$709,590Average Value$507Average Price per Sq Ft41Homes For Sale
A tight-knit Brooklyn community with waterfront homes
A working-class, family-friendly enclave in south Brooklyn, Gerritsen Beach was once a summer community in the 1920s before becoming home to year-round residents over the century. Today, this close-knit, slightly secluded neighborhood still has its bungalows, but most properties consist of single-family houses, detached duplexes or multibedroom, waterfront homes, as well as prewar co-ops. Situated between Sheepshead Bay to the west and the preserved wetlands of Marine Park to the east, it’s seaside living sans the urban bustle of the rest of Brooklyn. Jerry Minsky, a licensed real estate agent with Douglas Elliman, says the area is “an urban alternative to more suburban areas in Long Island or New Jersey.” Access to public transit, however, is rather cumbersome and the area is at risk of flooding. As opposed to the rest of New York City, where the renters are the majority, nearly 84 percent of residents own property, and price points are considerably lower.
Homes like this colorful Dutch colonial can be found within Gerritsen Beach.
A view of Gerritsen Beach from the Salt Marsh Nature Trail.
1/2
Single-family homes, detached duplexes, bungalows and co-ops
Many homes are prewar, circa 1920s, but some newer and renovated properties have come along post-Hurricane Sandy. Price points for single-family homes hover around $699,000, but the average home sale is $529,976, with a median single-family price of $615,000. Cozy, waterfront bungalows can go for $699,000, a newer single-family duplex for $648,000, and a colonial revival, detached duplex with a garage and terrace near the beach can list for $699,000. Prewar co-ops in mid-rise buildings are priced much lower, ranging between $165,000 for a one-bedroom to $239,000 for a three-bedroom. Some waterfront properties with boat slips along Plumb Beach Channel start at $1 million. Many of the homes are fixer-uppers and in need of renovation. Further south, bungalows and colonial-style duplexes are tightly packed along narrow, bayside streets, and docks and boat slips line Plumb Beach Channel, which runs inland along the western border of Gerritsen Beach.
A row of newer homes in Gerritsen Beach.
Expansive apartment buildings can be seen along the northern part of Gerritsen Beach.
1/2
Local shops and pubs along Gerritsen Avenue
Gerritsen Avenue is the main commercial drag of the community, with locally-owned shops, bodegas, pharmacies, pizzerias and pubs. Path of Cha offers a wide selection of gourmet teas, Tommy’s Italian Ices serves up cold treats, and The Gather Inn Again, a divey gastropub where the local volunteer firefighters tend to gather, are all along the avenue. On the waterfront, Tamaqua Bar & Marina is the main gathering spot for food and evening life. For groceries, Key Food can also be found along the northern end of the neighborhood, with several local markets in between.
Victoria Pizzeria is one of the oldest restaurants in Gerritsen Beach.
Tamaqua Bar & Marina is an iconic establishment in Gerritsen Beach.
1/2
Limited public school in and around the area
P.S. 277 Gerritsen Beach Elementary is the only public elementary school in the neighborhood, and it receives an A rating on Niche. In neighboring Marine Park, J.H.S. 278 serves middle school students and receives an A-minus rating, while in Sheepshead Bay, New Visions Charter High School - Advanced Math & Science, which has a B-plus-rating on Niche, was ranked as the number 14 charter high school in the state.
New Visions Charter High School for Advanced Math/ Science has a beautiful campus.
JHS 278 Marine Park provides educational excellence, preparing young minds for a bright future.
1/2
Preserved wetlands, hiking trails, and a private beach
The lush salt marsh and preserved grassy parklands of Marine Park are simply stunning, especially along the hiking trails. Residents can access the park and its trails on the southeastern side of the neighborhood. Several scenic points of interest from the trails are accessible by residents, including Point Lookout, which offers views of Manhattan and Jamaica Bay, and White Island Lookout, which overlooks the creek. Notably, it’s Brooklyn’s largest green space, complete with baseball fields, skate parks, bocce courts, canoe launch sites, a golf course, playgrounds and more. The Kiddie Beach, a private beach for local residents only, can be accessed at the end of Post Court and Hyman Court.
Kiddie Beach is a small well kept up beach in Gerritsen Beach.
Marine Park has a popular Golf Course close to Gerritsen Beach.
1/2
Express bus with access to Manhattan
There are no subway stops in the neighborhood, nor a ferry, however the BM4 Super Express bus brings residents to Midtown Manhattan via Madison Avenue for $7 each way. The nearest subway is one mile west into Sheepshead Bay, but the B31 bus line runs up the avenue and will take you to the Q train in roughly 10 minutes. Belt Parkway, which leads to Manhattan or farther east, is accessible via Knapp Street.
Gerritsen Beach counts with the BM4, and B31 Buses to connect with Brooklyn and Manhattan.
The Q and B Sheepshead Bay Train connects with buses to Gerritsen Beach.
1/2
Nature-based events at Marine Park
Brooklyn Public Library holds regular story time events, and in warmer months, residents head to Marine Park for outdoor events. Marine Park Alliance also holds regular outdoor survival courses, nature-based workshops and celebrations.
Important things to know
Subway is not readily accessible, except via bus. The area is also at risk for flooding.
The Sheepshead Bay Train Station is 15 min away from Gerritsen Beach.
The Tamaqua Marina shows how close the houses are to the water level in Gerritsen Beach.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Doesn't feel inviting for an outsider. Predominantly of one race. It is a quiet and safe neighborhood but in the night cars like to race.
4.0Current Resident
12/28/2023Niche Review
I like it here it is very nice and quiet and safe. Lots of greenery that has gotten me in touch with nature. The beach is also very nice as well. There is kind of nothing to do around here except walk in nature and on the beach, but that's alright. There are also not many stores around here which kind of sucks. Many of the people who live here have lived here their entire lives, so moving in I kind of felt like an outsider. It was definitely not very diverse when I moved in, but it has gotten a tad bit better.
1.0Niche User
8/29/2020Niche Review
DO NOT LIVE HERE IF BLACK, ITS A THREAT TO YOUR PERSONAL SAFETY. I know someone who has been in this neighborhood multiple times and have been attacked by dogs and threatened to be LYNCHED by mobs of teens younger than him. Dead Black teens show up along the marshes there all the time I've heard, and you do not need to be there long to realize your life is in danger. The lack of information about this is HORRIFYING and put black lives that consider living here at risk, who just see the positive statistics. DO NOT LIVE THERE IF YOU ARE NOT WHITE, DO NOT.
Are you familiar with the Gerritsen Beach neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Gerritsen Beach
US
Homicide
4
4
Sexual Assault
3
4
Assault with Weapon
4
4
Robbery
3
4
Burglary
3
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
3
4
Larceny
2
4
Crime Score
2
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Gerritsen Beach Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Gerritsen Beach, Brooklyn sell after 62 days on the market compared to the national average of 56 days. The median sale price for homes in Gerritsen Beach, Brooklyn over the last 12 months is $618,250, down 5% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Double Lot! This home is Sunny, spacious and Beautifully Renovated with a Waterview and sits on a nice quiet street. This 1 family 4-bedroom home features plenty of space for large family. The Sunny eat in kitchen has sliders to the extra large yard. Theres 2 bedrooms, large living room and full bath on the first floorThe second floor has 2 additional bedrooms, 3/4 bath, with room for
This one Family Detached high ranch Home is located in Gerritsen Beach. It is a High-Ranch with 4 Bedrooms and 2 Bathrooms . The entire house has been thoughtfully gut renovated. The First Floor is a modern open floor plan and consists of a New Kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a large island with pendant fixtures. Large open Living Room with a custom insert, Large Formal Dining Room
Gerritsen Beach-This 1 family 2-bedroom high ranch with partially finished basement. The first-floor features kitchen, L-shaped living room, full bath and 2 bedrooms all on one floor. There is a spacious, finished attic to use for a playroom or office.The full basement has 1/2 bath and one finished room for a bonus. Also in the basement, there is a large storage room that can be finished.
Presenting one of the finest one-bedroom cooperative residences currently available in Marine Park, this impeccably renovated home showcases exceptional craftsmanship and timeless style throughout. Glistening hardwood floors, elegant tray ceilings, custom high-hat lighting, and refined finishes create a warm and sophisticated atmosphere. The thoughtfully designed custom eat-in kitchen features
OPEN HOUSE BY APPOINTMENTS! Welcome to this bright and spacious 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom co-op located on the 5th floor of a well-maintained building in the desirable Brigham Park community. Offering approximately 750 sq. ft. of interior space, this coop features comfortable layout with separate rooms, a windowed eat-in kitchen, and a windowed bathroom.The apartment boasts classic parquet
2450 Gerritsen Avenue is a spacious two-family brick home located in the desirable Gerritsen Beach neighborhood of Brooklyn. This three-level property features a private driveway along with additional parking in front of the house, providing ample parking space for residents and guests. The roof was replaced in 2024, offering peace of mind for the new owner. The first and second floors are
Experience the ultimate Brooklyn waterfront lifestyle in this stunning, sun-drenched modern nautical home. Situated directly on the tranquil Gerritsen Beach canal, this property blends sleek design with relaxed coastal charm. Wake up to peaceful water views, come right out to your boats, and enjoy vibrant sunsets every single evening. The First floor opens to a Large living Room with heated tile
New Construction Home ! Every detail has been thoughtfully designed. Spacious, light-filled rooms flow seamlessly creating an atmosphere of refined comfort and effortless entertaining. The main level offers grand scale living, high ceilings, and lush textures-ideal for elegant dinners and celebrations. The contemporary design extends to luxurious bathrooms, radiant heated floors throughout, and a
Charming 1-Bedroom Co-op in a great neighborhood. Welcome to this bright and well-maintained 1-bedroom co-op located in a desirable, 100% owner-occupied building. This inviting apartment offers a spacious layout, abundant natural light, and a comfortable living environment, making it an excellent choice for both first-time buyers and those looking to downsize. The apartment is in good condition
Spacious 3-Bedroom Coop for Sale in Sheepshead Bay – Bright, Airy, and Well-Maintained! Located on the 5th floor of a well-kept building, this charming 3-bedroom coop offers a smart and functional layout that includes a spacious living room, an eat-in kitchen, three generously sized bedrooms—all with closets—and a full bathroom. Excellent natural light with southern exposure in the living room
3 Bedroom 2 full baths. Eat In Kitchen, Dining Area, Main Bedroom is very large. Plenty of closets in this elevator building with live in super. The building is close to shopping, houses of worship, Marine Park and Gateway Nation Recreational area.
This sunny 2 bedroom Co-op is located in Marine Park. There is a separate dining area and a large eat-in-kitchen with a window. The living room is very large along with the bedrooms and plenty of closets. Beautiful flooring and freshly painted walls are a plus. The location is perfect for going to the park along with close by shopping and buses to the city. Maintenance includes gas, electric and
This two-story home features two bedrooms, a full bath, an eat-in kitchen, and a one-car garage. The information provided is estimated to the best of our abilities at this time.
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
