Neighborhoods in Otsego County, NY

Otsego

Between Otsego Lake and Canadarago Lake, Otsego is a historic slice of Central New York where rolling hills meet small-town character. Founded in 1788, making it the oldest town in the county, Otsego includes much of Cooperstown, home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. “The lakes are a big part of Otsego, with the Susquehanna River
- Average Value
  
  $460K
- List Price
  
  $140K - $1.5M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  18 Listings
Otsego
Middlefield

The rural town of Middlefield covers nearly 65 square miles in Leatherstocking Country, a storied region in upstate New York known for its connection to the novels of James Fenimore Cooper. State forests and Otsego Lake surround the town and offer plenty of outdoor activities. “Otsego Lake is a year-round tourism draw, and especially in the
- Average Value
  
  $426K
- List Price
  
  $155K - $989K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  14 Listings
Middlefield
Springfield

Otsego Lake and the surrounding mountains make Springfield more than a farming community. The lake, which American writer James Fenimore Cooper called Glimmerglass in “The Leatherstocking Tales,” stretches from Cooperstown in the south to Springfield at its northern shore, providing 9 miles of water recreation and scenic views. Glimmerglass State
- Average Value
  
  $356K
- List Price
  
  $123K - $3.7M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  4 Listings
Springfield
Hartwick

Surrounded by state forests and a winding creek, the town of Hartwick is named for a Lutheran pastor from the 1700s who planned to build a religious paradise in rural Otsego County. These days, most pilgrims who visit the region do so to honor the baseball gods commemorated in Cooperstown, home of the National Baseball Hall of Fame & Museum.
- Average Value
  
  $332K
- List Price
  
  $84K - $1.3M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  7 Listings
Hartwick
Milford

The town of Milford’s vast farmlands, state forests and scattered hamlets serve as a rural buffer between Cooperstown and Oneonta . Around 3,000 people live in hamlets like Milford, Milford Center and Colliersville, and most of them commute to the nearby regional hubs for employment. When they’re not working, Milford’s residents have plenty of venues
- Average Value
  
  $279K
- List Price
  
  $37K - $714K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  10 Listings
Milford
Burlington

Burlington is a rural town in Otsego County, located about 10 miles outside of Cooperstown. Surrounded by open countryside and minutes from several state forests and parks, the community offers abundant natural beauty and year-round opportunities for outdoor recreation. While Burlington itself is largely residential, neighboring villages provide
- Average Value
  
  $275K
- List Price
  
  $73K - $436K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  4 Listings
Burlington
Cherry Valley

Cherry Valley is a scenic town located near Otsego Lake, 15 miles northeast of Cooperstown in Otsego County. Surrounded by waterways, state forests and parks, the community offers a tranquil rural setting with abundant nature and year-round outdoor recreation. The vibrant village center is lined with local shops, eateries, historical and cultural
- Average Value
  
  $258K
- List Price
  
  $85K - $573K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  8 Listings
Cherry Valley
Exeter

The town of Exeter offers rural living between the wild woodlands of Plainfield State Forest and the beaches of Canadarago Lake. “It’s a year-round opportunity with ice fishing, ice sports in the winter, and then boating and swimming in the summertime,” says Shelby MacLeish, assistant director of the Otsego County Conservation Association, which
- Average Value
  
  $256K
- List Price
  
  $74K - $1M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  3 Listings
Exeter
Westford

Situated in the Western Catskills, Westford offers a quiet lifestyle where the latest census reports that less than 900 residents live among rolling fields and country roads. Rooted in agriculture, the community is defined by active dairy, beef, vegetable and maple farms. Three major state parks circle the community, while essential amenities
- Average Value
  
  $254K
- List Price
  
  $88K - $599K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  5 Listings
Westford
Otego

Set along the banks of the Susquehanna River in the Western Catskills, Otego offers both mountain landscapes and small-town familiarity. Starting as a farming and timber community, the heritage is still seen in the rural countryside dotted with maple and evergreen trees. These forested hills frame a community of around 3,000 residents, most of
- Average Value
  
  $245K
- List Price
  
  $21K - $570K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  10 Listings
Otego
Laurens

The rural town of Laurens offers a slice of Appalachian living just ten miles outside the regional hub of Oneonta . More than 2,300 people live in villages and hamlets like Laurens, West Laurens and Mount Vision and work for the local school, small manufacturers or in retail jobs. Open countryside separates Laurens’ isolated sections, and state parks
- Average Value
  
  $243K
- List Price
  
  $43K - $851K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  11 Listings
Laurens
Plainfield

In Central New York, Plainfield offers a glimpse of rural life where farmland stretches across rolling hills, and homes are spread far from each other along winding country roads. “There’s not much in Plainfield but a collection of rural roads with working farms between larger cities,” says Jared Miller, a licensed real estate salesperson and
- Average Value
  
  $242K
- List Price
  
  $47K - $495K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  3 Listings
Plainfield
/19
Oneonta

Oneonta, NY, a college town on the Susquehanna River, hosts SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick College. Its historic downtown features artisan shops, while Neahwa Park offers riverside recreation. The city enjoys a lively summer season.
- Average Value
  
  $235K
- List Price
  
  $111K - $793K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  38 Listings
Oneonta
Roseboom

Located in the foothills of upstate New York's Catskill Mountains, Roseboom is a scenic agricultural area where homebuyers can find secluded homes on several acres while still being close to Cooperstown and Cobleskill. “I find that when I want culture, I can go to Cooperstown and have access to the lake and museums. And yet, it’s an easy drive to
- Average Value
  
  $234K
- List Price
  
  $49K - $365K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  3 Listings
Roseboom
Butternuts

Butternuts is a tranquil town nestled in the rolling hills of Otsego County, offering a rural lifestyle in central New York. Surrounded by scenic countryside, homes here often have spacious parcels, and residents have easy access to outdoor recreation. “The draw to Butternuts is really its country setting and the privacy of the properties,” says
- Average Value
  
  $231K
- List Price
  
  $86K - $508K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  8 Listings
Butternuts
New Lisbon

Set amid the foothills of New York’s Catskill Mountains, New Lisbon is a country retreat that’s within 16 miles of Oneonta and Cooperstown. “It’s a gorgeous area of rolling hills, mixed agricultural and wooded land,” says Richard Santos, who’s sold homes here since 2019 and is a licensed real estate salesperson with Keller Williams Upstate New
- Average Value
  
  $230K
- List Price
  
  $33K - $556K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  5 Listings
New Lisbon
Morris

Originally settled in 1770 and formally created in 1870, Morris is an established community in New York’s Butternut Valley that serves as a modest commercial hub for the surrounding rural area. The community’s age can be felt in its historic homes and farmhouses, and the area is also the home of the Otsego County Fair, which has taken place here
- Average Value
  
  $230K
- List Price
  
  $62K - $1.8M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  2 Listings
Morris
Richfield

Richfield offers small-town charm and lakeside living near Oneonta. Victorian homes, farmhouses, and waterfront properties range from $30K to $950K. Enjoy Canadarago Lake, parks, festivals, and local dining. A walkable village with car access, schools, and outdoor recreation.
- Average Value
  
  $228K
- List Price
  
  $36K - $978K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  8 Listings
Richfield
Worcester

Worcester, NY, 20 miles from Oneonta, blends small-town charm with scenic countryside. The historic district features the Wieting Theatre. Lutheranville State Forest offers outdoor activities. Homes range from quaint to rural.
- Average Value
  
  $222K
- List Price
  
  $40K - $548K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  14 Listings
Worcester
Edmeston

At the western edge of Otsego County, the town of Edmeston offers deep-rural living and direct highway access to Cooperstown. Around 1,900 people live there, whether in the hamlet of Edmeston or in historic properties along rural roads. “There’s a lot of nice country homes there,” says Patrick McNeil, an associate broker with the Parker Walsh Team
- Average Value
  
  $215K
- List Price
  
  $37K - $1M
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  3 Listings
Edmeston
Maryland

Beyond Oneonta’s eastern edge, the town of Maryland offers both a wealth of outdoor activities and immediate access to major roads. “The best thing about Maryland is that it’s really conveniently located on State Highway 7, which is a conduit that connects Oneonta with other regional towns, and it’s really close to Cooperstown,” says Richard
- Average Value
  
  $205K
- List Price
  
  $42K - $513K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  7 Listings
Maryland
Unadilla

Located along the Susquehanna River and Interstate 88, Unadilla is a rural community in upstate New York where the small-town atmosphere is complemented by regional accessibility. “One of the best things about Unadilla is it’s right on the I-88 corridor,” says Richard Santos, a licensed real estate salesperson with Keller Williams Upstate New
- Average Value
  
  $195K
- List Price
  
  $26K - $659K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  8 Listings
Unadilla
Pittsfield

Pittsfield, NY, 20 miles from Oneonta, offers rural living with farmhouses and ranch homes. Residents enjoy Calhoun Creek State Forest. New Berlin provides dining and shopping. Commutable to Cooperstown and Albany.
- Average Value
  
  $191K
- List Price
  
  $23K - $814K
- For Sale
  
  Homes For Sale
  
  3 Listings
Pittsfield

New York Otsego County

Neighborhoods in Nearby Cities

More About Living in Otsego County

Homes in Nearby Cities

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage