Rapidly growing residential neighborhood in Northwest Cape Coral
Burnt Store may be an odd name for a neighborhood, but it’s about as accurate as they come. Legend has it that an old settler’s trading post was burned down along what is now Burnt Store Road, and the name has stuck ever since. Today, the community is blossoming into one of the hottest spots for new residential construction in all of Cape Coral. Florida Ranch-style homes sit on quiet rural streets, often with empty plots of land on either side. Pine Island Road features a handful of shops and restaurants, and commercial development is still catching up to the neighborhood’s growth, although plans like the 7 Islands Project highlight significant monetary investments in the area. While locals certainly enjoy their residential seclusion, a different aspect of life draws many in. Canals wind throughout the neighborhood and connect to the deep blue waters of the nearby Gulf of Mexico. “Burnt Store is a boaters paradise,” says Veldin ‘Dean’ Miskic, a local associate broker at eXp Realty with more than nine years experience in the Cape Coral area. “For someone that has a boat and likes to go fishing, if you’re on gulf access property, you’re talking 10-15 max to get out onto the Gulf."
Burnt Store has two public golf courses in the area, with driving ranges and practice greens.
Burnt Store consists primarily of single-family homes on large lots, and waterway access.
Burnt Store is a community of boaters.
1/3
Florida Ranch-style homes with modern finishes
Burnt Store stretches from Pine Island Road to the Lee County line and is a mix of winding canals, new construction and swaths of undeveloped fields. Housing is concentrated in the southern end and features various Florida ranch-style homes with modern finishes. Spanish-Revival style houses with stucco exteriors and tiled roofs can also be found scattered throughout. Grassy lawns with young palm trees sprouting up are a common sight, while backyards often contain screened-in swimming pools. Properties along the canal have private boat docks in the back, which provide direct access to the nearby Gulf of Mexico. Price points vary greatly depending on location and gulf access, but all listings have steadily risen over previous years. “The land keeps increasing in value because of the location,” Miskic says. “The area is blowing up; there’s just a lot of money going in.” Single-family builds on dry lots tend to price between $300,000 and $550,000, while waterfront homes price anywhere from $700,000 to $1.3 million, depending on proximity to the Gulf. Empty dry lots range from .15 acres to nearly half an acre and sell between $20,000 and $100,000. Larger waterfront lots can reach up to $600,000. The city of Cape Coral is playing catch up to the area’s development, and many properties do not have city utilities, meaning they rely on well water and septic tanks. An expansion project of city utilities is in the works, so many homeowners may be required to pay up to $30,000 to get connected.
Many homes in Burnt Store are new builds with a typical Floridian style.
White stucco homes are a popular style for new builds in Burnt Store.
Most Burnt Store homes have private docks offering direct access to the waterways.
1/3
Career academies at Mariner High School
Lee County School District serves the neighborhood and offers an open-choice enrollment system. Younger students can begin at Trafalgar Elementary, which receives a B-plus rating on Niche. The B-rated Mariner Middle School was recognized by the Florida Music Educators’ Association for having nearly 70% of its students enrolled in a music course. Mariner High School receives a B-plus and features numerous career academies in fields ranging from hospitality and tourism to engineering.
Trafalgar Elementary School is an above average, public school located in Cape Coral, FL.
Mariner Middle School is centrally located near residential communities,
Mariner High School is a large public high school in Cape Coral.
1/3
Kayak along the Great Calusa Blueway
Burnt Store’s recreation-based lifestyle begins at Jim Jeffers Park, which sits in the neighborhood’s southern end and features soccer fields, softball diamonds and basketball courts. The park’s mega playground is one of the largest in the state and was designed as both an inclusive and completely accessible structure for all children. Sirenia Vista provides a convenient kayak or canoe launch to explore the deep blue waters of the nearby Gulf of Mexico. The Great Calusa Blueway is a 200-mile aquatic trail that runs by the park and meanders through the coastal waters of Lee County and the 14,000-acre Matlacha Pass Aquatic Preserve. Wildlife sightings are common, and many kayakers find themselves paddling next to manatees or dolphins. Golfers can tee off at Coral Oaks Golf Course, built within a century-old oak hammock. Burnt Store Marina is north of the neighborhood and is the largest full-service deep-water marina on the Florida Gulf Coast.
Life in Burnt Store revolves around outdoor activities, such as kayaking.
Boating through the Great Calusa Blueway is a common activity in Burnt Store.
Burnt Store residents have easy access to two popular golf courses.
1/3
Dine with manatees at Miceli’s
Miceli’s is a popular neighborhood staple serving fresh seafood and classic American fare with daily live music. Residents aren’t the only ones drawn in, as manatees and dolphins can be seen swimming in the canal from time to time. Down the street, Burnt Store Tavern is most crowded on game days, while El Toro Mexican Bar & Grill features a menu of birria tacos and margaritas. Grocery stores ranging from Walmart to Publix are located along Pine Island Road. For more extensive retail, Coralwood Shopping Center is 14 miles away and has over 20 name-brand stores and a movie theater.
Micelli's Restaurant near Burnt Store offers popular seafood dishes like the grouper Rueben.
Burnt Store Tavern is a popular place to watch the game and gather with friends.
Burnt Store residents will find groceries and essentials at the nearby Publix.
1/3
Northwest Cape Coral Association is active
The Northwest Cape Coral Neighborhood Association is available for most residents to join and is the largest community-based organization in the city. The organization began in 2004 and has advocated for issues ranging from quality of life to property right. A full calendar of events includes everything from board meetings to Christmas Boat Parades, and members are encouraged to play active roles in their community. The Association has played a role in the 7 Islands Project, a 48-acre mixed-use development featuring upscale dining and waterfront condos, which is expected to be completed in late 2024.
Live music is a staple in Southwest Florida communities, and Burnt Store is no exception.
Golfers at Burnt Store Country Club can have a refreshing drink and lunch under the tiki.
1/2
Travel along Burnt Store Road
Burnt Store Road received a makeover in 2023 and welcomes visitors from northern cities like Punta Gorda, 18 miles away. “They just expanded Burnt Store Road to facilitate the growth of Cape Coral,” Miskic says. “The road looks awesome, and it’s a lot easier to get in and out now.” Pine Island Road runs parallel and connects to downtown Fort Myers, 17 miles away. Southwest Florida International Airport is 34 miles away and offers various domestic and international flights. Cape Coral Hospital is the closest medical facility, 13 miles away.
Burnt Store is 34 miles from Southwest Florida International Airport.
Burnt Store Road connects the neighborhood to Punta Gorda and Cape Coral.
1/2
Hurricane Risks
Southwest Florida is prone to hurricanes, and the neighborhood is in a designated FEMA flood zone. Hurricane Ian was a Category 5 storm that hit Cape Coral—Fort Myers in 2022, resulting in the costliest storm in Florida’s history. Lee County is enrolled in the National Flood Insurance Program, and homeowners are encouraged to review available policies.
Burnt Store has evacuation routes along Burnt Store Road.
Burnt Store is prone to hurricane risks being so close to the water's edge.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Burnt Store neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Burnt Store
US
Homicide
1
4
Sexual Assault
1
4
Assault with Weapon
2
4
Robbery
3
4
Burglary
3
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
3
4
Larceny
3
4
Crime Score
2
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Burnt Store Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Burnt Store, Cape Coral sell after 160 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Burnt Store, Cape Coral over the last 12 months is $385,000, down 6% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Beautifully revitalized and newly staged, this 6th-floor corner residence at Vista del Sol is offered fully furnished and ready for its next owner. Rarely available, this light-filled corner unit features walls of windows that maximize privacy, natural light, and spectacular views. The versatile den has been thoughtfully transformed into a true 3rd bedroom, making this condo as functional as it
Into the Mystic. Southern Exposure. Direct Gulf Access. No Bridges. Deep Water. Sailboat Access. Motion is emotion, and this is where the boating lifestyle becomes real. Into the Mystic delivers true direct Gulf access with no bridges, no locks, and no waiting. Positioned on a deep water canal with highly desirable southern exposure, this property offers all day sun over the pool and waterfront
Experience Luxury Coastal Living at Its Finest. Discover refined elegance in this top-floor penthouse condo at Vista Del Sol, perfectly situated within prestigious Burnt Store Marina. This exquisite residence captures unparalleled panoramic views of Charlotte Harbor, Boca Grande, Cayo Costa, and the surrounding tropical paradise. Step inside the spacious open-concept floor plan, where soaring
*Gulf Access Pool Home on Rare 4-Way Intersecting Canal with Wide Water Views* Well-maintained and thoughtfully upgraded, this 4-bedroom plus den, 2-bath Gulf access residence offers a desirable waterfront setting on a wide 4-way intersecting canal, providing expansive water views, privacy, and a peaceful atmosphere. Eastern exposure delivers beautiful sunrise views over the water from the main
Welcome to a masterfully engineered waterfront estate where European sophistication meets Florida’s premier boating lifestyle. Offered furnished, this exceptional residence showcases uncompromising craftsmanship, intelligent design, and state-of-the-art automation throughout. From the moment you arrive, the new roof, fresh exterior paint, and pristine new cage set the tone for a home that has
Paradise Found!Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a top-floor end-unit condo in the highly coveted Vista del Sol community within Burnt Store Marina. This beautifully furnished 2-bedroom plus den, 2.5-bath residence blends casual Florida elegance with breathtaking views in every direction.Perched high above the community, this end unit offers sweeping panoramas of the marina,
If you value privacy, deep wide water canal with no bridges to world class fishing and beaches, beautifulsunsets in a custom-built one-of-a-kind home this can be yours. Located on the spreader "rim" canalacross from a state preserve, no structures will ever be built to obstruct your view or privacy. The homehas an east-west exposure to enjoy world class sunsets and experience the
Welcome to this beautifully maintained turnkey 4 bedroom, 2 bath pool home, built in 2021 and thoughtfully designed for comfort, style, and effortless Florida living. From the moment you step inside, you’ll appreciate the bright open floor plan, luxury vinyl flooring throughout, and tasteful furnishings that make this home truly move-in ready. The spacious kitchen is the heart of the
PRICE REDUCED TO $543,000 — Fully Renovated Coastal Farmhouse Pool Home in Cape Coral This is the one buyers have been waiting for — and the numbers prove it. Offered at $543,000 with all city water, sewer, and irrigation ASSESSMENTS PAID in full, this home delivers an immediate $50,000 advantage over comparable properties where those obligations remain outstanding. Add over $150,000 in
This home is VA assumable with a low interest rate, located in Flood Zone X—no flood insurance required—and offers low HOA fees. Welcome to Burnt Store Lakes, a vibrant community known for its scenic beauty, abundant wildlife, and endless outdoor recreation. Fully remodeled and thoughtfully upgraded, this rare gem blends modern elegance with prime access to eleven freshwater lakes, expansive
Welcome to 1605 NW 43rd Ave, your future “why didn’t we move here sooner?” home, tucked inside one of the most desirable pockets of NW Cape Coral. Surrounded by an enclave of stunning Gulf-access homes, this 4+Den, 2-Bath, 2-Car Garage beauty delivers space, style, and just the right amount of bragging rights. Step into the gourmet chef’s kitchen—yes, that kitchen—the one with high-end
Price Reduction in Paradise??? This is it...great view of intersecting canals....Waterfront living at its finest! Live the relaxed Florida lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of in this well-maintained 3-bedroom, 2 full bath PLUS a pool bath... home offers 2,253 sq ft of comfortable living space and boasts intersecting Gulf access canal views. Situated on an expansive 148 ft seawall, this property is
Coastal Living at Its Best – 2 Bed, 2 Bath Condo with COVERED PARKING in Harbor Towers at Burnt Store Marina! Welcome to Harbor Towers, located in the heart of the desirable Burnt Store Marina community! This spacious and well-maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo offers the perfect retreat for snowbirds or a great opportunity for investors. Enjoy an open-concept layout with a light-filled living
Beautiful rental home located in the desirable SW Cape Coral area, ideal for families seeking comfort, space, and a peaceful environment. This property features 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with a functional layout that offers spacious living areas and well-defined private spaces. It includes a two-car garage and a large driveway, providing excellent parking capacity for residents and guests.
This model home is a beautifully designed single-family residence that combines modern style with everyday comfort. This thoughtfully planned home offers a functional and inviting layout, typically featuring four bedrooms and three bathrooms, making it ideal for families, retirees, or seasonal residents. The open-concept floor plan creates a bright and airy atmosphere, seamlessly connecting the
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Now available in Cape Coral, FL - Featuring modern finishes, an open layout, and tile flooring throughout. Don't miss this opportunity for stylish living in a spacious, move-in ready home!$50 application fee for each adult (18+). No minimum credit score required. However, we do not accept applicants with evictions, active bankruptcies or
One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged. Now available in Cape Coral, FL - enjoy 1 FREE month of rent on this beautiful 4-bedroom home! Featuring modern finishes, an open layout, and tile flooring throughout. Don't miss this opportunity for stylish living in a spacious, move-in ready home!$50 application fee for each adult (18+). No minimum credit score required. However, we do not
Situated in a desirable NW neighborhood, surrounded by Gulf Access canals. Come see this beautiful 4-bedroom w/Den, 2-bathroom 2 Car garage house before it's too late! Upon entering, you'll immediately notice the attention to detail. The heart of the home is the great room, which is flooded with natural light with impact windows and glass sliders that lead to the extended under-truss lanai area.
BEAUTIFULL LUXURY HOME Brand new 3 bedroom 2.5 bath at Cape Coral Metallic color standing seam roof that contains a 35 yr warranty 48x24 Porcelain floors all throughout home Insulated high impact windows and doors High efficiency 16 seer A/C Low consumption 40 gallon water heater White quartz counter tops in kitchen and bathrooms Modern LED lights throughout home Luxury quality faucets White
Springs at Coral Shores is a brand new, premier apartment community offering private entry studio, 1, 2, and 3 bedroom homes in Cape Coral, FL. Enjoy beautiful onsite amenities, including a 24-hour fitness center, sparkling swimming pool, leash-free pet park, and more! We can't wait to show you around.
Unforgettable sunsets and Southwest Florida luxury!! Don’t miss this rare opportunity to rent a piece of paradise! This stunning Gulf access home offers everything you need to embrace the ultimate Florida waterfront lifestyle—from your own private beach and boating accommodations to expansive indoor-outdoor living spaces designed with both comfort and luxury in mind. Situated on a beautiful
**If you see this listing on CRAIGSLIST or FACEBOOK MARKETPLACE, it is fraud. Apply only on the My New Rental website***Discover modern living in this BRAND NEW single-family gem comes with a spacious 2-car garage and a beautifully sodded yard, perfect for your family and pets. Enjoy a contemporary lifestyle with stainless steel appliances, tile flooring in the kitchen and baths, plus
Experience the best of Southwest Florida in this "better-than-new" 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence. Spanning over 1,700 sq. ft. of sleek, modern living space, this home offers the perfect blend of coastal style and high-tech safety.Cook your meal in a Chef-Inspired Kitchen: Featuring stunning granite waterfall countertops, a custom tile backsplash, and a premium Samsung stainless steel smart
Be the first to live in this stunning new-construction 4-bedroom, 2-bath home just minutes from Crystal Lake Park and Fishing Entry #4. Enjoy spacious, open-concept living with a sleek kitchen, energy-efficient design, and stylish finishes throughout. Perfect for families and outdoor lovers alike, relax, fish, and explore all that Cape Coral has to offer right outside your door!?
At Burnt Store Village -Discover modern living in this BRAND NEW single-family gem comes with a spacious 2-car garage and a beautifully sodded yard, perfect for your family and pets. Enjoy a contemporary lifestyle with stainless steel appliances, tile flooring in the kitchen and baths, plus cozy wall-to-wall carpeting in all bedrooms. Energy-efficient doors and windows, along with LED lighting,
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
