Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree, NY Home for Rent

Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree, located on Long Island's South Shore in New York, is a waterfront community known for its sandy beaches, tiki bars and year-round fishing. Situated on a barrier island between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great South Bay, it offers a vacation-like lifestyle less than 60 miles from Manhattan. The area features two-story beach houses, often on stilts with garages beneath, and smaller cedar-sided cottages. Many homes include wraparound porches, piers, private boat docks and swimming pools. Despite its popularity, housing costs are relatively affordable due to the land being leased from the town of Babylon. Flood insurance is required in much of the community, though some areas are exempt. Outdoor activities are abundant, with boating, fishing, paddleboarding and kayaking being popular. Captree State Park offers a boat ramp, fishing pier and charter fishing tours, while Gilgo Beach is ideal for swimming and sunbathing. Cedar Beach Golf Course provides an 18-hole, par-3 golfing experience. Essential services and stores are accessible within a 10-minute drive to the mainland, including grocery stores like Stop & Shop and Best Farms. Dining options on the island include Salt Shack, Tiki Joe’s and Gilgo Beach Inn, known for their seafood and drinks. The Babylon Union Free School District serves the area, with Babylon High School offering AP and dual enrollment courses. Commuting to Manhattan is convenient via the Babylon Long Island Railroad station 9 miles away, offering a train ride of just over an hour.