$404,173Average Value$167Average Price per Sq Ft72Homes For Sale
New Palestine offers one-stoplight living 30 minutes from Indianapolis
New Palestine might be Indiana’s best-kept secret. Set among the midwestern state's checkerboard of green farmland, the small, one-stop-light town doesn’t seem like it would be less than 30 minutes outside Indianapolis. “Although you’re out of the hustle and bustle of the city, you’re still relatively close,” says Realtor Vickie Jordan of Home Bound Real Estate. “But the rural feel and close-knit community draws people to New Palestine the most.”
Well-built, beautiful homes line the streets of New Palestine.
Some attractive artwork found along the streets of New Palestine.
1/2
Historic and custom homes fill the housing spectrum in New Pal
Established in 1871, New Palestine – shortened to New Pal by residents – is a growing town that offers an amalgam of home styles, from historic to new. “The unique thing about New Palestine is that we’ve got a diverse community and a plethora of home styles,” Jordan says. “It’s not one-size-fits-all. We have 100-year-old historic homes that line the streets of downtown, one-million-dollar custom homes, and new construction.” It’s normal to see a 1970s rancher, a traditional farmhouse and a recently built contemporary Craftsman on the same street. The median listing price of real estate hovers at $363,500, with three to four bedrooms and two to three bathrooms common, and Jordan says that the property values in New Palestine stay consistent relative to other communities. “The property values out here tend to be a little bit higher than the surrounding areas, but you’re paying for the out-of-the-city community, great schools, and the amenities that come along with that,” she says.
An example of a beautifully restored home found in New Palestine.
New Palestine residents take great pride in the style and design of their homes.
1/2
Highly rated schools draw students from all over Hancock County
Students in New Palestine attend top-rated schools in the Southern Hancock County Community School Corporation, which received an A rating from the Indiana Department of Education. “Many families move here for the top tier school system and the top tier sports programs,” Jordan says. With a campus off Main Street, centrally located New Palestine High School has a flourishing athletics program that is a big part of the community. The school isn’t limited to freshmen through seniors living in New Palestine. Instead, it pulls students from all over Hancock County, making its student body of 1,200 almost half the size of the town’s population itself. Parents can also enroll their kindergarteners through fourth graders in Brandywine Elementary School, while New Palestine Intermediate School serves fifth and sixth graders. Both schools boast an A- overall rating from Niche. At New Palestine Junior High School, seventh and eighth grade students can participate in the school’s award-winning robotics team.
New Palestine Intermediate School serves fifth and sixth grade students in the New Palestine community.
New Palestine Elementary School serves students in the New Palestine community.
1/2
Sugar Creek Township Park features playing fields and walking trails
For a day of outdoor fun, residents take to the recreational facilities at Sugar Creek Township Park. The 88-acre tract features soccer fields, playgrounds, and a nine-hole disc golf course. Jordan says the park’s walking trails and the Pennsy Trail, which cuts through the north side of the town, is a popular place for folks to get some fresh air and take walks with their kids and pets.
Sugar Creek Park is located in the heart of New Palestine.
Sugar Creek Tmp Park in New Palestine is an 88-acre park with soccer fields and a dog park.
1/2
Seasonal events include summertime concerts and holiday happenings
The close-knit feel of the community is exemplified during events and festivals that bring residents together in every season. Most notable is the New Pal Summer Fest, a weekend celebration involving live music, food and vendors, and a 5k race. Enjoy local tunes during the town’s Music on Depot summer concert series every fourth Saturday from July to September, usher in the autumn season at the Harvest Fest in October and get in the holiday spirit for the annual Christmas parade and Winter Fest.
Coffee, ice cream and fast-food favorites round out the dining scene
When it comes to the local dining scene, residents have plenty of tantalizing options. “The new coffee shop called Barrel Racing Baristas is very popular,” Jordan says, adding that a few newer spots display the town’s growth and revitalization. “We’re not just growing in homes, but also in business and opportunities.” But there’s one local staple that takes the spotlight. “You can’t come to New Pal and not try Frosty Boy,” Jordan says of the walk-up ice cream stand on Main Street. With an extensive menu of sweets and more, the beloved drive-in serves up soft serve, slushes and sundaes, as well as an array of fast-food favorites, like cheeseburgers and hot dogs.
Even with its steady growth, the relaxed rural haven preserves its small-town charm. “New Pal just has that hometown feel that draws people in,” Jordan says.
New Palestine residents have plenty of seating at Barrel Racing Baristas.
Barrel Racing Baristas in New Palestine has quality artisan coffee and hand scooped ice cream.
1/2
Written By
Christina von Claparede-Crola
Photography Contributed By
Mark Chenoweth
Video By
Syd Silberman
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Stephen Geyer,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in New Palestine, IN sell after 52 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in New Palestine, IN over the last 12 months is $390,000, up 3% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
BIG and SPACIOUS!!! Welcome home to over 3,600 square feet of thoughtfully designed living in sought-after Schildmeier Village. This updated traditional home features 4 bedrooms, including a main-level primary suite, cathedral ceilings, dedicated office, bonus room, updated kitchen with hard-surface countertops and stainless steel appliances, UPGRADED luxury vinyl plank flooring, plus a beautiful
BEAUTIFUL ALL Brick 2 Sty Hm in Fox Cove which is known for its Gorgeous Custom Blt Upscale Homes on Generously Sized Yards! 2,882 SF (all Usable Space/NO kneewalls or lowsided walls)! PLUS there's a Large Unfin. Area to the Left of the Upper Game Rm which could be Floored/Standard Door Installed for Additional STORAGE Space (See Floorplans in Kitchen)! 3Car Sideload Garage which is 22'4" deep &
D.R. Horton, America's Builder presents the Cortland: a 2,278 square foot, single-story home featuring a desirable, sought-after open layout, 4 bedrooms, 3 baths and oversized 2.5 car side load garage. The spacious great room is open to the kitchen, which is the literal heart of this home. The Cortland's kitchen features white, 42" upper white cabinets for plenty of storage, spacious quartz
Looking for the space of a new-construction home without the wait? This beautifully upgraded 2021 Copperstone home offers 2,859 square feet, 5 bedrooms (or 4-bedroom plus main-level office), upstairs loft, a main-level office/flex room, and an exceptional 660-square-foot insulated garage with workshop space. Situated on one of the larger homesites in the community, this move-in-ready home
BIG and SPACIOUS!!! Welcome home to over 3,600 square feet of thoughtfully designed living in sought-after Schildmeier Village. This updated traditional home features 4 bedrooms, including a main-level primary suite, cathedral ceilings, dedicated office, bonus room, updated kitchen with hard-surface countertops and stainless steel appliances, UPGRADED luxury vinyl plank flooring, plus a beautiful
Discover one of southwest Hancock County's most unique building opportunities! Located just two miles east of New Palestine, Heron Trail offers 5.6 scenic acres of gently rolling farmland currently in crop production. Tucked approximately 700-800 feet from the road, the property borders the Columbus-Jackson Ditch, where mature woods create a private, picturesque setting for your dream home.
Welcome to this beautifully maintained 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom home in the highly desirable Copperstone community of New Palestine! Built in 2023, this spacious 2,760 sq. ft. home offers a thoughtfully designed floor plan with modern finishes and plenty of room for comfortable living. The main level features an open-concept layout with a bright great room, a stylish kitchen with a center island,
Are you looking to built your custom dream house . This spacious lot of 1.53 acre offers limitless potential for your development. Soil testing done. Septic identified . Located within 1 mile to restaurants, gas station and school. Financing available
Welcome home to The Harrison, a floorplan by Silverthorne Homes. Included in your new home are four bedrooms, two-and-a-half bathrooms, and many options to find the best fit for you and your family. Partial and full basements are an upgrade option with The Harrison.As you step into The Harrison, you are met with an open flex room that can be transformed into a study. An optional bedroom can
Welcome to this thoughtfully designed Eisenhower floor plan, offering convenient single-level living, open concept gathering spaces, and stylish finishes in the desirable Willow Ridge community. Located just minutes from I-465, U.S. 52, and other major roadways, Willow Ridge provides an excellent balance of suburban comfort and accessibility, making commutes to Indianapolis simple and efficient.
Starting at 2,600 square feet, The Arthur is built to please! This Silverthorne Homes floorplan is an excellent option for anyone looking to have a place to retreat to after an evening of fun with friends or family. This four bedroom and two-and-a-half bathroom floorplan with options to add an in-law suite and fifth bedroom is made to easily grow with you if needed.Choose from one of the many
Welcome home to The Eisenhower, an open floor concept ranch home by Silverthorne Homes. This three bedroom and two full bathroom home is perfect for anyone looking to downsize. An optional second floor bonus room or basement can give you extra living space if one floor is not enough.Stepping into the entry of The Eisenhower, notice the 9 ceilings and two bedrooms off the entryway. A full bathroom
BEAUTIFUL ALL Brick 2 Sty Hm in Fox Cove which is known for its Gorgeous Custom Blt Upscale Homes on Generously Sized Yards! 2,882 SF (all Usable Space/NO kneewalls or lowsided walls)! PLUS there's a Large Unfin. Area to the Left of the Upper Game Rm which could be Floored/Standard Door Installed for Additional STORAGE Space (See Floorplans in Kitchen)! 3Car Sideload Garage which is 22'4" deep &
Sprawling 4 bedroom 2.5 Bath located in charming New Palestine. A soaring 2 story entry greets you when you enter this newly renovated home. Attention to detail at every turn. Downstairs offers a gorgeous custom office setup with convenient shelving and built in wall safe. Half bath welcomes guests with it charming colors and updated finishes. Super spacious family room with a double-sided
D.R. Horton, proudly known as America’s Builder, introduces the Dayton at Fields at Sugar Creek—a masterpiece of size and style. Spanning an impressive 3,388 square feet, this 5-bedroom home offers open-concept living with an expansive great room, casual dining space, and a well-appointed kitchen. The kitchen boasts a spacious center island, ample countertops, and cabinets, plus a generous
Property Id: 1489940 Welcome home to this charming 3 bed, 2 bath single-family property in New Palestine! Built in 2014, this home is open concept with eat in kitchen, living room, and dining room including a dishwasher, fireplace, and back deck with a great view of the pond. With a spacious back yard, 3 car garage, and washer/dryer hookups, you can call this HOME! Offered at $2500/month
This home is professionally managed by Tricon, dedicated to creating exceptional rental experiences. Featuring 5 bedrooms, 3.0 bathrooms, and approximately 2,736 square feet, this well-maintained home offers a high standard of rental living, supported by a team that puts residents first. As a Tricon resident, you'll enjoy access to Tricon Vantage — a program designed to support your rental
Apply now or schedule your self-tour today and take the first step toward getting more than just a place to live. Rent with FirstKey Homes for a home that's right for you, plus professional service and maintenance, innovative resident programs, and more; that's the power of purple! This 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom rental home in New Palestine, IN, has a lot to offer; does it check all your
Apply now or schedule your self-tour today and take the first step toward getting more than just a place to live. Rent with FirstKey Homes for a home that's right for you, plus professional service and maintenance, innovative resident programs, and more; that's the power of purple! This 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom rental home in New Palestine, IN, might be the perfect fit for your lifestyle. See
Beautiful 2-Bedroom Apartment Available!Looking for a clean, quiet, and comfortable place to call home? This beautiful 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom unit is move-in ready!- Features:• Fresh paint• Brand-new carpet• Washer & dryer included• Dishwasher• Garbage disposal• Private balcony• Quiet location• Pets welcome!- Great place to call home!-Contact us
Beautiful 2-Bedroom Apartment Available!Looking for a clean, quiet, and comfortable place to call home? This beautiful 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom unit is move-in ready!- Features:• Fresh paint• Brand-new carpet• Washer & dryer included• Dishwasher• Garbage disposal• Private balcony• Quiet location• Pets welcome!- Great place to call home!-Contact us
Accepting Section 8 Welcome home to 4881 S 300 W Unit 18 in the heart of New Palestine, Indiana. This cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers 800 sq. ft. of bright, comfortable living in a peaceful community. The open layout and large windows bring in tons of natural light, giving the space a fresh, inviting feel. Whether you're hosting friends or enjoying a quiet night in, this apartment is
More Pictures Coming SoonSpacious 5-Bedroom 2Ba Home for Rent in New Palestine30 E. North Street, New Palestine, INRent: $2,200 per monthSecurity Deposit: $2,200Now available for rent, this spacious 5-bedroom single-family home offers plenty of room in a convenient New Palestine location. The property features a two-car attached garage and a fully fenced backyard,
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
