Section Image
110 Sir Richard W Unit Lot 15, Kill Devil Hills, NC For Sale $550,000 - listed by Michelle Gardner
For Sale $550,000
Section Image
Michelle Gardner listing agent for 12 Croatan Ct Unit 12, Manteo, NC - sold for $255,965
Sold $255,965
0 Bayview Dr Unit 131251, Stumpy Point, NC For Sale $59,900 - listed by Michelle Gardner
For Sale $59,900
Section Image
Michelle Gardner buyer's agent for 130 Roanoke Dr Unit 110, Kill Devil Hills, NC - sold for $450,000
Sold $450,000
Michelle Gardner listing agent for 717 Fernando St Unit Lot 3, Manteo, NC - sold for $350,000
Sold $350,000
Michelle Gardner buyer's agent for 4151 Lindbergh Ave Unit Lot 12, Kitty Hawk, NC - sold for $400,000
Sold $400,000

Michelle Gardner

Nags Head NC
5.0stars, 15 Reviews
Resort Realty - NH
31 Closed Sales
$15.7M Total Value
$256K - $1.9M Price Range
$506.3K Average Price
Prior 5 years

About Michelle

I've been selling real estate for over 20 years, currently in Outer Banks NC, previously in PA & NJ. I strive to make smooth transactions for my customers buying or selling. Working for your best interest with experience, knowledge and enthusiatic attitude is what I do!
Building lasting relationships with clients that continue to refer me and call on me over the years is very rewarding.
It is a honor to be your Trusted Real Estate Broker!
Home Types: House, Condo, Lot/Land, MultiFamily
Years of Experience: 9
Education: Bullington County College

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Total Deals 6
Total Value $2,340,865
Average Sale Price $390,144
Price Range $256K - $575K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 4
Total Value $1,834,000
Average Sale Price $458,500
Price Range $400K - $535K

Seller Deals

Total Deals 8
Total Value $3,330,865
Average Sale Price $416,358
Price Range $256K - $575K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 9
Total Value $3,857,000
Average Sale Price $428,556
Price Range $81K - $587K

Seller Deals

Total Deals 12
Total Value $4,354,265
Average Sale Price $362,855
Price Range $80K - $575K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals 19
Total Value $11,339,500
Average Sale Price $596,816
Price Range $81K - $1.9M

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Michelle's Listings and Deals

Awards and Designations

  • NAR - National Association of Realtors

Michelle's Reviews

5.0stars, 15 Reviews

12/17/25Anthony Deal

Google Review

I had the pleasure of working with Michelle Gardner on a transaction where our clients were relocating from Virginia to coastal North Carolina, and she was exceptional from start to finish.

As a loan officer who works with agents across multiple markets, I can confidently say Michelle stands out. She played a key role in helping our clients find the right home for their needs while navigating a long-distance move with ease. Her local market knowledge, responsiveness, and attention to detail made the entire process smooth and stress-free.

Communication was consistent, timelines were met, and our clients felt supported every step of the way. Michelle was a true partner in getting them into the home they needed, and the outcome reflected her professionalism and dedication.

I would absolutely refer future clients to Michelle and highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling in coastal North Carolina.

8/17/20Kim Burton

Google Review

Michelle is the most educated and well rounded Realtor i have ever worked with. She really knows her stuff and has been doing this forever. If I was buying or selling i would want her on my side!

1/26/20David Irby

Google Review

Michelle is an excellent Realtor.. very easy to work with!

Agent License: North Carolina 293580
Agent Photo

Michelle Gardner

(252) 581-8266
(252) 581-8266

Homes for Sale by City