252

Best Elementary Schools in Suffolk County, NY

  • South Street School
    South Street School
    South Street School
    /7

    South Street School

    130 South St, Manorville, NY 11949

    Public Elementary School K to 2nd

    • B
      Niche Grade

    • Students

      250

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      11:1

    South Street School
  • Tuttle Avenue School
    Tuttle Avenue School
    Tuttle Avenue School
    /7

    Tuttle Avenue School

    1 Tuttle Ave, Eastport, NY 11941

    Public Elementary School K to 2nd

    • B
      Niche Grade

    • Students

      229

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      13:1

    Tuttle Avenue School
  • Westhampton Beach Elementary School
    Westhampton Beach Elementary School
    Westhampton Beach Elementary School
    /7

    Westhampton Beach Elementary School

    379 Mill Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      378

    • Math Proficiency

      52%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      7:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      52%

    Westhampton Beach Elementary School
  • William Rall School
    William Rall School
    William Rall School
    /8

    William Rall School

    761 Wellwood Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      521

    • Math Proficiency

      57%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      11:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      52%

    William Rall School
  • Deauville Gardens Elementary School
    Deauville Gardens Elementary School
    Deauville Gardens Elementary School
    /9

    Deauville Gardens Elementary School

    100 Deauville Blvd, Copiague, NY 11726

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B
      Niche Grade
    • 7
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      479

    • Math Proficiency

      38%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      16:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      46%

    Deauville Gardens Elementary School
  • Hampton Bays Elementary School
    Hampton Bays Elementary School
    Hampton Bays Elementary School
    /11

    Hampton Bays Elementary School

    72 Ponquogue Ave, Hampton Bays, NY 11946

    Public Elementary School K to 4th

    • B
      Niche Grade
    • 7
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      682

    • Math Proficiency

      42%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      37%

    Hampton Bays Elementary School
  • Lincoln Avenue Elementary School
    Lincoln Avenue Elementary School
    Lincoln Avenue Elementary School
    /7

    Lincoln Avenue Elementary School

    440 Lincoln Ave, Sayville, NY 11782

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B
      Niche Grade
    • 7
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      422

    • Math Proficiency

      37%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      37%

    Lincoln Avenue Elementary School
  • Montauk School
    Montauk School
    Montauk School
    /7

    Montauk School

    50 S Dorset Dr, Montauk, NY 11954

    Public Pre-K, Elementary, Middle School Pre-K to 8th

    • A
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      331

    • Math Proficiency

      47%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      7:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      67%

    Montauk School
  • Saint James Elementary School
    Saint James Elementary School
    Saint James Elementary School
    /7

    Saint James Elementary School

    580 Lake Ave, Saint James, NY 11780

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      452

    • Math Proficiency

      67%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      14:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      72%

    Saint James Elementary School
  • Sylvan Avenue Elementary School
    Sylvan Avenue Elementary School
    Sylvan Avenue Elementary School
    /7

    Sylvan Avenue Elementary School

    600 Sylvan Ave, Bayport, NY 11705

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      260

    • Math Proficiency

      67%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      11:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      74.5%

    Sylvan Avenue Elementary School
  • Wading River School
    Wading River School
    Wading River School
    /7

    Wading River School

    1900 Wading River Manor Rd, Wading River, NY 11792

    Public Elementary School 3rd to 5th

    • A
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      442

    • Math Proficiency

      62%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      10:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      62%

    Wading River School
  • West Gates Elementary School
    West Gates Elementary School
    West Gates Elementary School
    /7

    West Gates Elementary School

    175 W Gates Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      340

    • Math Proficiency

      54.5%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      74.5%

    West Gates Elementary School
  • William Sidney Mount School
    William Sidney Mount School
    William Sidney Mount School
    /8

    William Sidney Mount School

    50 Dean Ln, Stony Brook, NY 11790

    Public Elementary School K to 6th

    • A
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      505

    • Math Proficiency

      57%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      57%

    William Sidney Mount School
  • Amagansett School
    Amagansett School
    Amagansett School
    /7

    Amagansett School

    320 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930

    Public Pre-K, Elementary School Pre-K to 6th

    • 7
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      130

    • Math Proficiency

      72%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      6:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      72%

    Amagansett School
  • Blue Point Elementary School
    Blue Point Elementary School
    Blue Point Elementary School
    /7

    Blue Point Elementary School

    212 Blue Point Ave, Blue Point, NY 11715

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B+
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      214

    • Math Proficiency

      44.5%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      7:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      54.5%

    Blue Point Elementary School
  • Edith L Slocum Elementary School
    Edith L Slocum Elementary School
    Edith L Slocum Elementary School
    /8

    Edith L Slocum Elementary School

    2460 Sycamore Ave, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B+
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      278

    • Math Proficiency

      44.5%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      10:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      44.5%

    Edith L Slocum Elementary School
  • Sag Harbor Elementary School
    Sag Harbor Elementary School
    Sag Harbor Elementary School
    /7

    Sag Harbor Elementary School

    68 Hampton St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

    Public Pre-K, Elementary School Pre-K to 6th

    • B+
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      440

    • Math Proficiency

      47%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      9:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      57%

    Sag Harbor Elementary School
  • Tamarac Elementary School
    Tamarac Elementary School
    Tamarac Elementary School
    /7

    Tamarac Elementary School

    50 Spence Ave, Holtsville, NY 11742

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B+
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      461

    • Math Proficiency

      57%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      11:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      37%

    Tamarac Elementary School
  • Tooker Avenue Elementary School
    Tooker Avenue Elementary School
    Tooker Avenue Elementary School
    /7

    Tooker Avenue Elementary School

    855 Tooker Ave, West Babylon, NY 11704

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B+
      Niche Grade
    • 6
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      280

    • Math Proficiency

      52%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      42%

    Tooker Avenue Elementary School
  • Arrowhead Elementary School
    Arrowhead Elementary School
    Arrowhead Elementary School
    /8

    Arrowhead Elementary School

    62 ARROWHEAD Ln, East Setauket, NY 11733

    Public Elementary School K to 6th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      571

    • Math Proficiency

      47%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      10:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      52%

    Arrowhead Elementary School
  • Babylon Memorial Grade School
    Babylon Memorial Grade School
    Babylon Memorial Grade School
    /7

    Babylon Memorial Grade School

    169 Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702

    Public Elementary School 3rd to 6th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      444

    • Math Proficiency

      52%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      62%

    Babylon Memorial Grade School
  • Cayuga Elementary School
    Cayuga Elementary School
    Cayuga Elementary School
    /7

    Cayuga Elementary School

    865 Hawkins Ave, Lake Grove, NY 11755

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      519

    • Math Proficiency

      52%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      12:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      52%

    Cayuga Elementary School
  • Edna Louise Spear Elementary
    Edna Louise Spear Elementary
    Edna Louise Spear Elementary
    /7

    Edna Louise Spear Elementary

    500 Scraggy Hill Rd, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

    Public Pre-K, Elementary School Pre-K to 6th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      369

    • Math Proficiency

      57%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      11:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      52%

    Edna Louise Spear Elementary
  • Forest Brook Elementary School
    Forest Brook Elementary School
    Forest Brook Elementary School
    /7

    Forest Brook Elementary School

    299 Lilac Ln, Smithtown, NY 11787

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • A-
      Niche Grade
    • 5
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      354

    • Math Proficiency

      62%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      9:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      52%

    Forest Brook Elementary School
  • Great Neck Road Elementary School
    Great Neck Road Elementary School
    Great Neck Road Elementary School
    /8

    Great Neck Road Elementary School

    1400 Great Neck Rd, Copiague, NY 11726

    Public Elementary School K to 5th

    • B-
      Niche Grade
    • 7
      GreatSchools

    • Students

      454

    • Math Proficiency

      34%

    • Student Teacher Ratio

      16:1

    • Reading Proficiency

      33%

    Great Neck Road Elementary School

Showing Results 76 - 100, Page 4 of 11

New York Suffolk County

Top-Rated Elementary Schools in Suffolk County, NY

For families seeking quality education in Suffolk County, NY, the area offers 252 school options serving Elementary grade levels, including the highly-rated Deauville Gardens Elementary School (7/10 on GreatSchools) and Montauk School (A on Niche). Local schools demonstrate strong academic achievement, with top performers reaching 72% math proficiency and 74% reading proficiency. Suffolk County has a variety of education options, ensuring families and homebuyers can find the right fit when choosing their new city or neighborhood.

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage

Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group