$167,364Average Value$160Average Price per Sq Ft2Homes For Sale
How Amercrest blends historic homes with newer development
Even though Amercrest is one of Columbus' Columbus’s oldest neighborhoods, it has changed a lot in recent years. With just over 100 homes, this northeast side area has seen steady redevelopment since the early 2000s, blending newer builds at the American Addition subdivision with midcentury and early 1900s houses. Locals take real pride in where they live, and buyers often notice that the lower-than-average home prices come with a strong sense of community.
Residents' individuality makes their homes their own in Amercrest.
On the edge of Amercrest is the American Addition Community Garden.
1/2
Both historic and 21st-century homes are available
Most homes here date back to the midcentury era or the early 1900s, with Cape Cods and ranch-style houses making up most of what you’ll see. Sidewalks are rare, and lots tend to be smaller with detached garages and plenty of mature trees. Inventory has stayed tight over the years, which makes solid pricing data harder to pin down, but home values in Amercrest usually land in the high $100,000 range, higher than Argyle Park and Devon Triangle but similar to Oriole Heights and Milo-Grogan.
“That’s a much lower price point for sure,” says Erik Hiss, a broker with Keller Williams Capital Partners Realty. “A lot of investors look over there, because your prices are going to be low.” Denise Moore, a Realtor with H.C. Bland Realty Company, points to recent revitalization paired with long-standing neighborhood pride. “There’s a sense of loyalty for people who live there,” she says. “They care about their neighborhood. It’s kept very clean; if you drive through, you’ll see people picking up trash. There’s pride in where they live.”
Amercrest also includes a sizable industrial area, anchored by SA Recycling and United Alloys & Metals, though there is still open land available for future homes. HOAs are not common in this part of the city.
Renovated and updated Craftsman-style homes in the neighborhood.
This community is less than 5 miles from downtown Columbus.
1/2
Columbus City Schools and a private university are nearby
Local kids are zoned for the Columbus City School District, the largest in the state. The district recently had 44 of its schools earn 3 stars or higher on Ohio’s state report cards, a solid sign of academic and administrative progress. The district also met state standards for college and career readiness, earning a 3-star rating in that category for 2024–2025, with especially strong results in career-technical programs. Ohio Dominican University is 2 miles away in Teakwood. Established in 1911, it combines a liberal arts education with Catholic and Dominican traditions.
Windsor STEM Academy has a student-to-teacher ratio of 17-to-1.
Columbus School For Girls in Bexley has a large courtyard with several walking paths.
1/2
Easy commuting options by car or COTA bus
Nearby thoroughfares include Interstates 71 and 670, along with Joyce Avenue. The Ohio State University, downtown Columbus, the Columbus VA Medical Center and John Glenn Columbus International Airport are all less than 5 miles away. “I have a client who lives there who says that it’s Columbus’ best secret,” Moore says. “He says it’s very quiet and close to everything.” The area has plenty of stops for the Central Ohio Transit Authority bus line, including several on East 5th and Joyce avenues.
Where residents go for parks, pools and big events
Amercrest has several outdoor recreational areas, suited for big day trips or quick walks around the park:
Marie Moreland Park is a neighborhood pocket park with ball fields, a walking loop and picnic areas.
Barnett Park is a bit larger, with athletic courts, a playground and a sprayground that’s popular in the summer.
The Ohio Expo Center and State Fairgrounds is best known for major events, including the Ohio State Fair and the Goodguys PPG Nationals.
Windor Park draws locals for its community pool, which has lap swimming, water slides and a splash park.
Where locals shop for groceries and eat out
The closest supermarket is an Arlington Park Save A Lot, about 2 miles away. Limited shopping options are available along North Cassady Avenue at places like the Shoppes at Airpointe. More reliable retail is at the Easton Town Center, a little over 5 miles north. This area also includes big-box stores like Walmart Supercenter. For dinner, locals can sample a casual Caribbean menu at Island Vibes Restaurant, or authentic Middle Eastern cuisine at Zaki Grill.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Location! Peaceful and private home with potential! The additional 40 x 130 lot has the possibility of being a separate buildable lot like others currently being built upon in the neighborhood. Large yard. Deep block garage. Minutes from Ohio State University, Columbus International Airport, and Downtown Columbus.
Homes like this don't come around often. Built less than 10 years ago and sitting on a huge double lot, this property gives you the best of both worlds, newer construction and a huge yard with endless opportunity for the space. Large front & back covered porches. Inside, you'll find an open and bright layout with a large living room, dining room and a clean and contemporary kitchen. Generous
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
