Holland
Holland, NY, a rural town 30 miles southeast of Buffalo, is known for farming and quiet living. It offers residential privacy and historic homes. Holland Hills Country Club and Beaver Meadow provide outdoor recreation.
Average Value
$330K
List Price
$100K - $474K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Explore Pioneer High School
Sardinia
Sardinia, NY, a rural town 37 miles from Buffalo, offers quiet living and green spaces. The Veteran's Park provides recreation, while Cattaraugus Creek is popular for fishing. Pioneer Senior High serves local students.
Average Value
$295K
List Price
$22K - $518K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
0 Listings
Sheldon
Sheldon, 30 miles from Buffalo, is a country community with roadside farmstands and open space. “This is a nice rural farm area,” says Melissa Haenle, a resident and agent with WNY Metro Roberts Realty, who has worked in the industry for 11 years. “We don’t find many properties that go on the market in Sheldon. They're usually over an acre lots,
Average Value
$278K
List Price
$40K - $483K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
0 Listings
Java
Among the gently rolling hills of farmland and woods of Wyoming County is the town of Java, where people live in hamlets or close to Java Lake in the Java Lake Colony. “It has a small private lake for kayaking, but people are starting to discover it,” says Brenda Bacon, an experienced Realtor with Howard Hanna Real Estate Services who also lives
Average Value
$258K
List Price
$73K - $690K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Arcade
Arcade is at the convergence of three counties, providing access to Olean, 34 miles away, and Buffalo, 42 miles away. “We’re in an area where three counties come together. It's called the tri-county area,” says Brenda Bacon, associate broker with Howard Hanna Real Estate Services. Bacon lives in the area and has worked here for 40 years. “So, you
Average Value
$252K
List Price
$144K - $537K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
3 Listings
Eagle
Not every person who moves to the Finger Lakes region of New York is looking for a vacation home on the water. Some people prefer life in a quiet town like Eagle in Wyoming County, where there are homes surrounded by rolling farmland and tucked along residential streets in the village of Bliss. “It’s a quaint, small town,” says Brenda Bacon, a
Average Value
$237K
List Price
$226K - $781K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Machias
Machias caters to two distinct populations: seasonal vacationers and a steady group of year-rounders. The population of about 500 increases in summer, when New Yorkers from big cities like Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse come to quiet Cattaraugus County. The county and overall region are full of lakes, ski resorts and space for homebuyers to get
Average Value
$231K
List Price
$19K - $559K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
8 Listings
Wethersfield
With rolling farmland and vast woodlands, Wethersfield offers rural living in Wyoming County, about 45 miles from Buffalo. Residents enjoy country living, remote farm properties and plenty of wide-open green space, although it’s a commute to dining and shopping destinations. Agriculture is the main driver of the local economy, including several
Average Value
$226K
List Price
$51K - $565K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
0 Listings
Yorkshire
Along the northern edge of Cattauragus County, Yorkshire offers homes on large lots and short commutes to busier cities and outdoor destinations. “If you’re looking for rural and affordable housing with a small-town feeling, it’s a good option,” says Melissa Frank, broker and owner of Metro Kirsch Real Estate, who has been in real estate since
Average Value
$220K
List Price
$42K - $808K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
5 Listings
Freedom
Long two-lane roads and working farms that stretch over gently rolling hills fill the town of Freedom. This Cattaraugus County area is just south of Arcade, where residents go for restaurants and shops, but Freedom has its own experiences like getting breakfast at Moore’s Maple Shack and Pancake House and fall trips to Bliss Family Farm. Freedom
Average Value
$217K
List Price
$72K - $464K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
1 Listing
Farmersville
Farmersville has been a rural part of Cattaraugus County since the town was founded in the early 1800s. Early residents were dairy farmers, and while farming is still a part of life here, Farmersville has turned into a quiet area to live close to state forests and away from noisy neighbors. “Farmersville is very rural,” says Travis Thurston, an
Average Value
$208K
List Price
$69K - $303K
For Sale
Homes For Sale
2 Listings
Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group
