$302,951Average Value$183Average Price per Sq Ft51Homes For Sale
A neighborly town with local traditions
“The biggest appeal to Sheridan is that it is the opposite of Carmel or Noblesville,” says Susan Forrest, Realtor with United Real Estate Indianapolis. “Sheridan has a more small-town feel.” It conjures the image that immediately comes to mind when imagining a friendly American main street. “There are several churches and some schools. Folks know each other and get along,” says Jim Miller, a Realtor with Berkshire Hathaway, who also sells homes in the area. Those who live here in Hamilton County occupy a mix of houses that can date as far back as the mid-20th century. Sheridan also hosts several annual events and parties.
Mid-20th century homes
Modest craftsman bungalows and ranch-style homes line either side of roads just big enough to fit a passing car, perhaps a pickup. Here, a single-family home can cost about $250,000, and prices typically range between $270,000 to $350,000. A four-bedroom and 3 bath newly constructed home can go from the high $200,000s to the low $300,000s. On the higher end, a three-bedroom, two-bath ranch-style home sitting on 19 acres, with a barn and a couple of outbuildings, will cost $1.2 million. “It’s one of a few towns where homes still fit a homebuyer’s budget. And since it’s in the best county for real estate in the state, your values should improve over time,” Miller says.
Older Sheridan homes have character and personality.
Homes in Sheridan are full of charm and beauty.
Homes to please any buyer can be found in Sheridan.
1/3
The Sheridan Community School District
Sheridan students attend Sheridan Elementary School, Sheridan Middle School and Sheridan High School, each scoring a B on Niche. Sheridan High’s football coach, Larry “Bud” Wright, has won the most games of any high school head coach in Indiana, and Sheridan Community Schools earns an overall B-plus.
Sheridan Elementary School has educated and cared for students in Sheridan for generations.
Sheridan High School offers high-level education to teenage students in Sheridan.
Sheridan Middle School offers the best education possible to its students.
1/3
Commutes to Downtown Indinapolis
Out in these parts, “If you’re not driving, you’re walking,” Miller says. For those who commute, state routes 47 and 38 are the main roads in and out of town, with Indiana 38 being the quickest path to the next nearest town and Downtown Indianapolis.
Popular pizza on Sheridan's Main Street
Sheridan’s Main Street has some newer and family-owned restaurants. Greek’s Pizzeria is a popular dining destination and is part of Main Street’s revitalization effort. Twin Kiss Drive-In is another community staple, where diners enjoy the Jumbo Fried Tenderloin and hot fudge sundaes. But besides the local Dollar General, familiar retail favorites are not too common. Residents who want to shop at Target must travel to nearby Carmel, or they can drive about 15 minutes south to Westfield to find Walmart. While there, they can pick up groceries at Meijer, Fresh Market or Aldi.
Main Street in Sheridan is full of life and local businesses.
Grab a hot, fresh pizza from Greek's Pizzeria for a delicious dinner any night of the week.
Twin Kiss Drive-In offers fresh food and ice cream in the warmer months.
1/3
Outdoorsy locals enjoy the Monon Trail
Locals enjoy getting outdoors at Biddle Memorial Park. Its playground features slides, a climbing apparatus and swings. Biddle also has a baseball field, basketball court, skatepark and picnic shelter. “It has beautiful oak trees,” Miller says. The Monon Trail is another option, running parallel to the park providing space to walk or cycle. Lastly, Veteran’s Park is smaller and is home to the Boxley Cabin, which was once where abolitionist George Boxley lived.
Biddle Memorial Park offers a spot for fun and outdoor recreation in Sheridan.
Veteran's Park stands as a lasting symbol to honor America's veterans.
Hop on a walking or bike trail for scenic views of Sheridan.
1/3
Spooky Octobers and a bustling Christmas Bazaar
Each October, Sheridan hosts its annual Harvest Moon Festival, where residents can enjoy food, music, carnival rides and participate in a Halloween costume contest. A few weeks later comes the Countdown to Christmas Bazaar, featuring handmade, home-baked and repurposed items for sale, plus breakfast, lunch and door prizes.
Written By
Nicholas Powell
Photography Contributed By
Kyle Baird
Video By
Remi Cox
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Jeffrey Mitchell,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Sheridan, IN sell after 49 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Sheridan, IN over the last 12 months is $330,757, down 2% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Tranquil Pond-Ranch Living in Maple Run - Welcome home to 1476 Paper Birch, a beautifully situated 3-bedroom, 2-full-bathroom ranch in the desirable Maple Run community. This fantastic single-story home offers a comfortable layout with seamless flow, making it an excellent opportunity for anyone looking to enjoy the ease of main-level living. Plenty of space to entertain or just gather around the
Enjoy low-maintenance townhouse living in this well-maintained, Pulte-built home within Westfield's Lancaster community. Conveniently located near Grand Park and the State Road 32 corridor, the residence highlights scenic pond views. Natural light fills the open-concept main level, where the living room, dining area, and kitchen all look out over the water. The kitchen is beautifully styled with
Opportunity awaits with this 1,858-square-foot end-unit townhouse in Westfield's desirable Lancaster subdivision. Built in 2022 by Pulte Homes, this residence offers three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths across two levels of modern living space. The main floor features an open-concept great room and a kitchen with a center island, while the upper level includes a primary suite with a walk-in
Olthof Homes presents the Lakewood! Welcome home to this beautifully designed 2,182 sf ranch offers the perfect blend of space, comfort and functionality. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home features an open-concept floor plan ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious great room flows seamlessly into the kitchen and dining area, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere. The
Olthof Homes presents the Cordoba. Step into this beautifully designed 1615 sf paired villa featuring an open-concept layout perfect for modern living. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers a spacious kitchen, with painted white cabinets, back splash and all 4 GE Stainless Steel Appliances. Dining and living area that flows seamlessly into a bright and inviting sunroom overlooking one of our
Olthof Homes presents the Willow. Open the front door of a home appointed with 3,142 square feet of living space and find a foyer that merges with a flex room to form a welcoming open area. The main hall leads to the great room, which adjoins the breakfast and large kitchen to form a comfortable, open space for lounging and dining. Another hall leads past the mudroom and walk-in pantry to a
The Waverly at Finley Creek blends open-concept living with flexible spaces throughout. The kitchen, cafe, and gathering room create a seamless main living area, while a first-floor flex room adds versatility. Upstairs features a loft, spacious secondary bedrooms, and a private owner’s suite. Includes an unfinished basement with the option to finish for added living space.
Discover the Harmony floor plan by D.R. Horton, America’s Builder—a masterfully designed single-level residence that seamlessly blends modern functionality with timeless style. This thoughtfully crafted home offers three spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms within a bright, open-concept living environment, perfect for both daily routines and effortless entertaining.As you step inside,
This commercial property consists of 3 lots totaling 2.62 acres. Currently zoned C1 Commercial. Two of the lots are 1acre each and the 3rd lot is .62 acres. Property is located just across from active strip mall and large neighborhood! Great location w/lots of possibilities
This thoughtfully designed two-story home features an open kitchen, cafe, and gathering room ideal for everyday living and entertaining. A versatile flex space sits off the foyer, while upstairs includes spacious rooms, a convenient laundry area, and a private owner’s suite with a large walk-in closet and bath.
Exciting Chance to Own and Develop a Commercial Building near the bustling 38 in Northern Hamilton County. With the new 100 Million dollar Sky Lake attraction in the same town, and just a few minutes down the road. This rare opportunity awaits in Sheridan with high traffic and immense potential. The property, which would ideally be used for commercial purposes, requires a significant
Welcome to Blackhawk Commons, a charming community nestled in the heart of Sheridan, IN. Our affordable rental community offers a variety of one, two, and three-bedroom floor plans designed to suit your lifestyle. Enjoy the convenience of modern apartment amenities like air conditioning, a dishwasher, high ceilings, and washer/dryer hookups. At Blackhawk Commons, we take pride in our Enterprise
This home is professionally managed by Tricon, dedicated to creating exceptional rental experiences. Featuring 4 bedrooms, 3.0 bathrooms, and approximately 2,182 square feet, this well-maintained home offers a high standard of rental living, supported by a team that puts residents first. As a Tricon resident, you'll enjoy access to Tricon Vantage — a program designed to support your rental
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
