Colin McCarthy

Southold NY

Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

6 Closed Sales

$4.2M Total Value

$565K - $930K Price Range

$692K Average Price

Prior five years

About Colin

Colin McCarthy is a real estate professional with eight years of multidisciplinary experience, distinguished by a strong foundation in residential and commercial brokerage. He has built a track record of advising clients, structuring transactions, and navigating complex deal processes across diverse asset types. Colin’s brokerage expertise is reinforced by practical experience in construction management and property operations, enabling him to bring technical and operational insight to every transaction. He has also led development initiatives from inception through completion, integrating financial oversight and stakeholder coordination to achieve successful outcomes across the full real estate lifecycle.

Home Types: Townhouse, House, Condo

Languages Spoken: English, Spanish

Years of Experience: 3

Education: New York University CUNY Manhattan

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$1,745,000

Average Sale Price

$581,667

Price Range

$565K - $595K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$1,477,000

Average Sale Price

$738,500

Price Range

$727K - $750K

Seller Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$2,675,000

Average Sale Price

$668,750

Price Range

$565K - $930K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals

Total Value

$1,477,000

Average Sale Price

$738,500

Price Range

$727K - $750K

Neighborhoods Colin is Experienced In

Greenport

2 Sales
Mattituck

2 Sales
Northwest Harbor

1 Sale
Southold

1 Sale

Colin's Open Houses

Co-Listing Agent

$2,399,000 Open Sat 1:30PM - 3:30PM
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,000 Sq Ft
470 Goose Creek Ln

Southold, NY
Waterfront living designed for effortless coastal comfort. Ideally located just moments from one of Southold’s premier beaches, this updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath contemporary home offers wide-open water views, beautiful sunrises and sunsets, and a seamless indoor–outdoor flow. The light-filled main level features a newly built modern kitchen that opens directly to the outdoor entertaining area,

Colin McCarthy Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

Colin's Active Listings

$1,600,000
- Land
- 2 Acres
- $800,000 per Acre
55975 Route 25

Southold, NY
2 Acres Of Highly Desirable Hamlet Business Zoning. Subdividable Into Half Acre Lots Or Build Multiple Structures. Multiple Residential Units Possible Or Residential/Commercial Mix. 4 Buildings Possible As Of Right. Great Route 25 Exposure & Great Location In Center Of Hamlet! Commercial Listing MLS# 3530579

Colin McCarthy Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

Co-Listing Agent

$799,000
- Land
- 2.29 Acres
- $348,908 per Acre
1350 Hortons Ln

Southold, NY
Discover The Perfect Canvas For Your Dream Estate On This Expansive 2+ Acre Lot, Offering The Ideal Balance Of Privacy And Convenience. Nestled In A Serene Setting, Yet Just Moments Away From The Vibrant Town Life, You’ll Be Close To Fine Dining, Shopping, And Everything The North Fork Has To Offer. This Unique Parcel Comes With Suffolk County Health Department Approval For An 8-Bedroom

Colin McCarthy Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

Co-Listing Agent

$2,075,000
- Land
- 2.4 Acres
- $864,583 per Acre
385 New Suffolk Ave

Mattituck, NY
Prime Development Parcel In Center of Mattituck's Burgeoning Business District! Multiple Business, Residential & Mixed Use Possibilities. 5 Buildings Possible As of Right. Commercial Listing MLS# 3530701, Additional information: Minimum Plot Size:10000

Colin McCarthy Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

$28,000 per month
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
1100 Pine Ave

Southold, NY
Permit #: 0160. This Superb 3-Bedroom, 2-Bathroom Ranch Home Showcases Gorgeous Water Views And Is Strategically Located Near Goose Creek Beach And The Pulsating Heart Of Southold, Allowing You To Enjoy The Best Of Both Worlds. The Interior Is Beautifully Designed With A Minimalist Aesthetic, Offering A Serene Retreat From The Every Day Hustle And Bustle. The Open Layout Allows For Easy Movement

Colin McCarthy Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

$30,000 per month
- 8 Beds
- 7 Baths
- 5,400 Sq Ft
650 Pine Ave

Southold, NY
A masterfully crafted resort style property, where coastal luxury meets effortless living. Tucked within a coveted private beach community with beach access, this resort-style property was designed for gathering, entertaining, and unwinding in total privacy. The home features a show-stopping 20’ x 40’ heated saltwater pool, framed by lush, manicured grounds that feel both serene and indulgent.

Colin McCarthy Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors
AHWD - At Home with Diversity
CIREC - Commercial and Investment Real Estate Certified
CNE - Certified Negotiation Expert

Agent License: New York 10401334649

Colin McCarthy

(631) 407-2860

Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate

(631) 407-2860

Homes for Sale by City

Colin McCarthy

About Colin

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Neighborhoods Colin is Experienced In

Colin's Listings and Deals

Colin's Open Houses

Colin's Active Listings

Awards and Designations