avenue is close to each other. “It can be considered walkable since the town is so small,” Dominiciano says. “If you live close to Main Street, you may be able to walk to the shops and restaurants. Otherwise, though, people drive.” Despite the train tracks crisscrossing throughout the neighborhood, there is no form of public transportation close by.
Mt. Holly Springs is a charming little neighborhood.
The streets of Mt. Holly Springs are lined with historic homes.
1/2
Written By
Brittany Bell
Photography Contributed By
Danny Lambert
Video By
Brandon Flash Craigie
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Katie Howard,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Mount Holly Springs, PA sell after 25 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Mount Holly Springs, PA over the last 12 months is $282,000, up 3% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Discover the charm of this beautifully renovated ranch-style home in the desirable Pine Road Heights neighborhood. With a major renovation completed in 2026, this residence seamlessly blends modern comforts with classic appeal. The sturdy brick exterior exudes timeless elegance, while the spacious 0.38-acre lot offers ample outdoor space for relaxation and recreation. Step inside to find a
Here is your chance to own nearly 10 acres of wooded land located along Route 94 in South Middleton Township. Located just minutes from Downtown Mt. Holly with endless recreational opportunities provided nearby in Pine Grove Furnace State Park, State Game Lands, the Mountain Creek, and the Appalachian Trail. Ample road frontage making the property very accessible. Enjoy hunting and timbering on
This 15 acre property offers 1 story living in a mountainous setting on a macadamed private lane. 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, open floor plan, 9 foot ceilings, new flooring,fresh paint, stainless steel appliances, gas fireplace, 2 car attached garage, plenty of closet space, pull down steps to attic for additional storage. Covered deck off the living room enjoy outside entertainment in any weather.
Located in the heart of Mount Holly Springs, across from Trine Park, this 3 bedroom home offers comfort, convenience, and outdoor enjoyment.Step inside and you'll find a functional layout for everyday living, including the convenience of main level laundry. Recent updates include newer roof, furnace, and hot water heater. Outside you can enjoy your own backyard retreat featuring an
Christine LindemulderIron Valley Real Estate of Central PA
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
