Amy Penninger

Amy Penninger brings a deep-rooted knowledge of Union County and its surrounding communities to every client interaction. With a background in education and over two decades of business ownership alongside her husband, Amy combines sharp organizational skills with a compassionate, people-first approach to real estate.

Before entering the world of real estate, Amy earned degrees from Southeast Missouri State University and Southern Illinois University Carbondale, then spent years as a dedicated public high school teacher. Her experience in both education and business—through her partnership in the family’s construction company and their farm—has shaped her into a highly detail-oriented, thoughtful and reliable professional.

Amy approaches every transaction as a client advocate, taking the time to research, inform and empower both buyers and sellers throughout the process. She’s passionate about helping individuals and families make confident, informed decisions — whether they are purchasing their first home, selling a home or investing in land. Amy prides herself in quick communication and the “golden rule” of treating clients in the manner in which she would like to be treated in their position.

“There’s truly nothing more rewarding than playing a vital role in a person’s journey to achieve their goals,” Amy says. “Providing guidance, knowledge and support to buyers and sellers so they can accomplish their individual goals is what I love most about real estate.”

Known for her enthusiasm, work ethic and genuine care for others, Amy chose to align with House 2 Home Realty for its strong marketing platform and commitment to community involvement. Her main office is located in Anna, but Amy is happy to meet clients in other locations, as well.