Nicole Mathew Real Estate Agent - RE/MAX Executives

1111 N Mckinley Ave, Rensselaer, IN For Sale $79,500 - listed by Nicole Mathew — For Sale $79,500

Nicole Mathew listing agent for Tbd S 250 W, Beaver Township, IN - sold for $194,900 — Sold $194,900

2538 S 388 W, Morocco, IN For Sale $387,900 - listed by Nicole Mathew — For Sale $387,900

Nicole Mathew buyer's agent for 570 E Amsler Rd, Rensselaer, IN - sold for $260,000 — Sold $260,000

348 W 300 S, Rensselaer, IN Pending $240,000 - listed by Nicole Mathew — Pending $240,000

Nicole Mathew

DeMotte IN

RE/MAX Executives

78 Closed Sales

$14.2M Total Value

$97.5K - $450K Price Range

$181.9K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Nicole

I have worked in both mortgage lending and real estate in the Jasper County, Indiana area. My objectives are to market properties utilizing sound planning, professional ethics, and a strong company support system. Real Estate transactions can become complicated and frustrating. When selecting a Realtor to represent you, it is important they know the market and understand the many steps involved and keeps things as simple as possible. Our customers at Preferred Group Realtors become our friends and we take great pleasure in providing the very best of service to them and their families. As a resident of Jasper County for over 16 years, I am very familiar with the schools, service, and business in the state, as well as the social and recreational establishments. Nothing gives me more enjoyment than helping a customer have a satisfying and successful real estate transaction. I look forward to meeting and serving you!

Home Types: Lot/Land, House, Mobile Homes, Commercial

Years of Experience: 11

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	8
Total Value	$1,842,700
Average Sale Price	$230,338
Price Range	$65K - $450K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	8
Total Value	$1,851,700
Average Sale Price	$231,463
Price Range	$180K - $300K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	14
Total Value	$3,024,500
Average Sale Price	$216,036
Price Range	$65K - $450K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	21
Total Value	$4,043,900
Average Sale Price	$192,567
Price Range	$26K - $300K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	47
Total Value	$8,534,900
Average Sale Price	$181,594
Price Range	$25K - $450K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	31
Total Value	$5,650,800
Average Sale Price	$182,284
Price Range	$8K - $360K

5 Year View

Areas Nicole is Experienced In

Nicole's Listings and Deals

Nicole's Active Listings

$79,500
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,340 Sq Ft
1111 N Mckinley Ave

Rensselaer, IN
LOOK AT WHAT IT COULD BE! She may not be winning any beauty contests yet, but give her some attention and she could be a showstopper! This 1340 sq. ft. fixer-upper is waiting for a glow-up. It's the opportunity for an investor, renovator, or buyer looking to create a home tailored to their own style. The home is being offered in its current condition and will require updates and improvements.

Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$387,900
- 4 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,144 Sq Ft
2538 S 388 W

Morocco, IN
Privacy, space, and timeless character come together in this exceptional 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home nestled against a picturesque wooded backdrop. Designed with soaring cathedral ceilings and inviting living spaces, this home offers the perfect balance of comfort and style. The impressive great room welcomes you with dramatic vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, and a floor-to-ceiling brick

Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$299,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,792 Sq Ft
320 S Cullen St

Rensselaer, IN
Life is sweeter at 320 S Cullen! 2-story gem featuring a stunning kitchen that truly serves as the heart of the home. Stylish finishes, ample cabinetry, and plenty of counter space for cooking, gathering, and entertaining. The main floor offers a full bathroom for added flexibility and convenience. Upstairs, you'll find three comfortable bedrooms along with a second full bath that includes the

Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$225,000
- Land
- 2.1 Acres
- $107,143 per Acre
0 N Melville St

Rensselaer, IN
8 Prime City Lots - Ideal for New Construction Seize the opportunity to own 8 city lots, perfectly situated in a highly desirable location, ideal for your next development project. This expansive property offers the space and potential to bring your vision to life, with city utilities readily available for easy connection. These lots are being sold as a single package and will not be divided,

Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$308,000
- Land
- 6 Acres
- $55,000 per Acre
1130 W Clark St

Rensselaer, IN
Exceptional 5.6-Acre Commercial Parcel! This property offers unmatched flexibility and a prime location to capitalize on market demand. Whether you're a developer, investor, or entrepreneur, this is a rare opportunity to secure a significant piece of commercial real estate in a sought-after area.

Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$240,000

Pending
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,610 Sq Ft
348 W 300 S

Rensselaer, IN
Escape to the simplicity of country living! Set on 1.52 peaceful acres, this classic 1.5-story farmhouse is ready for its next chapter. Inside, you'll find three upstairs bedrooms, a full bath on the main level, living room, and dining room highlighted by original hardwood flooring that reflects the home's character. Step outside and enjoy wide-open space and take in the quiet countryside. If

Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

Recently Sold

$279,900

Sold Aug 31, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,520 Sq Ft
716 E Stewart Dr

Rensselaer, IN
- 8% Below List
- 130 Days On Market
- $111/SF
- Current Est. Value $278K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$194,900

Sold Aug 28, 2026
- Land
- 11.00 Acres Lot
Tbd S 250 W

Beaver Township, IN
- 16% Below List
- 39 Days On Market
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$450,000

Sold Apr 3, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2.5 Baths
- 2,897 Sq Ft
1245 W Mt Calvary Rd

Rensselaer, IN
- 8% Below List
- 7 Days On Market
- $155/SF
- Current Est. Value $458K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$65,000

Sold Mar 27, 2026
- Land
- 4.85 Acres Lot
tbd 400 S

Knox, IN
- 19% Below List
- 24 Days On Market
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$132,000

Sold Mar 20, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,321 Sq Ft
710 W Charles St

Rensselaer, IN
- 12% Below List
- 3 Days On Market
- $100/SF
- Current Est. Value $165K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$254,900

Sold Mar 6, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 1,768 Sq Ft
326 S Home Ave

Rensselaer, IN
- 2% Above List
- 5 Days On Market
- $144/SF
- Current Est. Value $250K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$196,000

Sold Feb 24, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,288 Sq Ft
821 E Merritt St

Rensselaer, IN
- 11% Below List
- 113 Days On Market
- $152/SF
- Current Est. Value $194K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$270,000

Sold Jul 11, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,782 Sq Ft
3533 N 400 W

Winamac, IN
- 134 Days On Market
- $152/SF
- Current Est. Value $195K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

$160,000

Sold Mar 18, 2025
- 2 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 1,022 Sq Ft
325 S Weston St

Rensselaer, IN
- 6% Below List
- 164 Days On Market
- $157/SF
- Current Est. Value $166K
Nicole Mathew RE/MAX Executives

Awards and Designations

NAR - National Association of Realtors

Other Experience

First Time Homebuyers, Investments, Luxury Homes, Property Management, Foreclosures

Nicole Mathew

(219) 964-0935

Nearby Homes

Nicole Mathew

About Nicole

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Areas Nicole is Experienced In

Nicole's Listings and Deals

Nicole's Active Listings

Recently Sold

Awards and Designations

Other Experience