1605 Orange Ave W, Tallahassee, FL For Sale $225,000 - co-listed by Paul Fenstermaker — For Sale $225,000 • Co-Listing Agent

Paul Fenstermaker co-listing agent for 2517 Old Bainbridge Rd, Tallahassee, FL - sold for $350,000 — Sold $350,000 • Co-Listing Agent

2420 Fred Smith Rd, Tallahassee, FL For Sale $399,000 - listed by Paul Fenstermaker — For Sale $399,000

Paul Fenstermaker buyer's agent for 5751 Cypress Cir, Tallahassee, FL - sold for $245,000 — Sold $245,000

76 Harley Davidson Ln, Crawfordville, FL Under Contract $350,000 - co-listed by Paul Fenstermaker — Under Contract $350,000 • Co-Listing Agent

Paul Fenstermaker listing agent for 2128 Little River Ln, Tallahassee, FL - sold for $234,000 — Sold $234,000

5075 Water Valley Dr, Tallahassee, FL For Sale $265,000 - co-listed by Paul Fenstermaker — For Sale $265,000 • Co-Listing Agent

Paul Fenstermaker

114 Closed Sales

$31.4M Total Value

$160K - $650K Price Range

$275.4K Average Price

Prior 5 years

About Paul

Home Types: Multifamily, House, Condo, Townhouse, Lot/Land, Mobile Homes

Years of Experience: 4

Transaction History

1 Year
2 Year
5 Year

Seller Deals
Total Deals	20
Total Value	$5,926,050
Average Sale Price	$296,303
Price Range	$85K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	13
Total Value	$4,284,627
Average Sale Price	$329,587
Price Range	$130K - $562K

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	30
Total Value	$8,725,550
Average Sale Price	$290,852
Price Range	$85K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	26
Total Value	$8,519,527
Average Sale Price	$327,674
Price Range	$130K - $562K

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals
Total Deals	51
Total Value	$13,545,850
Average Sale Price	$265,605
Price Range	$48K - $650K

Buyer Deals
Total Deals	63
Total Value	$17,844,427
Average Sale Price	$283,245
Price Range	$30K - $640K

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Paul is Experienced In

Paul's Listings and Deals

Paul's Recent Active Listings

$399,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 2,144 Sq Ft
2420 Fred Smith Rd

Tallahassee, FL
Ready for your multi-family development! 1.6 acres in tremendous location. Brick home is somewhat dilapidated, but could be renovated and made nice. Suggested highest & best use is potential for 6 quads, or up to 26 townhomes or condos. Initial discussions with city have been started, inquire for more details. Home is occupied, please schedule tour if desired.

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$250,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,344 Sq Ft
2519 Hastings Dr

Tallahassee, FL
NEW ROOF! Clean inspection reports available. Ask about seller-paid rate buydown. This 3 bed 2 bath home has much to love. Spacious open floorplan with abundant counter space, for the cooking, the hosting, and the kids craft projects. Did we mention hardwood floors throughout? Recently updated bathrooms with custom tile and new vanities. All new insulated vinyl windows, and spray foam insulation

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$225,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,250 Sq Ft
1605 Orange Ave W

Tallahassee, FL
Active AirBNB with strong 3 year rental history, grossing $22k+ annually, and quickly filling up for this football season. Fully renovated in 2023 including roof, new flooring and paint throughout, updated kitchen and bathrooms, new hot water heater. Large bonus space that can be effectively used as a office, guest suite, second living area. Spacious yard and back deck, great for attracting

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$265,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,302 Sq Ft
5075 Water Valley Dr

Tallahassee, FL
Vaulted ceilings, large kitchen, open floorplan, and spacious master suite. This three bedroom, 2 bath home has a lot to love. Don't miss: 2022 roof, 2025 HVAC, 2025 water heater, fresh paint throughout - all the big items already done for you. Split floorplan means privacy for all. Great open floorplan with large kitchen and barstool seating, perfect for hosting those football parties and family

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$810,000
- Land
- 52 Acres
- $15,443 per Acre
25516 NE Cinelli Lake Cir

Hosford, FL
If your own private oasis is what you've been searching for, then look no further. This gorgeous North FL property boasts a stunning 1/2 acre pond, kept full even in dry weather by an 11 GPM artesian well, already stocked and ready for those peaceful fishing afternoons without the crowds. Abundant wildlife in this area, includes white tailed deer, turkey, dove, and more. 3 other home sites have

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$810,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,656 Sq Ft
25516 NE Lake Cinelli Cir

Hosford, FL
If your own private oasis is what you've been searching for, then look no further. This gorgeous North FL property boasts a stunning 1/2 acre pond, kept full even in dry weather by an 11 GPM artesian well, already stocked and ready for those peaceful fishing afternoons without the crowds. Abundant wildlife in this area, includes white tailed deer, turkey, dove, and more. 3 other home sites have

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$290,000
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,566 Sq Ft
2210 Joyner Dr

Tallahassee, FL
Timeless brick architecture, a spacious floorplan, the quintessential hardwood floors, and a quiet fenced backyard - all beautifully landscaped. This well-maintained 3 bedroom 2 bath home is built with a quality of craftsmanship we have lost somewhere along the way, and has that character you just won't find in those new builds. Great central location convenient to midtown, campus, downtown &

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$199,999
- 3 Beds
- 1.5 Baths
- 910 Sq Ft
4695 Autumn Woods Way

Tallahassee, FL
Ask about 0% down USDA loans! *** Introducing this cozy ranch-style cottage, with all the right things right. This brick-faced home offers fresh paint, new insulated vinyl windows, recent roof, and LVP flooring, for easy cleaning & worry free maintenance. Don't miss that great kitchen with ample cabinet space, large backyard fully privacy fenced, and the storybook live oak with bench swing

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Co-Listing Agent

$350,000

Under Contract
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 990 Sq Ft
76 Harley Davidson Ln

Crawfordville, FL
We are proud to introduce this beautiful slice of North FL paradise, on the market for the first time ever with all 15 acres available. Boasting the spring-fed pond for quiet mornings of private fishing, maintained trails through acres of woods abundant with wildlife of all kinds, boasting native hardwoods, and backing up to large conservation area. A second homesite with well and septic

Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Recently Sold

$234,000

Sold Jun 9, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,086 Sq Ft
2128 Little River Ln

Tallahassee, FL
- 2% Above List
- 4 Days On Market
- $215/SF
- Current Est. Value $232K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$299,000

Sold May 21, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,952 Sq Ft
2344 Vinkara Dr

Tallahassee, FL
- 8% Below List
- 104 Days On Market
- $153/SF
- Current Est. Value $298K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$525,000

Sold Apr 16, 2026
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 2,322 Sq Ft
1991 Buckfield Dr

Tallahassee, FL
- 3% Below List
- 0 Days On Market
- $226/SF
- Current Est. Value $523K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$253,000

Sold Mar 19, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,200 Sq Ft
2893 Duffton Loop

Tallahassee, FL
- 0 Days On Market
- $211/SF
- Current Est. Value $251K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$179,000

Sold Jan 30, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,502 Sq Ft
6206 Blountstown Hwy

Tallahassee, FL
- 2% Above List
- 79 Days On Market
- $119/SF
- Current Est. Value $196K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$242,000

Sold Jan 16, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,346 Sq Ft
5778 Split Oak Ln

Tallahassee, FL
- 0 Days On Market
- $180/SF
- Current Est. Value $248K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$85,000

Sold Jan 15, 2026
- 3 Beds
- 1 Bath
- 884 Sq Ft
1625 Old Bainbridge Rd

Tallahassee, FL
- 4% Below List
- 34 Days On Market
- $96/SF
- Current Est. Value $87K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$365,000

Sold Dec 30, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,833 Sq Ft
351 Colt Ct

Tallahassee, FL
- 6% Below List
- 34 Days On Market
- $199/SF
- Current Est. Value $369K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

$240,000

Sold Oct 8, 2025
- 3 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1,128 Sq Ft
4514 Hickory Forest Cir

Tallahassee, FL
- 13% Below List
- 120 Days On Market
- $213/SF
- Current Est. Value $242K
Paul Fenstermaker Fenstermaker & Associates Real

Agent License: Florida 3469948

Paul Fenstermaker

(850) 391-6888

Paul Fenstermaker

About Paul

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Buyer Deals

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Neighborhoods Paul is Experienced In

Paul's Listings and Deals

Paul's Recent Active Listings

Recently Sold