Mitchell, IN Houses for Sale

Located at 950 Earl Road, just east of Mitchell and less than 4 miles from the main entrance of Spring Mill State Park, this 14.35 acre tract provides a quiet country setting with privacy and established improvements. Set in a peaceful rural neighborhood, the property offers both convenience and seclusion, ideal for those seeking a manageable homestead or recreational retreat in southern

Zach Holt Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Step back in time with this spacious, character-filled home featuring beautiful original woodwork and timeless charm. Offering 5 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this home combines classic craftsmanship with modern comfort. Enjoy morning coffee in the bright sunroom, which could also be used as a 6th bedroom, or relax on the inviting front porch that highlights its vintage appeal. Inside, you’ll

Miranda Mann Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty-Bloomington

This stunning 2,128 sq ft 1.5-story home sits on a desirable corner lot just past Meadowmore in Mitchell. Featuring an open floor plan and thoughtful design, it offers 2 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths. The primary suite includes two large walk-in closets, Corian countertops, a relaxing garden tub, and a separate double shower. The second bedroom also features its own walk-in closet. The

Vicki Cooper RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home blends small-town charm with modern style. Enjoy poplar hardwood flooring in the living room and bedrooms, elegant tile floors in the bathrooms, and a stylish subway tile backsplash in the kitchen. The open-concept layout features chevron butcher block countertops, perfect for cooking and entertaining. Step outside to a spacious side yard and a

Sierra Bell RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

VERSATILE. SPACIOUS. PROMISING. Excellent investment opportunity! Currently owned and used by the Fraternal Order of Police, this property offers incredible potential for a variety of uses. Situated on 2.07 acres, it features three buildings - a 10x16 storage shed, a 36x24 shelter house perfect for outdoor events, and a spacious 2,780 sq. ft. main building. Step through the front door of the main

Natasha Johns Williams Carpenter Realtors

This stunning 5-bedroom, 2-bath home sits on 2 partially wooded acres with a spectacular view. Featuring a 2 car detached garage, a 3 car attached garage, a backyard circulating waterfall feature, a spacious basement, and a cozy fireplace, the property blends comfort with functionality. It’s an all-electric home with its own well, offering efficiency and independence. Located just half a mile off

Esteban Flores Hawkins & Root Real Estate

Charming Corner Lot Home in Prime Location! Welcome to your New Home! This beautifully maintained 2/3 bedroom, 1 bath residence boasts 1,248 sq ft of comfortable living space, perfect for anyone seeking room to grow or down size. Situated on a desirable corner lot inside city limits, you'll enjoy the convenience of urban living. Key features: Modern bath, functional 2 car garage (small cars),

Kelli Lucas LUCAS Indiana Realty and Home Services

This charming 3-bedroom, 2-full bath home is freshly renovated and ready for new owners! Situated on a spacious corner lot, the property features a one-car garage and a classic, well-defined floor plan. This prime location is within walking distance to Main Street the hub of community life. You’ll be just steps from local shops, restaurants, and the beloved Persimmon Festival parade route, making

Kayla Burgi RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

Discover the potential of this 1.2-acre property in the heart of Mitchell, featuring two well-maintained buildings totaling over 8,100 sq ft across four contiguous parcels. Currently set up as a church campus, this versatile property is ready for its next chapter—whether that’s continued ministry use, a private school, community hub, business expansion, or redevelopment opportunity. Enjoy ample

Teddy Conn Keller Williams - Indy Metro South LLC

If you have hobbies, a side hustle, or just need extra space, this unique property offers both a place to live and work—all in one convenient location. Situated right on US 50 W, it provides easy access to Bedford, Mitchell, Shoals, and surrounding areas. The main pole barn has been thoughtfully finished into an open-concept living space featuring a full kitchen (appliances included), a full bath

Gary West RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

Charming 3 bed, 1.5 bath home situated on 1.08 acres with convenient highway access. This property offers the potential to be expanded into a 4 bed, 2.5 bath layout—buyer to verify. Features include a beautiful covered front porch perfect for relaxing, a 1-car garage, and a basement for extra storage or future living space. Enjoy the blend of space, comfort, and location. A great opportunity for

Natasha Rowlett Williams Carpenter Realtors

Welcome to this beautifully maintained home nestled on a peaceful 2.5 acre lot, offering the perfect blend of rural tranquility and convenient access to town amenities. Built just 3 years ago, this modern home features a functional layout with one bedroom above grade and 2 additional bedrooms below grade. Enjoy 2 full bathrooms, a bright open-concept living area and quality finishes throughout.

Kelli Lucas LUCAS Indiana Realty and Home Services

New investment opportunity.... 4 buildings on 4 acres! 3 of the 4 buildings are identical from the exterior but offer different floor plans and functionality. One of the buildings have been used as a homestead for many years and although built to be two separate units, it was converted to have an additional sitting area between to the units but still has a kitchen, bathroom, and living space on

Chelsea Kieffner CK Realty Homes

Are you looking for a newly renovated home close to Mitchell Schools for you or your family...we've got you covered! If this home were any closer it would be in the middle of the BlueJackets Stadium! You'll definitely want to tour this sprawling, newly renovated, ranch home! Newer roof (approx. 2 years old), new luxury vinyl plank flooring with a hint of both warm and cool tones, fresh paint, new

Bobbi Benish Benish Real Estate Group

Ready just for you. This 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home is move in ready. With a living room , family room, and a 3 season room there is plenty of space. There is a single car attached garage and a separate 2 car heated detached garage as well. Then to make things even better a beautiful park is right across the street. All this and priced to sell.

Barry White Williams Carpenter Realtors

Escape to your own private paradise! This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom cabin sits on 64 stunning acres of mature woods, offering the ultimate retreat for nature lovers, hunters, and anyone seeking peace and privacy. With two serene ponds, a spacious barn/outbuilding, and endless trails to explore, this property is ideal for recreation, weekend getaways, or building your dream homestead.

Miranda Mann Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty-Bloomington

This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home has been completely transformed and is ready for its next chapter. Every detail was redone from the ground up — new wiring, plumbing, HVAC, drywall, flooring, kitchen, and bath. The open concept design gives the home a bright, easy flow, with luxury vinyl plank flooring that stands up to daily life. The kitchen comes fully equipped with modern appliances. Located near

Dylan Hoover Re/Max First

CHARMING. CONVENIENT. INVITING. This beautifully maintained THREE bedroom, TWO bathroom home is conveniently located just minutes from downtown amenities. Enjoy peaceful mornings or relaxing evenings on your covered front porch before stepping inside to be greeted by a beautiful wooden staircase and a welcoming layout. To your right, the spacious living room offers plenty of natural light and

Natasha Johns Williams Carpenter Realtors

Welcome to the iconic Morgan Keane Castle — a restored Victorian masterpiece nestled in the heart of Indiana farmland. This extraordinary historic home blends timeless charm with modern updates and sits on beautifully maintained grounds that offer both privacy and potential.From the moment you arrive, you're greeted by intricate Victorian architecture, a custom exterior color palette, a

Brittany Lewis ReMax Results, LLC

CONTEMPORARY. INVITING. FUNCTIONAL. This newly built patio home sits on a corner lot and offers TWO bedrooms and ONE full bathroom. Step inside to an open-concept living room and kitchen area with a breakfast bar, perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. A convenient laundry space is located just behind the kitchen, and the home comes complete with kitchen appliances for move-in ease.

Natasha Johns Williams Carpenter Realtors

Cozy and convenient, this home in the heart of Mitchell sits on a spacious double corner lot. Perfectly located right in town, you’ll be close to schools, parks, shops, and local events. The property offers plenty of outdoor space for gardening, play, or future possibilities—all while still being easy to maintain. Whether you’re looking for your first home, downsizing, or investing, this one has

TAKE A LOOK AT THIS LOVELY 2 BEDROOM, 1 BATHROOM COTTAGE WITH FENCED BACKYARD AND 2 CAR DETACHED GARAGE. THIS HOME FEATURES A UNIQUE LAYOUT AND CONVENIENT COMMUTE TO MITCHELL AND BEDFORD. SPACIOUS KITCHEN AND REAR EGRESS TO PATIO AREA. PROPERTY ALSO FEATURES 2 UTILITY SHEDS AND LARGE GAZEBO. SIP YOUR FAVORITE BEVERAGE AND ENJOY THE COVERED FRONT PATIO. ONE YEAR HSA HOME WARRANTY AND KITCHEN

Matthew Corey Williams Carpenter Realtors

Motivated & Priced To Sell! Seller Is Offering $3500 In Concession's With Accepted Offer! This cozy 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home is full of charm and move-in ready! Perfectly situated on a corner lot, it features an adorable backyard that’s just waiting to be enjoyed. Inside, you’ll find thoughtful updates including all new joists, subfloor, and flooring in the kitchen, plus updated flooring and

Miranda Mann Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty-Bloomington

You will not find an opportunity like this anywhere else! A wonderful 5 acre private retreat with a NEVER BEFORE LIVED IN home! That's right, this home has never been lived in and was just recently finished! A spacious open floor plan is highlighted by the large owners suite and the oak wood trim that came directly off of this property. The kitchen has beautiful hickory cabinets providing a great

A.J. Bowlen RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

Nice 2 bedroom home with many improvements. The list includes new light fixtures, new interior doors, fresh paint, new flooring, ceiling fans, porch rails, water lines, new drain piping throughout, new sewer line, gutters, and more! The setting is quiet with vacant lots on either side of the home.You'll find this home to be both charming and comfortable!

Karen Goodwine Williams Carpenter Realtors

THAT PERFECT BLEND OF CHARM AND CONVENIENCE AWAITS WITHIN THIS 4 BEDROOM, 3 FULL BATHROOM HOME ON A DOUBLE CITY LOT WITH LARGE POLE BARN, LARGE UTILITY SHED, SHELTER HOUSE, AND ACCESSIBLE PARKING. THIS LOVELY HOME FEATURES A LARGE LIVING ROOM, FAMILY ROOM WITH FIREPLACE, ENCLOSED FRONT PATIO AREA, PRIMARY BEDROOM IS EN SUITE ON MAIN LEVEL, 3 UPSTAIRS BEDROOM AND CENTRALIZED BATHROOM, PARTIAL

Matthew Corey Williams Carpenter Realtors

Discover this impressive 1,816 sq ft A-frame home where rustic charm meets modern convenience. Featuring 2-3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a loft, this home is anchored by a stunning fireplace and surrounded by serene natural beauty. Enjoy relaxing or entertaining on the expansive Trex deck, while the concrete drive and patios add ease and functionality to your outdoor living. The outdoor space

Karen Goodwine Williams Carpenter Realtors

FIXER UPPER ALERT! A DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH IN DOWNTOWN MITCHELL! EVER DREAMT OF OWNING A CHARMING HOME THAT YOU CAN MAKE YOUR OWN? WELL, DO I HAVE THE PERFECT OPPORTUNITY FOR YOU! THIS 2-BEDROOM, 1-BATH BEAUTY IS A DIAMOND IN THE ROUGH, READY TO SHINE WITH A LITTLE TLC AND CREATIVITY. WITH A CORNER LOT IN THE HEART OF DOWNTOWN MITCHELL, IT'S THE IDEAL PROJECT FOR ANYONE LOOKING TO ROLL UP THEIR

Natasha Rowlett Williams Carpenter Realtors

Beautifully updated and renovated brick ranch with several outbuildings sitting on 10 rolling wooded acres. New roof 2023, new seamless gutters w/gutter guard, new porch, open patio and fenced yard to minibarn. Finished 4 car 29x20 tandem attached garage with 7 ft overhead door. New kitchen cabs, appliances (LP gas range/oven) D/W, refrigerator, flooring & pantry. Newly Remodeled baths w/new

Leigh Turner eXp Realty, LLC

Start Showing Date: 5/26/2025 Featuring original hardwood floors in this charming updated 2 bedroom, 1 bath home located within the city limits. Large detached garage and fenced in back yard. This home is not just a place to live: it's a lifestyle! with easy access to local amenities your sure to enjoy. This home is move in ready and ready for a new owner.

Kelli Lucas LUCAS Indiana Realty and Home Services

Location- Location- Location is the key to this fixer upper. 3 Bedrooms, 1 bath , extra large lot, plus a over sized garage and a large covered back patio to sit and enjoy your morning, afternoon or evening beverage. Come make this home you're dream home.

Kelli Lucas LUCAS Indiana Realty and Home Services

Property is available for online auction only. See RealtyBid for auction, property, showing, and bidding information.

Brian Brockman Bang Realty