Cicero
Cicero, NY, a historic town on Oneida Lake, features established subdivisions and waterfront homes. Route 11 offers shopping and dining, while the lake provides extensive recreation. Well-rated schools serve the area.
Average Value
$321K
List Price
$145K - $1.2M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
41 Listings
Explore Paul V. Moore High School
Clay
Clay, NY, is a small town 15 miles from Syracuse with suburban and rural charm. Waterfront homes line the Seneca River, while Colonial Revivals sit inland. Clay Central Park hosts events and offers recreational facilities.
Average Value
$303K
List Price
$162K - $688K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
38 Listings
Sullivan
Sullivan’s winding residential roads give locals a place to live within 25 miles of both downtown Syracuse and Oneida Lake. This wide-ranging Madison County community encompasses the village of Chittenango, which offers small-town ambiance with suburban qualities, including roomy yards. Sullivan also stretches north toward the hamlet of Bridgeport,
Average Value
$306K
List Price
$80K - $871K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
28 Listings
West Monroe
West Monroe is bordered by Oneida Lake, a rural haven 21 miles from Syracuse, New York. Residents may live on the lake and have access to outdoor recreation while being close to Interstate 81 for commuting. "It’s rural and it's quiet. It’s away from the highway and the hustle and bustle,” says Patricia Hermanowski-Tousant, a real estate agent with
Average Value
$287K
List Price
$40K - $1.6M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
12 Listings
Constantia
Situated along Oneida Lake, Constantia refers to both a village and a town. The village is small, home to about 1,000 people. Meanwhile, the town is much bigger, including the nearby communities of Cleveland and Bernhards Bay, altogether with about 4,700 residents. “We have a pretty big footprint, so a lot of people live out back all the way by
Average Value
$274K
List Price
$40K - $882K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
12 Listings
Vienna
In Vienna, life centers around the water. The town sits on the north shore of Oneida Lake, a popular fishing spot, and contains Sylvan Beach, a resort village that draws many additional visitors each summer. Even though the area is a vacation spot for some, it has retained a sense of community thanks to local institutions like Eddie’s Restaurant,
Average Value
$273K
List Price
$58K - $1.3M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
20 Listings
Hastings
Much of Oswego County falls into either a rural community or a big town, but Hastings has a dash of both. “We’re on the transitional between the rural country and your city feel," says town historian Heather Stevens. "We’re smack dab in the middle. You’ve got the benefits of both.” The town of Hastings includes several villages, like Mallory and
Average Value
$263K
List Price
$65K - $578K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
13 Listings
Schroeppel
Schroeppel, 18 miles from Syracuse, New York, is a rural town with farmland and open green spaces. “It’s a big horse farm area and it’s not too far from the Salmon River,” says Susan Li, an associate broker with Coldwell Banker Prime Properties. Li has sold over 1,000 properties in the past 23 years. “If you are an outdoorsman and you like to
Average Value
$257K
List Price
$78K - $1.7M
For Sale
Homes For Sale
16 Listings
Parish
Parish combines small-town, rural living with accessibility. The town is just a few streets, with a public library, the fire department, some local restaurants and a handful of churches. “The fire barn is pretty much the hub of the village,” Mayor Jacqueline Murphy says of the Parish Fire Station Office. “It’s a nice small town, and we all get
Average Value
$246K
List Price
$60K - $389K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
8 Listings
Mexico
Mexico is one of many towns on the shores of Lake Ontario in Oswego County. The Little Salmon River links the central village, also named Mexico, to the Great Lake in western New York. There's plenty of space for the town's 5,000 residents to spread out and settle on a few acres, but locals still try to support local businesses and get to know
Average Value
$240K
List Price
$29K - $637K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
12 Listings
Palermo
Forests and crop fields make up most of Palermo, a small town in Oswego County with a quiet, secluded feel. “Palermo is very quaint. It doesn’t have a ton of things. It’s more country living,” says real estate agent Benjamin DiBlasi with NextHome CNY Realty. “There’s only a Dollar General and a gas station.” Beyond the town center are a few
Average Value
$228K
List Price
$37K - $424K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
4 Listings
Amboy
Amboy, home to around 1,300 residents, is a rural, remote community in eastern Oswego County. Crops, state forests and tributaries of Oneida Lake take up most of the town’s rolling terrain, and it’s this natural setting that appeals to homebuyers. “This is an area where just about everybody farms, fishes and hunts,” says Teri Arney-Scheirer, a
Average Value
$215K
List Price
$49K - $546K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
5 Listings
Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group
