15

Central Fire Island Homes for Rent

Section Image
  • /11

    $22,000 per month

    • 4 Beds
    • 4.5 Baths
    • 2,500 Sq Ft
    • House for Rent

    358 Crown Walk, Fire Island Pine, NY 11782

    Gorgeously renovated 4 bedroom, 4.5 bathroom with all the bells and whistles! This home truly stuns from the moment you arrive. The saltwater pool welcomes you at the front entrance. This home has been spectacularly revived to its now modern glory, while keeping the Fire Island Pines aesthetic intact. The handsome furnishings make this fully air-conditioned home excellent for lounging with a cup

    Andrew Manzo D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD

    358 Crown Walk, Fire Island Pine, NY 11782
  • /14

    $4,500 per month

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    19 Champlain St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $4,500 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Newly Renovated Awesome Location Spacious 4 Bedroom 2 Bath Private Deck With Tiki Bar And Outdoor Bathroom. Great For Entertaining. Includes Separate Entrances, Outdoor Shower/Full Bath, Handicap Access, 5 Bikes, 8 Beach Chairs, Wagon And Beach Umbrella.

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    19 Champlain St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770
  • /11

    $15,250 per month

    • 4 Beds
    • 4.5 Baths
    • House for Rent

    35 Huron St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $15,250 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Sunning Contemporary Retreat with Ocean Views, this 4-bedroom, 4 ?-bathroom haven is designed for luxury and comfort, boasting spectacular ocean views. Step inside to find an Aspen-inspired living area perfect for both relaxation and entertaining. The gourmet kitchen, equipped with

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    35 Huron St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /17

    $8,000 per month

    • 4 Beds
    • 1.5 Baths
    • House for Rent

    12 Seneca Walk, East Northport, NY 11731

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $8,000 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Fun in the Sun! Enjoy a Pool & a Hot Tub. 4 Bedrooms, 1 1/2 Baths. Secluded Yard with Huge Deck. Includes 6 bikes, 12 beach chairs, wagon & 2 umbrellas.

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    12 Seneca Walk, East Northport, NY 11731
  • /12

    $10,000 per month

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    5 Bayview Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $10,000 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Bay Front Living & Spectacular Sunsets from the Deck of this Bayfront Beach House. This Home has Just been Entirely Remodeled with 4 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths. New Pictures Coming Soon! Sleeps 12 Comfortably.

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    5 Bayview Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /17

    $5,300 per month

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • House for Rent

    18 Erie St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent. Rates fluctuate from $3,850 per week June and $5,300 per week July, NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Peaceful, Immaculate and Available in Ocean Bay Park. The front of the house includes 2 bedrooms plus an oversized bed in the living room (sleeps 6). There is a large deck with plenty of outdoor seating, a grill and a private outdoor shower. The

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    18 Erie St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /26

    $12,000 per month

    • 5 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    39 Seneca Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $12,000 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Oceanfront 5 bedroom, 2 bath Unique Cape Cod with Views from Every Window. Open Layout Living Room, Dining Room & Kitchen with Cathedral Ceilings. Enjoy the Sprawling Deck with Outdoor Shower & Incredible Ocean Views. Perfect for Entertaining.,

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    39 Seneca Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /11

    $25,000 per month

    • 1 Bed
    • 1 Bath
    • Apartment for Rent

    49 E Bayview Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Second Story Apartment is Available To Rent from Memorial Day through Labor Day, a full 13 weeks, for just $25,000. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Enjoy Sunsets every day this Summer in a Bay Front Oasis. This charming second story apartment has sweeping views of the Bay and its own Beach and Swim area to enjoy. The apartment is a 1 bedroom, 1 full bath with an open kitchen, dining

    Maureen Putman Netter Real Estate Inc

    49 E Bayview Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /25

    $24,000 per month

    • 3 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    29 Superior Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available to Rent June $4,800/weekly or $18,000/monthly, July & August $6,000/weekly or $24,000 monthly, September $4,000/weekly or $16,000 monthly. Additional information: July rent: $24,000, June rent: $18,000. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Location, Location, Location! Between Midway Ave. in Seaview and Superior St. in Ocean Bay Park, THREE HOUSES FROM THE BEACH.

    Mary Mallott Netter Real Estate Inc

    29 Superior Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /13

    $37,000 per month

    • 4 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    37 Kelp Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Seasonal For $37,000. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Quiet street 1 block from Bay Beach Park, 1 block to tennis courts and softball field. All new appliances and recently renovated kitchen and bathrooms. Very Durable Bamboo flooring throughout. Lovely private back deck with hot tub, outdoor shower, shed, washer/dryer, and new gas grill. Includes 6 bikes,

    Helene Stransky Netter Real Estate Inc

    37 Kelp Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /14

    $13,500 per month

    • 5 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    38 Oneida St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $13,500 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Two Story 5 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Home. This House Includes Bikes, Some Suitable For Children. It Also Has Beach Chairs, A Wagon And A Beach Umbrella.

    Lisa Campbell Netter Real Estate Inc

    38 Oneida St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770
  • /8

    $18,000 per month

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • Apartment for Rent

    44 Bayview Ave, Fire Island, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $18,000 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Available for Rent Memorial Day -Labor Day! Very Nice 2 Bed, 1 Full Bath Apartment That Includes Attached Deck and Comes w/ Wagon. Great Summer Rental!

    Mary Mallott Netter Real Estate Inc

    44 Bayview Ave, Fire Island, NY 11770
  • /20

    $7,500 per month

    • 5 Beds
    • 2 Baths
    • House for Rent

    32 Kelp Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $7,500 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Very Bright & Airy Cozy Home Located Very Close To Children's Playground - Perfect For Families. 5 Bedrooms, Sleeps 10 And 2 Full Baths Plus An Outside Shower! This Home Also Includes 4 Bikes, A Wagon, A Beach Umbrella And 8 Beach Chairs. Seaview Amenities: Bay beach, Kiddy pool, Playground and,

    Robin Citriniti Netter Real Estate Inc

    32 Kelp Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • /16

    $10,000 per month

    • 2 Beds
    • 1 Bath
    • House for Rent

    63 Thompson Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $10,000 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Charming 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath, Very Close To Beach! Great Ocean Bay Park Location! Additional information: Lease Term: August-Labor Day, July, July-August, June, Memorial-Labor, Monthly Rate $10,000. Seaonal Rates Available.

    Robin Citriniti Netter Real Estate Inc

    63 Thompson Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • /20

    $16,000 per month

    • 3 Beds
    • 1.5 Baths
    • House for Rent

    4 Superior St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

    This Home is Available To Rent Weekly For $16,000 NOT a month. Fire Island is a vacation destination. Single Story Home, Newly Renovated, Clean, Bright, And Open! Additional information: Lease Term: August-Labor Day, July, July-August, June

    Robin Citriniti Netter Real Estate Inc

    4 Superior St, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Why Live in Central Fire Island

Central Fire Island is a coastal neighborhood characterized by its pristine beaches, forests nestled between dunes, and small coastal towns. Known for its long history as an LGBTQ+ friendly area, Cherry Grove, or "The Grove," is one of the oldest communities and a popular summer destination for New York’s theater and arts groups since the 1930s. The island is car-free, with residents and visitors relying on walking, bicycles, or golf carts. The National Park Service reports that 2.2 million visitors come to Fire Island from May through October. Attractions include the Sunken Forest, a rare maritime holly forest, and Sailors Haven beach and marina. Architectural styles vary from beach cottages with cedar shake siding to contemporary and modern homes. The neighborhood has a lower crime risk compared to the national average. Events like The Invasion of the Pines on the Fourth of July and The Pines Party highlight the vibrant local culture. Nightlife is lively, with venues such as Cherry’s on the Bay, the Pavilion, and Sip-n-Twirl offering music, dancing, and drag shows. The Cherry Grove Community House and Theater hosts various events, including fitness classes and nighttime shows. Children attend the highly rated Bay Shore Middle School and Bay Shore High School on Long Island. The island's seasonality means most businesses close by the end of October, requiring residents to be well-prepared for the winter months. Access to the island is primarily by ferry, with reduced service in the off-season.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most popular neighborhoods for renters near Central Fire Island?
The most popular neighborhoods for renters near Central Fire Island are Western Fire Island and Downtown Bay Shore.
What are the most popular zip codes for renters near Central Fire Island?
The most popular zip codes for renters near Central Fire Island are 11731, 11770, 11706, 11730 and 11782.
How to Rent a Home