$266,303Average Value$164Average Price per Sq Ft1Home For Sale
Pomfret blends lakeside nature with academic energy
In the westernmost part of New York, the Town of Pomfret blends lakeside living with academic energy. Established in 1808, the town encompasses rolling farmland, the Village of Fredonia and the distinctive hamlet of Lily Dale Assembly on the shores of Cassadaga Lake. Fredonia is home to a state university that brings cultural events and a lively atmosphere to the area. The Canadaway Creek Wildlife Management Area offers over 2,000 acres for hiking, trout fishing and wildlife observation across forests, shrublands and ponds. The natural beauty of the Lake Erie region and the arts and educational opportunities in Fredonia come together in this corner of Chautauqua County.
Pomfret residencies consist of large plots of land making it a rural small-town living.
Pomfret draws buyers for its farming charm and proximity to Fredonia.
1/2
Special education programs at Fredonia High
The Fredonia Central School District earns a B-plus on Niche and is rated the best school district in Chautauqua County. Pre-kindergarteners and kindergarteners may attend Wheelock Early Childhood Center, which offers full- and half-day classes. B-rated schools include Fredonia Elementary for first through fourth grade and Fredonia Middle for fifth through eighth grade. Fredonia High School earns a B-plus and is one of three county schools that offer Special Olympics Unified Champion School programming. This program aims to provide inclusive sports and activities for those with and without intellectual and developmental disabilities. The State University of New York at Fredonia is also nearby.
Fredonia School district is rated the best school district in Chautauqua County.
Pomfret Pre-kindergarteners and kindergarteners may attend Wheelock Primary School.
1/2
Bungalows, colonial- and ranch-style homes
Fredonia is the town's residential and commercial hub. With a population of just over 13,000 residents as of the 2020 census, nearly 10,000 reside within the village. Residential streets give way to small bungalows, Cape Cods, Colonial Revivals, and historic colonial- and ranch-style homes priced from the $100,000s to the $500,000s. Pomfret's surrounding landscape consists of secluded properties scattered between swaths of farmland. Most of these properties consist of colonial- and ranch-style homes on spacious lots. Properties closer to Fredonia and Van Buren Bay, the town's only lakeside hamlet, can range from the mid-$200,000s to the $500,000s. Manufactured homes are priced from $30,000 to over $90,000, depending on acreage, while plots of land can range from around $85,000 to the mid-$400,000s. The town earns a CAP Index score of 2 out of 10, compared to the national average of 4.
Lily Dale is a designated nonprofit religious organization, which means potential homebuyers need approval from the Lily Dale Assembly before purchasing a home. Bungalows and cottages offer small-town charm, but little information is available regarding sales prices. "Most home sales are word-of-mouth transactions, and most are passed down throughout the family," says Louis Dispenza, a local Realtor with Midtown Realty, who has been in the industry for almost 20 years. Traditional mortgages are also unobtainable when buying property in the hamlet.
Residential streets give way to small Bungalows, Cape cods, Colonial-Revival and ranches.
Fredonia roads feature a mix of 20th-century bungalows, Cape Cods, Colonial Revivals and ranch-style homes, with some properties dating back to the 19th-century.
1/2
Village parks and Lake Erie views
Neighborhood parks are scattered around Fredonia. Barker Commons is a public green space along Main Street with fountains, park benches and a gazebo. It also serves as a gathering place for community events. Down the road, Russell Joy Park features a playground and sports courts, including four pickleball courts. Dunkirk's Point Gratiot Park is about 4 miles from the village and features stretches of sandy beach along Lake Erie. A covered pavilion makes it a favorite spot for sunset picnics, while a 1-mile path weaves around the point and leads to the historic Dunkirk Lighthouse. Just outside the village proper, The Vineyards Golf Course features a public 18-hole course surrounded by vineyards. Lily Dale also features its own community parks. Green spaces include a public dog park and a playground. The park adjoins a short nature trail that weaves around Leolyn Woods, one of the few old-growth forests in the region. More trails await at the nearby Greystone Nature Preserve, one of the many wooded preserves that make up Pomfret's rural landscape.
The light house in Dunkirk Township dates back to 1826.
Russell R. Joy park is Fredonia's main park for outdoor activities such as tennis, pickleball, basketball, baseball and even picnics.
1/2
Amenities in the village
Local businesses line the village's Main Street, while the Fredonia Opera House is up the road. Establishments range from casual American eateries to upscale Italian fare at Campano's Cucina. Tuscany Market & Deli is known for its specialty and made-to-order subs, but the village's most iconic landmark is The White Inn, a historic hotel and restaurant established in 1868. "They were closed for years, but they just reopened with brand new renovations, and their menu is amazing," Dispenza says. Chain grocers like Aldi and Tops Friendly Markets are about 2 miles east on the outskirts of the village. Big-box stores, including Walmart Supercenter and Tractor Supply Co., are scattered along U.S. Route 60 and Vineyard Drive. Ten miles away, Lily Dale also features its own eclectic mix of seasonal cafes, crystal shops and spiritual gift stores.
Fredonia Opera House is Fredonia's center of entertainment for residents with events, movies and shows.
Fredonia's most iconic landmark is The White Inn, a historic hotel and restaurant established in 1868.
1/2
Festivities along Main Street
Fredonia hosts five major festivals a year, including Miracle on Main Street, during which residents gather around Barker Commons for the village tree lighting, visits from Santa and caroling. Red, White, and Blues is another favorite event celebrating the region's local wineries every fall. Patrons can grab a glass of red or white wine while blues music echoes through the streets. In the summer, Lily Dale hosts 10 weeks of summer programming with seminars, workshops and healing services centered on the spiritual realm. Year-round events include weekly church services, yoga classes and meditation sessions. Approximately 20 miles away, the Chautauqua Institution was born out of a social movement in the late 19th and early 20th century. The Chautauqua Movement emphasized adult education and today the Institution attracts thousands of intellectuals and creatives during nine weeks of summer programming.
In the summer, Lily Dale hosts 10 wheels of summer programming with seminars, workshops and healing services centered on the spiritual realm.
Fredonia hosts five major festivals a year, including Miracle on Main Street.
1/2
Getting around Pomfret
The Chautauqua Area Regional Transit System offers public transportation throughout the town. Regular bus service connects residents from Fredonia to communities like Dunkirk and Mayville. Service from Jamestown to Lily Dale is available by request. However, the town's rural nature makes Pomfret a car-dependent community. Dunkirk's Brooks Memorial Hospital is about 7 miles from the heart of town or 3 miles from Fredonia. Erie International Airport and Buffalo Niagara International Airport are approximately 60 miles away via Interstate 90.
Written By
Lillie Duston
Photography Contributed By
Jack Lourenco
Video By
Benjamin Rose
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Frank Zellner,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Pomfret, NY sell after 6 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Pomfret, NY over the last 12 months is $38,000, down 59% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Just minutes south of Fredonia, this spectacular property offers a rare blend of privacy, natural beauty, and limitless potential. Whether you envision building your dream home, developing a multi-home retreat, or creating a private cabin or campground getaway, this property provides the perfect canvas. A custom gated and fenced entrance welcomes you in, leading to over four miles of
This is an excellent building lot with downhill slope that would be perfect for a walk-out basement with a great view of grape fields. It totals 1.6 acres with frontage of approximately 185.6’. Come build your dream home in this historic, sought-after village which was recently named “best place to retire in New York” by Travel and Leisure Magazine.
Vacant land located on North Road with a small section extending to Route 20, ideally situated between the two neighboring parcels also being offered. This unique property includes an Iroquois Gas well, which is maintained by the company, and the future owner will receive royalty payments. The site also offers the option to build and have gas available directly on the property. With plenty of
Bear Lake opportunity! Two cottages set on approximately 2.45 acres with over 500 feet of lake frontage and stunning water views. Plenty of space to add your own dock and fully enjoy lake life—kayaking, swimming, boating, and fishing. Bear Lake is known for its variety of fish, including largemouth bass, muskellunge, and walleye. The cottages offer charm and an excellent location, with great
Welcome to this charming 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in the Town of Pomfret, offering the perfect combination of comfortable living, thoughtful updates, and a picturesque setting. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the beautifully landscaped yard, highlighted by a peaceful creek that borders the property and a stunning natural waterfall. Step inside to discover a versatile bonus room just
Three apartments and a parking lot all in one unique parcel package! Totaling 12 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, this is a huge opportunity for any investor. A side by side duplex, where both units have upstairs and downstairs living space, coupled with a stand alone ranch house, all joined together by a parking lot big enough to fit at least 6 vehicles, and still there is yard space. Located in the
Discover the perfect setting for your dream home on this beautiful 2.5-acre parcel located on a quiet dead-end road in the Fredonia School District. With 546 feet of road frontage and a mix of wooded and open land, this property offers the ideal balance of privacy and natural beauty. The land is situated in the Agricultural District and zoned 311 Res VA Land, providing flexibility for a
Welcome to peace outside the busy village of Fredonia! This irregular plot of land, approximately 22 Acres, once used as a mobile park is cleared and ready for your vision to take it to the next level. Cleared land with a driveway in the front of the property have easy access and concrete borders for easy installation of new trailers or for new building. Used as a seasonal camp you have wooded
METICULOUSLY CRAFTED EXECUTIVE CUSTOM BUILT HOME COMPLETED NOVEMBER OF 2024, TUCKED IN TO A 6.8 ACRE PEACEFUL SETTING THAT IS MINUTES TO TOWN AND SCHOOLS. THIS HOME BOASTS OF 2763 SQ FT FEATURING PREMIUM QUALITY THROUGHOUT. NO EXPENSE WAS SPARED WHEN BUILDING THIS HOME TO GET THE QUALITY THAT SHOWS THROUGHOUT WITH MANY EXCEPTIONAL FEATURES. CUSTOM MADE CABINETRY HIGHLIGHTS THE GOURMET EAT IN
Let's check off all the boxes this amazing home has to offer!!! Located only about a mile outside the Village of Fredonia in a relaxed neighborhood of homes and farms, here we have a large home that has endless room inside! This raised ranch design features 6 rooms on upper level and 4 rooms on the lower level! 3 full bathrooms, 4 bedrooms with 2 more for an office, craft room, playroom or hobby
Discover the perfect blend of privacy, recreation, and rural charm at 5192 Webster Road in the Town of Pomfret. Situated on nearly 28 acres, this expansive property offers endless possibilities for farming, hunting, outdoor recreation, or building your dream country retreat. Featuring a mix of open land, Vineyards, and wooded acreage with a peaceful rural setting, this unique parcel provides
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
