$146,747Average Value$111Average Price per Sq Ft12Homes For Sale
Newcomerstown is a centrally located village with baseball ties
Newcomerstown is a village with around 4,000 residents that rests along the northern banks of the Tuscarawas River. “We have a small downtown with a few boutiques and lots of pizza places, and you’re about 45 minutes from most anything you’d want,” says Ron Hickman, a Realtor with Re/Max Crossroads Properties who has lived in Newcomerstown all his life. “It’s centrally located for travel into Zanesville and Canton.”
Baseball fans may know the village as the home of MLB pitcher Cy Young, who lived there during his later years. The local Elks lodge has a mural featuring Young, and the annual Cy Young Days Festival draws fans from around the region.
A mural in downtown Newcomerstown celebrates Cy Young and Woody Hayes.
The Tuscarawas River offers recreational opportunities in Newcomerstown, Ohio.
1/2
Homes with character, some affected by trains and flood zone
Sidewalks are relatively common throughout the community, and private driveways and back alleys provide off-street parking. Housing includes a mix of Colonial Revival, American Foursquare and ranch-style homes. “Most village homes are older, and some have a lot of character,” Hickman says. “There are also a few newer cabins near the river.”
Prices vary based on condition, with fixer-uppers selling from $30,000 to $70,000, and most houses running between $80,000 and $300,000. Manufactured homes are also available. They’re typically priced from $20,000 to $90,000, and owners pay about $400 in monthly lot rent. Railroad tracks run through the village, and freight trains sometimes pass, which may be a disturbance for residents. The Tuscarawas River’s level can rise during heavy rains, and lenders might require flood insurance for properties closest to the banks.
American Foursquare and Colonial Revival style homes are found throughout Newcomerstown.
A well-maintained ranch-style home is situated on a quiet street in Newcomerstown.
1/2
Newcomerstown's four public schools
Children may attend kindergarten and first grade at East Elementary School, which earns a B-minus on Niche. West Elementary School gets a C-plus, and it offers second through fifth grades and some preschool classes. Newcomerstown Middle School rates a C, and Newcomerstown High School gets a C-plus. High schoolers can participate in extracurricular sports, including golf, bowling and wrestling.
Newcomerstown Middle School proudly showcases its school spirit.
Since 1967, Newcomerstown High School has been dedicated to educating local students.
1/2
Village recreation and trips to Salt Fork State Park
Residents have access to a wide range of recreation. Cy Young Memorial Park is home to a baseball field, a playground and a pool. The village has its own bowling alley, Cy Young Lanes, and the River Greens Golf Course, about 5 miles west, is open to the public. Simonds-Heller Park has river access for fishing, canoeing and kayaking, and the nearly 5-mile Buckhorn Creek Trail offers space for biking and dog walking. Salt Fork State Park, about 20 miles south, is a popular weekend destination. It spans more than 17,000 acres and has wooded hiking trails and hunting areas. The reservoir that winds through its center provides opportunities for water sports, such as fishing and waterskiing.
Residents of Newcomerstown, Ohio, enjoy the pool at Cy Young Memorial Park.
Newcomerestown residents enjoy a round of golf at River Greens Golf Course.
1/2
Small businesses, plus more options in Canton and Zanesville
The village is home to a few small businesses, including The Feed Barn, a drive-through farming supply store. The Oddbox sells Pokémon cards and board games, and on Friday nights, the shop hosts Magic: The Gathering tournaments. Riesbeck’s is the village grocery. “The downtown has changed a lot since my childhood. People used to rely on stores in Newcomerstown, and it was unheard of to drive for shopping,” Hickman says. “Now, they drive to the Belden Village Mall in Canton or Colony Square Mall in Zanesville for most things.”
Newcomerstown also has a small selection of locally owned restaurants. In the mornings, some people head to Main Street Coffee for breakfast. Chilly Willy’s is a favorite for sundaes and hand-dipped ice cream. Dick’s Place offers casual home cooking, and Damon's All American Pizza Pie serves pizza, wings and subs.
The Feed Barn in Newcomerstown carries farm supplies and feed.
Main Street Coffee is open for breakfast and lunch in Newcomerstown.
1/2
Community events celebrate Cy Young and Christmas
At the end of June, the village holds Cy Young Days Festival, a weekend honoring the baseball legend who lived in Newcomerstown for many years. Participants can compete in a 5K race, watch the parade down Main Street and enjoy vintage baseball at Cy Young Memorial Park. The annual Christmas parade takes place in December. “I drive Santa around the parade route in my old Ford truck, and I take him to the Temperance Tavern Museum where he magically lights the Christmas tree,” Hickman says. “Then he goes inside and has milk and cookies with the kids."
Access to interstate travel and nearby emergency services
GoBus provides service into Cleveland and other Ohio cities, and Tuscarawas County Public Transportation offers on-demand shuttle service throughout the county. Most locals depend on cars for travel. Interstate 77 runs along the eastern edge of the community, connecting drivers to Canton, about 45 miles away, and the Akron-Canton Airport, around 50 miles north. The closest emergency room is in the Coshocton Regional Medical Center, approximately 15 miles west.
Written By
Ginny West
Photography Contributed By
Tim Nightengale
Video By
Alex Finneran
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Angie Hartong,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Newcomerstown, OH sell after 35 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Newcomerstown, OH over the last 12 months is $150,000, up 1% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
LIVE AUCTION 06/24/2026 at 6:00 PM | Parcel 1 | Situated on 52.42 acres and offered in 2 parcels, this exceptional log cabin property combines luxurious country living with premier recreational and hunting opportunities. Built in 2014, the cabin with a finished walkout basement offers 2,695 sq ft of finished living space and comes fully furnished, making it truly turnkey for use as a getaway
Onsite auction with online bidding available, Thursday, June 4th at 6:00 PM. Located just a few miles south of Newcomerstown is your chance to own and manage 118 acres of whitetail paradise. This one is sure to please with the many trails, food plots, 2 blinds along with 9 tree stands that were all carefully planned and designed by Whitetail Habitat Designs. The work has all been done, and as you
An exceptional opportunity to own 20.5 acres near Stone Creek with mineral rights included, offering endless possibilities for recreation, investment, or future development. This well-designed hunting property features a blind, tree stand, two water sources, established food plots, and an extensive trail system, creating an ideal whitetail habitat. In addition, the property boasts multiple
Escape to your own slice of the outdoors with this almost 32 acre wooded parcel featuring 4 established food plots, trails, and a home set up as a cabin built in 2002. Whether you are looking for a hunting retreat, weekend getaway, or private country residence, this property delivers.The home offers an open, rustic feel with 3 bedrooms and 2 baths. This home's attached garage is perfect for
Buildable and improved lot in the Mizers Riverview Subdivision in Newcomerstown. Electricity is already on the property. A great place to build your dream home. Call today to set up a showing.
Beautiful original woodwork and pocket doors await you in this Century home. Many updates throughout are already complete for you such as the windows, 200 Amp box, roof, Shaw vinyl flooring, kitchen and bathroom . With 3 bedrooms and 1 large bath this home is ready for your personalization, just needing some cosmetic details. A large fenced in backyard includes a storage shed. The garage is a 2
Here is a Solid Brick 2-bedroom 1 bath home situated on a large lot with a nice detached garage. Plenty of outdoor space for gardening, entertaining, or future improvements. Has a new roof and solid bones add some TLC and its ready to shine! A great opportunity for investors and buyers looking to add their personal touch. Selling As Is . Cash offers only.
This spotless, well cared for home is ready for new owners! The owner has carefully updated this home with keeping important historical features in mind; original hardwood floors and trim that have been refinished, lovely fireplace and antique light fixtures, and the 4-season porch is the perfect place for all of your plants to live a happy life! The beautiful Amish built kitchen includes all
ONLINE ONLY AUCTION 06/22/2026 Beautifully updated country home offering peaceful living with plenty of space inside and out! Situated on 1.57 acres, this charming property features 2 bedrooms and 1 full bath on the main floor, along with a spacious kitchen and large living room perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The basement offers potential for an additional bedroom, office, or extra living
Charming and cozy home set on 1.95 flat, usable acres in a great location. From the inviting front porch to the functional layout, this property offers the perfect mix of comfort and country living. Inside, you’ll find main-level living with two bedrooms upstairs, creating a practical and private layout. Being sold fully furnished, nearly everything stays-making this a true move-in ready
Opportunity to own a versatile rural property on 27.18 acres near Newcomerstown, featuring a home and a swine facility all in one package.The property includes a 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home with a 2-car attached garage. The home has a spacious kitchen and dining area. It is equipped with an electric furnace and central air conditioning. A wood furnace is currently used as a secondary heat
*Price Improvement- Priced to Sell* Beautiful 6-acre parcel located in Coshocton County. Unrestricted land less than a 10-minute drive to both Newcomerstown and West Lafayette. Whether you're looking to build, place a mobile home, or hold as an investment, this property offers flexibility to fit your plans. Electric is available at the road. A well and septic system would be required if building.
Fully remodeled 3BR 2 1⁄2BA home for sale in Newcomerstown. This 2 story home sits on a nice 45’ X 116’ city lot and has ample room outside for adding a garage or patio area and has been very extensively remodeled inside and out. A 16’ X 32’ master suite addition was added to the home bringing the finished living area to 1730 SQ FT. The remainder of the first floor houses an open and very sizable
Property Id: 2147684Here is a nice efficiency apartment located close to town and across the street from the library. It's perfect for a single occupant and includes a pull down hide-a-bed, also includes a full bath and Refrigerator, Stove and Microwave. There is a small laundry mat located on the property for the tenants to use. The trash is included and the Tennant will be responsible
2 bed 1 bath apartment located in downtown Newcomerstown. Updated and ready for occupancy. Background check required at applicants expense. $750 first month's rent and $750.deposit required for move in. All utilities tenants expense (water, gas, electric) Residential Apt Unit. No pets, NO HUD, absolutely no smoking! No exceptions. Application must be on file and income must be verified before any
Residential Apt Unit, 2 bed 1 bath apartment located in downtown Newcomerstown. Newly renovated and ready for occupancy. Background check required at applicants expense. $900 first months rent and $900 deposit required for move in. All utilities expenses paid include (water, gas, electric and trash) NO PETS, NO HUD
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
