8

Shirley, NY Homes for Rent

Section Image
  • /8

    $3,600 Per Month

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,140 Sq Ft
    • House for Rent

    35 Auborn Ave, Shirley, NY 11967

    Welcome to this bright and well-maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bath home in the heart of Shirley! Enjoy a spacious layout featuring hardwood floors throughout, sun-filled bedrooms, and an updated kitchen with ample cabinet space. The home also offers a large living area perfect for relaxing or entertaining, plus a private yard for outdoor enjoyment. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, and major

    Lily Fung Keller Williams Legendary

    35 Auborn Ave, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /29

    $3,700 Per Month

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,606 Sq Ft
    • House for Rent

    39 Seymour Dr, Shirley, NY 11967

    Welcome to this beautifully maintained Victorian-style home offering 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms in a convenient Shirley location. Recently updated, this home features a modern eat-in kitchen with quartz countertops, shaker cabinetry, and stainless steel appliances. The main level offers comfortable living and dining areas, hardwood flooring, and a cozy family room with a stone

    Atakan Aslan 365 Realty Group Inc

    39 Seymour Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /11

    $4,200 Per Month

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • 1,470 Sq Ft
    • House for Rent

    44 Pine Tree Dr, Shirley, NY 11967

    Full house for rent in Shirley. On main level you have kitchen, dining area, sunroom, living room, one full bathroom and two bedrooms. Upstairs you will find two bedrooms including master bedroom and one full bathroom. Basement is included for storage. Washer/dryer is in basement. This house is located in a quiet residential area close to nearby beaches, parks, and other amenities. Owner is

    Joe Andriano Potter Real Estate

    44 Pine Tree Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /13

    $2,400 Per Month

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 800 Sq Ft
    • Apartment for Rent

    118 Oak Ave Unit C, Shirley, NY 11967

    2 Bedroom Apartment for Rent – Shirley, NY (Available Immediately)Spacious and well-maintained 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment located in a quiet private house in Shirley. This second-floor walk-up offers comfortable living with access to a huge shared yard, perfect for relaxing or enjoying outdoor space.Features include:+Bright 2-bedroom, 1-bath layout+Second-floor walk-up in private

    Kenneth Ahrem US Homeowners Solutions Corp

    118 Oak Ave Unit C, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /8

    $5,500 Per Month

    • 5 Beds
    • 3 Baths
    • House for Rent

    413 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY 11967

    Welcome to 413 Glen Dr, Shirley, a spacious single-family ranch available for rent beginning August 1st with a 12-month lease term. This well-maintained home features 5 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, offering plenty of room for comfortable living. Enjoy an inviting eat-in kitchen equipped with stove, refrigerator, microwave, dishwasher, along with a washer and dryer. The home boasts beautiful

    Myrian Quinonez ARVY Realty

    413 Glen Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /10

    $3,800 Per Month

    • 3 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • House for Rent

    40 Fairview Dr, Shirley, NY 11967

    Welcome to this freshly updated 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch in Shirley. This move-in-ready home features fresh paint throughout and brand-new carpeting, creating a clean and inviting atmosphere. The spacious layout offers comfortable one-level living with bright living spaces and generously sized bedrooms. The kitchen provides ample storage and functionality, while the yard offers plenty of room to

    Tyler Brown RE MAX SPARROW REALTY

    40 Fairview Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /19

    $4,500 Per Month

    • 3 Beds
    • 2.5 Baths
    • 2,100 Sq Ft
    • House for Rent

    126 Trafalgar Dr, Shirley, NY 11967

    Open and spacious, luxury rental. This year round property boasts an open floor plan, large laundry room on the main floor, custom kitchen and lots of storage. Oversized balcony from kitchen and master suite give views to the water, where there is dock access. Walk-in closets, seamless drain shower, and vaulted ceilings are just a few of this homes many upgrades. Home comes furnished

    Amber Mccoy Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life

    126 Trafalgar Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
  • /7

    $3,900 Per Month

    • 4 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,756 Sq Ft
    • House for Rent

    126 Flower Rd, Shirley, NY 11967

    4 bedroom, 1 full bath with basement, home offering plenty of room. Features 2 bedrooms on the main floor. Updated kitchen, generous bedroom sizes, and a functional layout with dinning area. Exterior highlights include a large fenced yard. A great rental opportunity with space, comfort, and convenience.

    Jason Romaniello Blue Shark Realty Group Inc

    126 Flower Rd, Shirley, NY 11967

Why Live in Shirley

Shirley, NY, located on Long Island's South Shore, is a hamlet known for its waterfront charm and historical significance. Once a retreat for New York City elites, it now offers a mix of original bungalows, ranch-style homes, and newer Colonials, reflecting its evolution from a vacation spot to a full-time residential area. The community is recognized for its affordability compared to the broader Long Island region, with median home prices significantly lower than the area's average. Residents enjoy a variety of attractions, including fishing, boating, and swimming in Bellport Bay and Fire Island. Shirley Beach and Smith Point County Park provide sandy shores and recreational activities, while the Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge offers hiking and wildlife watching. The Long Island Skydiving Center adds a unique thrill to the area. Shirley's crime rate is lower than the national average, contributing to its appeal. Educational opportunities are robust, with the William Floyd Union Free School District and Longwood Central School District both highly rated. Higher education is accessible with Suffolk County Community College and Stony Brook University nearby. The hamlet's commercial hubs along William Floyd Parkway and Sunrise Highway feature diverse dining options, including the notable Southpaw brewery. For commuters, the Long Island Expressway and the Mastic-Shirley LIRR station provide routes to New York City, while Long Island MacArthur Airport and JFK International Airport offer convenient air travel options.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to rent a home in Shirley, NY?
The median rent for a home in Shirley, NY is $3,850 per month, though prices vary by neighborhood, size, and property type. As of June 2026, condos tend to be the most affordable option while townhouses and single-family homes are currently more expensive.
How much do you need to make to afford rent in Shirley, NY?
To comfortably afford the median rent in Shirley, NY, a household needs to earn roughly $154,000 per year. This is based on the common guideline that households should spend no more than 30% of gross income on housing. Most landlords require monthly household income of at least 3x the monthly rent, and with a median rent of $3,850 per month in Shirley, NY, renters typically need to show $11,550 per month in gross income to qualify. Actual affordability will vary depending on household debts, other living expenses, and overall budget.
Is it more affordable to rent or buy in Shirley, NY?
In Shirley, NY, the price-to-rent ratio is 11.8, which generally favors renting. This ratio divides the median home price by the annual median rent: below 15 typically favors buying, 15 to 20 is balanced, and above 20 typically favors renting. Your finances, how long you plan to stay, and costs like mortgage rates, taxes, and maintenance all factor into the decision.

Rental Home Trends

Number of Homes for Rent
8
Median Rent
$3,850
Median Single Family Home Rent
$3,700
Median Townhouse Rent
$3,500
Median Condo Rent
$2,400
How to Rent a Home