$567,135Average Value$322Average Price per Sq Ft9Homes For Sale
Bethlehem is a peaceful getaway for city dwellers
Bethlehem started as a farming community before the Revolutionary War. Centuries later, rolling farmland and forested hills still draw people to this rural community, whether for a permanent home or a relaxing getaway from the city. “Litchfield County is a big draw for weekenders from New York,” says Beverly Mosch, a longtime Bethlehem resident and a Realtor with Sotheby's International Realty. “Most move to Washington or Roxbury, but you get more house for your money here.”
The town’s rural setting offers peaceful drives and beautiful views.
Bethlehem’s welcoming signs greet visitors to this historic Connecticut town.
1/2
Historic and modern homes with a wide price range
Houses date as far back as the 1700s but include many newer builds as well, some with a modern flair, some staying true to the historic aesthetic. Smaller houses and homes in need of renovations can sell for $200,000 to $350,000. Preserved historic Colonials and midcentury houses can sell from $400,000 to more than $1 million. New Traditional homes from the 2000s on several acres of land — some with views of woods, farmland or lakes — sell in the same range.
A historic home in Bethlehem surrounded with lush greenery.
Residents appreciate the tranquility and scenic beauty of Bethlehem’s rural landscape.
1/2
Small town businesses on Main Street
The town has a handful of businesses on and near Main Street. Nick’s Country Kitchen is a casual spot for comfort food and all-day breakfast. Little Town Deli has breakfast and lunch sandwiches. And Painted Pony Restaurant serves steak, seafood and pasta inside and on the patio. It offers a lively dining experience with Tuesday trivia nights and bands playing every Saturday. There are also a few local shops, including Percy Thomson Meadows, a tiny market run by a fifth generation family farm that sells meat, eggs and other locally sourced produce on an honor system. “You leave your money or write a check and grab what you need,” says Mosch. “It’s really a statement about life in Bethlehem.” Across the street, Towne Apothecary serves as a small-town pharmacy and gift shop. At Diane’s Gift and Garden, shoppers will find antiques, quirky signs and flowers. Ace Hardware is on Main Street and there’s a Dollar General about 5 minutes away. For everyday shopping needs, Mosch says people drive 30 minutes to Waterbury. “Costco is alive and well in Waterbury and people here use it extensively. They’ll stock up so they don’t have to go out shopping for a while.”
Ace Hardware on Main Street serves Bethlehem’s home improvement needs.
Locals gather at Painted Pony for patio dining and weekend entertainment.
Bethlehem’s Main Street features unique spots like Little Town Deli for casual dining.
Locals gather at Nick’s for all-day breakfast and a welcoming atmosphere.
1/4
A recreational pond and a historic home with grounds to roam
During the summer, locals enjoy visiting the 110-acre Long Meadow Pond, whether to go boating, fishing or to relax on the beach. Come winter, the pond is used for ice skating and ice fishing. Veterans Memorial Park on Main Street has a playground, along with tennis and pickleball courts available by reservation. The Bellamy-Ferriday House & Garden is one of the town’s oldest homes, built in the mid-1700s, and serves as a museum and a place to stroll 10 acres of scenic grounds.
Long Meadow Pong in Bethlehem offers a soccer field, a beach, and a playground.
A family enjoys an afternoon at Long Meadow Pond Recreation Area.
1/2
Community events celebrate agriculture, garlic and Christmas
The Bethlehem Fair has been an annual tradition since 1925. The September event features fair food and amusement rides, and celebrates agriculture with farm animals, tractor shows and pumpkin contests. “Kids will raise calves and bring them to the fair,” says Mosch. “They typically sleep with their calf in the hay the night before to keep them happy and calm for the big day.” The Bethlehem Fair Grounds also host the Connecticut Garlic & Harvest Festival every October. It’s complete with garlic food stands, cooking demos and live music. “The festival brings vendors from all over,” says Mosch. “There’s one that even makes garlic ice cream.” During Christmastime, Main Street gets lit up, from the storefronts to the fire station and the town hall. There’s a triangular town green where a Christmas tree gets lit up every year as well.
Well-rated public schools and an all-boy's boarding school
Students attend Bethlehem Elementary School, which receives a B-plus grade from Niche. They’ll head to Woodbury for Woodbury Middle School and Nonnewaug High School, both rated B. The high school offers a media arts program with state-of-the-art broadcasting equipment. Students create on-air material for the school channel, which also airs sporting events. The Woodhall School, a boarding school for boys in ninth through 12th grade, is also in Bethlehem. The private school receives an A-minus.
Bethlehem Elementary School services both Woodbury and Bethlehem residents.
Niche gives Woodbury Middle School a B rating.
Nonnewaug High School scores a B rating from Niche.
1/3
Close to two highways
U.S. routes 6 and 202 are both about 4 miles away. Hartford and New Haven, the two closest major cities, are less than an hour away. New York City travelers have a two-hour commute. The closest commercial flights are out of Bradley International Airport near Hartford.
Written By
Nicolas Stuart
Photography Contributed By
TJ Wengert
Video By
Brandon Flash Craigie
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Zach Nichols,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Bethlehem, CT sell after 71 days on the market compared to the national average of 57 days. The median sale price for homes in Bethlehem, CT over the last 12 months is $465,000, down 5% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Custom-built in 2015, this 3,900 sq ft property combines modern comfort with timeless heritage. The 3,200 sq ft main residence features 3 bedrooms, a private office (or 4th bedroom), and an open-concept layout that flows from a custom kitchen-complete with a brick backsplash, live-edge island, and coffee bar-into a cathedral family room with a granite-hearth fireplace. A standout feature is the
Coming Soon!! Turnkey modernized antique with luxury finishes. Best value under $900K. Right near the Washington, CT border and a few short miles to the Mayflower Inn & Spa 90 min from NYC. Set on a scenic country road in the heart of Litchfield County. 1800s caretaker's cottage with original wide-plank floors, significantly expanded over the decades and fully renovated 2023-2026. Dramatic
A little touch of heaven in a sweet Bethlehem Lake community, nestled in sought after Litchfield County. Completely rebuilt and completed in 2025, this 900+ sq ft home is perfect as a weekend getaway, year-round retreat, or an ideal option for short-term rental use. Designed with an eye for detail, the great room blends living, dining, and kitchen spaces under vaulted ceilings with beams,
Welcome to Todd Hill Stables! Incredible opportunity for turnkey horse facility with additional room for expansion on almost 40 acres! Live, work and play on this beautiful property in a prime location with sweeping southern views. The property features a 184ft x 63ft indoor riding arena with elevated viewing area. Adjacent to the indoor arena is unique building to live and work all in one. It
Beautiful and secluded 1.9 acres of expansive yard in the beautiful Litchfield county/Town of Bethlehem. 7 room 4 bedroom 1 bath Cape style home with 1 car attached garage. Enjoy the spacious covered deck. Updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances and quartz countertop, updated bath, refinished hardwood floors; new furnace and roof. Move-in condition. Minutes from shopping, March Farms,
Builders take notice of Tulip Tree Village Condominium Complex in Southern Bethlehem! 4-5 plots available for freestanding residential homes! Owner will sell as a package or staggered sales over time. Owner financing possible with qualified builder. Cul de sac community with existing homes and the 4-5 additional home sites that are currently for sale. This is a condo complex and Unit 6 is
Builders take notice of Tulip Tree Village Condominium Complex in Southern Bethlehem! 4-6 plots available for freestanding residential homes! Owner will sell as a package or staggered sales over time. Owner financing possible with qualified builder. Cul de sac community with existing homes and the 4-6 additional home sites that are currently for sale. Maps attached!
This authentic antique home is ideally located on one of Bethlehem's most desirable country roads, surrounded by other elegant historic properties. Meticulously maintained, it showcases true period charm with spacious rooms, high ceilings, original wide-board floors throughout, and a grand central chimney serving three fireplaces. The main level is perfect for both daily living and entertaining,
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY WITH MULTIPLE POSSIBILITIES!!! Located in the classic New England town of Bethlehem on 8.5+ acres this is your opportunity for unlimited potential. Build your own Private Estate, Family Compound, Multi-Family Investment, Business Operations with Offices and Storage, Horse Property, Farm and Possible Residential Development. There are two Residential homes and additional
Historic Estate with Pond, Barns and 12.7 Acres of Natural Beauty - Step into a piece of New England history with this exceptional 12.7-acre estate, featuring a historic sea captain's home originally built in Mystic and relocated to Bethlehem in 1961. Rich in heritage and thoughtfully updated with newer roof and mechanics, the home offers three spacious bedrooms, including a primary suite with a
Unique opportunity to own a one-of-a-kind contemporary retreat where home, lifestyle, and business potential come together. This 3-bedroom, 2 full bath property is filled with character, featuring a sun-drenched living room with soaring ceilings and a stunning floor to ceiling brick fireplace as its centerpiece. The spacious rear deck overlooks a private, tree lined yard, creating the perfect
RARE OPPORTUNITY! Your True Lakefront Escape Awaits! Welcome to a rare opportunity to own a year-round 2-3 bedroom cottage directly on beautiful Long Meadow Lake-where you can step outside and dip your feet right in the water from your own property. Cherished by the same family for over 40 years, this home offers the perfect chance to CREATE your own lakeside retreat. Whether you envision simple
A mid-century modern-inspired, one story Litchfield County single family home. This comfortable, furnished (OR unfurnished) 2 (or 3) BR, 1.5 Bath single-family home sits on a 4+ acre lot. In bucolic Bethlehem, the property is located nearby to March Farm, The Bantam Market, Arethusa Farms, Bantam Arts, Litchfield Green, Washington Depot Farmers Market, Steep Rock Preservation, the New Morning
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
