16

Mayhill, NM Homes for Sale under $400,000

Section Image Section Image
  • 4 Sherwood Forest Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    4 Sherwood Forest Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    4 Sherwood Forest Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /41

    $259,900

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,040 Sq Ft

    4 Sherwood Forest Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Quintessential Mountain Retreat – Turn-Key & Ready to Enjoy Escape to the cool mountains with this charming, fully furnished cabin located just 8.5 miles from Cloudcroft. Nestled on a spacious 0.459-acre lot, this move-in-ready mountain home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and rustic charm. The property features a large circular driveway with ample parking for multiple vehicles,

    Agent Photo

    BRENT BRADSHAW

    Cloudcroft Properties

    4 Sherwood Forest Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 95 Mescalero Ave, Mayhill, NM 88339
    95 Mescalero Ave, Mayhill, NM 88339
    95 Mescalero Ave, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /19

    $399,900

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,080 Sq Ft

    95 Mescalero Ave, Mayhill, NM 88339

    This versatile property is zoned both residential and commercial, offering endless possibilities in the heart of Cloudcroft. This beautifully remodeled two-bedroom home is ideally located just steps from downtown shops, restaurants, and local attractions, while the nearby forest provides easy access to hiking, nature, and the cool mountain air. Currently operating as a successful Airbnb, the

    Agent Photo

    ARTHUR CONDITO

    Equity Real Estate of Alamogordo LLC

    95 Mescalero Ave, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 18 Carpenter Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
    18 Carpenter Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
    18 Carpenter Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /46

    $354,000

    $5K PRICE DROP
    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,718 Sq Ft

    18 Carpenter Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339

    This inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is filled with natural light, thanks to an abundance of windows that create a bright and welcoming atmosphere throughout. The main bedroom serves as a comfortable retreat with a walk-in closet and private ensuite bath, while two additional bedrooms and a full bath are thoughtfully positioned on the opposite end of the home, offering added privacy for family or

    DEBBIE LOPER Future Real Estate

    18 Carpenter Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 1826 Rio Penasco Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    1826 Rio Penasco Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    1826 Rio Penasco Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /15

    $174,900

    • Land
    • 6 Acres
    • $29,150 per Acre

    1826 Rio Penasco Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339

    This unrestricted 6 acres borders national forest in the Sacramento Mountains in Mayhill NM. The lot has mountain views from all directions. There are several spots suitable for building, property can be used for manufactured homes, tiny homes or bring your RV endless possibilities. There is a recorded easement for easy access to the lots. Must see!!!

    CHRISTINE BARRY Aspen Trails Realty

    1826 Rio Penasco Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 4 Friar Tuck, Mayhill, NM 88339
    4 Friar Tuck, Mayhill, NM 88339
    4 Friar Tuck, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /28

    $215,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,320 Sq Ft

    4 Friar Tuck, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Tucked away in the desirable Robinhood subdivision of Mayhill, this cozy 3-bedroom home offers mountain charm and easy access to all the recreation and small-town amenities the area is known for. Situated on a .28-acre lot, the 1,320 sq ft residence was originally built in 1960 and has been thoughtfully enclosed with attractive board-and-batten siding, blending rustic character with comfortable

    DEBBIE LOPER Future Real Estate

    4 Friar Tuck, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 37 Juniper Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
    37 Juniper Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
    37 Juniper Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /49

    $230,000

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,600 Sq Ft

    37 Juniper Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Located beneath the pines of Mayhill, NM. This property has two homes and lots of possibilities!! A manufactured 4 bedroom 2 bath home with 2 living areas and a master bedroom with a suite! The second home is a 2 bedroom 1 bath home with a large deck. A large insulated shop is also attached. Please call today to take a look!!

    Schabrina Montoya Cripple Creek Realty, LLC

    37 Juniper Ln, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 3 Deadwood Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    3 Deadwood Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    3 Deadwood Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /48

    $299,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 864 Sq Ft

    3 Deadwood Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Mountain living at its finest! Take in the views and absorb everything Cloudcroft has to offer with this amazing home situated on 3 lots, totaling 1.66 acres. This home was built in 2013 and was custom built with large windows to take full advantage of the south facing sun. Original owner. The home itself is extremely cozy with an open concept floor plan. The main bedroom is downstairs and there

    JOSEPH PACHECO Aspen Trails Realty

    3 Deadwood Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 66 Will Scarlett, Mayhill, NM 88339
    66 Will Scarlett, Mayhill, NM 88339
    66 Will Scarlett, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /38

    $364,000

    $15K PRICE DROP
    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,300 Sq Ft

    66 Will Scarlett, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Charming Mountain Cabin on 3.45 Acres Bordering National Forest Nestled in the heart of the Sacramento Mountains, this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom mountain cabin offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and adventure. Situated on 3.45 scenic acres and directly bordering national forest land, this property is a dream retreat for outdoor enthusiasts, nature lovers, or anyone seeking

    Kara Cochran Future Real Estate

    66 Will Scarlett, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 48 Cowan Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    48 Cowan Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    48 Cowan Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /37

    $199,900

    • Land
    • 2 Acres
    • $99,950 per Acre

    48 Cowan Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Rare unrestricted 2 acres bordering National Forest!!!! This property has a mild slope at the top near road with a shared water well and power to property line. This acreage would make a great building site or even a great place for recreational use. These 2 acres are through a gated community named Cloud Country Estates yet unrestricted and (not) part of The Estates or the HOA. Property owners

    Thomas Mack Aspen Trails Realty

    48 Cowan Rd, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 17 Sunflower Trail, Mayhill, NM 88339
    17 Sunflower Trail, Mayhill, NM 88339
    17 Sunflower Trail, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /17

    $125,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 628 Sq Ft

    17 Sunflower Trail, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Rustic mountain cabin with renovation potential on approximately .722 acres in the Sacramento Mountains. Located at the end of a quiet road, this 2-bedroom, 1-bath property is approximately 12 miles from Cloudcroft and 7 miles from Mayhill. Ideal for a buyer ready to restore, renovate, or customize, the cabin offers a solid starting point with several recent improvements, including a cleaned and

    Rebekah Graham Future Real Estate

    17 Sunflower Trail, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 10 Circle Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    10 Circle Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    10 Circle Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /15

    $219,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,280 Sq Ft

    10 Circle Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Mountain Retreat with Modern Updates – Perfect for Retirement or a Summer Getaway Escape to the cool mountain air and enjoy the peaceful lifestyle you've been dreaming of in this updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath mountain home situated on a spacious 0.78-acre lot just 13 miles east of Cloudcroft. Offering 1,280 square feet of living space, this charming home has been thoughtfully updated throughout.

    Marsha Slane Cloudcroft Properties

    10 Circle Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 154 Bell Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    154 Bell Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    154 Bell Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /23

    $295,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,056 Sq Ft

    154 Bell Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339

    If you want to feel like you are sitting on the top of the world than this is just the place for you. This 3 bedroom/2 bath log sided home has great room both inside and out. The open living area has a minisplit for comfort year around plus a fireplace for those sometimes chilly nights. The open concept with the living room/kitchen/dining area combined with high ceilings and mulitple windows give

    Marsha Slane Cloudcroft Properties

    154 Bell Dr, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 3104 Highway 82 Unit T1, Mayhill, NM 88339
    3104 Highway 82 Unit T1, Mayhill, NM 88339
    3104 Highway 82 Unit T1, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /34

    $155,900

    $19K PRICE DROP
    • Land
    • 2.81 Acres
    • $55,480 per Acre

    3104 Highway 82 Unit T1, Mayhill, NM 88339

    If looking for a rare and flat Mountain Property this parcel is conveniently located off of highway 82. and is approx. 2.81 acres with great views up and down James Canyon, shared water well and power to the property line. This location allows recreational vehicles, horses and can also be a fantastic building site for residential home or a commercial property - mostly unrestricted.

    Thomas Mack Aspen Trails Realty

    3104 Highway 82 Unit T1, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 9 Sugar Maple, Mayhill, NM 88339
    9 Sugar Maple, Mayhill, NM 88339
    9 Sugar Maple, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /27

    $300,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 2 Baths

    9 Sugar Maple, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Incredible cabin in the mountains! Spacious property with endless customization possibilities. Amazing loft, beautiful hardwood throughout property, blank palette for the second bathroom just waiting for your ideas with too many features to mention! Wrap around deck, newer metal roof, with wonderful amenities in the community! Perfect vacation property to get away or retire in peace and comfort.

    Bella Wright Dynamic Properties Of New Mexico

    9 Sugar Maple, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 1300 Chautauqua Canyon Blvd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    1300 Chautauqua Canyon Blvd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    1300 Chautauqua Canyon Blvd, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /26

    $279,000

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,024 Sq Ft

    1300 Chautauqua Canyon Blvd, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Charming Home located on 2 lots in the Village of Cloudcroft. This 2 bedroom / 1 bath home has a pellet stove insert in the living room and a one car garage. Easy access off a paved road. Covered front porch and an open back deck let you enjoy the cool New Mexico summers and wildlife.

    Teri Scott Amigo Realty

    1300 Chautauqua Canyon Blvd, Mayhill, NM 88339
  • 2605 Highway 82, Mayhill, NM 88339
    2605 Highway 82, Mayhill, NM 88339
    2605 Highway 82, Mayhill, NM 88339
    /16

    $230,000

    • Land
    • 4.88 Acres
    • $47,141 per Acre

    2605 Highway 82, Mayhill, NM 88339

    Looking for a great getaway spot 15 minutes from the Village of Cloudcroft. Just shy of 5 acres this lot is ready to use, whether you are looking for somewhere to park an RV, build on or place a manufactured home. This lot is in a no zone area which has no restrictions on the type of home you can have. Horses are also allowed. Septic has been installed for a 4 bedroom home. The dirt work is

    CHRISTINE BARRY Aspen Trails Realty

    2605 Highway 82, Mayhill, NM 88339
New Mexico Otero County

Real Estate & Homes in Mayhill, NM under $400,000

How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage

Copyright © 2026 CoStar Group