Section Image

Sara Shier

5.0stars, 36 Reviews
EXP Realty, LLC.
152 Closed Sales
$28.5M Total Value
$90.1K - $830K Price Range
$187.8K Average Price
Prior five years

About Sara

Home Types: House, MultiFamily, Condo, Townhouse
Years of Experience: 7

Transaction History

Seller Deals

Total Deals
10
Total Value
$2,314,200
Average Sale Price
$231,420
Price Range
$130K - $420K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
32
Total Value
$7,176,162
Average Sale Price
$224,255
Price Range
$124K - $513K

Production Over Time

1 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals
15
Total Value
$3,171,700
Average Sale Price
$211,447
Price Range
$119K - $420K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
62
Total Value
$13,569,887
Average Sale Price
$218,869
Price Range
$95K - $830K

Production Over Time

2 Year View by Quarter

Seller Deals

Total Deals
39
Total Value
$6,679,851
Average Sale Price
$171,278
Price Range
$42K - $450K

Buyer Deals

Total Deals
113
Total Value
$21,866,687
Average Sale Price
$193,511
Price Range
$18K - $830K

Production Over Time

5 Year View

Sara's Listings and Deals

Sara's Reviews

5.0stars, 36 Reviews

1/30/26C. G.

Google Review

Fact: Sara got my wife and I our dream home.
This review could end here, but I feel like that would be doing Sara a disservice.
We wanted to stay local, we wanted to stay within budget, but most of all, we simply wanted a place to call our own. Prior to meeting Sara, we had toured about 50 houses in just over a year, and made almost as many offers. Every house we toured, we were encouraged to put an offer in, in spite of glaring issues. We heard over and over, “this is the one for you”, and we believe it every single time. The FOMO and desperation were suffocating. We were waiving inspections, we were offering to cover seller’s costs, we were out of ideas and fresh out of hope. Every house we saw, we tried to say, “this is it”, and then we would inevitably be crushed when it slipped through our fingers. We were starting to think we would rent forever.
Then: Sara.
We were matched with Sara via Zillow’s built-in realtor finder to tour a house in our neighborhood. Sara met us promptly at the house. She carried herself with relaxed confidence, calm and observant, belying her tenacity and resolve. Expecting to see yet another house we would put on a pedestal and flaws we would overlook, something was different. Sara said “this isn’t the one for you”. We were shocked. Did she know something we didn’t? What was her game? Then she showed us another property. Again, she said “I don’t think this is the one for you either”. Fearful of the housing market continuing to sour around us, we scheduled a third property tour with Sara.
We came to the property where Sara had arrived some time before.
“This is the one for you.” And you know what? She was right.
Sara is an amazing realtor. She knows the business, she knows the angles, but more importantly, she has the taste, vision, and empathy to place the correct client in the correct house. The very first offer that Sara drafted for my wife and I sealed the deal on our dream home. We have been in our new property for about 4 months at the time of this writing, and we wake up grateful every day.
As first time homebuyers, Sara landed us the deal and stayed close with us through the whole process, patient and knowledgeable. To call her calculating sounds cold, but she knows what she is doing, and she will fight like hell for her clients. Our first Christmas in our home, we received a key-shaped ornament from Sara. It was such a sweet and thoughtful touch, especially since our business had already concluded. Sara genuinely cares about what she does, and she genuinely cares about her clients and their desires and tastes.
If you want to buy a house, good luck. If you want to buy a home, call Sara Shier.

1/5/26Courtney Beach

Google Review

Sara has been absolutely amazing. Her wealth of knowledge and expertise is unmatched. I had full trust in her through the entire process and was never disappointed.

11/11/25Jaegar Camp

Google Review

Sara helped me buy my first home this year and I could not of been happier with her services! I was uneducated on the home buying process and using the VA home loan. Sara was so kind and patient while walking myself and my fiancé throughout the process making it a stress free experience. Sara was always available for questions and even got her hands dirty while viewing houses! She helped us find the perfect house that we can now call Home! Thank you Sara!

Agent License: Ohio 2019003598
Agent Photo

Sara Shier