$193,880Average Value$142Average Price per Sq Ft1Home For Sale
Convenience is sacred in Sacred Heart
Sacred Heart is a quiet, residential enclave just south of the Fox River. The community’s home inventory dates back to the 1950s, predated by Sacred Heart School, an early 20th-century Catholic institution that serves as the neighborhood’s namesake. In addition to its historical suburban charm, the neighborhood is conveniently close to the Interstate 41 corridor a mile to the west, a significant asset for commuters. “It’s definitely a priority for the people who need it,” says Stephanie Brehmer, an Oshkosh native and Realtor with First Weber Realtors. “For anyone who works outside the city, the interstate is a feature that grabs their attention.” Walkable parks and nearby schools only contribute to Sacred Heart’s convenient setup. Big-box shops and common fast-food franchises are located off the interstate, but folks can also patronize a few locally owned cafes and shops in the neighborhood. With downtown 2 miles to the east, residents can easily travel across the various drawbridges to head to jobs or businesses on the other side of the Fox River.
A little free library signals neighborly spirit across Sacred Heart’s blocks.
Telephone poles line the residential streets of Sacred Heart, where midcentury homes vary in style from traditional architecture to bungalows. Out front, sidewalks and road verges sprout newly planted trees, part of an effort to expand the city’s Urban Tree Canopy and beautify the neighborhood. Beyond the rooftops, residents might catch a glimpse of the red brick steeple at Sacred Heart School or its neighbor, St. Jude the Apostle. Homes surrounding Knapp Street have a full view of the parish, which predates the community by nearly 30 years. Most feature detached garages with paved driveways and modest yards, ranging in price from $100,000 to $285,000—slightly below average in Oshkosh.
A traditional home in Sacred Heart shows tidy updates and a sunny front lawn.
Modest footprints and single‑story layouts suit everyday living here.
1/2
Walking to Stoegbauer Park
Stoegbauer Park is within walking distance of most homes, a community green space on Idaho Street featuring a playground, baseball field and basketball court. But those seeking a broader range of amenities can head to South Park, less than a mile down the street. “The park was recently renovated,” Brehmer says. “They added more water features and stocked the pond so it’s great for fishing. There are these beautiful walking trails and it's just a really nice place kind of in the middle of the south side.” These paved paths are woven throughout, connecting the ball courts, playground and pavilions to the fishing ponds at the park’s heart. Many fishermen, however, opt to cast out at William A. Steiger Park. Featuring two launch sites and a popular casting dock, Steiger has been a go-to fishing spot for years.
Waterfront views near Sacred Heart invite quiet afternoons and easy sunsets.
Playgrounds near Sacred Heart give kids room to run between games and picnics.
1/2
Public & private schooling in Oshkosh
Families are zoned for the Oshkosh Area School District, beginning at Franklin Elementary. Less than a mile west on 5th Avenue, Franklin earns a B-minus on Niche and provides onsite before- and after-school care through the Oshkosh YMCA. Perry Tipler Middle School shares a campus with the Advanced Learning Program (ALP) Charter School. Earning a B-minus, the school requires an application process for students enrolling in the fast-paced charter program. Oshkosh West High School earns a B-plus. The school’s swimming pool, three gymnasiums and auditorium accommodate extracurriculars, including athletics and music. Lourdes Academy is a B-plus-rated private, spiritual option enrolling grades K-12. The academy provides its own roster of athletic leagues, including a football team that plays at the J.J. Keller Field at Titan Stadium along the Fox River.
Franklin Elementary serves Sacred Heart families with before‑ and after‑care.
Schools near Sacred Heart feature updated facilities and easy drop‑off loops.
1/2
St. Jude the Apostle Parish & Sacred Heart School
St. Jude the Apostle Parish — a towering stone structure built in the early 20th century — sits on the corner of Knapp and 6th Street, a landmark in the community surrounding it. While the parish is expected to remain, its congregation has discussed demolishing the older building next door: Sacred Heart School. Though it’s been closed since the 1990s, Sacred Heart’s iconic red-brick steeple has anchored its titular neighborhood for decades. As of 2024, demolition dates have not yet been decided, nor has a final decision been made regarding the site’s future development.
St. Jude the Apostle Parish stands as a landmark near Sacred Heart.
Homes near the steeple enjoy a Sacred Heart backdrop of bells and brick.
1/2
Two miles from Interstate 41
Residents of Sacred Heart live just 2 miles east of I-41 — convenient for commuters heading north into the Fox Cities. “In Oshkosh, we don’t have a bypass that makes it convenient to jump interstates,” Brehmer says. “You’re either traveling through the city or hopping on 41.” As for reaching the downtown scene, residents can take one of four drawbridges to cross the Fox River. Most opt for the Bascule Bridge, which provides a straight shot to Main Street. “In the summer, you have to plan for extra commute time because it’ll take another 15 minutes to cross those bridges,” she continues. Residents can get around by bus using the GO Transit stops along the north and south end of the neighborhood on Witzel and 9th Avenues. Aurora Medical Center Oshkosh is about 3 miles north. Though Wittman Regional Airport is a mile south, most residents opt to fly out of Appleton International Airport, 22 miles north.
Big-box stops and walkable small businesses
Living within a couple miles of Interstate 41 means Sacred Heart residents are close to the thoroughfare’s offerings, including a Walmart Supercenter and Fleet Farm. Big-box shops like Aldi, Target and Pick ‘n Save are 2 miles south, neighboring casual eats and retailers like Petco and Goodwill. But coffee, donuts and sandwiches are within walking distance at Thunderbird Bakery & Café, a new addition to the intersection of 6th Avenue and Knapp Street. Originally a vendor at the Oshkosh Farmer’s Market, Thunderbird opened its first brick-and-mortar bake shop in 2023. Jeff’s on Rugby attracts happy hour regulars throughout the week, serving pub grub in the form of burgers and fresh fish sandwiches. “The owner is a fantastic chef,” Brehmer says. “It’s a great neighborhood restaurant that cares about the community with regular patrons and great reviews.”
An OfficeMax near Sacred Heart is a handy stop for school and home office supplies.
Walmart and other big‑box stores along I‑41 simplify weekly errands.
1/2
Front row seats to EAA AirVenture
Wittman Regional Airport is located a mile south of Sacred Heart, meaning residents get a front-row seat to the annual swarm of Experimental Aircraft Association AirVenture attendees. Considered the world's largest gathering of aviation enthusiasts, AirVenture features air shows, workshops and interactive displays held throughout the week — attracting around 750,000 people every year. “Our population triples during EAA,” says Eric Lichterman, a local Realtor with Century 21 Ace Realty. “I live on that side of town, so we get fighter jets flying over our house all day long. After about 30 rounds of flyovers, your windows start to rattle.” Less hectic is the Oshkosh Farmer’s Market, held every Saturday morning from June through October. There, guests peruse over 150 vendors selling local produce and handmade crafts on Main Street. During the off-season, the city hosts an indoor market at the Oshkosh Arena with around 30 weekly vendors.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Sacred Heart neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Sacred Heart Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Sacred Heart, Oshkosh sell after 51 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Sacred Heart, Oshkosh over the last 12 months is $224,000, up 29% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Back on market due to buyer financing Welcome to this charming 2-story home featuring 4 spacious bedrooms and 1 beautifully remodeled bathroom. With fresh cosmetic updates throughout, including new floor, paint and fixtures this home offers the perfect blend of classic character and modern comfort. Enjoy a bright and functional layout, a large kitchen ready for your personal touch, and a
S-Side Ranch style duplex has 1 bedroom & 1 bath per unit. Separate utilities paid by tenants. Concrete drive affords ample parking. Wall A/C units for cooling & central space heating for furnaces. Ranges & refrigerators included. Block foundation w/crawl space. Both units under long-term leases.
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
