$205,790Average Value$78Average Price per Sq Ft0Homes For Sale
Garden Prairie offers country living in Boone County
With one diner and one bar, Garden Prairie is a simple town about 20 miles from the city of Rockford. This small farming community of less than 600 residents lies out in the countryside of Boone County, where Matthew Mueller moved in 2020 to operate Emma J Farms. “We moved from a bigger town, so I like the privacy,” Mueller says. “It’s a place where people still leave their doors unlocked and don’t really have to worry about anything.” Mueller’s unattended, self-serve farmstand serves as a testament to his trustworthiness of the community, where the CAP Index Crime Score is 1 out of 10, compared to the national average of 4. While Garden Prairie isn’t known for being a touristy town, travelers do stop there to stay at the Northwoods RV Resort.
Self‑serve local produce highlights Garden Prairie’s neighborly spirit.
Neighbors in Garden Prairie enjoy easygoing rural surroundings.
1/2
Early 1900s and midcentury homes on spacious lots
Homes in Garden Prairie rarely come on the market. According to Homes.com calculation, which uses a combination of estimate data, the average home value in the town was around $200,000 in mid-2025. Common housing styles include bungalows and Victorian-style homes from the early 1900s and ranch-style homes built in the mid to late 1900s. Some are on quarter-acre lots, while others have up to 5 acres of land.
Classic layouts and big yards define Garden Prairie houses.
Early‑1900s touches mix with midcentury updates in Garden Prairie.
1/2
Neighbors connect at Garden Prairie Cafe and Pleasant Street Tavern
The community has two restaurants on Pleasant Street, which intersects with U.S. 20. Garden Prairie Café serves homestyle food in a casual diner atmosphere, and Pleasant Street Tavern is the local watering hole. “If you go to Garden Prairie Café in the morning, you’ll see your neighbors there catching up and eating breakfast before going out to work on their tractors for the day,” Mueller says. “On Friday nights, neighbors will go to Pleasant Street Tavern to hang out and drink beer.” While locals can pick up produce from the stand at Emma J Farms, Belvidere is about 5 miles away with Walmart, Aldi and other stores. Rockford has an even broader selection of retailers less than 20 miles away.
Garden Prairie welcomes travelers with friendly, low‑key gathering places.
Garden Prairie Café anchors Pleasant Street with friendly service.
1/2
Getting to Belvidere, Rockford and Chicago
From U.S. 20, it takes about 10 minutes to drive to Belvidere and 30 minutes to Rockford. There’s no public transportation in Garden Prairie, but Chicago’s Metra commuter train will extend to Belvidere in 2027. From Garden Prairie, it’s about a 90-minute to two-hour drive to Chicago.
Recreation and events at Garden Prairie Park and a conservation area
Garden Prairie Park is in the middle of town, within walking distance of many homes. It features a pavilion, playground and ball field. The Garden Prairie Park Improvement Association owns and maintains the park, which hosts an Easter egg hunt every year and a chicken broast in July and August. “The chicken broast is our biggest event,” Mueller says. “It draws a lot of people from the surrounding area. You get a half a chicken, sweet corn and some other food. It’s just a nice way for the community to get together.” Garden Prairie is also home to County Line Conservation Area, where hikers can explore nature trails and fish in the Kishwaukee River.
The County Line Conservation Area has long trails for residents of Garden Prairie.
Garden Prairie Park is a lovely neighborhood park.
1/2
Upgraded Career and Technical program at Belvidere High School
Kids go to public school in Belvidere through the Belvidere Community Unit School District 100. Students attend Meehan Elementary School and Belvidere South Middle School, both of which receive C grades from Niche. They’ll go on to Belvidere High School, graded a C-plus. In 2024, the high school used a $100,000 grant to upgrade its Career and Technical classrooms with new equipment, giving them more hands-on experience to prepare for the workforce.
Students from Garden Prairie can attend Belvidere High School.
Students from Garden Prairie can attend Belvidere South Middle School.
Meehan Elementary School is amazing school for students from Garden Prairie.
1/3
Written By
Nicolas Stuart
Photography Contributed By
Andrew Perrius
Video By
Conar McDaniel
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Karen Streelman,
an experienced agent in this area.
On average, homes in Garden Prairie, IL sell after 4 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Garden Prairie, IL over the last 12 months is $211,000, up 122% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
LP/Propane tank, Harmon pellet stove, and wood-burning system. Includes stair lift, detached workshop, carport, and a full front porch—perfect for BBQs and relaxing outdoors. FULLY REMODELED KITCHEN featuring elegant quartz countertops, breakfast bar, and eat-in space-perfect for family living and entertaining. softener replaced in 2024. Two sump pump systems: one electric and one with battery
This versatile property is a rare find in Boone County, featuring multiple ideal locations for building your dream home. Imagine waking up to the beauty of nature right outside your window. As we venture into the timbered section, the southwest corner of the tillable field has transformed into a well-established food plot, complete with a natural screening area for privacy from the road. This
Escape to the peace and quiet of the countryside! This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home sits on a full acre and offers a perfect blend of charm, comfort, and opportunity. Step onto the full front porch and into a vaulted living room with a stunning two-story fieldstone fireplace. The open-concept layout flows into a FULLY REMODELED KITCHEN featuring elegant quartz countertops,
Welcome to a remarkable property in eastern Boone County, where opportunity and natural beauty converge. This stunning land boasts over 650 feet of road frontage along Lawrenceville Road, providing multiple access points for convenience and privacy. On the north side, you’ll find approximately 14 acres of tillable ground, available for open tenancy in 2025. This fertile land gently slopes to the
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
