NOT LISTED FOR SALE

25 Brewster Ln E Setauket, NY 11733

Setauket Area

Estimated Value: $9,624,000

6 Beds
8.5 Baths
20,000 Sq Ft
$481/Sq Ft Est. Value

Sale Details

Date Sold: May 19, 2026

Last sale price $9,500,000 $475 Per Sq Ft

Est. 1% increase in value since last sale

Current estimated payment $54,589 / mo

318 Days on Market

Highlights

  • Beach Front
  • Docks
  • Indoor Pool
  • Setauket Elementary School Rated A
  • Water Access
  • Sauna

About This Home

As of May 2026

Introducing 25 Brewster Lane, a brand-new waterfront estate nestled in the prestigious enclave of Strong's Neck in East Setauket-one of the most coveted and historically rich neighborhoods on Long Island's North Shore. Set on 4.0 private, landscaped acres with direct frontage on Port Jefferson Harbor, this 20,000+/- sq ft (includes finished lower level) architectural masterpiece blends timeless elegance with resort-style living. The home features 6 bedrooms and 9 bathrooms across three expansive levels, all serviced by a private elevator. Inside, you'll find soaring ceilings, radiant heated floors, five fireplaces, and a fully integrated smart home and whole-house entertainment system. Every space is oriented to capture stunning water views and natural light. The main level is designed for both elevated entertaining and everyday living. At its center is a chef's kitchen featuring a massive island, top-of-the-line appliances, a sunlit eat-in breakfast area, a formal dining room, a bar/lounge-style space with a fireplace, as well as a home theater room-perfect for hosting or relaxing in style. The first floor also includes a full guest suite with private bath. Upstairs, the primary suite offers an exceptional private retreat with panoramic harbor views, a spa-like bathroom, separate his-and-her dressing rooms, a sitting room with fireplace, and a private study. The second level also includes four additional bedrooms, each with its own ensuite bathroom, providing both comfort and privacy. The fully finished lower level is a destination in itself, complete with a gym, golf simulator, and game room. Two spectacular pools elevate the experience-an indoor pool with waterfall feature and an outdoor infinity-edge pool that blends seamlessly into the harbor backdrop. Beautiful patios, full outdoor kitchen, and entertainment terraces offer luxurious indoor-outdoor living. A protected mooring area just off the property's shoreline and potential for future dock installation provides convenient boat access for the marine enthusiast. Located just minutes from the shops, restaurants, and marinas of Port Jefferson Village, 25 Brewster Lane is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to own new construction on the water in one of the North Shore's most private and storied settings.

Last Agent to Sell the Property

John Vitello

Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons Brokerage Phone: 631-287-4900 License #40VI1046035 Listed on: 05/16/2025

Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons

Co-Listed By

Shan Chowdhury

Brown Harris Stevens W Hampton Brokerage Phone: 631-287-4900 License #10301219802

Last Buyer's Agent

David Guzzetta

American Way Real Estate Inc License #31GU0816173

Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area

Home Details

Home Type

  • Single Family

Est. Annual Taxes

  • $83,922

Year Built

  • Built in 2025 | Remodeled in 2024

Lot Details

  • 4 Acre Lot
  • Beach Front
  • Landscaped
  • Private Lot
  • Additional Parcels

Parking

  • 3 Car Garage

Home Design

  • Colonial Architecture
  • Contemporary Architecture
  • Stone Siding
  • Cedar

Interior Spaces

  • 20,000 Sq Ft Home
  • 3-Story Property
  • Elevator
  • Whole House Entertainment System
  • 5 Fireplaces
  • Sauna
  • Radiant Floor
  • Water Views
  • Finished Basement
  • Basement Fills Entire Space Under The House
  • Smart Thermostat

Kitchen

  • Electric Oven
  • Microwave

Bedrooms and Bathrooms

  • 6 Bedrooms
  • Main Floor Bedroom
  • Bathroom on Main Level

Pool

  • Indoor Pool
  • Infinity Pool

Outdoor Features

  • Water Access
  • Mooring
  • Docks

Schools

  • Setauket Elementary School
  • Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
  • Ward Melville Senior High School

Utilities

  • Forced Air Heating and Cooling System
  • Radiant Heating System
  • Propane
  • Cesspool
  • Cable TV Available

Listing and Financial Details

  • Legal Lot and Block 001-002 / 01-00
  • Assessor Parcel Number 0200-024-00-01-00-001-001

Home Details

Home Type

Single Family

Est. Annual Taxes

$83,922

Year Built

Built in 2025 | Remodeled in 2024

Lot Details

4 Acres

Parking

3

Listing Details

  • Property Type: Residential
  • Architectural Style: Colonial, Contemporary
  • Property SubType: Single Family Residence
  • Levels: Three Or More
  • Year Built: 2025
  • Year Built Effective: 2024
  • Attribution Contact: 631-287-4900
  • Co List Office Mls Id: KEYBRNH01
  • Co List Office Phone: 631-288-5500
  • Carport Y N: No
  • CurrentPrice: 9500000.00
  • MlsMajorChangeType: Sold
  • CurrentPrice_By_LivingArea: 475.00000
  • ListPrice_By_LivingArea: 492.50000
  • ListPrice_By_OriginalListPrice: 0.78800
  • ListPrice_By_LotSizeAcres: 2462500.0000
  • LivingAreaSearchSqFt: 20000.00
  • Special Features: NewHome
  • Property Sub Type: Detached
  • Year Renovated: 2024

Interior Features

  • Appliances: Electric Oven, Microwave, Other, Oven, Refrigerator
  • Interior Amenities: First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Elevator, Sauna, Smart Thermostat, Whole House Entertainment System
  • Fireplaces: 5
  • Full Bathrooms: 8
  • Half Bathrooms: 1
  • Basement: Finished, Full
  • Total Bedrooms: 6
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Living Area: 20000
  • Basement YN: Yes

Exterior Features

  • Construction Materials: Cedar, Stone
  • Waterfront Features: Beach Access, Beach Front, Water Access, Waterfront
  • Pool Features: In Ground, Indoor, Infinity
  • Pool Private: Yes
  • Spa: Yes
  • View: Water
  • Exterior Features: Dock, Mooring
  • Waterfront: Yes

Garage/Parking

  • Garage Spaces: 3
  • Garage: Yes

Utilities

  • Cooling: Central Air
  • Heating: Forced Air, Radiant, Radiant Floor
  • Sewer: Cesspool
  • Utilities: Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Phone Connected, Propane
  • Water Source: Public

Condo/Co-op/Association

  • Senior Community: No
  • Association: No

Schools

  • Middle School: Paul J Gelinas Junior High School

Lot Info

  • Lot Size Acres: 4
  • Lot Size Sq Ft: 174392
  • Lot Features: Landscaped, Private, Views, Waterfront
  • Parcel Number: 0200-024-00-01-00-001-001
  • Property Attached: No
  • Additional Parcels: Yes

Rental Info

  • Lease Considered: No

Tax Info

  • Tax Annual Amount: 83922.15
  • Tax Block: 01-00
  • Tax Lot: 001-002
  • Tax Year: 2025

MLS Schools

  • Elementary School: Setauket Elementary School
  • High School: Ward Melville Senior High School
  • Middle School District: Three Village

Ownership History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Name Owned For Owner Type

Purchase Details

Listed on
May 16, 2025
Closed on
May 19, 2026
Sold by
Tantillo Raymond
Bought by
Seller's Agent
John Vitello
Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
Buyer's Agent
David Guzzetta
American Way Real Estate Inc
List Price
$9,850,000
Sold Price
$9,500,000
Premium/Discount to List
-$350,000
-3.55%
Views
514
Current Estimated Value
$9,624,000

Home Financials for this Owner

Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Estimated Appreciation
$124,000
Avg. Annual Appreciation
5.32%

Purchase Details

Closed on
Jul 21, 2023
Sold by
Tantillo Raymond
Bought by
Tantillo Raymond

Purchase Details

Listed on
Feb 11, 2019
Closed on
Jun 20, 2019
Sold by
Thomas Marion T Est and Zagroba
Bought by
Tantillo Raymond and Tantillo Catherine
Seller's Agent
Ann Strong
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Buyer's Agent
Brian Hickey
Hickey & Smith REALTORS
List Price
$3,350,000
Sold Price
$2,500,000
Premium/Discount to List
-$850,000
-25.37%

Home Financials for this Owner

Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Avg. Annual Appreciation
20.68%
Original Mortgage
$1,500,000
Interest Rate
4%
Mortgage Type
Purchase Money Mortgage

Purchase Details

Closed on
Aug 23, 1995
Sold by
Kowalski Paul and Kowalski Denise Marie
Bought by
Thomas Charles
Source: Public Records

Home Values in the Area

Source: Public Records

Average Home Value in this Area





Source: Public Records

Agents Specializing in Setauket, NY

See All Agents

Purchase History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Buyer Sale Price Title Company
$8,000,000 --
Tantillo Raymond -- None Available
Tantillo Raymond $2,500,000 --
Thomas Charles -- Chicago Title Insurance Co
Source: Public Records

Mortgage History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Status Borrower Loan Amount
Previous Owner $3,950,000
Previous Owner Tantillo Raymond $2,517,400
Previous Owner Tantillo Raymond $1,500,000
Source: Public Records

Property History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Event Price List to Sale Price per Sq Ft Prior Sale
05/19/2026 05/19/26 Sold $9,500,000 -3.6% $475 / Sq Ft
03/30/2026 03/30/26 Pending -- -- --
02/19/2026 02/19/26 For Sale $9,850,000 +3.7% $493 / Sq Ft
02/18/2026 02/18/26 Off Market $9,500,000 -- --
02/17/2026 02/17/26 For Sale $9,850,000 +3.7% $493 / Sq Ft
02/17/2026 02/17/26 Off Market $9,500,000 -- --
01/06/2026 01/06/26 Price Changed $9,850,000 0.0% $493 / Sq Ft
01/06/2026 01/06/26 For Sale $9,850,000 +3.7% $493 / Sq Ft
09/30/2025 09/30/25 Off Market $9,500,000 -- --
05/16/2025 05/16/25 For Sale $12,500,000 +400.0% $625 / Sq Ft
12/10/2024 12/10/24 Off Market $2,500,000 -- --
06/20/2019 06/20/19 Sold $2,500,000 -16.4% $755 / Sq Ft View Prior Sale
04/25/2019 04/25/19 Pending -- -- --
02/22/2019 02/22/19 Price Changed $2,990,000 -10.7% $903 / Sq Ft
02/11/2019 02/11/19 For Sale $3,350,000 -- $1,012 / Sq Ft
Source: OneKey® MLS

Tax History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Year Tax Paid Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. Land Improvement
2025 $20,923 $20,150 $1,900 $18,250
2024 $20,923 $19,000 $1,900 $17,100
2023 $20,923 $5,000 $1,900 $3,100
2022 $29,296 $1,900 $1,900 $0
2021 $29,296 $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
2020 $30,143 $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
2019 $30,143 $0 $0 $0
2018 $27,498 $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
2017 $27,498 $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
2016 $27,101 $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
2015 -- $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
2014 -- $7,700 $1,900 $5,800
Source: Public Records

Agents Affiliated with this Home

  • Section Image
  • Section Image
  • Section Image
  • Section Image
  • Section Image
See All Agents

Map

Source: OneKey® MLS

MLS Number: 848679

OneKey® MLS

APN: 0200-024-00-01-00-001-001

Your Personal Tour Guide

Ask me questions while you tour the home.