$595,990Average Value$472Average Price per Sq Ft59Homes For Sale
Old world charm in McGinley Square
McGinley Square is close to urban areas like Journal Square and Downtown Jersey City, making it ideal for those who want to dip into the action. Megan Gülick, an associated licensed broker with Corcoran Sawyer Smith, puts it this way: “McGinley Square is the anchor of Jersey City.” But people seek out this neighborhood for its distinctly historic homes and sophisticated look, too. “It’s a place with old world charm, where you’ll see people walking to Lincoln Park,” says Tamayo Oppenheimer, Realtor with Silver and Oak Realty. “Some residential streets have a big reputation. People will tell me to call them about any homes on Bentley Avenue, regardless of price.” The neighborhood gets its name from Roger McGinley, the founding pastor and builder behind St. Aedan's Church. As one of the most notable pieces of local architecture, it resembles a fortress with large brick walls and a domed roof. Near the north side is Journal Square’s PATH train station, too, giving commuters an option that’s considered even more desirable than the local light rail stations.
Renovated rowhouses, colonials from the low $500,000s
"Some people move here because if you want to live around Jersey City in with a place with character, but you're priced out of downtown, McGinley Square is a really good alternative," Gülick says. It’s possible to find a one-bedroom condo in the low $300,000s. But the neighborhood is full of single-family homes, too, and that’s an appealing factor. “You’ll see a lot of prewar homes in McGinley Square,” says Oppenheimer. Renovated rowhouses are a common sight, and these can range anywhere from the low $500,000s up to $750,000. Despite these urban-forward housing styles, it’s also still possible to see homes that would fit right into a suburban setting. Colonial styles feature covered front porches, bay windows and yards of ivy that frame a narrow walkway. Prices for these four-bedroom properties can reach into the upper $800,000s.
Renovated rows of homes are a common sight in McGinley Square, Jersey City.
Colonials with charming covered front porches add character to the streets of McGinley Square.
1/2
Cafes and international cuisines
This community is filled with cafes, underscoring its old-world, pedestrian-friendly character. Blue Coffee serves single-origin brew in a chic space with marble floors and abundant natural lighting. Snapdragon Coffee & Social aims for more of a traditional coffee house with hardwood floors, exposed brick walls and plush couches to lounge on while eating a sandwich or bagel. Then there’s The Cottage Brunch & Espresso, which feels like a rustic market in the middle of Monticello Avenue: there’s a back patio, and the menu ranges from French toast to omelettes. For more cozy neighborhood institutions, places like Venti sell deli food in an intimate space. McGinley Square is also known for supporting a range of cuisines, including Dominican, Pakistani and Honduran. For a traditional supermarket that covers everything from produce to frozen food, 99 Ranch Market on the south side is a close option.
The Snapdragon Coffee and Social also hosts regular events that are a hit with Mcginley locals.
Discover delightful flavors and cozy ambiance at Cafe Alyce in McGinley Square, Jersey City.
1/2
Taco Tour, Mother's Day Market
McGinley Square plays host to various events through the year. There’s a Cinco De Mayo Taco Tour and a Mother’s Day Market in the spring, while October brings the Heart of the City Fall Festival. The Neighborhood Clean-Up event on Earth Day brings out residents, but so does the Live Music Series, held on Saturdays from June to October – musical genres range from pop to folk to jazz.
Magnet programs at Lincoln High
Julia Barnes Elementary covers kindergarten through eighth grade, and earns a C-plus rating from Niche. Lincoln High is known for magnet programs that cover many interests, from law to the culinary arts. The school earns a C-minus. Private school options include Hudson Catholic Regional High, which is co-ed, and Saint Dominic Academy, an all-girls Catholic school that covers seventh through 12th grade.
Lincoln High school earns an overall score of C- on Niche.
The Julia A. Barnes School is a public school situated in Jersey City.
1/2
Lincoln Park's walking paths
There are a few small green spaces in and around McGinley Square, ideal for a quick hit of relaxation, like Boyd-McGuiness Park, which features a playground, a Little Free Library, tables for chess and a splash pad. Bergen Hill Park feels more like a tree-lined haven, and frequently hosts public events, like yoga classes and movie nights. Lafayette Park on the south side is the neighborhood’s biggest park. It has a pair of playgrounds and a spiderweb of walking paths that lead to a central gazebo.
NJ Transit linking McGinley Square residents to seamless transportation options.
Pedestrians thrive, but commuters have Interstate 78
“McGinley Square is a neighborhood where you’re going to see a lot of foot traffic,” says Oppenheimer. Besides this pedestrian-friendly atmosphere, the neighborhood is also conducive to commuting. Interstate 78 on the south side helps drivers make the 5-mile trek into Manhattan in about half an hour. Bus lines are abundant here, too. Grand Street is a commercial corridor trafficked by buses, but other key paths are serviced as well, like Monticello Avenue, Summit Avenue and Montgomery Street.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in McGinley Square, Jersey City sell after 61 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in McGinley Square, Jersey City over the last 12 months is $420,000, down 9% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Just Listed! Discover the only newly renovated two-family home with just a 10-minute walk to the PATH, on one of Journal Square’s most sought-after streets. This 5-bedroom, 5-bathroom multifamily spans nearly 4,000 sq ft and features a 3 bed / 3 bath duplex for unit 1 and a 2 bed / 2 bath residence for unit 2 above - each thoughtfully redesigned with coffered ceilings, crown moldings, hardwood
Stunning Brownstone in Jersey City! Discover the charm of this beautifully renovated brownstone nestled in the vibrant community of the McGinley Square neighborhood of Jersey City. This property seamlessly blends classic architectural elegance with modern amenities, making it the ideal urban retreat. With timeless architectural details and thoughtfully updated interiors, this residence offers the
Linda BarbaProminent Properties Sotheby's International Realty-Englewood Cliffs
AWESOME LOCATION JOURNAL SQUARE 3BR 1 BATH 1260 SQUARE FT OF LIVING SPACE. COME SEE THIS GEM WITH PROGRESSION ALL AROUND. BRING YOUR VISION AND CREATE YOUR DREAM HOME OR AIR B AND B GREAT LOCATION BETWEEN WEST SIDE AND KENNEDY BLVD. DONT MISS THIS OPPORTUNITY. UPSCALE NEIGHHOOD WITH GREAT INCOME POTENTIAL.
Step into sophisticated city living at Gothic Tower, a pre-war gem walking distance to the Journal Square PATH Station. This expansive 1-bedroom, 1-bath residence offers nearly 1,000 sq ft of modern elegance wrapped in timeless charm.Inside, you'll find beautiful flooring, stunning Venetian plaster marble walls, and natural stone walls that add texture and warmth. A smart voice and phone-enabled
Next Level triplex Home meets Urban Luxury living in this Extraordinary 4 Bedroom 3 Bath custom curated designer House. Replete with expansive outdoor living spaces; a gardened blue stone Terrace & Balcony! Step into this Gallery style home boasting a Movie set quality w/ theatrical flourishes inside & out. Dripping in high end finishes; custom millwork, lavish white oak chevron flooring to
Versatile and full of charm, this Jersey City gem offers the ideal setup for multi-generational living, rental income, or a spacious single-family home. The ground-level 1BR 1 Bathroom suite has its own entrance and backyard access—perfect for guests or tenants. Upstairs, a bright and airy duplex features 2 full baths, multiple bedrooms (4) including a master ensuite. Enjoy a welcoming front
Welcome to the highly desirable Beacon Rialto building. This two-bedroom, two-bathroom condo offers thoughtfully designed living space. The kitchen is a chef's delight, featuring sleek black countertops, updated stainless steel appliances, and a island connects the kitchen to the spacious living and dining areas. Perfectly designed for entertaining, the open floor plan allows for distinct
This two-Bedroom, one-bath apartment located in the McGinley Square Section of Jersey City is now available for rent! It features stainless steel appliances, hardwood floors, washer & dryer inside the unit, and central A/C/ Heat.
Bergen Lafayette is the neighborhood to be a part of and Arlington Hill is the building you want to be in! Arlington Hill is a New, Modern, Luxury rental residence offering an upscale look, feel, and vibe all of its own. The warm, neutral tones and clean lines resonate throughout the building's common amenity rooms and individual residences. *Additional Floor Plan Available. The building
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
