Estimated payment $2,366/month
Total Views
41,664
5
Beds
2
Baths
2,968
Sq Ft
$134
Price per Sq Ft
Highlights
- Freestanding Bathtub
- Main Floor Bedroom
- Separate Formal Living Room
- Wood Flooring
- Victorian Architecture
- Corner Lot
About This Home
Welcome to the Preacher’s Retreat- a stunning Victorian built in 1873 as the manse for the Lodi Presbyterian Church, now lovingly restored and decked out in a hip, eclectic style. This one-of-a-kind home perfectly blends historic charm with modern conveniences and sits in the heart of the Finger Lakes, centrally located between Seneca and Cayuga wine trails and just minutes from Watkins Glen, Ithaca, and some of the region’s most beautiful state parks for swimming, hiking, and boating. Step inside and be wowed by soaring ceilings, period details, and thoughtful updates throughout. Recent renovations (2021) include: all-new electrical and plumbing, high-efficiency dual-fuel forced air system, new roof and gutters with guards, and brand-new water systems (jet pump, well pump saver, storage tank, and multistage filtration). The kitchen was rebuilt in period style, while the bathrooms exude spa-like luxury, think curb-less shower, dual rainfall heads, clawfoot tub, and double sinks in a massive upstairs bath. A new laundry was added to the first floor, and mini-splits were installed upstairs for comfort. The home is sold fully furnished and decorated, an eclectic, funky, yet romantic mix that makes it move-in ready. Outside, enjoy a large, level yard, paneled privacy fence, and hog wire fence with vining plants creating a living green screen. Whether you’re dreaming of a unique full-time residence or a standout short-term rental on the Wine Trail, this property is ready to deliver. Just bring your suitcase and settle in. Come experience it for yourself! Step inside this romantic Victorian to see just how effortlessly historic charm and modern style come together. Showings will resume on 2/1/2026
Listing Agent
Warren Real Estate of Ithaca Inc. Brokerage Phone: 607-280-3339 License #30SE0908346 Listed on: 09/23/2025
Home Details
Home Type
- Single Family
Est. Annual Taxes
- $3,598
Year Built
- Built in 1880
Lot Details
- 0.54 Acre Lot
- Lot Dimensions are 181x134
- Partially Fenced Property
- Corner Lot
- Rectangular Lot
Home Design
- Victorian Architecture
- Stone Foundation
- Blown-In Insulation
- Foam Insulation
- Metal Roof
- Wood Siding
Interior Spaces
- 2,968 Sq Ft Home
- 2-Story Property
- Entrance Foyer
- Separate Formal Living Room
- Formal Dining Room
- Storm Windows
Kitchen
- Gas Oven
- Gas Range
- Microwave
- Dishwasher
- Wine Cooler
Flooring
- Wood
- Ceramic Tile
Bedrooms and Bathrooms
- 5 Bedrooms | 2 Main Level Bedrooms
- 2 Full Bathrooms
- Freestanding Bathtub
Laundry
- Laundry Room
- Laundry on main level
- Dryer
- Washer
Basement
- Basement Fills Entire Space Under The House
- Walk-Up Access
- Exterior Basement Entry
- Dirt Floor
Parking
- No Garage
- Gravel Driveway
Outdoor Features
- Open Patio
- Porch
Schools
- South Seneca Elementary School
- South Seneca High School
Utilities
- Ductless Heating Or Cooling System
- Forced Air Heating System
- Air Source Heat Pump
- Heating System Uses Propane
- Heating System Powered By Leased Propane
- Well
- Tankless Water Heater
- Water Purifier is Owned
- High Speed Internet
Listing and Financial Details
- Assessor Parcel Number 452601-002-000-0001-010-000-0000
Map
Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area
Tax History
| Year | Tax Paid | Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. | Land | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | $3,219 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2023 | $31 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2022 | $2,917 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2021 | $3,156 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2020 | $2,825 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2019 | $1,273 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2018 | $2,681 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2017 | $2,644 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2016 | $2,630 | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2015 | -- | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
| 2014 | -- | $80,500 | $10,200 | $70,300 |
Source: Public Records
Property History
| Date | Event | Price | List to Sale | Price per Sq Ft | Prior Sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10/25/2025 10/25/25 | Off Market | $399,000 | -- | -- | |
| 10/24/2025 10/24/25 | For Sale | $399,000 | 0.0% | $134 / Sq Ft | |
| 10/07/2025 10/07/25 | Price Changed | $399,000 | -6.1% | $134 / Sq Ft | |
| 09/23/2025 09/23/25 | For Sale | $425,000 | +119.2% | $143 / Sq Ft | |
| 02/06/2023 02/06/23 | Sold | $193,900 | +2.6% | $65 / Sq Ft | View Prior Sale |
| 01/07/2023 01/07/23 | Pending | -- | -- | -- | |
| 10/26/2022 10/26/22 | For Sale | $188,900 | +46.6% | $64 / Sq Ft | |
| 12/18/2020 12/18/20 | Sold | $128,825 | -3.9% | $43 / Sq Ft | View Prior Sale |
| 11/18/2020 11/18/20 | Pending | -- | -- | -- | |
| 08/20/2020 08/20/20 | For Sale | $134,000 | -- | $45 / Sq Ft |
Source: Ithaca Board of REALTORS®
Purchase History
| Date | Type | Sale Price | Title Company |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warranty Deed | $191,400 | None Available | |
| Deed | -- | Arthur Petronio | |
| Deed | $60,000 | -- |
Source: Public Records
Mortgage History
| Date | Status | Loan Amount | Loan Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open | $200,000 | Purchase Money Mortgage |
Source: Public Records
About the Listing Agent
Kate Seaman, proud native of Ithaca, New York, and enthusiast of Cayuga Lake, Ithaca Schools, and the captivating Finger Lakes region. While her journey took her away for college and into a thriving career in retail management, the magnetic pull of her beloved hometown drew her back, sparking her venture into real estate.
With a career spanning since 2000, Kate stands among the top one percent of Realtors at Warren Real Estate and the entire Ithaca Board of Realtors. Her commitment to
Kathleen's Other Listings
Source: Ithaca Board of REALTORS®
MLS Number: R1638788
APN: 452601-002-000-0001-010-000-0000
Nearby Homes
- 8850 New York 414
- 8681 Lower Lake Rd
- 8048 Lookout Point Rd
- 8966 Victoria Dr
- 7991 Rock River Rd
- 7477 State Route 414
- 9580 Lodi Center Rd
- 2126 Chapman St
- 7206 Main St
- 00 New York 96a
- 0 New York 96a Unit S1626736
- 0 New York 96a Unit 24288713
- 0 New York 96a Unit S1652739
- 00 New York 414
- 7153 Prospect St
- 7134 Main St
- 2090 New York 96a
- 1399 Main (County Road 132) Rd
- 1477 County Road 132
- 240 Plum Point Rd Unit 16
- 5854 Route 96
- 36 Millard St
- 3040 Agard Rd
- 1787 State Route 96 Unit A
- 480 Lansingville Rd Unit 2
- 602 N Porter St Unit Lower
- 1474 Trumansburg Rd
- 602 A N Porter St Lower
- 200 W Hill Cir
- 3110 N Triphammer Rd Unit 2
- 344 Creek Rd
- 219 W Main St
- 202 S Catherine St Unit Lower
- 202 Ny-14 Unit Upper
- 143 Campbell Ave Unit Apartment
- 201 Cypress Ct
- 81 Madison St Unit 1
- 115 Raymond St
- 385 S Main St
- 494 Exchange St