$308,069Average Value$152Average Price per Sq Ft46Homes For Sale
The Sandstone Capital of the World
Home to the largest sandstone quarry in the world, Amherst combines the neighborhood feel of a small-town community with modern city amenities in Lorain County, Ohio. “Amherst is desirable for the school system and its proximity to major highways and shopping centers,” says Gail Maier, Realtor with Howard Hanna. Established as a city in 1960, Amherst developed due to the lumber and grindstone industries. Its location along the shore of Lake Erie consists of several quarries with abundant sandstone, which are used to make grindstones commonly used in public building construction. Amherst’s booming grindstone production led to railroad expansion and the city’s recognition as The Sandstone Capital of the World. While there are no active quarries in Amherst today, its sandstone history is seen in local architecture, like the Amherst Town Hall, which was built almost entirely out of sandstone. The city is now home to 13,000 residents, and companies like UH Amherst Health Center and Nordson Corporation, a dispensing equipment manufacturer, are the city’s top employers. Community mainstays like the locally-owned Hot Dog Heaven and seasonal events like the Miracle on Main Street in December play a role in maintaining a strong identity and a know-your-neighbor feel. With a suburban lifestyle and commuter accessibility, Amherst is a sought-after community along Beaver Creek, all just 35 miles outside Cleveland.
Amherst is best known as the sandstone capital of the world.
Sandstone quarries, some nearly 200 feet deep, sit quietly on the outskirts of Amherst.
1/2
Ranch-styles, new builds and expansive Colonial Revivals
Low-cost housing, new builds, and a sense of privacy attract buyers to Amherst. "The market in Amherst is very good,” says Maier, with over a decade of real estate experience in the area. “Home prices are down, but there’s not enough homes on the market right now.” Most homes cost around $265,000, which is $130,000 less than the national average.” Prices range from $240,000 for a three-bedroom ranch-style to upwards of $600,000 for a four-bedroom Colonial Revival with expansive acreage. The housing stock is primarily single-family ranch-style homes; however, 19th-century American Foursquares and bungalows are concentrated downtown. Multi-family townhouses are available in subdivisions like English Lakes starting in the mid-$200,000s. Many subdivisions have developed over the past decade, and new construction is ongoing in neighborhoods like Eagle Ridge and The Reserve At Beaver Creek, beginning in the low $300,000s.
Colorful American Foursquare homes stand out in Amherst.
Some Ranch-style in houses in Amherst sit on wooded lots.
1/2
City parks and gatherings at Maude Neiding Memorial Park
Amherst has a few parks within its borders for residents to enjoy. Amherst residents are accustomed to all four seasons, with average summer highs of 82 degrees Fahrenheit and winter lows of 21 degrees. Maude Neiding Memorial Park is a primary gathering space with a mulched playground, paved walking paths, and an outdoor community pool open from June through August. Amherst Township Park is another option to the east, offering a jungle gym with swings and sports facilities for baseball and soccer. The Amherst Beaver Creek Reservation is on the north side. It has a playground, picnic pavilion and hiking trails across 108 acres. The Beaver Creek Trail is 1.5 miles long and offers waterfront views of Beaver Creek. The public FoxCreek Golf & Racquet Club is in neighboring Lorain. It has an 18-hole championship golf course and an indoor tennis facility for players of all skill levels. For a contemplative time, the Amherst Historical Society is located downtown. Visitors can explore exhibits, preserved landmarks, and artifacts that depict the origin story of Amherst.
Maude Neiding Park, in the heart of Amherst, features a playground, pool, and pavilions for gatherings.
Beaver Creek Reservation is an ideal place for Amherst residents to go for a long walk in nature..
1/2
The annual Miracle on Main Street
Residents can celebrate the start of the holiday season in December at the annual Miracle on Main Street event. It starts with a parade along Park Avenue and features a range of seasonal activities from pictures with Santa to Christmas carols and the holiday market in downtown Amherst. Visitors can grab a free hot chocolate and catch the highly anticipated tree-lighting ceremony at Town Hall.
High marks at Amherst Exempted Village Schools
Families in Amherst are zoned for Amherst Exempted Village School District, which earns a B-plus from the review site Niche. It serves over 3,500 students and is ranked 128 out of 607 for the best school district in Ohio. It has one elementary school, one middle school, one junior high school and one high school. Most students attend Marion L. Steele High School, earning a B-plus with an advanced curriculum with 7 AP courses for higher education preparation. Private options like Lorain Preparatory Academy and St. Joseph Parish School are also available. Those interested in pursuing higher education can look to Lorain County Community College, which awards associate degrees in over 170 programs.
Amherst's Marion L. Steele High School offers a variety of sports programs.
Students from Amherst can attend Walter G. Nord Elementary School.
1/2
Grocers, eateries and breweries in downtown Amherst
Groceries and everyday essentials are available at commercial hubs on the city's north side. Shopping areas like Deerfield Town Center and Light House Commons feature a mix of retailers like Walmart Supercenter, Meijer and Target along Highway 2. Locals can choose between fast-food chains and locally-owned eateries in downtown Amherst when dining in the area. “The downtown area has been improved with lots of places to shop, eat and drink,” says Maier. Notable restaurants include Hot Dog Heaven, which has served classic ball-park fare in the community since 1976. Breweries like The Brew Kettle are also popular, offering a unique selection of seasonal and specialty IPAs in the city's heart.
Hot Dog Heaven, in Amherst, specializes in hot dogs made with customizable toppings.
Amherst locals have quick access to major grocers and local retailers.
1/2
Healthcare and commuting into Cleveland on U.S. I-90
Highway 2 runs along the northern border, connecting residents to neighboring areas and U.S. Interstate 90 for commutes into Cleveland. Amherst has no public transportation; however, the Lorain County Transit bus offers rides to neighboring Lorain and Elyria. When traveling farther, the Cleveland Hopkins International Airport is 24 miles away. For healthcare, the UH Amherst Health Center is located in downtown Amherst.
Crime
According to FBI data, the Amherst Police Department’s violent and property crime rates remain well below national figures. Violent crime increased by 700% in 2023, while property crime fell by 4%.
Written By
Christian Slater
Photography Contributed By
Nile Vincz
Video By
Francesco Basti
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Floria Aguilera,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Amherst, OH sell after 39 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Amherst, OH over the last 12 months is $288,970, up 8% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Distinctive 5-bedroom 3 full 2 half bath Cape Cod with room to spread out on 4.86 acres, located south of I-90 for convenient highway access. An inviting front porch welcomes you into this spacious home featuring a first-floor primary suite with double closets and an en-suite bath, plus two additional main-level bedrooms and a second full bath with double-sink vanity. Upstairs, it offers two
Country Charm Meets Modern Comfort on 2.5 Acres!Welcome home to this beautifully remodeled country property in Henrietta Township! Originally built in 1850, this home perfectly blends timeless character with today's modern updates.Featuring 3 large bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, you'll love the spacious layout designed for comfortable living. The inviting living room is highlighted by a
A beautiful home warms the heart! Gather around the cozy fireplace and be comfortable during this winter season. Unique and exceptional 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath townhouse style (single family home) with beautiful stone and vinyl exterior, 2 car attached garage with entry to the kitchen is a plus and very convenient. Quality Amherst schools! Enter to be amazed by this spectacular, 2 story foyer and
Welcome home to this spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch in the desirable Eagle Ridge Development within the Amherst School District. This newer home features an open-concept layout, updated flooring, neutral finishes, and a split-bedroom design offering added privacy. Enjoy added convenience with lawn/grounds maintenance and snow removal included, making for easy, low-maintenance living.The
Welcome home! Beautifully remodeled and thoughtfully designed, this spacious 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of modern updates, comfortable living space, and room to spread out. The inviting living room features a charming decorative fireplace, while the formal dining room provides the perfect setting for everyday meals or entertaining. The spacious family room addition offers
You know what you want – an open floor plan that still feels inviting, enough space for your family to move while still feeling close to what’s going on, and all the amenities you need at a price you can afford. Look no further than the Ivy, Ryan Homes’ 1660 square foot home that offers all this and more. The main level features a welcoming foyer with a coat closet, and a large open great room
The Pine townhome blends sensibility and style. Enter the welcoming foyer from the covered porch or through the garage. It’s the perfect location for a family zone. The wide-open great room flows seamlessly into the gourmet kitchen and light-filled dining area, where an optional island can provide extra storage and counter space. Upstairs, find two generous secondary bedrooms and a full bath;
Exceptional Custom Colonial on a Private 2.12-Acre Retreat! Welcome home to this impressive 5-bedroom, 4-bath Colonial offering the perfect blend of space, comfort, and functionality. Situated on a private 2.12-acre lot, this property is designed for both everyday living and unforgettable entertaining. The main level features a luxurious first-floor owner's suite with double vanities, a jetted
Build your dream home in the country on nearly 5 beautiful acres located in the highly desirable Firelands Local School District! Enjoy the perfect blend of rural living and convenience, with easy access to Route 2 and the Ohio Turnpike for quick travel east or west. The property features a spacious 30' x 70' barn and an existing dug well, providing a great foundation for your future plans.
Looking to right size to a more manageable home, this home would be perfect for you. This is a 3 bedroom , 1 full bath with a living room, formal dining room, kitchen and laundry room on one floor. There is a sliding door from the dining area to a deck overlooking a large backyard perfect for children to play or your own garden. You are located close to all the stores and schools in Amherst. Call
Welcome to this beautifully upgraded Amherst home, where luxury, comfort, and functionality come together in every detail. Thoughtfully improved throughout, this move-in-ready property offers exceptional indoor and outdoor living spaces designed for everyday enjoyment and entertaining. Step inside to find a spacious floor plan highlighted by three fireplaces located in the living room,
Charming Home in a Quaint Neighborhood within the Amherst School District. Welcome to this delightful 3-bed/2-bath home nestled in a peaceful neighborhood. Featuring a classic layout with spacious living areas, this property offers endless potential for those looking to add their personal touch.Highlights:* Prime location in a quiet, established community* Generous lot* Plenty of windows
Distinctive 5-bedroom 3 full 2 half bath Cape Cod with room to spread out on 4.86 acres, located south of I-90 for convenient highway access. An inviting front porch welcomes you into this spacious home featuring a first-floor primary suite with double closets and an en-suite bath, plus two additional main-level bedrooms and a second full bath with double-sink vanity. Upstairs, it offers two
The Villas at Quarry Ridge brings a fresh approach to Amherst, OH villas, offering thoughtfully designed 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom single-story villa homes at 230 S. Leavitt Rd. This brand-new community is built for residents who want modern comfort and low-maintenance convenience in one of Northeast Ohio's most welcoming small towns.
Pinecrest Apartments located in Amherst, Ohio offers 1 and 2 and 3 bedroom apartments for rent. This community offers amazing amenities in these beautiful apartment homes such as free heat and water, fully carpeted units, ceiling fans, air-conditioning...the list goes on.
This apartment is quite the find!!! It is nestled among trees and has been freshly painted. It has all new carpeting throughout and the bathroom as has nice updates. Very spacious apartment with an eat in kitchen and pantry. Off street parking. There is a stackable washer/dryer in this unit. Has newer windows and entry doors. Oh, and we almost forgot, ALL UTILITIES ARE INCLUDED!!!
This apartment is quite the find!!! It is nestled among trees and has been freshly painted. It has all new carpeting throughout and the bathroom as has nice updates. Very spacious apartment with an eat in kitchen and pantry. Off street parking. There is a stackable washer/dryer in this unit. Has newer windows and entry doors. Oh, and we almost forgot, ALL UTILITIES ARE INCLUDED!!!
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
