Casey Key Homes for Sale

Experience true Florida coastal living in this impeccably maintained Key West–style home on Casey Key, offering the rare and coveted Gulf-to-Bay lifestyle. Thoughtfully designed with high ceilings and a bright, open feel, this residence blends relaxed island charm with modern updates throughout. Step outside to a beautifully landscaped, fenced, and gated backyard—your own private oasis. Enjoy the

Valerie Dall'acqua PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

There is something unmistakable about Gulf-front living on Casey Key, the rhythm of the water, the ever-changing light and sense of well-being that only a beachfront setting can offer. This stunning residence captures that lifestyle beautifully, offering a relaxed yet refined coastal retreat designed for everyday living and effortless entertaining. Completed in January 2026, the recent

Mike Warm PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Wake up every morning to beautiful Gulf views from your third floor primary suite! Experience effortless luxury in this exceptional Gulf-front estate on the pristine shores of Casey Key, where privacy, tranquility, and sweeping water views await. Originally built in 1951 and tastefully renovated in 2016 and 2025, this beach-front residence seamlessly blends classic character with refined modern

Ryan Miller HARRY ROBBINS ASSOC INC

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Vintage Waterfront Cottage on Casey Key. Quietly set on Casey Cove Drive, a private cul-de-sac just off Casey Key Road, this refreshed vintage cottage offers exceptional privacy and 180-degree Intracoastal Waterway views across Blackburn Bay. Located within a protected, minimal-wake cove, the setting is serene and timeless—where coastal breezes,

Lisa Napolitano DOUGLAS ELLIMAN

This captivating Gulf-to-Bay residence is the epitome of timeless coastal elegance. Begin your mornings on the lanai, coffee in hand, as the sun rises over the Intracoastal Waterway. Spend your days boating from the private bayside dock and your evenings on your stretch of sandy beach, where spectacular Gulf sunsets are a nightly ritual. Inside, expansive light-filled interiors frame breathtaking

Valerie Dall'acqua PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

If you are looking for the ultimate in bayside waterfront living on Casey Key, come see this newly remodeled home on a rare cul-de-sac site with water views on three sides and from almost every room. In the past year the home has been upgraded with 24-inch white porcelain tile flooring, quartz countertops, new paint, fixtures and hardware, an open kitchen with two islands, and a new 5-ton main

Deborah Grossman EXIT KING REALTY

WELCOME TO ONE OF THE FEW BRAND-NEW GULF FRONT HOMES FOR SALE ON THE WEST CENTRAL COAST OF FLORIDA. A rare opportunity, where cutting-edge design meets wide Gulf vistas. Nestled on the prestigious barrier island of Casey Key, this newly constructed Modern Coastal estate by Modesta Homes exemplifies modern beachfront living. Positioned directly on the sand with sweeping Gulf views, this striking

Jennifer Zales COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Welcome to Casey Key — a secret escape on Florida’s Gulf Coast. This enchanting five-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bath Spanish Revival estate captures the essence of timeless architecture and modern luxury, offering a private gulf-to-bay sanctuary unlike any other. A stately wrought-iron gate welcomes you to an inviting courtyard, the perfect prelude to this exceptional home. As you step inside, the

Lisa Napolitano DOUGLAS ELLIMAN

Pre-Construction. To be built. This is your chance to own a newly imagined Gulf-front estate on one of Sarasota’s most exclusive barrier islands. Positioned on 0.43 acres with 107 feet of direct Gulf frontage, this offering presents a 3,489 sq. ft residence designed by the renowned Stofft Cooney Architects in collaboration with Perrone Construction. The home’s architecture celebrates the Gulf at

Hailey Kendall WILLIAM RAVEIS REAL ESTATE

Beachfront Bliss on Casey Key – Rare Hotel-Zoned Investment OpportunityIntroducing Casey Key Retreat: a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own income-producing beachfront property on the highly desirable shores of Casey Key. Situated directly on the Gulf of Mexico, this exceptional offering is one of the few properties on the key that is fully licensed and zoned for motel/hotel use — a

Sam Beaugrand LASBURY-TRACY REALTY INC.

Gulf-front serenity on Casey Key. On the desirable shores of Casey Key, this quintessential beachfront retreat, Osmyrrah, is a sanctuary of tranquility, designed for relaxed, organic living with an intimate connection to the sea. With private, pristine beachfront and panoramic Gulf views, you’ll be immersed in dazzling sunsets, soft white sands and the soothing rhythm of the waves every single

Judie Berger PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Welcome to 416 Casey Key Rd – an exceptional waterfront estate offering private Gulf beach access, spectacular views, and elevated, storm-safe construction on one of Florida’s most exclusive barrier islands. This three-story concrete block home offers timeless coastal design paired with the latest modern features for seamless living and entertaining. Inside, you’ll find four spacious bedrooms,

Vladislav Konatar KONA REALTY

Introducing a rare and extraordinary opportunity to own one of the largest and most coveted properties on Casey Key. This sprawling 2.08-acre estate, featuring an impressive 300 feet of pristine Gulf of Mexico beachfront, is the epitome of coastal luxury. With exclusive Gulf-to-Bay access and 90 feet of Intracoastal Waterway frontage, this property offers unparalleled privacy and endless

Amanda Heese SMITH & ASSOCIATES REAL ESTATE

Designed by renowned architect George Merlin and built in 2006 by Christner Brothers to hurricane-resistant building code, this home rests securely on concrete-driven pilings and exudes unparalleled quality. Watch the sunrise over the Intracoastal Waterway from the deepwater boat dock and lift. Spend the afternoons on your private beach along the sandy shore of the gulf where spectacular sunsets

Valerie Dall'acqua PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Double your pleasure with two beaches and one extraordinary Gulf-to-Bay opportunity on exclusive Casey Key. This rare .58-acre waterfront parcel spans from the Gulf to Blackburn Bay, offering approximately 85 feet of private Gulf frontage plus a newly expanded sandy shoreline along the bay—creating a truly unique dual-beach setting.This property presents an exceptional opportunity for a

Mike Warm PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Experience unparalleled luxury on the coveted south end of Casey Key, where this custom Gulf-front estate offers 90 feet of pristine beach frontage, endless views of the turquoise Gulf waters, and the most walkable wide beach on the Key. Built with timeless craftsmanship, the residence spans over 12,000 square feet in total, featuring five bedrooms, six-and-a-half baths, and two spectacular

Lori Carey PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

A RARE CASEY KEY OPPORTUNITY — Discover a 4,300+ sq. ft. STORM-RESISTANT waterfront residence that blends privacy, craftsmanship, and breathtaking bay views on one of Florida’s most exclusive barrier islands. This move-in ready estate sits on the serene shores of Little Sarasota Bay, offering a deep-water dock, a steel-roofed covered boat slip, a deep-water wet slip, and a 10-foot private deeded

Kelley Ann Ayers AYERS AND ASSOCIATES REAL ESTATE