Sarah Whitley

Hi, I’m Sarah. While I grew up in Austin, Texas, I found my true home in Pagosa Springs with my husband, Jackson, and our dog, Peach. What first drew us here was the space, the scenery, and the slower pace of life—but what’s kept us is the sense of community and the unmatched connection to the outdoors.

Like many of my clients, I was once searching for a place that felt Like the right fit. Today, I spend my time exploring local trails, discovering open fields where Peach can run free, and helping others experience everything Pagosa Springs has to offer. From quiet mountain neighborhoods to wide-open land with room to breathe, I love sharing the beauty and possibilities of this area.

I specialize in residential homes and land, working closely with clients who are relocating from out of state and dreaming of a mountain lifestyle. I take a thoughtful, personal approach—listening carefully, answering questions honestly, and guiding you through the process at a pace that feels right. I can’t wait to show you what Pagosa Springs is all about and help you find a place that truly feels Like home.

Working at Jann C Pitcher- the oldest real estate firm in Pagosa Springs- we have over 30 years of collective experience in the southern Colorado market. Knowledge is plentiful and happily shared amongst our colleagues.