NOT LISTED FOR SALE

95 Buttonball Rd Old Lyme, CT 06371

Estimated Value: $738,000 - $815,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1,394 Sq Ft
$551/Sq Ft Est. Value

Sale Details

Date Sold: December 10, 2025

Last sale price $764,000 $548 Per Sq Ft

Est. 1% increase in value since last sale

Current estimated payment $4,578 / mo

17 Days on Market

Highlights

  • 26.28 Acre Lot
  • Partially Wooded Lot
  • Attic
  • Mile Creek School Rated A
  • Antique Architecture
  • 3 Fireplaces

About This Home

As of December 2025

This charming and seemingly sturdy antique home needing updating has substantial value in its 26+ acres site. Pretty wide-board floors, 3 fireplaces and a cozy porch contribute to its vintage vibe. A detached garage and additional outbuildings add to the feel of a mini old-timey farm. Subdivision possibilities.

Last Agent to Sell the Property

Vivian Senft

Coldwell Banker Realty Brokerage Phone: (860) 227-9133 License #RES.0765512 Listed on: 10/17/2025

Coldwell Banker Realty

Co-Listed By

Marilyn Jacobs

Coldwell Banker Realty Brokerage Phone: (860) 227-9133 License #RES.0334460

Last Buyer's Agent

Nancy Mesham

Coldwell Banker Realty License #RES.0760007

Coldwell Banker Realty

Home Details

Home Type

  • Single Family

Est. Annual Taxes

  • $5,161

Year Built

  • Built in 1835

Lot Details

  • 26.28 Acre Lot
  • Partially Wooded Lot
  • Property is zoned RU40

Parking

  • 2 Car Garage

Home Design

  • Antique Architecture
  • Stone Foundation
  • Frame Construction
  • Asphalt Shingled Roof
  • Clap Board Siding

Interior Spaces

  • 1,394 Sq Ft Home
  • 3 Fireplaces
  • Partial Basement
  • Attic or Crawl Hatchway Insulated
  • Washer

Kitchen

  • Oven or Range
  • Dishwasher

Bedrooms and Bathrooms

  • 3 Bedrooms
  • 2 Full Bathrooms

Outdoor Features

  • Shed
  • Rain Gutters

Schools

  • Mile Creek Elementary School
  • Lyme-Old Lyme Middle School
  • Lyme-Old Lyme High School

Utilities

  • Cooling System Mounted In Outer Wall Opening
  • Hot Water Heating System
  • Heating System Uses Oil
  • Private Company Owned Well
  • Hot Water Circulator

Listing and Financial Details

  • Assessor Parcel Number 1551148

Home Details

Home Type

Single Family

Est. Annual Taxes

$5,161

Year Built

Built in 1835

Lot Details

26.28 Acres

Listing Details

  • Neighborhood: Mile Creek
  • Property Type: Single Family For Sale
  • Style: Antique
  • Sq Ft Est Heated Above Grade: 1394
  • Total Sq Ft: 1394
  • Year Built: 1835
  • New Construction: No/Resale
  • Direct Waterfront: No
  • Home Warranty Offered: No
  • Radon Mitigation Air Ynu: Unknown
  • Radon Mitigation Water Ynu: Unknown
  • Directions: GPS
  • Financing Used: Cash
  • Street Type: Road
  • Office Attribution Contact: (860) 434-8600
  • Reserve Prospect: No
  • Special Features: None
  • Property Sub Type: Detached

Interior Features

  • Total Bedrooms: 3
  • Total Bathrooms: 2
  • Full Bathrooms: 2
  • Fireplaces: 3
  • Attic Description: Access Via Hatch
  • Basement Description: Partial
  • Appliances: Oven/Range, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Washer
  • Attic: Yes

Exterior Features

  • Exterior Features: Shed, Gutters
  • Exterior Siding: Clapboard
  • Foundation Type: Stone
  • Roof Information: Asphalt Shingle
  • Waterfront Description: Not Applicable
  • Swimming Pool: No
  • Construction Description: Frame

Garage/Parking

  • Garages Number: 2
  • Garage And Parking: Detached Garage

Utilities

  • Cooling System: Wall Unit
  • Heat Type: Hot Water
  • Heat Fuel Type: Oil
  • Fuel Tank Location: Above Ground
  • Hot Water Description: Upright Tank
  • Water Source: Private Well
  • Sewer: Cesspool

Lot Info

  • Acres: 26.28
  • Lot Description: Lightly Wooded
  • Zoning: RU40
  • Parcel #: 1551148

Tax Info

  • Tax Year: July 2025-June 2026
  • Property Tax: 5161

MLS Schools

  • Elementary School: Mile Creek
  • Middle Jr High School: Lyme-Old Lyme
  • High School: Lyme-Old Lyme

Ownership History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Name Owned For Owner Type

Purchase Details

Listed on
Oct 17, 2025
Closed on
Dec 10, 2025
Sold by
Bought by
Seller's Agent
Vivian Senft
Coldwell Banker Realty
Buyer's Agent
Nancy Mesham
Coldwell Banker Realty
List Price
$619,000
Sold Price
$764,000
Premium/Discount to List
$145,000
23.42%
Views
66
Current Estimated Value
$768,005

Home Financials for this Owner

Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Estimated Appreciation
$4,005
Avg. Annual Appreciation
0.99%
Source: Public Records

Range of Values:

--
Value Increase
--
Percent Increase
--
Adjusted for Inflation
Collateral Analytics

Collateral Analytics Collateral Analytics AVMs (Automated Valuation Model) employ a number of statistical approaches combined with neighborhood-specific comparable selection guarantees the most up-to-date and precise valuations.

Not Available

Collateral Analytics does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

ICE

ICE Mortgage Technology ICE Mortgage Technology’s AVM (Automated Valuation Model) is a state-of-the-art online residential property valuation tool that provides a quick and accurate estimate of the value of almost any home in the U.S.

Not Available

ICE Mortgage Technology does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

First American

First American First American Data & Analytics’ next-generation AVM combines unrivaled data assets with a blended ensemble of valuation models to produce highly accurate, reliable valuations you can trust.

Not Available

First American does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

Quantarium

Quantarium Quantarium’s valuation service, repeatedly proven the industry’s most accurate and comprehensive, is supercharged with a self-learning and auto-tuning AI engine that continually becomes smarter and more accurate as it processes daily inputs from the industry’s leading RE data lake.

Not Available

Quantarium does not have data for the current month. Please view the chart for historical values.

Average Value
Not Available
List Price
Sold Price
Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area

Home Values in the Area

Source: Public Records

Average Home Value in this Area

Source: Public Records

Purchase History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Buyer Sale Price Title Company
$764,000 --
Source: Public Records

Property History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Date Event Price List to Sale Price per Sq Ft
12/10/2025 12/10/25 Sold $764,000 +23.4% $548 / Sq Ft
11/03/2025 11/03/25 Pending -- -- --
10/17/2025 10/17/25 For Sale $619,000 -- $444 / Sq Ft
Source: SmartMLS

Tax History

We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.

Year Tax Paid Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. Land Improvement
2025 $5,161 $318,010 $180,910 $137,100
2024 $5,593 $229,210 $139,010 $90,200
2023 $5,386 $229,210 $139,010 $90,200
2022 $5,386 $229,210 $139,010 $90,200
2021 $5,341 $229,210 $139,010 $90,200
2020 $5,318 $229,210 $139,010 $90,200
2019 $5,184 $231,310 $146,310 $85,000
2018 $5,068 $231,310 $146,310 $85,000
2017 $5,031 $231,310 $146,310 $85,000
2016 $4,904 $231,310 $146,310 $85,000
2015 $4,770 $231,310 $146,310 $85,000
2014 $4,842 $246,310 $146,310 $100,000
Source: Public Records

Agents Affiliated with this Home

  • Vivian Senft

    Seller's Agent in 2025

    Vivian Senft

    Coldwell Banker Realty

    (860) 227-9133

    48 Total Sales

    Vivian Senft
    Section Image
  • Marilyn Jacobs

    Seller Co-Listing Agent in 2025

    Marilyn Jacobs

    Coldwell Banker Realty

    (860) 304-6264

    15 Total Sales

    Marilyn Jacobs
    Section Image
  • Nancy Mesham

    Buyer's Agent in 2025

    Nancy Mesham

    Coldwell Banker Realty

    (860) 227-9071

    172 Total Sales

    Nancy Mesham
    Section Image
See All Agents

Map

Source: SmartMLS

MLS Number: 24136586

SmartMLS

APN: OLYM-000013-000000-000097

Connecticut New London County Old Lyme 06371

95 Buttonball Rd, Old Lyme, CT

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

SmartMLS IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Nearby Homes
Your Personal Tour Guide

Ask me questions while you tour the home.