$440,368Average Value$239Average Price per Sq Ft5Homes For Sale
Coveted location, low turnover
Parkside Heights popped up on the banks of Pheasant Branch Creek in the early 1960s. Today, the quiet suburb in central Middleton is highly sought-after for its location. Within five minutes of a vast nature conservancy and a plethora of outdoor recreation opportunities, as well as downtown Middleton, it’s certainly convenient. Peggy Adams, a Realtor with more than 10 years of local experience, attests that its location is part of the reason that turnover in this neighborhood is so low. “It’s got great access to outdoor amenities, but it’s equally close to shopping and dining and downtown. Middleton schools are also very good, so it’s got all the things people look for when they’re looking for a place to put down roots and settle long term,” says Adams, adding that those same amenities tend to increase each home’s resale value. “In general, home values in Middleton don’t decrease, they just increase. And here, a lot of these homes have only had one or two owners, so it’s amazing to see the difference between what a homeowner paid for their home in the ‘80s and what they sold it for last year. And it’s all because the location is so highly sought-after and houses going up for sale here are so rare,” she says.
Room to roam is what makes the Parkside Heights neighborhood in Middleton, Wi so popular.
Sandhill Cranes are known to frequent the Middleton Hills Soccer Field.
A two-story Colonial-style house is seen in the Parkside Heights neighborhood.
1/3
Parkside Heights living
The neatly spaced homes lining these shady residential streets were built mostly between the 1960s and ‘70s in styles ranging from classic brick ranches to larger Split Levels and traditional Colonial Revivals. Prices here run from $250,000 up to more than $550,000. “You can find houses on either side of the median here, which makes it a good neighborhood for a wider range of buyers,” says Adams, adding that the median price for a home in Middleton sits around the $470,000 mark. “Even the homes on the lower end of the scale are going to be well-maintained—it’s that kind of neighborhood—they might just need a few cosmetic updates, maybe modern fixtures and a coat of paint.”
A Cape-Cod/Colonial-style house is a common style in the Parkside Heights neighborhood.
Various split-level houses line the streets in the Parkside Heights neighborhood.
1/2
Highly rated Middleton-Cross Plains schools
Kids here go to schools in the highly sought-after Middleton-Cross Plains Area School District. The exact path they take during their grade school careers varies depending on address, so parents are advised to double-check the boundary maps ahead of registration. Many go to Elm Lawn Elementary between preschool and fourth grade, Kromrey Middle between fifth and eighth grade and Middleton High for ninth through 12th grade. In 2024, both Elm Lawn and Kromrey earned A grades from Niche. Middleton earned an A-plus that same year. Teens at Middleton High can participate in a wide range of extracurriculars, from Astronomy Club and Student Senate to Badminton Club and Woodworking.
This is the signage and exterior for Kromrey Middle School.
Parents in Middleton may send their teenagers to Middleton High School .
The main entrance to Elm Lawn Elementary School in Middleton.
1/3
Parks and preserved nature
Locals can get outside for some fresh air and exercise at Parkside Heights Park, conveniently located within half a mile of most homes. The pocket park spans the acre-and-a-half space between Northbrook Drive and Ravine Drive, offering everything from a classic playground and sandboxes with diggers to a basketball court and picnic areas. In the winter, there’s even an ice skating rink. Just half a mile south, residents can stretch their legs on the Pheasant Branch Trail, a two-lane paved trail that follows Pheasant Branch Creek. The Pheasant Branch Conservancy, a 160-acre nature preserve with miles of trails webbed through woodlands and prairies, is a short walk northwest up the trail.
Enjoy a long nature walk at Pheasant Branch Conservatory in Middleton Hills.
Playground equipment can be found at Parkside Heights Park in Madison, WI.
This is the signage for Parkside Heights Park in Madison, WI.
1/3
Convenient shopping and dining
Groceries and other everyday essentials are close at hand with the local Pick ‘n Save less than five minutes north across Century Avenue. The grocery store is near several eateries, a hair salon, healthcare offices and even a credit union, all clustered around the corner of Pheasant Branch Road and Frank Lloyd Wright Avenue. Grab lunch or dinner, or even weekend brunch, at Craftsman Table & Tap, on Frank Lloyd Wright Avenue across the corner from Pick ‘n Save. The cozy pub-like eatery has been known for its hearty food, including classic Wisconsin cheese curds, and craft beer since 2012. On Parkside Heights’ west side, at the corner of Parmenter Street and Donna Drive, residents can enjoy a sweet treat at Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream.
Grab a seat and order some cocktails at 1847 The Stamm House in Parkside Heights.
Parkside Heights
Locals do their grocery shopping at the Metro Market in Parkside Heights.
1/3
Fun in Middleton
On the first Saturday in August, locals from across Dane County flock to downtown Middleton for the annual National Mustard Day celebration, an outdoor food festival with hot dogs, brats and mustard sampling. There’s even live music and games with prizes. “It’s one of the biggest events in this area every year—and so fun, it’s a cool thing to do with the whole family,” says Adams. And the fun doesn’t stop when summer ends; Bockfest takes place each February at Capital Brewery, featuring live music, food trucks and flying fish.
Kids can enjoy the playground at Middleton Hills Park, while parents relax in the shade.
Parkside Heights locals check out some indoor fun at Greenway Station in Middleton, WI
1/2
Commuting from Parkside Heights to Madison is simple with the local Metro bus system.
Commuting from Middleton to Madison
It’s easy to get around town without a car with stops along the Metro Transit bus line close at hand along Parmenter Street and Century Avenue, two main thoroughfares surrounding Parkside Heights. Flying farther afield isn’t hard, either, with Dane County Regional Airport just 20 minutes northeast, around Lake Mendota. Heading to downtown Madison takes about the same amount of time, depending on traffic, heading southeast around lake Mendota instead.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Parkside Heights, Middleton sell after 38 days on the market compared to the national average of 52 days. The median sale price for homes in Parkside Heights, Middleton over the last 12 months is $434,000, up 8% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Roomy 4 bedroom (plus office/den) Middleton Home in a great location. Generous storage & walk-in closets with a touch of a mid-century feel. Well cared for and ready for your personal updates to make it your home. Completely fenced large back yard ready to enjoy. Garage could be 3 spots if you count the tandem spot. Basement Workshop. Just across the street from Parkside Heights Park & a short
Situated in a quiet, park like setting, this 2-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom condo is steps away from everything Middleton has to offer! A sunny, open concept first floor living space with a wood burning fireplace opens up to spacious kitchen and dining room with a private balcony overlooking green space. Upstairs you will find two spacious bedrooms with large closets and a full bathroom. Basement has
This Middleton gem is within walking distance to restaurants, parks, & Pheasant Branch Conservancy bike/walking path. Solid with "good bones." Built in 1966. Beautiful hardwood floors in the living room, hall and all 3 bedrooms need a sanding & varnish. Great closets and other storage space including crawl space under kitchen. Hard to find both a first floor gathering room with wood fireplace and
Welcome to life at the TROTTA, one of Middleton's newest community, where residents will enjoy our spaciously designed apartment homes and a friendly, small-town vibe. Our community of Affordable and Market Rate one, two, and three-bedroom apartments feature modern high-end amenities, and was designed to elevate your day-to-day experience. Find comfort, walkability, sociability, and convenience
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
