$305,104Average Value$182Average Price per Sq Ft55Homes For Sale
A neighborly town with local traditions
“The biggest appeal to Sheridan is that it is the opposite of Carmel or Noblesville,” says Susan Forrest, Realtor with United Real Estate Indianapolis. “Sheridan has a more small-town feel.” It conjures the image that immediately comes to mind when imagining a friendly American main street. “There are several churches and some schools. Folks know each other and get along,” says Jim Miller, a Realtor with Berkshire Hathaway, who also sells homes in the area. Those who live here in Hamilton County occupy a mix of houses that can date as far back as the mid-20th century. Sheridan also hosts several annual events and parties.
Mid-20th century homes
Modest craftsman bungalows and ranch-style homes line either side of roads just big enough to fit a passing car, perhaps a pickup. Here, a single-family home can cost about $250,000, and prices typically range between $270,000 to $350,000. A four-bedroom and 3 bath newly constructed home can go from the high $200,000s to the low $300,000s. On the higher end, a three-bedroom, two-bath ranch-style home sitting on 19 acres, with a barn and a couple of outbuildings, will cost $1.2 million. “It’s one of a few towns where homes still fit a homebuyer’s budget. And since it’s in the best county for real estate in the state, your values should improve over time,” Miller says.
Older Sheridan homes have character and personality.
Homes in Sheridan are full of charm and beauty.
Homes to please any buyer can be found in Sheridan.
1/3
The Sheridan Community School District
Sheridan students attend Sheridan Elementary School, Sheridan Middle School and Sheridan High School, each scoring a B on Niche. Sheridan High’s football coach, Larry “Bud” Wright, has won the most games of any high school head coach in Indiana, and Sheridan Community Schools earns an overall B-plus.
Sheridan Elementary School has educated and cared for students in Sheridan for generations.
Sheridan High School offers high-level education to teenage students in Sheridan.
Sheridan Middle School offers the best education possible to its students.
1/3
Commutes to Downtown Indinapolis
Out in these parts, “If you’re not driving, you’re walking,” Miller says. For those who commute, state routes 47 and 38 are the main roads in and out of town, with Indiana 38 being the quickest path to the next nearest town and Downtown Indianapolis.
Popular pizza on Sheridan's Main Street
Sheridan’s Main Street has some newer and family-owned restaurants. Greek’s Pizzeria is a popular dining destination and is part of Main Street’s revitalization effort. Twin Kiss Drive-In is another community staple, where diners enjoy the Jumbo Fried Tenderloin and hot fudge sundaes. But besides the local Dollar General, familiar retail favorites are not too common. Residents who want to shop at Target must travel to nearby Carmel, or they can drive about 15 minutes south to Westfield to find Walmart. While there, they can pick up groceries at Meijer, Fresh Market or Aldi.
Main Street in Sheridan is full of life and local businesses.
Grab a hot, fresh pizza from Greek's Pizzeria for a delicious dinner any night of the week.
Twin Kiss Drive-In offers fresh food and ice cream in the warmer months.
1/3
Outdoorsy locals enjoy the Monon Trail
Locals enjoy getting outdoors at Biddle Memorial Park. Its playground features slides, a climbing apparatus and swings. Biddle also has a baseball field, basketball court, skatepark and picnic shelter. “It has beautiful oak trees,” Miller says. The Monon Trail is another option, running parallel to the park providing space to walk or cycle. Lastly, Veteran’s Park is smaller and is home to the Boxley Cabin, which was once where abolitionist George Boxley lived.
Biddle Memorial Park offers a spot for fun and outdoor recreation in Sheridan.
Veteran's Park stands as a lasting symbol to honor America's veterans.
Hop on a walking or bike trail for scenic views of Sheridan.
1/3
Spooky Octobers and a bustling Christmas Bazaar
Each October, Sheridan hosts its annual Harvest Moon Festival, where residents can enjoy food, music, carnival rides and participate in a Halloween costume contest. A few weeks later comes the Countdown to Christmas Bazaar, featuring handmade, home-baked and repurposed items for sale, plus breakfast, lunch and door prizes.
Written By
Nicholas Powell
Photography Contributed By
Kyle Baird
Video By
Remi Cox
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Mario Soriano,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Sheridan, IN sell after 44 days on the market compared to the national average of 58 days. The median sale price for homes in Sheridan, IN over the last 12 months is $335,000, up 1% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Located in the highly sought-after Lancaster community in Westfield, this low-maintenance paired villa offers a great combination of space, functionality, and everyday convenience. With 2,635 sq. ft. of well-designed living space, the home features an open layout with high ceilings and plenty of natural light throughout. The main level includes a spacious living room with a cozy fireplace, a
Enjoy low-maintenance living in this beautiful, "better than new", paired villa located in the popular Lancaster community in Westfield. Numerous improvements after purchase of this ENERGY STAR certified home include new refrigerator, water softener, central vac, reverse osmosis, gas cooktop (converted from electric), custom window treatments with blackouts, storm door, washer/dryer, smart lock,
Welcome to your new 4 bedroom + loft home! This property offers nearly 3,000 square feet, fully fenced rear yard, 9-foot ceilings and hard surface flooring throughout the main level, all bedrooms have walk-in closets, and upper-level laundry. Walk up to the covered front porch and stay out of the weather, protected from the sun, or sit and talk with neighbors. Enter the large foyer and to the
If easy, single-level living is what you've been searching for, this never-lived-in Arbor Homes Chestnut may be exactly what brings your search to a close. Originally built as the Maple Run model home, this ranch was finished with a level of upgrades that goes well beyond the standard spec and it's ready for its very first owner. The traditional elevation is clean and classic, accented by
Welcome home to 19397 Astoria Ave! This maintenance-free paired villa offers a modern open floor plan, perfect for entertaining friends and family. This single-story residence encompasses 2 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, complete with a bright sunroom and a 2-car garage. Key Features: Gourmet Kitchen: The kitchen features granite counters, a double sink, white cabinets with crown molding, elegant
Meet the HarmonyAt some point, home stops being about how much space you have and starts being about how well it works for your life. The Harmony was designed with that in mind.This two-bedroom, two-bathroom ranch offers 1,776 square feet of comfortable, low-maintenance, single-level living. No stairs. No wasted spacejust a layout that makes everyday life feel more settled.The open-concept
Enjoy low-maintenance townhouse living in this well-maintained, Pulte-built home within Westfield's Lancaster community. Conveniently located near Grand Park and the State Road 32 corridor, the residence highlights scenic pond views. Natural light fills the open-concept main level, where the living room, dining area, and kitchen all look out over the water. The kitchen is beautifully styled with
This impressive 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home with a 2.5-car garage offers the perfect blend of space, style, and comfort. An open main level flows seamlessly between the living, dining, sunroom and kitchen areas creating an inviting layout for everyday living. Just off the main entrance of the home is an office or den with French doors and the light-filled sunroom provides the perfect spot to
Olthof Homes presents the Harmony. Discover easy living in this low maintenance 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom ranch home offering 1776 square feet of thoughtfully designed space. The open concept layout features a bright kitchen overlooking the dining and great room perfect for everyday living and effortless entertaining. A 3rd bedroom in lieu of a flex room provides the ideal spot for a home office, den
Opportunity awaits with this 1,858-square-foot end-unit townhouse in Westfield's desirable Lancaster subdivision. Built in 2022 by Pulte Homes, this residence offers three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths across two levels of modern living space. The main floor features an open-concept great room and a kitchen with a center island, while the upper level includes a primary suite with a walk-in
Experience the perfect blend of elevated design and single-story ease in this stunning ranch home built by Arbor homes. The chestnut floor plan offer 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence boasts over 1,804 square feet of high-end finishes. From the 9-foot ceilings and luxury vinyl plank flooring to the vaulted main living area bathed in natural light, every inch of this home feels intentional and airy. The
Olthof Homes presents the Brighton. Step into comfort and style with this beautifully designed 1532 sf paired villa featuring an open-concept layout perfect for entertaining and everyday living. This spacious 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom and flex room with architectural columns, home offers a seamless flow from the living room to the kitchen and dining areas, enhanced by abundant natural light. Enjoy
Picture yourself in the spacious and flexible Empress floorplan a 3,200 sq. ft. home with five bedrooms, multiple living areas, and endless options to make it your own. Designed for those who love to entertain, The Empress offers both elegance and everyday comfort.Step inside to a welcoming living room that can double as a home office or sitting area. A powder room and formal dining room make
The Aspen II floorplan has it all- from a spacious home office, an open concept living and kitchen area, a large loft, and four bedrooms with plenty of space. You cant go wrong choosing this floorplan! Make The Aspen II your own with the many optional upgrades. If you fall in love with the interior, you will love the elevations on the exterior of this new build home!Entering off the front porch,
Introducing the Ironwood by Arbor Homes where openness meets functionality in a thoughtfully designed floorplan.Step into a welcoming foyer with a convenient powder room near the front of the home. The garage includes built-in storage and direct access to the mudroom, perfect for stowing away sports gear or bikes during winter.The spacious great room is ideal for relaxing or entertaining guests,
18661 Moray ST, 1896 square foot condominium in Westfield, IN, offering an attractive and modern home experience. This property is in great condition and ready to elevate your lifestyle. The heart of this 2 story townhome is its open-plan kitchen, seamlessly integrating with the living room with a lot of natural light. It features a functional island, complete with a sink. The property offers 3
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
