16

St. John, IN Homes for Sale under $200,000

Section Image Section Image
  • 10280 Joliet St, Saint John, IN 46373
    10280 Joliet St, Saint John, IN 46373
    10280 Joliet St, Saint John, IN 46373
    /5

    $139,900

    • Land
    • 1 Acre
    • $139,900 per Acre

    10280 Joliet St, Saint John, IN 46373

    Rare 1-acre lot in St. John--nestled in a private, wooded setting yet minutes from shopping, dining, and conveniences. Enjoy serene views, mature trees, and the perfect balance of seclusion and accessibility. A unique opportunity to build your dream home in one of the area's most desirable locations. No HOA. Lot dimensions 80' x 562' x 78' x 546'

    Agent Photo

    Jennifer Stiglitz

    Better Homes and Gardens Real

    (844) 841-1430

    10280 Joliet St, Saint John, IN 46373
  • 11244 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11244 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11244 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $135,000

    • Land
    • 0.82 Acre
    • $164,634 per Acre

    11244 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Beautiful partially wooded lot on over 3/4 of an acre in the new Parrish Woods subdivision. Bring your custom builder or use one of ours. Close to St. John, shopping, dining, and schools. Only 15 lots left in this 28 lot development.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    11244 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 11263 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11263 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11263 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $116,000

    • Land
    • 0.57 Acre
    • $204,947 per Acre

    11263 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Beautiful Half acre lot in the new Parrish Woods Development! Bring your Custom Builder or choose one of our selected custom builders. Close to Shopping, food, and schools. Hour from Chicago.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    11263 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 8884 Hillside Dr, Saint John, IN 46373
    8884 Hillside Dr, Saint John, IN 46373
    8884 Hillside Dr, Saint John, IN 46373
    /6

    $169,900

    • Land
    • 0.4 Acre
    • $422,637 per Acre

    8884 Hillside Dr, Saint John, IN 46373

    Prime Lake Hills lot! Don't let this one pass you by. Enjoy all Lake Hills has to offer. Walking paths, bike trails, a 34-acre lake, a fishing pier, outdoor amphitheater. Town sewer & water. Serene atmosphere yet close to shopping, restaurants, and entertainment. Easy commute to Chicago as well as Lake Michigan. Pick your builder!

    Elaine Eich McColly Real Estate

    8884 Hillside Dr, Saint John, IN 46373
  • 9545 112th St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9545 112th St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /2

    $108,500

    • Land
    • 0.5 Acre
    • $217,000 per Acre

    9545 112th St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Half acre lot in the new Parrish Woods Subdivision. 28 home development, all custom builds. Bring your own custom builder or let us connect you with one of our. Close to Shopping, dining, and schools.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    9545 112th St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 9550 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9550 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9550 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $109,900

    • Land
    • 0.53 Acre
    • $207,358 per Acre

    9550 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Wooded half acre lot in the new Parrish Woods Subdivision. Bring your custom builder or use one of ours. Great location close to shopping, dining, lake, and schools.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    9550 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 11271 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11271 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11271 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $121,000

    • Land
    • 0.9 Acre
    • $134,444 per Acre

    11271 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Wooded lot just under an acre in the New Parrish Woods Subdivision, just south of 231 in Cedar Lake. Bring your custom builder or let us help you find one that suits your needs. Close to shopping, dining, and schools. Hour commute to Chicago.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    11271 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 11236 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11236 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /2

    $142,000

    • Land
    • 0.87 Acre
    • $163,218 per Acre

    11236 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Beautiful .87 acre lot in the new Parrish Woods Subdivision. This 28 lot subdivision will all be custom homes. Bring your custom builder or use one of ours. Close to dining, shopping, and schools.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    11236 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 10238 White Water Crossing, Saint John, IN 46373
    10238 White Water Crossing, Saint John, IN 46373
    10238 White Water Crossing, Saint John, IN 46373
    /22

    $164,999

    • Land
    • 0.32 Acre
    • $520,502 per Acre

    10238 White Water Crossing, Saint John, IN 46373

    Here it is folks!!! The walkout lot in a fabulous, high end, coveted neighborhood that you have been looking for! This picturesque lot is located in the highly desirable Lake Hills subdivision in St John. Build your custom home with the contractor of your choice and enjoy everything this amazing community has to offer such as walking trails, bike paths, parks, outdoor amphitheater, lakes and

    Scott Miller BHHS Executive Realty

    10238 White Water Crossing, Saint John, IN 46373
  • 9532 Keilman St Unit 2, Saint John, IN 46373
    9532 Keilman St Unit 2, Saint John, IN 46373
    9532 Keilman St Unit 2, Saint John, IN 46373
    /46

    $194,900

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • 1,157 Sq Ft

    9532 Keilman St Unit 2, Saint John, IN 46373

    Well cared for and thoughtfully updated, this two-bedroom, one-bath condo offers easy living in desirable St. John, Indiana. Enjoy an open and inviting layout with a bright living area that leads to a private balcony, restructured just one year ago-ideal for relaxing or entertaining. The eat-in kitchen features a new dishwasher and new flooring (both 3 months old), while the stove, washer, dryer,

    Antje Gehrken A.R.E. Partners Inc.

    9532 Keilman St Unit 2, Saint John, IN 46373
  • 12850 W 102nd Ave, Saint John, IN 46373
    12850 W 102nd Ave, Saint John, IN 46373
    /2

    $199,900

    • Land
    • 0.85 Acre
    • $234,624 per Acre

    12850 W 102nd Ave, Saint John, IN 46373

    Timberland Estates is an exclusive, five-lot wooded cul-de-sac featuring spacious 1-2 acre lots. The property is .85 of an acre located in the Town of St. John; however, has a Dyer mailing address. Enjoy the convenience of quick access to Chicago will still savoring the tranquility of a a country setting. The wooded parcel offers the convenience of city water and sewer along with the potential

    Tom Cummings Keller Williams Preferred Real

    12850 W 102nd Ave, Saint John, IN 46373
  • 9531 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9531 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9531 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $124,000

    • Land
    • 0.83 Acre
    • $149,398 per Acre

    9531 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Wooded lot just under an acre in the new Parrish Woods subdivision. Great location close to shopping, schools, and dining. Bring your custom builder or let me help you find one that suits your needs.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    9531 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 11252 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11252 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11252 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $107,000

    • Land
    • 0.46 Acre
    • $233,115 per Acre

    11252 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Almost half acre corner lot in the new Parrish Woods Subdivision.Bring your custom builder or use one of ours. Just a stones throw away from St. John and near shopping, dining and schools.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    11252 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 9555 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9555 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    9555 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /3

    $109,900

    • Land
    • 0.55 Acre
    • $199,818 per Acre

    9555 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Beautiful half acre partially wooded lot in the new Parrish Woods Development. Bring your custom builder or use one of ours. Close to shopping, dining and the lake.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    9555 112th Place, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
  • 11825 Heron Lake Rd, Saint John, IN 46373
    11825 Heron Lake Rd, Saint John, IN 46373
    11825 Heron Lake Rd, Saint John, IN 46373
    /4

    $150,000

    • Land
    • 0.51 Acre
    • $292,969 per Acre

    11825 Heron Lake Rd, Saint John, IN 46373

    Rare Lakefront Opportunity in Heron Lake Subdivision! Don't miss your chance to own the last available lakefront lot in the highly sought-after Heron Lake Subdivision in St. John! This spacious half-acre parcel offers breathtaking water views in a peaceful, natural setting--an ideal location to build your custom dream home. Perfectly suited for a walk-out basement, this lot provides both beauty

    Katherine Wietbrock McColly Real Estate

    11825 Heron Lake Rd, Saint John, IN 46373
  • 11220 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    11220 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
    /2

    $135,000

    • Land
    • 0.83 Acre
    • $162,651 per Acre

    11220 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

    Beautiful lot on almost an acre in the New Parrish Wood Subdivision. Great location, close to 41, shopping, dining, and schools. Bring your own custom builder or use one of ours.

    Heather Bahl Better Homes and Gardens Real

    11220 Atherton St, Cedar Lake, IN 46303
Indiana Lake County St. John

Real Estate & Homes in St. John, IN under $200,000

Home Trends in St. John, IN

On average, homes in St. John, IN sell after 26 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in St. John, IN over the last 12 months is $520,617, down 10% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.

Housing Trends

Median Sale Price
$520,617
Median Single Family Sale Price
$566,990
Median Townhouse Sale Price
$289,990
Average Price Per Sq Ft
$211
Number of Homes for Sale
24
Last 12 months Home Sales
26
Months of Supply
11.10
Median List Price
$561,990
Median Change From 1st List Price
1%
Median Home Sale Price YoY Change
-10%
How to Buy a Home How to Finance a Home How to Sell a Home

In St. John, you'll find a diverse selection of properties with 16 homes for sale under $200,000, catering to budget-conscious buyers seeking affordable housing solutions. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer in search of a cozy starter home or an investor eyeing a promising opportunity, these affordable homes provide a gateway into the real estate market in St. John, IN.

Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.

Homes.com Licensing Information

§ 442-H New York Standard Operating Procedures

New York Fair Housing Notice

TREC: Information about brokerage services, Consumer protection notice

California DRE #01937601

Contact Homes.com Brokerage

Copyright © 2025 CoStar Group