Garrett Criswell Real Estate Agent - Raeco Realty

518 S Illinois St, Monticello, IN For Sale $199,900 - listed by Garrett Criswell — For Sale $199,900

Garrett Criswell listing agent for 3299 N 925 W, Delphi, IN - sold for $293,000 — Sold $293,000

525 W Marion St, Monticello, IN For Sale $269,000 - listed by Garrett Criswell — For Sale $269,000

Garrett Criswell buyer's agent for 310 S Railroad St, Monticello, IN - sold for $169,000 — Sold $169,000

6105 E US 24, Monticello, IN For Sale $1,720,000 - listed by Garrett Criswell — For Sale $1,720,000

Garrett Criswell

Monticello IN

Raeco Realty

202 Closed Sales

$47.6M Total Value

$100K - $1.2M Price Range

$235.7K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Garrett

Garrett, a local to the Monticello area, grew up in rural Idaville hunting, farming, showing livestock, and enjoying the great outdoors. In 2015, he married his high school sweetheart, Tori, and together they have two beautiful daughters.

After a hunting accident in October 2020, Garrett relied on his faith in God to lead him. He joined a church group at Faith Covenant Fellowship and felt his calling was to leave the railroad behind and pursue a career in real estate. Redlow Group, a family friendly company who puts God first, was a perfect choice for his new journey. Garrett is eager to put his people skills, hard work ethic, and knowledge of the surrounding area to work to help you find your perfect slice of heaven on earth! Garrett’s more recent transition from country living to lake life gives him an advantage in finding you the perfect home in either setting.

When Garrett is not traveling with his family, he enjoys boating on Lake Freeman, helping on his grandparents farm, and hunting.

Home Types: House, Mobile Homes, Lot/Land, Condo

Years of Experience: 5

Education: Garrett studied at Ivy Tech.

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	39
Total Value	$9,939,700
Average Sale Price	$254,864
Price Range	$100K - $500K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	24
Total Value	$5,656,500
Average Sale Price	$235,688
Price Range	$30K - $470K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	66
Total Value	$15,968,500
Average Sale Price	$241,947
Price Range	$80K - $500K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	40
Total Value	$10,193,900
Average Sale Price	$254,848
Price Range	$30K - $750K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	114
Total Value	$27,471,001
Average Sale Price	$240,974
Price Range	$30K - $1.2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	88
Total Value	$20,133,100
Average Sale Price	$228,785
Price Range	$25K - $750K

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Garrett is Experienced In

Garrett's Listings and Deals

Garrett's Recent Active Listings

$199,900
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,582 Sq Ft
518 S Illinois St

Monticello, IN
This 3-bedroom, 2-bath home with a bonus room downstairs offers a great combination of original character and fresh updates throughout. Inside, you’ll find beautiful original hardwood floors, a real wood-burning fireplace, a freshly painted interior, and an updated kitchen featuring painted cabinets, new countertops, and a pantry for additional storage. Both bathrooms have been refreshed with new

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$269,000
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,518 Sq Ft
525 W Marion St

Monticello, IN
Welcome to this spacious and versatile 4-bedroom, 3-bath Bedford stone home situated on a desirable corner lot. Originally designed as a duplex and thoughtfully converted back into a single-family residence, this unique property offers endless possibilities. Whether you're looking for a large family home, a private mother-in-law suite, space for grown children, or the opportunity to convert it

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$1,720,000
- 4 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 4,380 Sq Ft
6105 E US 24

Monticello, IN
Welcome to a truly rare waterfront opportunity offering approximately 4,300 square feet, 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, 4.5 private acres, and nearly 500 feet of shoreline. Built by the same legendary craftsman responsible for constructing Tony Stewart’s personal residence, this handcrafted log-style home showcases exceptional quality and timeless design. The exterior logs were individually sourced

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$74,900
- Land
- 0.75 Acre
- $99,867 per Acre
TBD E Highchew (Lot 3) Ct

Monticello, IN
Lot 1- Located on Highchew Ct off East Shafer Dr, these are approximately .75 acre lots that offer a great opportunity to build your dream home, a pole barn, or create your own private recreational getaway. Situated on a quiet dead-end private road, these parcels provide a peaceful setting while still being just a short distance from town and all of the lake area amenities. Enjoy the space and

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$99,900
- Land
- 1 Acre
- $99,900 per Acre
TBD E 600 N (Lot 4)

Monticello, IN
LOT 4- Located on 600 N / Bluebell Ct, these 1-acre lots offer a great opportunity to build your dream home, build a pole barn, or create your own recreational retreat. Enjoy beautiful lake views directly across the road while being tucked away on a quiet dead-end road. With plenty of space and a peaceful setting, these parcels provide the perfect blend of privacy and convenience near the lake.

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$74,900
- Land
- 0.75 Acre
- $99,867 per Acre
TBD E Highchew (Lot 1) Ct

Monticello, IN
Lot 1- Located on Highchew Ct off East Shafer Dr, these are approximately .75 acre lots that offer a great opportunity to build your dream home, a pole barn, or create your own private recreational getaway. Situated on a quiet dead-end private road, these parcels provide a peaceful setting while still being just a short distance from town and all of the lake area amenities. Enjoy the space and

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$99,900
- Land
- 1 Acre
- $99,900 per Acre
TBD E

Monticello, IN
LOT 3- Located on 600 N / Bluebell Ct, these 1-acre lots offer a great opportunity to build your dream home, build a pole barn, or create your own recreational retreat. Enjoy beautiful lake views directly across the road while being tucked away on a quiet dead-end road. With plenty of space and a peaceful setting, these parcels provide the perfect blend of privacy and convenience near the lake.

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$99,900
- Land
- 1 Acre
- $99,900 per Acre
TBD E

Monticello, IN
LOT 1- Located on 600 N / Bluebell Ct, these 1-acre lots offer a great opportunity to build your dream home, build a pole barn, or create your own recreational retreat. Enjoy beautiful lake views directly across the road while being tucked away on a quiet dead-end road. With plenty of space and a peaceful setting, these parcels provide the perfect blend of privacy and convenience near the lake.

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$99,900
- Land
- 1 Acre
- $99,900 per Acre
TBD E 600 N (Lot 5)

Monticello, IN
LOT 5- Located on 600 N / Bluebell Ct, these 1-acre lots offer a great opportunity to build your dream home, build a pole barn, or create your own recreational retreat. Enjoy beautiful lake views directly across the road while being tucked away on a quiet dead-end road. With plenty of space and a peaceful setting, these parcels provide the perfect blend of privacy and convenience near the lake.

Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

Recently Sold

$293,000

Sold Aug 7, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,980 Sq Ft
3299 N 925 W

Delphi, IN
- 3% Above List
- 3 Days On Market
- $148/SF
- Current Est. Value $225K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$235,000

Sold Jul 6, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1,960 Sq Ft
1114 Maxwell Ave

Monticello, IN
- 2% Above List
- 4 Days On Market
- $120/SF
- Current Est. Value $229K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$209,900

Sold Jul 2, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,512 Sq Ft
4274 N Raccoon Cir

Monticello, IN
- 6 Days On Market
- $139/SF
- Current Est. Value $215K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$385,000

Sold Jul 2, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,880 Sq Ft
1509 Tioga Ravine

Monticello, IN
- 45 Days On Market
- $134/SF
- Current Est. Value $418K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$206,500

Sold Jun 29, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,904 Sq Ft
83 W 100 S

Reynolds, IN
- 3% Above List
- 24 Days On Market
- $108/SF
- Current Est. Value $198K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$225,000

Sold Jun 26, 2026
- 1 Bed
- 2 Baths
- 1,316 Sq Ft
318 N Beach Dr

Monticello, IN
- 2 Days On Market
- $171/SF
- Current Est. Value $224K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$185,000

Sold Jun 25, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,252 Sq Ft
12164 U S 421

Monticello, IN
- 3% Below List
- 16 Days On Market
- $148/SF
- Current Est. Value $235K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$183,000

Sold Jun 11, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,210 Sq Ft
11129 N Quiet Water Rd

Monticello, IN
- 5% Below List
- 3 Days On Market
- $151/SF
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

$250,000

Sold Jun 5, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,328 Sq Ft
310 E 12th St

Brookston, IN
- 3 Days On Market
- $188/SF
- Current Est. Value $248K
Garrett Criswell Raeco Realty

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors

Garrett Criswell

(574) 228-4339

Raeco Realty

(574) 228-4339

Homes for Sale by City

Garrett Criswell

About Garrett

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Garrett is Experienced In

Garrett's Listings and Deals

Garrett's Recent Active Listings

Recently Sold

Awards and Designations