107 Cincinnatus, NY Real Estate Listings

Sort by:
$74,900Est. Payment
2 Beds | 1 Bath | 780 Sqft
5341 Brown Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Mobile Manufactured For Sale

Take a look at this one of a kind property bordered by 1700 acres of state land with a 1/2 acre spring fed pond! 2 pads in place for building, utilities ready to go. Permitted for 2 homes with a drilled 100' well, brand new well pump, septic tank, and electric run to the house. Separate electric meters for each pad & new breaker box for well & hot water heater in the last few years. 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom home currently onsite with a fuel oil furnace and wood stove; make this a hunting camp or fix it up for your escape from the city! (Seller may also include a newer zero turn mower, newer bucket tractor, new side by side UTV, and other equipment).

$184,500Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,904 Sqft
5246 Gee Brook Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Mobile Manufactured For Sale

This home is available to those who act now! You will love this delightful 3 bedroom and 2 full bath home offering almost 2,000 feet. The land has so many bonuses you won't be disappointed. You will find it resourceful and entertaining. Breathtaking views of the country side, pond with sandy beach and a oasis, borders state land and offers plenty of wildlife. Find multiple uses for the pole barn that is heated with separate power and a pour concrete floor. Imagine cuddling up to a cozy fireplace with a good book. Keep your fuel prices down by supplementing with wood in the woodstove and living room fireplace. Enjoy the benefits of picking apples, watching sunrises and sunsets off your front covered porch.. All of this situated on a plentiful 11 plus acres and waiting for you to love it too!

$145,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 1 Bath | 2,439 Sqft
4109 Suarez Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Welcome to this great remodeled Cape Cod home located on 3.1 acres of country living. First floor has been totally remodeled with new flooring, appliances and so much more. 2 living/family rooms with open floor plan that leads into a beautiful updated kitchen, new windows and metal roof. Pocket door takes you to the bathroom/laundry room and 1 bedroom. The upstairs still has the 1939 original look, with some TLC this home would be complete and ready for the next family to make memories!!

$182,500Est. Payment
5 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,832 Sqft
2879 East View Terrace, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Enjoy this solidly built colonial style home nestled on a dead end street. This lovely property has a beautiful exterior complete with a newly build brick outdoor fireplace, landscaped grounds, an above ground pool and a deck. Inside you will find a new spacious living room off the back of the house that overlooks the landscaped back yard. Inside has an open concept to a second living space and kitchen, (Corian countertops). A primary bedroom and a full bath with a walk in closet is on the main floor, there are 4 bedrooms on the second level, and a large bedroom in the attic space. The roof is newer, nicely sided, and there is a new on demand hot water tank. With just a little trim work needed and a few rooms painted this house would be priced higher. Make this your haven yours to enjoy, call today for a showing.

$42,900Est. Payment
7.53 Acres
3426 Hubbards Hills Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

You will feel you are on top of the world from this incredible site. Beautiful area for hunting, camping or enjoying your water toys. Pond on property and Otselic river nearby. Just 2.2 miles from Cincinnatus schools. Nearby state land. This property is an inexpensive entry into recreation land or a superb size and value for a building lot.

$74,900Est. Payment
3 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,422 Sqft
3970 Telephone Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

This home has been in one family since 1947. It has had several improvements; newer furnace, 200 amp-CB, vinyl windows, newer walk-in shower. replacement stairs to the second floor. Double LR, large dining room and eat-in kitchen. First floor bathroom with 3 BRs up. Enclosed front porch. Two garages, one near the house, the other in upper corner near the road. There are two electric meters; one for house an done on light pole in the yard. More photos to come!

$249,500Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,784 Sqft
4691 Dutch Hill Rd Spur, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Beautiful secluded two story ranch style house on almost 7 acres of land. House was built 21 years ago and very well kept. Featuring Large living areas including Large great room, new central air conditioning. Very large deck, Beautiful Gardens and views, large two bay pole barn/garage, two fire places, and fire pit area outside. Also features air circulation system attached to Furnace. Gazebo comes apart for the winter and is stored in the shed. Perfect Country living.

$329,900Est. Payment
4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2,556 Sqft
4273 Mosher Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

This custom built home has so much to offer. Complete first floor living with master bedroom, en suite and walk in closet, 2 bedrooms, 2nd bath,large laundry room and office perfect for working from home. The master bath has seperate claw foot soaking tub, walk in shower with seat and heated towel rack. Custom lighting throughout with a open concept livingroom/diningroom/kitchen. Large dining room currently has table with seating for 10. In addition a full second floor with a finished space that can be a 4th bedroom with 1/2 bath , game room ,or whatever suites your needs. Plus there is potential for more finished space with an unfinished area of over 700 sqft, or just keep as easy access storage. Wrap around deck with view for miles, 34 x 36 heated garage, additional 30 x 16 workshop over the garage also heated. Small fenced area with deluxe chicken coop serves as a nice farmette. Newley dug pond just waiting for some rain, this property could be just what you have been looking for!

$94,000Est. Payment
5 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,732 Sqft
2780 Lower Cincinnatus Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Newly refurbished house with ample living space, including 4 bedrooms, possible 5 (one downstairs), new flooring, newly insulated, painted interior, pellet stove, large open kitchen and separate dining room. The living room is spacious with plenty of lighting and newer windows. Downstairs has electric heat, but seller says Pellet stove heats the house nicely. This is a fantastic price for the size of the house. Close to schools, and convenient location.

$86,346Est. Payment
47.97 Acres
000 German Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

48 acres of open and wooded land in Cortland county, town of Cincinnatus. The nice open field has a level to a gentle roll, a large beaver pond, mature pine and hemlock with some wild apple trees, hardwoods with areas of nice underbrush cover. This a great place for a getaway to camp and enjoy the outdoors or to build your new home. Located 30 minutes from Cortland and Norwich, and 3.5 hours from NYC.

$19,900Est. Payment
8.18 Acres
00 Cheningo Solon Pond Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

Nice parcel for those who want to build a home, camp or just as a little hunting spot in Taylor NY. The property goes down from the road and has Pond Creek in the back. All wooded with apple and brush loaded with deer tracks. 8.18 acres of relaxation! While walking the land I saw plenty of deer tracks for those who are into hunting or for those who are into watching the wildlife. Have a look at the photos. Nice small parcel for you to buy and add whatever you would like!

$299,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,664 Sqft
4343 Potter Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

133 beautiful country acres including 40 acre Solon Pond. Excellent hunting, fishing, swimming, kayaking, hiking, snowmobile riding, all recreation possibilities in the woodlands and theres also tillable land. Make the 4 bedroom, 2 bath farmhouse your own. Enjoy the spacious and open living room. Serve meals in the eat-in kitchen or in the formal dining room. There is a bedroom and full bath on the first floor or there are three other, nice size bedrooms upstairs to choose from with another full bath. Finish the full attic for an office or rec room! Store your belongings in the two story, one car garage or in the second two story building. Go to www.solonpond.com for more info. The sky is the limit with this amazing property!

$595,000Est. Payment
0 Acres
5471 Telephone Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Lots Land For Sale

Spectacular setting! This family-run property known as Knickerbocker Country Club has been a family run business for two generations. What started out as a dream has become a reality in the well manicured and active country golf club. Banquets, weddings, and golfing provide a relaxing getaway for people near and far. Spacious clubhouse is a perfect spot for lounging and for light dining. Excellent reputation, great location, and tremendous potential to take this to the next level. Fully turnkey operation. Also under "Commercial" in MLS

$43,995Est. Payment
4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,920 Sqft
2995 East Freetown Texas Valley Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Property is a unique feature and a piece of natural history as it used to be the East Freetown Post Office. Needs completion so has to be a rehab or cash only deal... but it has the potential of being 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Or mix it up and use this unit as a two family. Currenty owner had the vision for that so upstairs offers layout and plumbing for kitchen. The entry ways to allow it to be a single family or a multi will work either way. Great price and a country location. A great project house.

$415,000Est. Payment
4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1,817 Sqft
3638 Taylor Valley Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

Operating CERTIFIED ORGANIC DAIRY FARM with 127 beautiful acres. A big game hunters dream or a farmer's paradise that includes 50 acres of forest with abundant wildlife. 70 acres of fenced-in tillable land with spring fed water lines to all pastures. The barn is equipped with 45 comfort stalls, 2 heifer pens, ridged concrete floor, Patz barn cleaner, 18 x 50 silo with a Patz unloader, concrete barnyard, and round bale unroller. This farmhouse is a 4 or 5-bedroom, 1 bath with a newly renovated boot room and some interior updates including hard wood floors throughout the living area. Also included is a 3-year-old propane boiler and an outside wood furnace. Cows and a short line of equipment available upon request at additional cost.

$179,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1,680 Sqft
426 N End Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Mobile Manufactured For Sale

Two mobile homes on just over 26.5 acres! The 2004 Double wide features 3 Bedrooms and 2 Full Bathrooms, with spacious living and family rooms. The Master bedroom is also connected to one of the bathrooms! Outside, you have a large back deck connected to the home with access to an above ground pool! The 2 car garage is just off to the left of the Double wide with added storage above each bay! The Single wide also features 3 Bedrooms and 2 Full bathrooms, as well as a enclosed wrap-around porch with metal roofing on the whole home! The added mudroom just off the back of the house was built with lumber from the property! Behind the Single wide is a barn with 10 box stalls, 4 cow stalls and stores over 1,000 bails of hay! Don't forget about the 40X80 Pole Barn built in 2013! More than enough room to store large equipment and outdoor toys! Beautiful Property in a country setting, on a quiet back road!

$62,000Est. Payment
3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2,280 Sqft
Cincinnatus, NY 13040
House For Sale

2280 sq ft. Pre-Foreclosure Single Family Home features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Pre-foreclosures can offer opportunities to purchase properties at attractive prices.

version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="30px" height="24px" >