Tammy Tinnerello
William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
(959) 215-5434
143 Total Sales
51 in Old Lyme
$274K - $1.7M Price Range
95 Buttonball Rd Old Lyme, CT 06371
Old Lyme AreaEstimated Value: $773,396
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,394
Sq Ft
$555/Sq Ft
Est. Value
Highlights
- 26.28 Acre Lot
- Partially Wooded Lot
- Attic
- Mile Creek School Rated A
- Antique Architecture
- 3 Fireplaces
About This Home
As of December 2025This charming and seemingly sturdy antique home needing updating has substantial value in its 26+ acres site. Pretty wide-board floors, 3 fireplaces and a cozy porch contribute to its vintage vibe. A detached garage and additional outbuildings add to the feel of a mini old-timey farm. Subdivision possibilities.
Last Agent to Sell the Property
Coldwell Banker Realty Brokerage Phone: (860) 227-9133 License #RES.0765512 Listed on: 10/17/2025
Co-Listed By
Coldwell Banker Realty Brokerage Phone: (860) 227-9133 License #RES.0334460
Create a Home Valuation Report for This Property
The Home Valuation Report is an in-depth analysis detailing your home's value as well as a comparison with similar homes in the area
Home Details
Home Type
- Single Family
Est. Annual Taxes
- $5,161
Year Built
- Built in 1835
Lot Details
- 26.28 Acre Lot
- Partially Wooded Lot
- Property is zoned RU40
Parking
- 2 Car Garage
Home Design
- Antique Architecture
- Stone Foundation
- Frame Construction
- Asphalt Shingled Roof
- Clap Board Siding
Interior Spaces
- 1,394 Sq Ft Home
- 3 Fireplaces
- Partial Basement
- Attic or Crawl Hatchway Insulated
- Washer
Kitchen
- Oven or Range
- Dishwasher
Bedrooms and Bathrooms
- 3 Bedrooms
- 2 Full Bathrooms
Outdoor Features
- Shed
- Rain Gutters
Schools
- Mile Creek Elementary School
- Lyme-Old Lyme Middle School
- Lyme-Old Lyme High School
Utilities
- Cooling System Mounted In Outer Wall Opening
- Hot Water Heating System
- Heating System Uses Oil
- Well
Listing and Financial Details
- Assessor Parcel Number 1551148
Ownership History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
Date
Name
Owned For
Owner Type
Purchase Details
Listed on
Oct 17, 2025
Closed on
Dec 10, 2025
Sold by
Ann Collver Elliott Relt and Essex Savings Bank
Bought by
Seller's Agent
Vivian Senft
Coldwell Banker Realty
Buyer's Agent
Nancy Mesham
Coldwell Banker Realty
List Price
$619,000
Sold Price
$764,000
Premium/Discount to List
$145,000
23.42%
Views
66
Current Estimated Value
Home Financials for this Owner
Home Financials are based on the most recent Mortgage that was taken out on this home.
Estimated Appreciation
$9,396
Avg. Annual Appreciation
1.62%
Original Mortgage
$573,000
Outstanding Balance
$563,158
Interest Rate
6.22%
Mortgage Type
Unknown
Estimated Equity
$210,238
Home Values in the Area
Average Home Value in this Area
Agents Specializing in Old Lyme, CT
-
Tammy Tinnerello
-
Linda O'Hara
Linda O'Hara
William Raveis Real Estate
(860) 881-2876
98 Total Sales
1 in Old Lyme
$450,000 Price
-
Cathy Lynch
Cathy Lynch
Coldwell Banker Realty
(475) 241-0593
197 Total Sales
1 in Old Lyme
$715,000 Price
-
Jackie Calhoun
Jackie Calhoun
Coldwell Banker Realty
(845) 613-4943
185 Total Sales
1 in Old Lyme
$650,000 Price
-
Bridget Morrissey
Bridget Morrissey
Responds QuicklyBridget Morrissey Realty LLC
(959) 500-5037
85 Total Sales
2 in Old Lyme
$569K - $700K Price Range
-
Courtney Cusano
Courtney Cusano
Coldwell Banker Realty
(959) 200-8602
135 Total Sales
1 in Old Lyme
$590,000 Price
Purchase History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Date | Buyer | Sale Price | Title Company |
|---|---|---|---|
| $764,000 | -- |
Source: Public Records
Mortgage History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Date | Status | Borrower | Loan Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Open | $573,000 |
Source: Public Records
Property History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Date | Event | Price | List to Sale | Price per Sq Ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12/10/2025 12/10/25 | Sold | $764,000 | +23.4% | $548 / Sq Ft |
| 11/03/2025 11/03/25 | Pending | -- | -- | -- |
| 10/17/2025 10/17/25 | For Sale | $619,000 | -- | $444 / Sq Ft |
Source: SmartMLS
Tax History
We collect this data history from publicly available records. To have your information removed, we recommend requesting removal directly through your county’s website.
| Year | Tax Paid | Tax Assessment Tax Assessment Total Assessment is a certain percentage of the fair market value that is determined by local assessors to be the total taxable value of land and additions on the property. | Land | Improvement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $5,161 | $318,010 | $180,910 | $137,100 |
| 2024 | $5,593 | $229,210 | $139,010 | $90,200 |
| 2023 | $5,386 | $229,210 | $139,010 | $90,200 |
| 2022 | $5,386 | $229,210 | $139,010 | $90,200 |
| 2021 | $5,341 | $229,210 | $139,010 | $90,200 |
| 2020 | $5,318 | $229,210 | $139,010 | $90,200 |
| 2019 | $5,184 | $231,310 | $146,310 | $85,000 |
| 2018 | $5,068 | $231,310 | $146,310 | $85,000 |
| 2017 | $5,031 | $231,310 | $146,310 | $85,000 |
| 2016 | $4,904 | $231,310 | $146,310 | $85,000 |
| 2015 | $4,770 | $231,310 | $146,310 | $85,000 |
| 2014 | $4,842 | $246,310 | $146,310 | $100,000 |
Source: Public Records
Agents Affiliated with this Home
-
Vivian Senft
Seller's Agent in 2025
Vivian Senft
Coldwell Banker Realty
(860) 227-9133
46 Total Sales
-
Marilyn Jacobs
Seller Co-Listing Agent in 2025
Marilyn Jacobs
Coldwell Banker Realty
(860) 304-6264
12 Total Sales
-
Nancy Mesham
Buyer's Agent in 2025
Nancy Mesham
Coldwell Banker Realty
(860) 227-9071
172 Total Sales
Map
Source: SmartMLS
MLS Number: 24136586
APN: OLYM-000013-000000-000097
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Nearby Homes
- 2 Rowland Rd
- 25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd
- 11 Buttonball Rd Unit "The Ashton"
- 184 Shore Rd
- 29 Flat Rock Hill Rd
- 88-A Flat Rock Hill Rd
- 2 Dogwood Dr
- 36 White Sands Beach Rd
- 228-B Mile Creek Rd
- 41 Springfield Rd
- 8 Biscayne Blvd
- 2 Myrica Way
- 12 Wychwood Rd
- 14 Biscayne Blvd
- 280 Shore Rd
- 45 Biscayne Blvd
- 8 Hatchetts Hill Rd
- 10 Hartford Ave
- 91 Whippoorwill Rd
- 56 Columbus Ave
- 4 Cedar Hollow Dr
- 92 Buttonball Rd
- 103 Buttonball Rd
- 89 Buttonball Rd
- 5 Cedar Hollow Dr
- 3 Cedar Hollow Dr
- 81 Mile Creek Rd
- 90 Mile Creek Rd
- 88 Mile Creek Rd
- 86 Mile Creek Rd
- 86 Buttonball Rd
- 92 Mile Creek Rd
- 84 Mile Creek Rd
- 94 Mile Creek Rd
- 82 Mile Creek Rd
- 88A Buttonball Rd
- 96 Mile Creek Rd
- 10 Cedar Hollow Dr
- 80A Craig Rd
- 80-1 Mile Creek Rd
Your Personal Tour Guide
Ask me questions while you tour the home.