Karen Ostermeier Real Estate Agent - Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

W5647 Forest Rd, Elkhorn, WI Under Contract $2,999,999 - listed by Karen Ostermeier — Under Contract $2,999,999

Karen Ostermeier listing agent for N7491 Bay Dr, Elkhorn, WI - sold for $625,000 — Sold $625,000

271 Fontana Blvd Unit 413, Fontana, WI Pending $440,000 - listed by Karen Ostermeier — Pending $440,000

Karen Ostermeier buyer's agent for N6640 Laural Rd, Elkhorn, WI - sold for $395,000 — Sold $395,000

W5368 Plantation Rd, Elkhorn, WI For Sale $1,525,000 - listed by Karen Ostermeier — For Sale $1,525,000

Karen Ostermeier

Responds Quickly

Lake Geneva WI

Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

63 Closed Sales

$48.9M Total Value

$12.5K - $3.9M Price Range

$775.6K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Karen

I have dedicated my career almost exclusively to helping people find the lake house or country estate of their dreams, specializing in second home real estate. I also know intimately what it is like to split one’s time between an Illinois primary home (I'm from Naperville) and that place “Up North” the home that you really can’t wait to get back to as fast as you can!

Home Types: Other, House, Lot/Land, Condo, Multifamily

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	6
Total Value	$3,350,000
Average Sale Price	$558,333
Price Range	$250K - $1.2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	10
Total Value	$10,437,700
Average Sale Price	$1,043,770
Price Range	$165K - $3.9M

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	13
Total Value	$10,100,000
Average Sale Price	$776,923
Price Range	$250K - $2.2M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	21
Total Value	$17,465,300
Average Sale Price	$831,681
Price Range	$13K - $3.9M

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	27
Total Value	$19,698,600
Average Sale Price	$729,578
Price Range	$95K - $2.6M

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	36
Total Value	$29,161,400
Average Sale Price	$810,039
Price Range	$13K - $3.9M

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Karen is Experienced In

Geneva National

2 Sales

Karen's Listings and Deals

Karen's Recent Active Listings

$1,525,000
- 5 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 3,960 Sq Ft
W5368 Plantation Rd

Elkhorn, WI
Rare opportunity on Lauderdale Lakes! Set on a 1.3 acre parcel w/218' of frontage, this property offers privacy and breathtaking views in a peaceful setting. Designed for making family memories, this 5BD, 4BA home features 2 FP's, an eat-in kitchen w/island, pantry and extra cabinetry. A spacious primary ste w/deck access and endless views. The open layout flows effortlessly to large covered deck

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$1,599,000
- 4 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 2,490 Sq Ft
W5510 Westshore Dr

Elkhorn, WI
Completely updated in 2000, this home is being sold turnkey and ready for Summer fun. This multi-level, multi-bedroom home offers peace of mind from day one and beyond. Located on Green Lake and within walking distance to the Landing lakeside restaurant. The main level open concept great rm invites you to gather around the quartz kitchen island, farmhouse sink and SS appliances flanked by the FTC

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$299,000
- Land
- 0.54 Acre
- $553,704 per Acre
Lt123 Oak Ln

Lauderdale Lakes, WI
First-time available: 2 adjacent waterfront lots on Lauderdale Lakes. Heavily wooded and sloping to peaceful, channel frontage. A sanctuary feel with birds and wildlife as your neighbors. There was once a pier here but only the pier posts remain. Buyer is responsible for all inspections and pier replacement and permits. Survey is in Documents tab. Both lots being sold together, as is.

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$65,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 583 Sq Ft
w 4945 County Road Es

Unit 126

Elkhorn, WI
Beautifully updated 2 bed, 1 bath Willow Run unit with addition, located on the largest, level lot in this seasonal RV community. Views of the pond with wildlife, tennis, and new pickleball courts, and no one across the street to block the view. 2017 Winnebago with full kitchen and island, dining area, and living room. Bath with a full-size shower, conveniently located near the bedroom and living

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$2,999,999

Under Contract
- 5 Beds
- 5 Baths
- 4,024 Sq Ft
W5647 Forest Rd

Elkhorn, WI
Rare opportunity to own this beautifully updated Lauderdale Lakes home offering 4,024SF on 1/3 wooded acre with 62' of prime swim frontage and spectacular water views. The dramatic 3 story great room is the centerpiece, with soaring windows and FTC fireplace that flows into the completely remodeled kitchen with island, dining table for 12 and showcasing breathtaking lake views. The home features

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$440,000

Pending
271 Fontana Blvd

Unit 413

Fontana, WI
Deep water boat slip #413 (AB 11x30) in exclusive Abbey Harbor, in beautiful Fontana. Enjoy all the harbor has to offer, including the Harbor House clubhouse bar with restrooms, shower facilities, and new covered Pavilion Bar overlooking the pool. Private members-only parking and walking distance to all Fontana has to offer, including restaurants, coffee shops, shopping, the public beach and The

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$1,449,000

Under Contract
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,216 Sq Ft
W5193 Sterlingworth Ct

Elkhorn, WI
This Lauderdale Lakes gem ticks all the boxes! Oozing with character this 3-bed, 2-bath (both remodeled) ranch with an open floor plan, cathedral ceiling and charming original hardwood floors has a beautiful stone FP in the great room, kitchen island cleverly concealing the washer/dryer, voice command lighting and a screened porch overlooking the beautiful, crystal clear spring fed waters of Mill

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$1,499,000

Pending
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,391 Sq Ft
211 3rd Ave

Fontana, WI
This masterfully created property in the heart of Fontana features 3BD's, 3BA's and cathedral ceilings but the true showstopper is the pub room for entertaining friends. The 4+ car heated garage is the ultimate spot to store your boat and lake toys. Outside, the fenced yard provides a private retreat or additional storage, while the elevated balcony offers panoramic views of the Abbey Harbor and

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$499,000

Under Contract
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,464 Sq Ft
W6093 Mariner Hills Trail

Elkhorn, WI
This move-in-ready 3 bed, 2.5-bath property was designed with family living in mind. With two spacious family rooms and a loft, there's plenty of room for everyone to spread out--whether it's movie nights, play space for the kids, or gathering with friends and family. Situated on a fenced, wooded .73 ac lot, the backyard offers a pool, garden beds, a shed and a safe place for children and pets to

Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

Recently Sold

$625,000

Sold May 22, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,674 Sq Ft
N7491 Bay Dr

Elkhorn, WI
- 4% Below List
- 50 Days On Market
- $234/SF
- Current Est. Value $622K
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$525,000

Sold Dec 23, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,180 Sq Ft
W5680 Ridge Rd

Elkhorn, WI
- 12% Below List
- 164 Days On Market
- $445/SF
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$1,200,000

Sold Sep 19, 2025
- 2,400 Sq Ft
N7656 State Park Rd

Whitewater, WI
- 4% Below List
- 26 Days On Market
- $500/SF
- Current Est. Value $1M
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$250,000

Sold Aug 8, 2025
- Land
- 0.43 Acres Lot
Lt27 North Dr

Lauderdale Lakes, WI
- 16% Below List
- 21 Days On Market
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$430,000

Sold Aug 5, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,128 Sq Ft
W5229 Surfwood Dr

Unit 3B

Elkhorn, WI
- 7% Below List
- 62 Days On Market
- $381/SF
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$320,000

Sold Jul 17, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,872 Sq Ft
N7094 Evergreen Ln

Elkhorn, WI
- 8% Below List
- 51 Days On Market
- $171/SF
- Current Est. Value $343K
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$1,050,000

Sold Oct 18, 2024
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,336 Sq Ft
W5706 North Dr

Elkhorn, WI
- 18% Below List
- 95 Days On Market
- $449/SF
- Current Est. Value $1M
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$550,000

Sold Oct 3, 2024
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,560 Sq Ft
W5721 Nine Indian Trail

Elkhorn, WI
- 15% Below List
- 78 Days On Market
- $215/SF
- Current Est. Value $587K
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

$335,000

Sold Sep 27, 2024
- 1 Bed
- 2 Baths
- 1,780 Sq Ft
N6889 Lakeshore Dr

Elkhorn, WI
- 12% Below List
- 48 Days On Market
- $188/SF
- Current Est. Value $320K
Karen Ostermeier Compass Wisconsin-Lake Geneva

Karen Ostermeier

(877) 475-1467

Responds Quickly

(877) 475-1467

Homes for Sale by City

Karen Ostermeier

About Karen

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Karen is Experienced In

Karen's Listings and Deals

Karen's Recent Active Listings

Recently Sold