Garrett Criswell

Monticello IN

Raeco Realty

200 Closed Sales

$47.1M Total Value

$96K - $1.2M Price Range

$235.7K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Garrett

Garrett, a local to the Monticello area, grew up in rural Idaville hunting, farming, showing livestock, and enjoying the great outdoors. In 2015, he married his high school sweetheart, Tori, and together they have two beautiful daughters.

After a hunting accident in October 2020, Garrett relied on his faith in God to lead him. He joined a church group at Faith Covenant Fellowship and felt his calling was to leave the railroad behind and pursue a career in real estate. Redlow Group, a family friendly company who puts God first, was a perfect choice for his new journey. Garrett is eager to put his people skills, hard work ethic, and knowledge of the surrounding area to work to help you find your perfect slice of heaven on earth! Garrett’s more recent transition from country living to lake life gives him an advantage in finding you the perfect home in either setting.

When Garrett is not traveling with his family, he enjoys boating on Lake Freeman, helping on his grandparents farm, and hunting.

Home Types: House, Manufactured, Lot/Land, Condo

Years of Experience: 5

Education: Garrett studied at Ivy Tech.

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	38
Total Value	$9,646,700
Average Sale Price	$253,861
Price Range	$100K - $500K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	23
Total Value	$5,487,500
Average Sale Price	$238,587
Price Range	$30K - $470K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	65
Total Value	$15,675,500
Average Sale Price	$241,162
Price Range	$80K - $500K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	39
Total Value	$10,024,900
Average Sale Price	$257,049
Price Range	$30K - $750K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	113
Total Value	$27,178,001
Average Sale Price	$240,513
Price Range	$30K - $1.2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	87
Total Value	$19,964,100
Average Sale Price	$229,472
Price Range	$25K - $750K

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Garrett is Experienced In

Garrett's Recent Active Listings

$270,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,344 Sq Ft
11142 N Quiet Water Rd

Monticello, IN
Enjoy lake life on Lake Freeman in this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offering 75 feet of canal frontage on Quiet Water Road and just minutes from the main lake. This property features a screened-in back patio, detached garage, asphalt driveway, boat lift, and two jet ski lifts (one currently not functional). Across the road, you'll find a 2-acre township-owned greenspace that can be enjoyed for

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$250,000
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,062 Sq Ft
406 A&B Marion St

Monticello, IN
Great investment opportunity with this remodeled duplex situated on a corner lot! Unit A (downstairs) offers 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, a large bedroom, spacious laundry area, eat-at kitchen island, basement access, and recent remodeling throughout. Unit B (upstairs) features 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, central air, a newer furnace (1 year old), spacious laundry room, large bedroom, and updated kitchen,

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$250,000
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,518 Sq Ft
525 W Marion St

Monticello, IN
Solid limestone exterior duplex situated on a corner lot offering great curb appeal and investment potential! Unit 525A features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, hardwood floors, spacious bedrooms, and a primary en-suite. Kitchen includes all appliances including gas stove, dishwasher, refrigerator, and microwave. Dedicated laundry area with washer and dryer included. Garage access off 3rd Street. Unit

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$150,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 748 Sq Ft
408 Turpie St

Monticello, IN
This charming 2 bed 1 bath home offers easy, low maintenance living in a great location. The interior has been freshly painted, giving the home a clean and updated feel, with new flooring in the kitchen and bathroom adding a modern touch. Enjoy your morning coffee or unwind in the evening on the covered front porch, perfect for relaxing. The detached two car garage provides plenty of space for

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$265,000
- 5 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,983 Sq Ft
322 S Bluff St

Monticello, IN
Welcome to this one of a kind bluff home nestled in a friendly neighborhood with timeless charm. This spacious 5 bed/ 2.5 bath home has been the backdrop for decades of memories including family gatherings in the formal dining room and even the seller’s own wedding held right inside. From the moment you step through the front entrance you will notice the stunning original woodwork and rare

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$249,900
- Land
- 0.46 Acre
- $543,261 per Acre
5219 E Quiet Water Ct

Monon Township, IN
SALE MUST INCLUDE 5224 E QUIET WATER CT MONTICELLO IN 47960 ACROSS THE ROAD. WILL NOT BE SPLIT. SALE PRICE FOR BOTH LOTS VALUE EQUALS $549,900.00 MLS #202615839. photos are of both properties This property features a spacious 50X54 pole barn on nearly a quarter acre. The barn boasts concrete floors, electric, two overhead doors, spray foam insulation, heated, and a designated room already plumbed

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$300,000
- Land
- 0.36 Acre
- $833,333 per Acre
5224 E Quiet Water Ct

Monon Township, IN
SALE MUST INCLUDE 5224 E QUIET WATER CT MONTICELLO IN 47960 ACROSS THE ROAD. PARCELS WILL NOT BE SPLIT. SALE PRICE FOR BOTH LOTS VALUE EQUALS $549,900.00 (MLS #202615838) Photos are of both properties. Build your dream lake home on this prime main lake lot on beautiful Lake Shafer. Nestled in a quiet neighborhood, this property offers 105 feet of concrete seawall along with a professionally

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$289,900
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,970 Sq Ft
262 N State Road 39

Monticello, IN
BACK ON MARKET NO FAULT OF SELLER Well-built brick home on a spacious .75 acre lot with a fenced yard, offering plenty of room to enjoy outdoor living. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home features a large open foyer, a cozy living room with fireplace, and a seperate family room with built-in cabinets that could also work great as a home office space. (or even a large dining area) The galley kitchen

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

Joint Agent

$489,900
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 1,852 Sq Ft
12135 N Upper Lakeshore Dr

Monticello, IN
Welcome to 12135 Upper Lake Shore - one of the best positioned properties in all of Sunset Park on Lake Freeman. Built, loved, and maintained by the same family for two decades - here's a rare opportunity to purchase in this highly coveted, private, lake life community. Situated on a lake-level double lot, providing ample parking space, room for additional development (garage, etc), and

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

Recently Sold

$235,000

Sold Jul 6, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1,960 Sq Ft
1114 Maxwell Ave

Monticello, IN
- 2% Above List
- $120/SF
- 4 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $216K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$209,900

Sold Jul 2, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,512 Sq Ft
4274 N Raccoon Cir

Monticello, IN
- $139/SF
- 6 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $217K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$385,000

Sold Jul 2, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,880 Sq Ft
1509 Tioga Ravine

Monticello, IN
- $134/SF
- 45 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $412K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$206,500

Sold Jun 29, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,904 Sq Ft
83 W 100 S

Reynolds, IN
- 3% Above List
- $108/SF
- 24 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $197K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$225,000

Sold Jun 26, 2026
- 1 Bed
- 2 Baths
- 1,316 Sq Ft
318 N Beach Dr

Monticello, IN
- $171/SF
- 2 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $242K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$185,000

Sold Jun 25, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,252 Sq Ft
12164 U S 421

Monticello, IN
- 3% Below List
- $148/SF
- 16 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $212K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$183,000

Sold Jun 11, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,210 Sq Ft
11129 N Quiet Water Rd

Monticello, IN
- 5% Below List
- $151/SF
- 3 Days On Market
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$250,000

Sold Jun 5, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,328 Sq Ft
310 E 12th St

Brookston, IN
- $188/SF
- 3 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $227K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$165,000

Sold Jun 2, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 794 Sq Ft
418 Chestnut St

Monticello, IN
- 3% Below List
- $208/SF
- 48 Days On Market
- Current Est. Value $169K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors

Garrett Criswell

(574) 228-4339

Raeco Realty

(574) 228-4339

Homes for Sale by City

Garrett Criswell

About Garrett

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Garrett is Experienced In

Garrett's Listings and Deals

Garrett's Recent Active Listings

Recently Sold

Awards and Designations