Michelle Shay Real Estate Agent - Coldwell Banker Realty

26 W Orange St, Lititz, PA For Sale $299,999 - listed by Michelle Shay — For Sale $299,999

Michelle Shay listing agent for 100 Glossbrenner Ave, Lebanon, PA - sold for $324,900 — Sold $324,900

312 Pennsylvania Ave, Mount Gretna, PA Pending $479,000 - listed by Michelle Shay — Pending $479,000

Michelle Shay buyer's agent for 100 4th St, Sharpsburg, PA - sold for $280,000 — Sold $280,000

216 Pennsylvania Ave, Mount Gretna, PA Pending $499,999 - listed by Michelle Shay — Pending $499,999

Michelle Shay

Lancaster PA

Coldwell Banker Realty

55 Closed Sales

$20.8M Total Value

$269.9K - $740K Price Range

$378.5K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Michelle

Michelle Shay is a Lancaster/Lebanon County Real Estate professional who has been Licensed since the beginning of 2010. She has had the opportunity to work with first home buyers, growing families, investors, and families that are relocating. All of these situations have provided her with a diverse set of skills and experience through a variety of challenges. She looks forward to putting these skill to work for you.

Whether you have been through the home buying/selling process before, or if this is your first experience, she is here to help! Real Estate is an ever changing industry and there are many reasons why it is important to have a professional working for you!

As a member of the Kevin Brown Team, Michelle believes that quality customer service, a good knowledge base and solid resources are what make buying or selling a home a positive experience. Contact Michelle today to begin your journey in finding a place to call home!

Home Types: Townhouse, House, Multifamily

Years of Experience: 14

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	13
Total Value	$5,040,539
Average Sale Price	$387,734
Price Range	$193K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	14
Total Value	$5,707,900
Average Sale Price	$407,707
Price Range	$249K - $740K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	24
Total Value	$8,688,539
Average Sale Price	$362,022
Price Range	$170K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	18
Total Value	$7,319,050
Average Sale Price	$406,614
Price Range	$235K - $740K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	29
Total Value	$10,512,540
Average Sale Price	$362,501
Price Range	$170K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	26
Total Value	$10,302,950
Average Sale Price	$396,267
Price Range	$235K - $740K

5 Year View

Areas Michelle is Experienced In

Michelle's Listings and Deals

Michelle's Active Listings

$299,999
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,420 Sq Ft
26 W Orange St

Lititz, PA
Experience the charm and convenience of Lititz Borough living! Welcome home to this well-maintained duplex. 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, hardwood flooring, efficient floor plan, a second-floor balcony, eat-in kitchen with a gas oven/range, first-floor laundry, new water heater, workshop area in the lower level, walk up attic, 2 porches, and a beautiful garden. PLUS... a detached garage for

Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$479,000

Pending
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,181 Sq Ft
312 Pennsylvania Ave

Mount Gretna, PA
Open House is Canceled***Welcome to 316 Pennsylvania Avenue in Mt. Gretna, a uniquely designed custom cottage with a wraparound porch that's sure to be the envy of the neighborhood. Generous in both size and personality, this charming home is ideally situated directly across from the tennis courts and park.The oversized primary suite showcases a distinctive turret space, a private

Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$499,999

Pending
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,168 Sq Ft
216 Pennsylvania Ave

Mount Gretna, PA
Prime Chautauqua location—be in the heart of it all! Located just across from the park. This charming 4-bedroom Mt. Gretna cottage offers off-street parking, a large wrap-around porch, high ceilings, exposed beams, beautiful original windows, and a custom built-in corner cabinet. Convenient first floor full bath with walk-in shower and laundry/mud room. All furnishings and appliances

Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

Recently Sold

$324,900

Sold Sep 1, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 917 Sq Ft
100 Glossbrenner Ave

Lebanon, PA
- 7% Below List
- 20 Days On Market
- $354/SF
- Current Est. Value $301K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$525,000

Sold Jul 31, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,200 Sq Ft
835 Verden Dr

Hummelstown, PA
- 5% Above List
- 3 Days On Market
- $239/SF
- Current Est. Value $492K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$649,900

Sold Jul 30, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 2,250 Sq Ft
2401 S Lincoln Ave

Lebanon, PA
- 2 Days On Market
- $289/SF
- Current Est. Value $489K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$400,000

Sold Jul 17, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,052 Sq Ft
411 2nd St

Mount Gretna, PA
- 10% Above List
- 2 Days On Market
- $380/SF
- Current Est. Value $314K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$480,000

Sold Jun 30, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,006 Sq Ft
419 Lancaster Ave

Mount Gretna, PA
- 25% Above List
- 3 Days On Market
- $239/SF
- Current Est. Value $452K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$454,930

Sold May 19, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,698 Sq Ft
210 Harvard Ave

Mount Gretna, PA
- 3% Below List
- 7 Days On Market
- $268/SF
- Current Est. Value $461K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$379,900

Sold May 8, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,344 Sq Ft
631 S Broad St

Lititz, PA
- 11 Days On Market
- $283/SF
- Current Est. Value $370K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$322,000

Sold Jan 27, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,341 Sq Ft
541 E Guilford St

Lebanon, PA
- 1% Above List
- 8 Days On Market
- $138/SF
- Current Est. Value $329K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

$281,509

Sold Nov 19, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,320 Sq Ft
28 Brookview Dr

Lititz, PA
- 4 Days On Market
- $213/SF
- Current Est. Value $296K
Michelle Shay Coldwell Banker Realty

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors

Agent License: Pennsylvania RS314644

Michelle Shay

(717) 454-2440

Nearby Homes

Michelle Shay

About Michelle

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Areas Michelle is Experienced In

Michelle's Listings and Deals

Michelle's Active Listings

Recently Sold

Awards and Designations