Nathaniel Bennett Real Estate Agent - F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

945 Jameson Ct, New Castle, IN For Sale $198,500 - listed by Nathaniel Bennett — For Sale $198,500

Nathaniel Bennett listing agent for 3198 S Crestview Dr, New Castle, IN - sold for $175,000 — Sold $175,000

427 N 20th St, New Castle, IN For Sale $130,000 - listed by Nathaniel Bennett — For Sale $130,000

Nathaniel Bennett buyer's agent for 2313 E Cornell Ave, Muncie, IN - sold for $113,000 — Sold $113,000

9148 S County Road 675 E, Cambridge City, IN Pending $150,000 - listed by Nathaniel Bennett — Pending $150,000

Nathaniel Bennett

New Castle IN

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

88 Closed Sales

$18.3M Total Value

$67.5K - $750K Price Range

$207.6K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Nathaniel

Nathan is a lifelong resident of Henry County. He was raised by parents who taught him the value of home ownership. Even before HGTV was a thing, they did their part to elevate the neighborhoods they lived in by buying the worst home in a neighborhood and renovating it for resale and repeating this cycle every few years.
A married man with a family of his own now, Nathan and his wife have chosen to stay in Henry County to create the same quality of life he grew up in. Nathan’s career path into real estate has been a winding but rewarding road. A professional musician for over fifteen years, Nathan’s musical career culminated in touring the US and Europe with The Elms. Highlights of this part of his life includes playing at Farm Aid by invite of John Mellencamp and many live appearances on the Q95 Bob and Tom show. A cycling accident resulting in a broken wrist acquainted Nathan with the unique and transformative gifts of physical therapy and so after completing his training, he has worked as a Physical Therapy Assistant at Henry Community Health at Forest Ridge for the last 7 years.
His move to F.C. Tucker is an outcome of his life’s experiences and a dedication to continue to serve the community and surrounding areas that have supported him. He looks forward to sharing his love of real estate with you by managing the details so you can simply feel comfortable and confident in the process.

Home Types: Commercial, House, Mobile Homes, Lot/Land, Condo, Multifamily

Years of Experience: 4

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	16
Total Value	$4,136,000
Average Sale Price	$258,500
Price Range	$118K - $600K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	15
Total Value	$4,259,400
Average Sale Price	$283,960
Price Range	$50K - $750K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	25
Total Value	$5,204,900
Average Sale Price	$208,196
Price Range	$40K - $600K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	21
Total Value	$5,222,300
Average Sale Price	$248,681
Price Range	$50K - $750K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	43
Total Value	$8,532,865
Average Sale Price	$198,439
Price Range	$5K - $600K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	45
Total Value	$9,739,900
Average Sale Price	$216,442
Price Range	$4K - $750K

5 Year View

Areas Nathaniel is Experienced In

New Castle

47 Sales
Muncie

9 Sales
Southside

3 Sales
Ashland-Millville

3 Sales
Middletown

3 Sales
Pendleton

3 Sales

Nathaniel's Listings and Deals

Nathaniel's Active Listings

$198,500
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,304 Sq Ft
945 Jameson Ct

New Castle, IN
Classic brick, comfortable living, and a peaceful setting-945 Jameson Ct. has all the essentials of a wonderful place to call home. Located in the quiet Jameson Court neighborhood, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath brick ranch offers 1,304 square feet of practical, easy-to-enjoy living space. The home features a comfortable layout with three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, providing flexibility for

Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

$130,000
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 864 Sq Ft
427 N 20th St

New Castle, IN
A private setting, an inviting front porch, and more space than you might expect—427 N. 20th St. is full of pleasant surprises. This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home sits on a generous .60-acre lot surrounded by mature trees, creating a peaceful setting with an impressive amount of privacy. Inside, the open floor plan gives the main living area a comfortable, connected feel that’s well suited for everyday

Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$240,000
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 2,186 Sq Ft
1208 Woodlawn Dr

New Castle, IN
Some have character. Others have location. This one has both. Nestled on one of New Castle's most beloved streets, this charming 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers 2,186 square feet of timeless appeal. Woodlawn Drive winds through a canopy of mature trees and classic homes, making it one of the city's most desirable addresses. A beautiful old-fashioned covered front porch welcomes you home. It's the

Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$150,000

Pending
- 4 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 2,158 Sq Ft
9148 S County Road 675 E

Cambridge City, IN
Acreage, outbuildings, and plenty of potential. Situated on 3.6 acres near Cambridge City, this property offers a rare combination of land, space, and substantial outbuildings. The 2,158-square-foot farmhouse features four bedrooms and one bathroom, along with a detached 2-car garage. Additional structures include two large barns measuring approximately 60' x 40' and 55' x 40', plus a 60' x 20'

Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$220,000

Pending
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,744 Sq Ft
1857 N County Road 300 W

New Castle, IN
Welcome to 1857 N. 300 W.! Nestled on a spacious .75-acre lot in the Shenandoah School District, this well-maintained home offers 1,744 square feet of comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath. Step inside to find a large living area that's perfect for gathering with family and friends, along with an inviting eat-in kitchen that serves as the heart of the home. The functional

Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

Recently Sold

$175,000

Sold Sep 22, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,716 Sq Ft
3198 S Crestview Dr

New Castle, IN
- 9% Above List
- 1 Day On Market
- $102/SF
- Current Est. Value $227K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

$117,800

Sold Sep 22, 2026
- 2 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1,296 Sq Ft
3622 N Lakeside Dr

Muncie, IN
- 2% Below List
- 75 Days On Market
- $91/SF
- Current Est. Value $121K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

$255,000

Sold Sep 9, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,828 Sq Ft
911 Phyllis Dr

New Castle, IN
- 4% Above List
- 5 Days On Market
- $139/SF
- Current Est. Value $267K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$205,000

Sold Aug 7, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,328 Sq Ft
3049 Brentwood Rd

New Castle, IN
- 10 Days On Market
- $154/SF
- Current Est. Value $201K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$175,000

Sold Jul 24, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,372 Sq Ft
1617 Plymouth Dr

New Castle, IN
- 12% Below List
- 75 Days On Market
- $128/SF
- Current Est. Value $175K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$424,900

Sold May 26, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,778 Sq Ft
3400 Roberta St

New Castle, IN
- 4 Days On Market
- $153/SF
- Current Est. Value $432K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$310,000

Sold May 19, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,560 Sq Ft
106 N County Road 200 E

Connersville, IN
- 9% Below List
- 29 Days On Market
- $121/SF
- Current Est. Value $309K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$137,500

Sold Dec 1, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 788 Sq Ft
2720 E Fairoaks Dr

New Castle, IN
- 2% Above List
- 0 Days On Market
- $174/SF
- Current Est. Value $150K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

$164,900

Sold Nov 21, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,255 Sq Ft
508 Cedar Dr

New Castle, IN
- 1 Day On Market
- $131/SF
- Current Est. Value $179K
Nathaniel Bennett F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Nathaniel Bennett, and what is their real estate background?

How many homes has Nathaniel Bennett sold in New Castle, IN?

What is Nathaniel Bennett's track record representing buyers?

What is Nathaniel Bennett's track record as a listing agent?

What areas does Nathaniel Bennett serve?

How can I contact Nathaniel Bennett?

Nathaniel Bennett

(765) 575-9473

Nearby Homes

Nathaniel Bennett

About Nathaniel

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Areas Nathaniel is Experienced In

Nathaniel's Listings and Deals

Nathaniel's Active Listings

Recently Sold

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Nathaniel Bennett, and what is their real estate background?

How many homes has Nathaniel Bennett sold in New Castle, IN?

What is Nathaniel Bennett's track record representing buyers?

What is Nathaniel Bennett's track record as a listing agent?

What areas does Nathaniel Bennett serve?

How can I contact Nathaniel Bennett?