$511,927Average Value$221Average Price per Sq Ft1Home For Sale
Historic homes surround pretty Lake Ella
Lake Ella is traditionally known for its stately historic homes, but newer homes have been popping up as the location grows in popularity. “Homes here are in high demand because people can walk down the street to charming boutiques and local restaurants in Midtown,” says Jennifer Patty, Realtor for 29 years in Tallahassee with Bestsellers Realty. Residential streets hug the community’s namesake, Lake Ella, where residents come for a stroll or wildlife watching. Some historic Colonial Revivals and Victorian mansions still stand, giving the neighborhood its charm, with an assist from its palm trees and whimsically twisted live oaks draped with Spanish moss. The highly regarded Leon County Schools, rated A-minus by Niche, are also a draw.
Lake Ella is largely formed around the beautiful serene lake its named after.
Enjoy the beauty of nature at Lake Ella.
1/2
Restaurants and shops are a short walk away in Midtown
Most homes are just a block or two from shops and eateries at Lake Ella. “The cottages at Lake Ella have been around 100 years, and they’re now locally owned businesses,” says Barbara McGarrah, the founder of Barb’s Brittles, a confectionery and ice cream shop in one of the historic cottages. These stone buildings were originally part of a motor court with roots dating to the late 1920s. The neighborhood is also an easy walk from a bustling corridor of shops and restaurants. “The homes here are lovely, but people really come here because there’s so much activity nearby,” says Patty. Outdoor dining is popular, and locals chat over java at Lucky Goat Coffee Company and share craft brews and specialty cocktails at Liberty Bar & Restaurant. Table 23, a 1920s house converted into a restaurant, has a spacious porch where diners enjoy modern southern fare under shady live oaks. For groceries, Publix and Whole Foods are within walking distance.
Barb's Southern Gourmet Brittle & Ice Cream is a local favorite for delicious sweet treats.
The Cottages At Lake Ella has great local shops to shop from.
Lucky Dog Cafe is close to Lake Ella and is a local favorite for artisan coffee.
1/3
Star Metro busses provide transportation throughout the Tallahassee area.
StarMetro buses stop at numerous places in Midtown
The neighborhood is pedestrian friendly, but it’s easy to travel to various points around the city by catching a StarMetro bus at multiple stops in Midtown. Tallahassee International Airport is 9 miles away.
Tallahassee celebrates spring over the course of a weekend
Springtime Tallahassee is a weekend festival in late March that celebrates the city. The event begins with a music festival followed by Jubilee in the Park, an all-day event with local food vendors, artists and live music performances at the nearby Downtown Chain of Parks. All of these events lead up to the Grand Parade, one of the largest parades in the Southeast. Spectators fill the streets to see more than 100 brightly decorated floats and high-stepping marching bands trumpeting through the city.
Improv musicians are a regular event at Lake Ella.
Lake Ella has some of the most gorgeous scenic views in Tallahassee.
1/2
The park at Lake Ella has a walking trail and cottage shops
A paved trail loops around Lake Ella for almost one mile, passing benches and resident ducks. Flanked by a gazebo, mossy live oaks and abundant greenery, it's a pretty place to stroll. “People love to exercise, to bring families out to feed the ducks and patronize the cottages,” says McGarrah. “It’s a wonderful place to come out and relax.” It's also a good place to sample a new ice cream flavor – McGarrah’s chocolate sunflower brittle ice cream was named the best ice cream in Florida by the Food Network in 2021. With its lush grassy spaces under the shade of even more large live oaks, Los Robles Park is another pleasant place to unwind.
Walk along the paved sidewalks around Lake Ella and enjoy the beauty of Tallahassee.
Outdoor seating at Leon's at Lake Ella is great for enjoying amazing food and great weather.
1/2
Cottages, Colonial Revivals and historic mansions populate this walkable neighborhood
Swaying palms, shady live oaks and lush lawns hug Lake Ella’s highly walkable streets, giving the community a laid-back atmosphere. “Prices have risen with the location's popularity, but homes can be found for a wide range of budgets,” says Patty. Newer two-bedroom duplexes start at $255,000, but single-family homes can start at $300,000, including a three-bedroom cottage with a large hedge-lined lawn. Homebuyers can also find a two-bedroom Colonial Revival with a two-story porch and a trellis-covered patio. Historic mansions are on the higher end of the price range, like a million-dollar six-bedroom Tudor estate with a wrap-around driveway and fine carpentry details. Other million-dollar historic mansions with Victorian or Southern Colonial architecture add to the historic Tallahassee aesthetic.
Traditional modern colonial homes can be found in Lake Ella.
Lake Ella offers residents cozy brick style homes close to nature.
Lake Ella has 1930's tudar style homes that have a lot of character.
1/3
Leon High School receives an A grade from Niche
Students in the neighborhood are only a mile from elementary, middle and high schools that are a part of the highly touted Leon County Schools, given an A-minus by Niche. Some neighborhood students will enroll at Ruediger Elementary, graded a C-plus, and continue at Augusta Raa Middle School, rated a B. They round out their academic journey at the outstanding Leon High School, which receives an A. Florida State University football may own Saturdays in Tallahassee, but on Fall Fridays, the community comes out to cheer the Leon Lions.
Kate Sullivan Elementary School has a B+ on Niche.
Augusta Raa Middle School is a great school to enroll your child while living in Tallahassee.
Leon High School has an excellent score of A on Niche.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
Are you familiar with the Lake Ella neighborhood?
to let others know what life in this neighborhood is like.
Crime and Safety
1 - Low Crime, 10 - High Crime
Lake Ella
US
Homicide
3
4
Sexual Assault
4
4
Assault with Weapon
4
4
Robbery
4
4
Burglary
7
4
Motor Vehicle Theft
6
4
Larceny
5
4
Crime Score
4
4
Source: WhatIsMyCrimeRisk.com
Lake Ella Demographics and Home Trends
On average, homes in Lake Ella, Tallahassee sell after 66 days on the market compared to the national average of 53 days. The median sale price for homes in Lake Ella, Tallahassee over the last 12 months is $475,000, up 9% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
Beautifully constructed 2700+ square foot building conveniently located on 5th Ave in the heart of Midtown. Walk to shops, restaurants, night-life and more. This building is currently acting as a commercial office but could be easily converted to a wonderful home. Whether you want a central office space or a home in the hottest part of town, this is your opportunity. Hardwood floors throughout,
Property Id: 1290185AVAILABLE 12/15/25 for monthly rentalTHIS IS A MID TERM RENTAL- UTILITIES/WiFi/FURNITURE INCLUDED!Lakefront townhouse in popular Midtown, 5 mins to downtown & the Capitol, 10 mins to FSU & FAMU. Walk to a huge selection of restaurants & beautiful Lake Ella with a .6 mile paved path in the park across the street. Offers you a mini vacation as you work
Centrally located property next to all the desirable offerings of Midtown. A two-bedroom, one-bathroom unit with original refinished hardwood floors and upgraded LVP flooring throughout is available for rent. Property features include off-street parking, fresh paint throughout, and in-unit laundry.
Incredible opportunity in historic Los Robles with fantastic location. This apartment building consists of a shared two story private foyer with unit #1 downstairs and unit #2 upstairs. This listing is for unit # 2- upstairs. The entire building has been completely redone & updated to keep the charm while adding in all the modern conveniences. All new exterior & interior paint. Real hardwood
Sound Score® measures the noise level of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
