$640,466Average Value$401Average Price per Sq Ft18Homes For Sale
From farmland to quiet Long Island suburb
Farmingville started as an area with family-owned farms, but today, brand-new townhouses, apartments and single-family homes fill this residential town in Long Island. “Farmingville has more apartments than surrounding areas, but it’s a quiet residential town without much industry. They have a lot of entertainment, like car shows and concerts. It’s also in the middle of Long Island, close to the expressway,” says Larry McKenna, a team leader and licensed real estate agent with Signature Premier Properties who has over 17 years of experience helping homeowners in Farmingville and other Long Island towns. Interstate 495 runs along the southern border, and residents who commute into central New York have a short drive to Ronkonkoma Station to catch the train. In addition to convenient commuter routes, locals live near popular parks and historic sites like the 1850s schoolhouse at the Thomas Muratore Park at Farmingville Hills County Park to explore.
Welcome to Farmingville.
Visit the famous Veterans Memorial in Farmingville.
1/2
Established Cape Cods and brand-new rental homes
With no sidewalks to take up space, residents live in Cape Cods or ranch-style homes that sit on large yards, often with a pool in the backyard, and usually sell for $435,000 to $625,000. “There is some new construction happening, but it’s very limited. You might see a developer buy a home with 2 or 3 acres, tear it down, and build a couple of new ones, but it’s few and far between,” McKenna says. The newer homes built as recently as 2024 feature Cape Cod-style designs and can sell for $650,000 to $745,000. The Arboretum is also growing with apartments and rental townhouses. The CAP Index score gives Farmingville a crime score of 2 out of 10, with 4 being the national average.
Colonial Revivals are popular in Farmingville.
Ranch style homes are an option in Farmingville.
1/2
Champions cheer at Sachem High East
Students head to Waverly Avenue Elementary School every morning for class and later attend Sagamore Middle School, both of which get B-plus ratings from Niche. Sachem High School East welcomes students to learn and join one of their many championship-winning teams, such as the cheerleading squad. Niche gives Sachem High East an A-minus. College students don't have to travel far to get to class at Suffolk County Community College, just north of the town.
Students head to Sagamore Middle School every morning for class.
Sachem High School East is located off of Granny Road.
1/2
Exercising and learning at Thomas Muratore Park
Visitors to Thomas Muratore Park can stop by the Terry House and Bald Hill Schoolhouse, built in the 1850s, before hiking along the 2-mile trail. The Farmingville Historical Society also hosts events like Easter egg hunts and trick-or-treat trails for Halloween. Waverly Avenue Park and Greentree Park are quiet areas with playground equipment for kids and paved walking trails for morning joggers and dog walkers. Those who prefer exercising their brains can take a short drive to the Sachem Public Library or the Middle Country Public Library Selden Branch to check out books or enroll in programs for patrons of all ages.
The Bald Hill Schoolhouse at Thomas Muratore Park can be toured virtually.
Take a stroll on the many paths of Thomas Muratore Park.
1/2
Trying Portuguese and Mexican dishes at Fax Chix
Horseblock Road is lined with restaurants like Olé Restaurant, a popular spot for its Portuguese menu. Sam’s Sushi Bistro is known for its friendly service and selection of sushi, bento boxes and soups. Residents get a table at Fax Chix Restaurant for a dinner of Portuguese or Mexican dishes. Stocking up on groceries is simple with the Walmart in Centereach Square, surrounded by stores like Big Lots, Sally Beauty and Dollar Tree, and the Stop & Shop in Expressway Plaza. Even more grocery, shopping and dining options sit along Middle Country Road, including Target, Home Depot and locally owned restaurants.
FaxChix Restaurant in Farmingville serves Mexican and Portuguese fare in a bustling space.
Walmart in the nearby Centereach shopping center has all your needs.
1/2
Shopping local or catching a concert at Bald Hill
From May to September, the Triangle Park for the Farmers, Artisans, and Friends Market welcomes residents to shop and dine with their neighbors. Some visit the Catholic Health Amphitheater at Bald Hill for the Maggio Environmental Summer Concert Series to see musicians and artists from different genres perform. McKenna says Bald Hill also organizes car shows and a spectacular Fourth of July fireworks display. The Farmingville Resident Association gets neighbors together for comedy nights and annual community spring cleaning events. McKenna also mentions Farmingville puts on a street fair every June for vendors to drum up business and neighbors to enjoy a fun day together. The Chamber of Commerce blocks off Portion Road to make room for the beer garden, car show, chalk competition, live music stage and local vendors.
The sounds of summer are here at the Catholic Health Amphitheater in Farmingville.
Farmigville Residents Association hosts a community marketplace at Triangle Park.
1/2
Taking the express line at Ronkonkoma Station
Commuters heading into central New York start their commutes at the Ronkonkoma Station. This station has plenty of parking, frequent train arrivals and an express route to New York City. Those who want to drive about 16 miles to spend the day on the north or south shores can use Middle Country Road to connect to Interstate 495. Some travel 7 miles to the Long Island MacArthur Airport to catch a flight for work or a vacation.
Head to nearby Ronkonkoma to catch the train to NYC or Eastern Long Island.
The Long Island Expressway (Interstate 495) meets Farmingville at North Ocean Avenue.
1/2
Historic church offering help to the community
The Farmingville Congregational United Church of Christ has welcomed the public since it was built in 1890. The congregation also offers a food pantry on the second and fourth Sundays of every month for those who need a helping hand.
The Farmingville Congregational United Church of Christ offers a food pantry twice a month.
The Farmingville Congregational United Church of Christ has welcomed the public since 1890.
1/2
Written By
Tina Davis
Photography Contributed By
J. Michael DeMeo
Video By
Antoine Allen
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Elena Rivas,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Farmingville, NY sell after 44 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Farmingville, NY over the last 12 months is $635,000, up 2% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Great beginnings start here at 20 Daisy Place in Selden! Move-in ready and totally redone - Full Basement, New Electric throughout (2024). Heating system installed in 2018, Roof replaced in 2021, Brand new plumbing in 2025. Newer Vinyl Flooring, Kitchen and all appliances redone in 2025, Full bathroom in 2025. Brand new windows and siding. Septic tank (2021) is a Septi-tech 5 system & more.
Beautiful fully renovated 3 bedroom ranch house for sale. Over size lot .New kitchen, new bathroom, finished basement with separate entrance. Low taxes. Double driveway & plenty of upgrades throughout. This home is truly a must-see—don’t miss out, it won’t last long!
Remarkable Colonial Nestled on Oversized Property in Desirable North Farmingville Neighborhood! You are Welcomed by a Stone Front Porch & Double Door Entry into your Tiled Foyer. The Kitchen is Fully Equipped with Wood Cabinetry, Granite Counters, Tile Backsplash, Built In Pantry & Stainless Appliances Accented with an Eat In Area in front of the sun drenched Bay Window. Formal Dining Room,
Great beginnings start here at 20 Daisy Place in Selden! Move-in ready and totally redone - Full Basement, New Electric throughout (2024). Heating system installed in 2018, Roof replaced in 2021, Brand new plumbing in 2025. Newer Vinyl Flooring, Kitchen and all appliances redone in 2025, Full bathroom in 2025. Brand new windows and siding. Septic tank (2021) is a Septi-tech 5 system & more.
This one won't wait, and neither should you. Tucked at the quiet end of a sought-after cul-de-sac, this home sits on a private .48-acre parcel backing a recharge basin, no rear neighbors, just total seclusion. The fully fenced yard is lushly landscaped with specimen mature plantings that create a natural privacy screen money simply can't replicate overnight. And when you're ready to re-enter the
Beautiful fully renovated 3 bedroom ranch house for sale. Over size lot .New kitchen, new bathroom, finished basement with separate entrance. Low taxes. Double driveway & plenty of upgrades throughout. This home is truly a must-see—don’t miss out, it won’t last long!
Remarkable Colonial Nestled on Oversized Property in Desirable North Farmingville Neighborhood! You are Welcomed by a Stone Front Porch & Double Door Entry into your Tiled Foyer. The Kitchen is Fully Equipped with Wood Cabinetry, Granite Counters, Tile Backsplash, Built In Pantry & Stainless Appliances Accented with an Eat In Area in front of the sun drenched Bay Window. Formal Dining Room,
Magnificent home with rental potential located close to all. Drop your bags because this home is move-in ready. You are instantly drawn to the stunning Brazilian cherry floors and large Living Room with cathedral ceilings. Kitchen features stainless steel appliances, granite countertops with a wrap around peninsula for entertaining. A full basement provides a ton of additional living space. The
This unique and beautiful 4 bedroom, 2 full bathrooms Splanch-style home blends comfort, charm, and modern farmhouse touches throughout. Step inside to a welcoming foyer. There is a one bedroom and full bath on the first floor providing flexibility for family living, guests, or a home office. At the heart of the home is a beautiful Eat in kitchen featuring granite countertops, ample cabinetry,
Welcome to Ridgewood Avenue! This inviting 5 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers no through traffic and features a charming, welcoming granny porch, perfect for relaxing. Step inside to a spacious living room with wood floors, a wood-burning fireplace, and gorgeous moldings. The dining room shines with crown molding, and the eat-in kitchen boasts stainless steel appliances and granite counters. The
Welcome to 19 Bridle Path an exceptional opportunity to secure a beautifully maintained home in the heart of Farmingville, offered at $635,000. From the moment you arrive, the curb appeal commands attention. This home has four bedrooms and two bathrooms. Step into sun-filled living spaces that feel both inviting and elevated, creating a nice environment for everyday living and effortless
A True 4 Bedroom Ranch with a Half Basement on 50 x 125 Property. Home features an Open Floor plan with Large Kitchen, Dining Room and Living Room. New Top of the Line Heating System in 2025 plus New Hot Water Storage in 2023. Amazing Back yard with many fruit trees and berries! Fruit trees including Apple, Peach, Cherry, Plum, Pear, Walnut, Almond & Fig. Plus a row of Blackberry bushes,
Newly renovated single-family house sitting in a nice, quiet cul-de-sac in Farmingville, featuring 1 bed, 2 bath, living room, formal dining room, and eat-in kitchen on the 1st floor. 3 bed, 2 full bath on 2nd floor. Full finished basement with a separate entrance and a Bath. Attic for storage. Ready to move in. Good Location.
Welcome to this charming and well-maintained home nestled in the heart of Farmingville! This property offers a perfect blend of comfort and convenience, featuring a spacious layout with abundant natural light throughout. The home boasts generously sized bedrooms, an inviting living area, and a functional kitchen ideal for everyday living and entertaining.
Don't miss out on this indescribable treasure! Walk through to experience the superior craftsmanship as well as future potential found in this unique property. Custom built by owner with no expense spared and with only the finest quality materials and finishes. The quality is obvious, starting with the stucco exterior on all sides and authentic New Jersey natural stone throughout the facade which
A Spectacular Award Winning Gated Townhouse Community, Fairfield Hills At Farmingville, You Won't Believe It's A Rental. Private entry ranch/duplex style one bedroom plus den and two bedroom plus den all two bath. Gourmet kitchen featuring whirlpool appliances, side-by-side refrigerator/freezer, self-cleaning gas range, gas heat. So many features: ceiling fans, some customizable closets, ceramic
Property FeaturesApartment Residences: One Bedroom. Two Bedroom. Three Bedroom.Two Bedroom and Three Bedroom Plans With Two BathsAmple Community ParkingOn-Site MaintenanceNear to Bald Hill and Brookhaven Amphitheatre. Easy travel to Port Jefferson Harbor or Patchogue Village.LUXURY RENTAL RESIDENCES FEATURING:Tuscany Kitchen Cabinetry with Brushed Nickel HardwareResidences with Granite
Root Yourself. Grow. Flourish. Welcome to our serene 62-acre community where natural beauty meets modern living in the heart of Farmingville, New York. At The Arboretum, youll discover a refined collection of flats, lofts, town homes, and detached residences thoughtfully designed for comfort, connection, and convenience. From open, airy interiors to expansive outdoor amenities, every detail
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
