$387,168Average Value$204Average Price per Sq Ft35Homes For Sale
Rural roots run deep in this growing enclave
In Sumterville, U.S. Route 301 tells the story of an evolving community. The main thoroughfare in this rural pocket of Sumter County, 301 used to be quieter — it could take five minutes for someone to see another car, says Leslie Strickland, a local realtor with Florida Realty Investments who grew up in this area. Now, though, traffic has increased so that it could take someone five minutes to be able to pull out onto 301, Strickland says. It’s a sign of the times. Sumterville, long known for its wide-open acreage, is now attracting more people and new construction, in part because of the burgeoning selection of close-by jobs.
“What actually drew people years ago is not the same thing that’s drawing people now,” Strickland says. “What’s drawing people now is trying to get out of the bigger urban areas. They’re trying to get more of the country life."
New homes are sprouting rapidly
There are still quite a few established homes around the Sumterville area, some of which date back to the mid-20th century and some that sit on several acres. But area growth, including the establishment of the 424-acre Governor Rick Scott Industrial Park, is drawing new residents. The park, open since 2020, is already home to several companies and is a key part of a larger economic corridor in the region that is expected to add a total of 20,000 jobs. One of the catalysts of the job growth is to support The Villages, a rapidly growing 55-and-up community nearby. “I think people are going to move there who work in The Villages,” says Robyn Cavallaro, a local Realtor with Florida Realty Investments. “The largest growing population are the over-55 communities. I know they’ve got a lot of things that they’re building over there.”
In turn, Sumterville is now home to a spate of new construction, welcoming the newcomers. Many of the available options here were built in the last several years and come with smaller lots, along sidewalk-lined suburban-style streets. As this community expands, listings are still available at relatively accessible prices — numbers often range between $200,000 and $500,000, though some of the bigger options with more acreage can creep up toward $800,000.
Sumter schools hit high marks
Kids in Sumterville can attend schools in the Sumter District Schools system, which carries an A-minus grade on Niche. Students can participate in a music program at the B-plus-rated Lake Panasoffkee Elementary that offers the opportunity to participate in the area’s all-county music concert and the all-state chorus. Many here can then progress to South Sumter Middle, a B-plus-rated school whose elective course options range from agriculture to business, before attending the B-rated South Sumter High, where there’s a dedicated agriscience academy. Sumterville also offers one of the Lake-Sumter State College’s campuses, on a 40-acre site where students can take classes toward associate degrees in things like business administration and computer science.
A spot right at the heart of Florida is a boon
This community is situated right at the heart of the state and, as rural as it still is, it’s conveniently close to the amenities of some of the surrounding areas. Strickland notes that people here can be in cities like Bushnell in a matter of just about 10 minutes, via Route 301. Route 301 is a connection to the myriad amenities of The Villages as well. Also, Sumter County Road 470 links people here with Interstate 75 for trips through the rest of the region.
Nearby communities come with much to offer
Sumterville residents can make the quick drive down to Bushnell to enjoy popular restaurants like Odd Cuples Cafe, which is a hit for breakfast. The Villages has a lot to offer in terms of restaurants as well, says Cavallaro, who lives there. That list includes a location of the chain Metro Diner, a spot whose chicken and waffles are beloved. Locals can also grab groceries and other essentials close by at spots like the Publix in The Village and the Walmart in Bushnell, both only about 8 miles away.
Enjoy outdoor time at the titular park
Sumterville has its own park at the center of the community, complete with a community center that features meeting rooms and a kitchen area. The park offers a playground and covered picnic area as well. Bushnell offers more conveniently close outdoor fun, including the 30-acre Kenny Dixon Sports Complex, full of multipurpose fields, baseball and softball diamonds, tennis courts and even a skate park.
Sumter County Fair is a long-running tradition
One of the stalwarts of the annual calendar in this area is the Sumter County Fair, which takes place over the course of more than a week in early March. The fair dates back to 1955. Strickland has fond memories of going to it as a kid, and it’s still a hit. The fair features everything from live music and comedy to a renowned livestock show.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Sumterville neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Sumterville Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Sumterville, FL sell after 57 days on the market compared to the national average of 55 days. The median sale price for homes in Sumterville, FL over the last 12 months is $274,888, up 1% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Lot 11! Welcome to classic Southern elegance of 12 Oaks Club and Lodge. A haven for guests, visitors and residents to experience and enjoy. Dappled sunlight plays on the long, tree-lined lane where more than 300 magnificent Spanish moss-draped live oak trees punctuate acres of parkland, preserved as a testament to resilience and an enduring love of nature. The winding drive transports you,
Lot 20! Welcome to classic Southern elegance of 12 Oaks Club and Lodge. A haven for guests, visitors and residents to experience and enjoy. Dappled sunlight plays on the long, tree-lined lane where more than 300 magnificent Spanish moss-draped live oak trees punctuate acres of parkland, preserved as a testament to resilience and an enduring love of nature. The winding drive transports you,
Lot 12! Welcome to classic Southern elegance of 12 Oaks Club and Lodge. A haven for guests, visitors and residents to experience and enjoy. Dappled sunlight plays on the long, tree-lined lane where more than 300 magnificent Spanish moss-draped live oak trees punctuate acres of parkland, preserved as a testament to resilience and an enduring love of nature. The winding drive transports you,
Experience the perfect blend of modern farmhouse living and country charm on this beautiful 11-acre property, ideally located just minutes from The Villages and The Villages Charter School. Built in 2019, this custom 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers quality finishes, an open-concept design, and endless possibilities for horse enthusiasts or anyone seeking room to roam.Inside, you’ll find
Virtually Staged. Built in 2023, this move-in ready home offers modern finishes and low-maintenance living. The open floor plan features granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a split-bedroom layout, and a whole-home water softener already installed. Located in a community close to I-75, making it an easy commute to The Villages, Ocala, Tampa, and Orlando. Shopping, restaurants, grocery
Seize this rare opportunity to acquire a prime parcel of vacant commercial land, ideally located near the signalized intersection of, Hwy 301 and Hwy 470, just minutes from the newly expanding town of Middleton, Florida – a vibrant part of The Villages community. This strategically positioned 5.5 acres sits between I-75 and the Florida Turnpike, offering exceptional accessibility and visibility
Under Construction. The Marshfield Plan is a 2-story home that seamlessly blends communal and private spaces, ideal for both entertaining and relaxing. The sleek kitchen showcases beautiful cabinetry, Quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances, including a smooth-top range, microwave hood, and dishwasher. The main floor includes a spacious bedroom, while the upper level features
Welcome to this beautiful 3/2 HOME built in 2025 located in Sumterville offering the perfect blend of modern peaceful country living. This Home sits on 4.8 acres with lots of privacy and plenty of yard that is Fenced. The Home is 3 bedroom, 2 Bathroom features a warm Farmhouse style. The Kitchen has quartz countertops, lots of cabinetry for storage. All appliances are stainless steel. Open
4 bed | 2 bath | 2-bay | 1818 sqft *Closing costs are additional and not included in the USDA 30 year fixed rate 100% financing. Terms and availability of this loan program, and the sales price, are examples only and are subject to change without notice. Loans are subject to credit approval. Restrictions and conditions may apply. USDA loans are subject to income and geographic eligibility
Under Construction. The Marshfield Plan is a 2-story home that seamlessly blends communal and private spaces, ideal for both entertaining and relaxing. The sleek kitchen showcases beautiful cabinetry, Quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances, including a smooth-top range, microwave hood, and dishwasher. The main floor includes a spacious bedroom, while the upper level features
A perfect 10! 10 acres in the city of Sumterville that is in Sumter County. This location is incredible and rare to find. Minutes from the new section of The Villages(A Beautiful retirement community), Middleton (A family oriented community), where the newest shopping, dining and recreation experiences are at. Also convenient to The Florida Turnpike and Interstate I-75. Commute to Tampa or
Better than Money in the Bank. A GREAT investment. Here's why... 301 is approved to be 4 lanes. There is a proposed Hwy 75 exit at 514 (Coleman landing overpass). 301 is being rerouted around Coleman and widened to 4 lanes. A huge area between 301 and Hwy 75 is industrial zoning and under development. Plus you have all the Villages housing. Higher traffic count equals higher land
Built in 2025 and thoughtfully improved, this Ryan Homes Willow offers the space and flexibility buyers are looking for. The main level features an open kitchen, dining area and great room, plus an enclosed flex room that works beautifully as a private office, guest room or potential fifth bedroom. Upstairs, you’ll find four bedrooms, two full baths, a separate loft and conveniently located
Virtually Staged. Welcome to this beautiful 2024-built two-story home in Sumterville! Freshly painted throughout the interior, this newer residence offers a clean, modern feel and a wonderful opportunity to enjoy comfortable living with the benefits of a recently constructed home. The spacious two-story layout provides excellent separation between living spaces and bedrooms, making it ideal for
Brand-new construction home available for rent! This beautiful property has never been occupied and offers a fresh, modern living experience with all-new finishes, appliances, and systems. Enjoy the comfort and peace of mind that comes with being the first resident in a pristine home.Located in a desirable neighborhood, residents benefit from a quiet, well-maintained community with convenient
Local Logic measures the walkability, access to public transit and bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
