Section Image

Johnathan Shirey

Gulf Coast International Prop
22 Closed Sales
$56.7M Total Value
$128K - $16M Price Range
$2.6M Average Price
Prior 5 years

About Johnathan

Originally from Canton, Ohio, Johnathan moved to Florida in 2003, beginning his career as an assistant to one of the country’s top agents before earning his own license and building a thriving business. Ranked as the #60 Agent by Volume in Naples in the 2025 RealTrends Verified rankings, Johnathan is recognized for his data-driven approach, forward-thinking strategies, and deep commitment to client education. A veteran Naples agent with more than 17 years of experience, Johnathan has built his career on understanding market cycles, analyzing monthly market statistics, and helping clients confidently navigate an ever-changing real estate landscape.

Johnathan’s philosophy is rooted in patience, active listening, and a client-first mindset. Known for his trusted monthly market reports, he provides clear, accurate insights while maintaining a calm, thoughtful presence throughout each transaction. Clients often describe him as a steady guide, never aggressive, always attentive, who makes the process smooth, informed, and enjoyable. His expertise spans downtown Naples, waterfront neighborhoods, and top country club communities, consistently placing him among the top 1% of agents in Naples, Florida, and nationwide.
With Johnathan, clients receive more than representation, they gain a knowledgeable advisor and dedicated partner committed to achieving their real estate goals.

When he’s not immersed in real estate, Johnathan enjoys spending time with his wife, working out, playing tennis, or traveling. A passionate skier, he frequents Aspen, Vail, and Jackson Hole, and visits international destinations. At home in North Naples, he also enjoys relaxing by the pool, spending time at the beach, and attending Porsche Club of America events.
Home Types: Condo, House
Years of Experience: 18

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Total Deals
1
Total Value
$425,000
Average Sale Price
$425,000

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
1
Total Value
$9,300,000
Average Sale Price
$9,300,000

Seller Deals

Total Deals
3
Total Value
$3,125,000
Average Sale Price
$1,041,667
Price Range
$425K - $2M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
2
Total Value
$25,300,000
Average Sale Price
$12,650,000
Price Range
$9.3M - $16M

Seller Deals

Total Deals
8
Total Value
$8,838,192
Average Sale Price
$1,104,774
Price Range
$395K - $2.2M

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
14
Total Value
$47,895,000
Average Sale Price
$3,421,071
Price Range
$128K - $16M

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Johnathan's Listings and Deals

Other Experience

Luxury Homes, New Construction
Agent License: Florida #NAPLES249519056
Agent Photo

Johnathan Shirey