$2,350,000

35 S Penataquit Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706

Downtown Bay Shore Neighborhood

Estimated payment $14,921/month

Total Views 377,574
9 Beds
4.5 Baths
5,646 Sq Ft
$416 Price per Sq Ft

Highlights

  • 1.4 Acre Lot
  • Deck
  • High Ceiling
  • Brook Avenue Elementary School Rated A
  • 4 Fireplaces
  • Wine Refrigerator

About This Home

Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer.
This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four working fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.

Listing Agent

Margaret Smith

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty Brokerage Phone: 631-647-7013 License #10301220901 Listed on: 05/21/2025

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Home Details

Home Type

  • Single Family

Est. Annual Taxes

  • $25,396

Year Built

  • Built in 1890

Lot Details

  • 1.4 Acre Lot

Parking

  • 3 Car Garage

Home Design

  • Frame Construction
  • Cedar

Interior Spaces

  • 5,646 Sq Ft Home
  • 3-Story Property
  • High Ceiling
  • 4 Fireplaces
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Formal Dining Room
  • Storage
  • Partially Finished Basement
  • Basement Fills Entire Space Under The House

Kitchen

  • Eat-In Kitchen
  • Gas Oven
  • Dishwasher
  • Wine Refrigerator
  • Stainless Steel Appliances
  • Trash Compactor
  • Disposal

Bedrooms and Bathrooms

  • 9 Bedrooms
  • En-Suite Primary Bedroom

Laundry

  • Dryer
  • Washer

Outdoor Features

  • Deck
  • Porch

Schools

  • Brook Avenue Elementary School
  • Bay Shore Middle School
  • Bay Shore Senior High School

Utilities

  • Ductless Heating Or Cooling System
  • Cooling System Mounted To A Wall/Window
  • Heating System Uses Natural Gas
  • Private Water Source

Listing and Financial Details

  • Exclusions: DR, Kitchen Chandeliers, Urns, Drapes
  • Assessor Parcel Number 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000

Home Details

Home Type

Single Family

Est. Annual Taxes

$25,396

Year Built

Built in 1890

Lot Details

0

Parking

3

Listing Details

  • Property Type: Residential
  • Architectural Style: Other
  • Property SubType: Single Family Residence
  • Levels: Three Or More
  • Exclusions: DR, Kitchen Chandeliers, Urns, Drapes
  • Year Built: 1890
  • Attribution Contact: 631-647-7013
  • Carport Y N: No
  • Special Features: None
  • Property Sub Type: Detached

Interior Features

  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Oven, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Trash Compactor, Washer, Gas Water Heater, Wine Refrigerator
  • Interior Amenities: Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, High Ceilings, Primary Bathroom, Storage
  • Fireplaces: 4
  • Full Bathrooms: 4
  • Half Bathrooms: 1
  • Basement: Full, Partially Finished
  • Total Bedrooms: 9
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Living Area: 5646
  • Basement YN: Yes

Exterior Features

  • Construction Materials: Cedar, Frame
  • Pool Private: No
  • Spa: No
  • Patio and Porch Features: Deck, Porch
  • Waterfront: No

Garage/Parking

  • Garage Spaces: 3
  • Garage: Yes

Utilities

  • Cooling: Ductless, Wall/Window Unit(s)
  • Heating: Natural Gas
  • Sewer: Public Sewer
  • Utilities: Natural Gas Connected
  • Water Source: Private, Public

Condo/Co-op/Association

  • Senior Community: No
  • Association: No

Schools

  • Middle School: Bay Shore Middle School

Lot Info

  • Lot Size Acres: 1.4
  • Lot Size Sq Ft: 60984
  • Parcel Number: 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000
  • Property Attached: Yes

Rental Info

  • Lease Considered: No

Tax Info

  • Tax Annual Amount: 25395.99
  • Tax Year: 2024

MLS Schools

  • Elementary School: Brook Avenue Elementary School
  • High School: Bay Shore Senior High School
  • Middle School District: Bay Shore

Map

Range of Values:

Collateral Analytics

Collateral Analytics Collateral Analytics AVMs (Automated Valuation Model) employ a number of statistical approaches combined with neighborhood-specific comparable selection guarantees the most up-to-date and precise valuations.

Not Available

Collateral Analytics does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

ICE

ICE Mortgage Technology ICE Mortgage Technology’s AVM (Automated Valuation Model) is a state-of-the-art online residential property valuation tool that provides a quick and accurate estimate of the value of almost any home in the U.S.

Not Available

ICE Mortgage Technology does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

First American

First American First American Data & Analytics’ next-generation AVM combines unrivaled data assets with a blended ensemble of valuation models to produce highly accurate, reliable valuations you can trust.

Not Available

First American does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

Quantarium

Quantarium Quantarium’s valuation service, repeatedly proven the industry’s most accurate and comprehensive, is supercharged with a self-learning and auto-tuning AI engine that continually becomes smarter and more accurate as it processes daily inputs from the industry’s leading RE data lake.

Not Available

Quantarium does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

Average Value
Not Available
List Price
Sold Price
Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area

Home Values in the Area

Source: Public Records

Average Home Value in this Area

Source: Public Records

Tax History

Year Tax Paid Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. Land Improvement
2024 -- $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2023 -- $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2022 $20,385 $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2021 $20,385 $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2020 $21,068 $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2019 $20,385 $0 $0 $0
2018 -- $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2017 $20,279 $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2016 $20,275 $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2015 -- $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
2014 -- $77,900 $17,900 $60,000
Source: Public Records

Property History

Date Event Price Change Sq Ft Price
05/21/2025 05/21/25 For Sale $2,350,000 0.0% $416 / Sq Ft
09/25/2024 09/25/24 Price Changed $1,810 -2.9% $5 / Sq Ft
09/21/2024 09/21/24 Price Changed $1,865 +0.8% $5 / Sq Ft
09/20/2024 09/20/24 Price Changed $1,850 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
09/18/2024 09/18/24 Price Changed $1,845 +0.8% $5 / Sq Ft
09/14/2024 09/14/24 Price Changed $1,830 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
09/13/2024 09/13/24 Price Changed $1,835 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
09/11/2024 09/11/24 Price Changed $1,840 +0.5% $5 / Sq Ft
09/09/2024 09/09/24 Price Changed $1,830 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
09/07/2024 09/07/24 Price Changed $1,825 +0.8% $5 / Sq Ft
09/06/2024 09/06/24 Price Changed $1,810 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
09/04/2024 09/04/24 Price Changed $1,815 -0.5% $5 / Sq Ft
09/02/2024 09/02/24 Price Changed $1,825 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
08/31/2024 08/31/24 Price Changed $1,820 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
08/31/2024 08/31/24 Price Changed $1,815 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
08/27/2024 08/27/24 Price Changed $1,820 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
08/26/2024 08/26/24 Price Changed $1,825 +1.4% $5 / Sq Ft
08/24/2024 08/24/24 Price Changed $1,800 -1.4% $5 / Sq Ft
08/23/2024 08/23/24 Price Changed $1,825 +4.3% $5 / Sq Ft
08/22/2024 08/22/24 Price Changed $1,750 +0.6% $4 / Sq Ft
08/21/2024 08/21/24 Price Changed $1,740 +3.0% $4 / Sq Ft
08/21/2024 08/21/24 Price Changed $1,690 -1.7% $4 / Sq Ft
08/20/2024 08/20/24 Price Changed $1,720 +0.6% $4 / Sq Ft
08/18/2024 08/18/24 Price Changed $1,710 +0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
08/17/2024 08/17/24 Price Changed $1,705 -0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
08/15/2024 08/15/24 Price Changed $1,710 +1.2% $4 / Sq Ft
08/14/2024 08/14/24 Price Changed $1,690 -3.2% $4 / Sq Ft
08/13/2024 08/13/24 Price Changed $1,745 +1.2% $4 / Sq Ft
08/07/2024 08/07/24 Price Changed $1,725 +5.8% $4 / Sq Ft
08/07/2024 08/07/24 Price Changed $1,630 -3.0% $4 / Sq Ft
08/05/2024 08/05/24 Price Changed $1,680 -1.5% $4 / Sq Ft
08/03/2024 08/03/24 Price Changed $1,705 -2.3% $4 / Sq Ft
08/07/2023 08/07/23 For Rent -- -- --
07/30/2023 07/30/23 Price Changed $1,745 0.0% $4 / Sq Ft
07/12/2023 07/12/23 Price Changed $1,745 +1.7% $4 / Sq Ft
07/12/2023 07/12/23 Price Changed $1,715 -1.7% $4 / Sq Ft
07/11/2023 07/11/23 Price Changed $1,745 -1.4% $4 / Sq Ft
07/03/2023 07/03/23 Price Changed $1,770 -1.7% $4 / Sq Ft
07/01/2023 07/01/23 Price Changed $1,800 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
06/30/2023 06/30/23 Price Changed $1,795 +1.1% $4 / Sq Ft
06/29/2023 06/29/23 Price Changed $1,775 +11.3% $4 / Sq Ft
06/28/2023 06/28/23 Price Changed $1,595 -19.0% $4 / Sq Ft
06/21/2023 06/21/23 For Rent -- -- --
04/11/2023 04/11/23 Price Changed $1,970 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
04/07/2023 04/07/23 Price Changed $1,965 +4.0% $5 / Sq Ft
04/03/2023 04/03/23 Price Changed $1,890 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
04/02/2023 04/02/23 Price Changed $1,895 -1.3% $5 / Sq Ft
03/31/2023 03/31/23 Price Changed $1,920 +0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
03/29/2023 03/29/23 Price Changed $1,915 +1.3% $5 / Sq Ft
03/28/2023 03/28/23 Price Changed $1,890 +1.6% $5 / Sq Ft
03/27/2023 03/27/23 Price Changed $1,860 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
03/18/2023 03/18/23 Price Changed $1,865 -0.3% $5 / Sq Ft
03/18/2023 03/18/23 Price Changed $1,870 +14.7% $5 / Sq Ft
02/28/2023 02/28/23 Price Changed $1,630 -0.9% $4 / Sq Ft
02/28/2023 02/28/23 Price Changed $1,645 -0.6% $4 / Sq Ft
02/25/2023 02/25/23 Price Changed $1,655 -0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
02/23/2023 02/23/23 Price Changed $1,660 +3.1% $4 / Sq Ft
02/23/2023 02/23/23 Price Changed $1,610 -0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
02/22/2023 02/22/23 Price Changed $1,615 -0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
02/20/2023 02/20/23 Price Changed $1,620 +0.6% $4 / Sq Ft
02/18/2023 02/18/23 Price Changed $1,610 -0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
02/17/2023 02/17/23 Price Changed $1,615 -0.3% $4 / Sq Ft
02/16/2023 02/16/23 Price Changed $1,620 -0.9% $4 / Sq Ft
02/15/2023 02/15/23 Price Changed $1,635 -- $4 / Sq Ft
06/07/2022 06/07/22 For Rent -- -- --
05/19/2022 05/19/22 For Rent -- -- --
Source: OneKey® MLS

Purchase History

Date Type Sale Price Title Company
Deed $1,150,000 Sutton Land Title
Deed $1,150,000 Sutton Land Title
Deed -- --
Deed -- --
Interfamily Deed Transfer -- Fidelity National Title Ins
Interfamily Deed Transfer -- Fidelity National Title Ins
Source: Public Records

Mortgage History

Date Status Loan Amount Loan Type
Open $50,000 Credit Line Revolving
Open $550,000 New Conventional
Closed $550,000 New Conventional
Source: Public Records

About the Listing Agent

Margaret Smith
Margaret Smith

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

(631) 251-4913

Section Image

Margaret (Meg) Smith has more than 30 years of experience as a real estate professional. She graduated with honors as an Education Major and Spanish Minor from Purdue University. In 1984, she opened Kidnastics, a preschool in Babylon Village, NY. While looking to expand this business, she became interested in Real Estate. In 1987, she sold her preschool, and her real estate career began. In 2010 she started her own brokerage, Meg Smith and Associates Real Estate, which was acquired by Daniel

View Margaret's Profile

Margaret's Other Listings

  • 147 S Windsor Ave, Brightwaters, NY 11718

    $1,200,000 Pending

    • 4 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 4,195 Sq Ft
    • 147 S Windsor Ave
    • Brightwaters, NY

    Location, Location, Location. Nestled in the heart of Brightwaters Village, this Classic Center Hall Colonial has all the Charm one expects from Brightwaters Village. Living room with Cozy Fireplace, Sunroom overlooking Private Backyard, Patio, and Pergola, Chef’s Kitchen with generous sized Counter Space to accommodate your Sous Chef. A Library or Home Office complete with Built Ins for reading

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    Section Image
  • 24 Hollister Ln, Islip, NY 11751

    $1,250,000

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,464 Sq Ft
    • 24 Hollister Ln
    • Islip, NY

    Sophisticated ranch living, redefined with modern luxury and timeless style. This newly renovated home showcases exceptional craftsmanship, exquisite finishes, and thoughtful design in every detail.Step through the welcoming foyer, adorned with rich, floor-to-ceiling custom millwork, and feel the warmth and sophistication that define this home. The foyer offers a direct view into the elegant

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    Section Image
  • 849 Udall Rd, West Islip, NY 11795

    $629,000 Pending

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,652 Sq Ft
    • 849 Udall Rd
    • West Islip, NY

    Step into this beautifully renovated 4 bedroom 2 full bath Cape Cod that blends classic charm with breezy beach vibes. Every detail has been thoughtfully updated to create a serene coastal inspired retreat. The light-filled interior features a fresh, open layout with coastal tones, stylish finishes, and warm hardwood floors. The renovated kitchen features quartz counter tops, a butcher block

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    Section Image
  • 1668 Manatuck Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    $600,000 Pending

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 2,284 Sq Ft
    • 1668 Manatuck Blvd
    • Bay Shore, NY

    Charming 3 bedroom 2 Full Bath Colonial nestled in Brightwaters Farms is the one you have been waiting for! Set on over a .30 acre lot, this home offers both space and privacy while maintaining a cozy, intimate feel throughout. Step inside to find a warm and inviting layout featuring a sunlit living room, a formal dining area perfect for gatherings, and a spacious eat in kitchen with an extra

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

    Section Image
  • 52 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    $900,000 Sold Dec 16, 2024

    • 5 Beds
    • 3 Baths
    • 52 Ocean Ave
    • Bay Shore, NY

    Have you ever dreamed of owning a "Golden Oldie" with a wrap around porch with easy access to a town filled with restaurants, shops, marinas, and ferries to Fire Island? Do you love perennial flowers which bloom all year round- that have lovingly been planted over the years? This 5 bedroom 3 bath home meticulously maintained could be yours! This legal 2 family dwelling, (non conforming) built

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • 276 Ocean Ave, Islip, NY 11751

    $2,105,000 Sold Jun 24, 2025

    • 6 Beds
    • 6.5 Baths
    • 6,619 Sq Ft
    • 276 Ocean Ave
    • Islip, NY

    This stunning 6,619 square foot Waterfront estate offers unmatched luxury, comfort, and panoramic natural beauty. Set on 1.93 acres, the expansive property greets you with breathtaking water views and majestic park-like grounds. This home boasts a resort style in-ground pool that seamlessly integrates with the tranquil waterfront, creating the perfect setting for both relaxation and entertaining.

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • 311 Woodland Dr, Brightwaters, NY 11718

    $1,200,000 Sold Dec 16, 2024

    • 3 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 311 Woodland Dr
    • Brightwaters, NY

    Welcome to this Enchanting English Tudor nestled in the heart of the Lakes Section of Brightwaters Village. With three levels of meticulously crafted finishes, this home has unparalleled charm and sophistication. Hardwood Floors throughout. Eat in Kitchen with soap stone countertops. Breakfast Area featuring custom coffered ceilings, Every room is more spectacular than the next. Freshly Painted,

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • 1325 Potter Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    $725,000 Sold Feb 21, 2025

    • 3 Beds
    • 1.5 Baths
    • 1325 Potter Blvd
    • Bay Shore, NY

    Nestled in the heart of Brightwaters Farms, this stunning 1920's Colonial exudes classic elegance and is set on nearly 1/3 acre of beautifully landscaped grounds with extensive gardens and mature trees. Offering 3 bedrooms, this home combines modern comforts with classic appeal. The inviting living room features a cozy fireplace, perfect for relaxing evenings, while the formal dining room

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

  • 194 Captains Way, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    $704,000 Sold Sep 12, 2024

    • 2 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 194 Captains Way
    • Bay Shore, NY

    Two Bedroom Brigantine model on the West Side of the Admiralty can be yours for the summer! Freshly Painted and new carpeting allows you to move right in and begin enjoying life in this incredible community! 230 Acres on the Great South Bay with it's own private marina which can accommodate up to a 48 foot boat. The Admiralty allows a private oasis from everyday stress. Tru Hart tennis courts,

    Margaret Smith Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Source: OneKey® MLS

MLS Number: 847363

OneKey® MLS

APN: 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000

New York Suffolk County Bay Shore 11706 Downtown Bay Shore

35 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY

This home is located at 35 S Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 and is currently priced at $2,350,000, approximately $416 per square foot. This property was built in 1890. 35 S Penataquit Ave is a home located in Suffolk County with nearby schools including Brook Avenue Elementary School, South Country Elementary School, and Bay Shore Middle School.

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

OneKey® MLS The data relating to real estate for sale or lease on this web site comes in part from OneKey® MLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Ten-X are marked with the OneKey® MLS logo or an abbreviated logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker.
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Copyright 2025 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.

Nearby Homes
Margaret Smith
Margaret Smith
Listing Agent Section Image
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
(631) 251-4913