









About Nicolas
I believe in Elkhart County. I believe in our future. I volunteer as a mentor at local schools, and as a coach for several youth programs.
I have two Bachelor's Degrees. Business Administration from Manchester College in 2002, and History from Indiana University in 2010. My passion for education comes through in my attention to detail for my clients.
I was born and raised in Middlebury, and still call it home today. You will see me at many local events, especially home basketball and football games! I love the people in this area. My neighbors are my friends.
Transaction History
- 1 Year
- 2 Year
- 5 Year
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
1 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
2 Year View by Quarter
Seller Deals
Buyer Deals
Production Over Time
5 Year View
Neighborhoods Nicolas Has the Most Experience In
Nicolas' Listings and Deals
Nicolas's Recent Active Listings
-
$649,900
- 5 Beds
- 3.5 Baths
- 4,239 Sq Ft
- 13562 Shavano Peak Dr
- Middlebury, IN
*OPEN HOUSE, Thursday, June 19, 4-7pm* Located in The Summit, one of Middlebury's most prestigious communities, this 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath home sits on a beautifully landscaped 1+ acre lot. Nearly every detail is custom, from the cabinetry to the stone countertops. The main level includes a spacious primary suite, laundry, home office, and a dual-sided gas fireplace connecting the living and hearth
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$800,000
- TBD County Road 23
- Bristol, IN
Discover the perfect blend of beauty, utility, and seclusion on this stunning 28.84-acre parcel in Bristol. Featuring approximately 22.84 acres of mature hardwood forest enrolled in a classified forest designation for significant property tax savings, this land offers unmatched natural serenity. Enjoy a fully stocked pond ideal for fishing or relaxing by the water’s edge, plus an additional
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$1,515,000
- 5 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 3,289 Sq Ft
- 55960 County Road 23
- Bristol, IN
Prepare to be amazed by this beautifully updated 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom home nestled on 9 scenic acres, with an additional 28+ acres of serene woodland, restored prairie, and a fully stocked pond. Inside, you’ll find a finished walkout basement, a flexible floorplan, and a closet upstairs already plumbed for a potential fourth bathroom. Enjoy your mornings on the aluminum deck overlooking nature,
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$325,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,472 Sq Ft
- 721 Highland Dr
- Middlebury, IN
Here’s your opportunity to own an affordable, well-maintained home in the highly desirable Highland Hills subdivision in Middlebury. This 3-bedroom, 2-bath home includes hardwood floors, a bright sunroom, and a deck overlooking the backyard—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The main level includes laundry for added convenience, while the finished basement provides extra living space with a
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$375,000
- 5 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,768 Sq Ft
- 13043 County Road 14
- Middlebury, IN
Enjoy the charm of rural living just minutes from downtown Middlebury in this nicely updated 5-bedroom, 3-bath home on 1.5 peaceful acres. Featuring a fully finished basement and spacious layout, this home offers the flexibility and room you’ve been looking for. The kitchen boasts modern updates, and both levels offer full laundry hookups for added convenience. The oversized garage provides
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$313,000
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,420 Sq Ft
- 67625 Alesha Way
- Millersburg, IN
Stylish and efficient modern two-story home with smart use of space and thoughtful design. Main level features hardwood flooring in the living area, a convenient half bath, with a kitchen that opens to the eat in dining area and tiered backyard trex deck/patio for summer BBQs. All bedrooms are located upstairs alongside the laundry room—no hauling baskets up and down stairs! Lower level includes
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$1,100,000
- 6 Beds
- 5 Baths
- 4,834 Sq Ft
- 58859 Sun Gold Blvd
- Goshen, IN
Start Showing Date: 5/27/2025 New life has been breathed into this beautifully remodeled 6 Bedroom Ranch Estate on 13+ acres in Jefferson Township. Thoughtfully updated throughout, the home features an open-concept kitchen and living area with granite countertops and modern appliances—perfect for gathering and entertaining. The primary suite is a true retreat, complete with a luxurious spa-like
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$699,900
- 3 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,330 Sq Ft
- 17699 County Road 112
- Bristol, IN
Discover peaceful country living with modern amenities in this beautifully designed 3-bedroom, 3-bath home on nearly 8 acres of land. Nestled in a scenic rural setting, this property offers the perfect blend of privacy, space, and functionality. Inside, you'll find an open-concept main level featuring a spacious kitchen with granite countertops, stainless appliances, and ample cabinetry. The
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
-
$715,000
- 5 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 3,289 Sq Ft
- 55960 County Road 23
- Bristol, IN
Prepare to be impressed by this one-of-a-kind country escape! Nestled on 9 peaceful acres, this 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom home blends quality craftsmanship with modern comfort in a serene natural setting. Enjoy a fully finished walkout basement, an expansive aluminum deck for outdoor living, and a flexible floorplan perfect for everyday life or entertaining. Stay cozy year-round with a
Nicolas Wyse RE/MAX Results-Goshen
Awards and Designations
- 100% Club, 2013-2015
- Chairman's Club 2017
- Executive Club, 2012
- Hall of Fame
- Lifetime Achievement
- Platinum Club, 2016, 2018-2022
- RE/MAX Hall of Fame
- RE/MAX Lifetime Achievement
- NAR - National Association of Realtors
- e–PRO - Internet Professional
- green - Green Designation
Other Experience
Nicolas' Reviews
3/3/22Karen LaChance
Google Review
Nic Wyse was very personable and helpful when selling my property in December. He has great knowledge of the selling process. I recommend him for any real estate transaction. He is a pleasure to work with.
2/27/22Tim Mast
Google Review
2/22/22Todd Miller
Google Review
2/22/22Hannah Berkey
Google Review
Very helpful with the process of buying a home!!
2/22/22Amy S
Google Review
Selling my home was the biggest decision I had ever made. I had a tremendous amount of emotions about it, but from the very first meeting, Nic handled everything so thoughtfully that I immediately knew I was in great hands. Not only did I feel at ease, but it also became fun and something I was really excited about. I had no idea how long it would take to sell even in a strong sellers market because my home was one that needed the perfect buyer. I also had no idea what purchasing a home may look like. Within a week, I had found the perfect home for me that Nic negotiated a very fair price for, and I sold for exactly what I wanted. There were several hiccups before closing that Nic always communicated with me but handled every single one of them. I closed on both homes exactly when I planned on and was able to move without any issues. I am so grateful for the experience and wouldn’t change a thing.
2/22/22Jacob Berkey
Google Review
Nic was very helpful during the entire process, would highly recommend!
2/21/22Emily Wogomon
Google Review
Nicolas Wyse at RE/MAX helped my husband and I sell our old house and buy a new one. He was very helpful, patient, respectful, professional, flexible, and punctual. He answered all of our questions and was always just a phone call, text, or email away! We would recommend him to all of our friends and family!
2/21/22Ashley Foreman
Google Review
Nic is truly the best. We had our first connection with him when we bought last home back in 2012 and just got connected with him by an online click. When we went to sell our home last year, we were open to other realtors and made contact with one but she proved not to be helpful at all and decided to reach out to Nic again. I am sure glad we did! Not only did he respond quickly, but he gave us data and guided us in the direction to get the most "bang for our buck". Nic always responded to messages quickly and if he did not know an answer he got back to us when he had it. Nic is very knowledgeable in the real estate industry and we felt very comfortable knowing that our home was in great hands and were were getting what we deserved. Our home ended up selling for more than asking price (and in less than 2 days), sure the housing market might be most of that but without Nic's help we would not have gotten to that point. If you are in need of a Real Estate agent, look no further! Nic is a genuine, down to earth person and we are so very appreciative of his help. We will refer everyone his way!
2/20/22Donald Greer
Google Review
2/18/22Mark S
Google Review
2/18/22Eric Schrock
Google Review
2/18/22Laverne Miller
Google Review
Nic Wise has been a huge help in finding real estate for our family, over the last 6 years! If you are looking for a real estate agent he is the best!
8/27/21Kenneth Grover
Google Review
8/21/21r Wildrick
Google Review
Nic made buying a house so easy. He was ready and available to help us with any question we may have had. When things went sideways he found a way to make it work. I would highly recommend Nic to anyone looking to buy a home.
8/21/21Sherry Hanson
Google Review
Nic could not have been better…very quick response when I had a question. Highly recommend!
7/19/21Jake Bell
Google Review
We used Nic when we moved 1100 miles away and needed to get our house sold. It was a long process, as we had some hiccups with the home along the way. Nic was patient, he worked hard for us, and was a reliable and calming voice when frustrations were high on our end. It was stressful trying to sell a house long distance, but knowing that we had someone back in Indiana that we could rely on and get advice from was a great help!
I would highly recommend Nic if you're looking for someone that will work hard for you, and be that voice of reason during the stressful process of home buying/selling!
7/19/21Nate Brown
Google Review
Did what he said he could. Communication was awesome! Highly recommend.
7/18/21Karina Wagner
Google Review
7/17/21Julie Eslinger
Google Review
Nic has helped me close on two transactions. He saw the value in the house I sold in 2015 and listed it higher than other realtors were going to. Better yet, it sold for full asking price during a time where the market wasn’t as high as it is now. He also helped us secure a house in 2018 when the market was high. The house we purchased had multiple offers within 24 hours of going to market so speed and accuracy was necessary. We could count on Nic to get everything completed timely and correctly. He also connected us with loan officers that were willing to complete things over the weekend to make sure the deal went through. We would use Nic again from both the buying and selling side.
7/14/21Joanna Shoufler
Google Review
7/10/21John Culp
Google Review
Nic was an excellent realtor for us. The seller wanted a private sale and Nic was amazing as our agent. He went above and beyond to make sure we understood everything and he made our experience effortless. The hardest part of our experience was saying goodbye to Nic! I miss our daily showings with him, lol.
7/9/21Michael
Google Review
Great guy to work with goes above and beyond to get job done!
7/9/21John Lane
Google Review
Nic was great to work with. He responded quickly to every question I asked and was willing to go the extra mile. I highly recommend Nic if you are trying to sell or purchase.
7/8/21Jeremiah Grubert
Google Review
Nic is professional and very responsive to his clients needs. He helped me with the sale of my home in the past and sold it very quickly above list price.
7/8/21Scott Dornseif
Google Review
Nic was great to work with. We were buying a summer home "remotely" and Nic was instrumental in this process. Very understanding and communicative. Nic did video walk throughs of homes we were interested in and so helpful in finding what we now love. MORE IMPORTANTLY, Nic knows the business and directed us with the best options for making offers in a really hot market. In such a competitive market Nic made our offer acceptance a reality when we normally would have been last considered, due to not being local to the sale. I would very much recommend Nic whether you are selling, buying or both.
7/7/21Rex Gleim
Google Review
Nic was easy to work with, pleasant and personable. He sold our house in a reasonable time and there were no problems either during or after the sale.
7/6/21Ryan Weinzetl
Google Review
Diligent, honest, straight forward, great communication. Overall buying process wasn't as stressful as some say it is. The selling agent and the sellers, slowed things down. Nick was punctual and kept me in the loop from day 1.
7/6/21Pam Templeton
Google Review
It was a pleasure working with Nic. I so appreciated him taking care of details! Took the stress out of selling my home.
7/6/21Karl Creech
Google Review
My experience.... A realtor is similar to an attorney when you’re trying to find a home.
Several years ago, I was in that position. Everywhere I turned, was met with denial and frustration. About 8 months and 7 homes later. My wife and I found what we thought could be our home. But just like the other 7, we were met with deception and what I believe was discrimination. Being we are a biracial family. The realtor took my offer (never turned it in to the bank)and told me later that there was a higher offer. Knowing that I had excellent credit, a substantial down payment, preapproval from the best mortgage lender . Made me really scratch my head. Three months went by and a coworker told me that the property was on the market again. I called the realtor again.He would not return my calls. That’s when I called " The Nicholas Cage”. I told him about the property and what I thought about the realtor. Being the man that he is, he said that the realtor was probably just doing his job. That I may just be paranoid from my past experiences. Later we went to look at the property with Nicolas. Where he quickly figured out that I was right. This realtor didn’t want me to buy the property. What did Nicolas do??? Went around the realtor and straight to the owning bank and submitted my offer , which was quickly excepted. My family and I have been living in what we feel is paradise ever since. I strongly believe that it wouldn’t have been possible without Nicolas.
If you need a real realtor with a no nonsense approach, that will have your best interest at heart.... Nicolas Wise is that realtor. If you want someone that’s going to talk and act like a pro but leave you in the dark.... you’ll need to call someone else!!!
7/5/21Marcus Eicher
Google Review
7/5/21Lynn Blyly
Google Review
7/5/21Tim Risner
Google Review
7/5/21Laura Keil
Google Review
7/5/21Kayla Wall
Google Review
Absolutely fantastic! Prompt and professional yet down to earth. Helped us find a home that met every single one of our needs. Sold our house and made sure we were able to close both houses the same day. Highly recommend Nicolas Wyse.
7/5/21Julie Roth
Google Review
We had a great experience working with Nic, both in selling our home and purchasing a new one. He’s professional and does everything in a timely manner.
7/5/21Scott M
Google Review
Nic is very good at his job and did a great job keeping us informed and fast to respond and get with other agents. He will be our realtor whenever we need one.
7/5/21Todd Lederman
Google Review
We enjoyed working with Nic Wyse on several residential & commercial projects. He displayed honesty & integrity with all of our interactions with him. Nic is an excellent communicator & was always willing to listen to our questions & ideas. We would be quick to recommend him to others & use him again!
7/2/21Cindy Ritchie
Google Review
Nic sold our house in a week! Responds quickly to calls or messages.
7/2/21Desiree Latisnere
Google Review
7/2/21Gene Shirk
Google Review
We would highly recommend Nic. He is very professional and works hard to make the transaction as smooth as possible.
7/2/21Haley Ridenour
Google Review
7/1/21Greg Ritchie
Google Review
6/29/21Gregg Bell
Google Review
6/29/21Bob Roth
Google Review
6/29/21Dustin Diller
Google Review
Nic was instrumental in selling our home and helping us purchase our current home. He was responsive to our requirements and extremely professional. We would certainly place our first call to Nic when considering our next real estate transaction!
6/27/21Chadd Croy
Google Review
Nick found us our dream home. Thanks a lot nick for everything you did for us
6/27/21Charles Bradshaw
Google Review
6/27/21Chad Dilday
Google Review
Nic was fantastic from start to finish with the purchase of our new house! He took the time to answer any questions we had. On several occasions he met us at the house on short notice and on our time schedule. Very personable and friendly. We can’t thank him enough for the professional and friendly service we received.
6/27/21Erik Weiss
Google Review
Work with Nic to sell a property in Middlebury. Even though I live hours away Nic made the whole process seamless. Nic was very attentive, never once did he not get right back to me and kept me in the loop through the whole process. I would highly recommend Nic on your next property transaction.
6/27/21Debora Winn
Google Review
You did a great job Nic! Sold our home in 3 days. Very professional and made it very easy for us. I would recommend you to anyone looking to sell or buy a home. Great Job!!
6/27/21Chee Hong Choong
Google Review
6/27/21Charlene Eslinger
Google Review
Nic provided excellent service in selling our personal home as well as an estate home. He listened and worked diligently In structuring each sale. His recommendations and advice were based on full knowledge if the real estate market.
6/27/21Brittany Urrutia
Google Review
Great experience with buying and selling our home! It was a smooth process. Nic made sure to take good care of us through everything!
8/14/20Adam Flick
Google Review
Excellent experience with selling our property and purchasing a new place!

