Neighborhoods in the 14058 ZIP Code

Six miles north of Batavia, Elba is a rural town with a peaceful village center and single-family homes priced below the national median of $420,000. "That's 'the Onion Capital of the World,' says Andrea Walton, a real estate agent at Gerace Realty, and a Genesee County local. "It's known for its muckland, which is real deep, black, nutrient-rich.

Relaxed and rural, Barre is a sprawling, sparsely populated stretch of Orleans County. "If you’re looking for privacy and quiet, that’s what you’ll find in Barre,” says Ilene Benfer, a real estate agent with Small City Real Estate and a former resident. “People are looking more for acreage. A lot of hunting goes on up there.” Though it’s primarily