$885,378Average Value$560Average Price per Sq Ft77Homes For Sale
A destination barrier island community
Treasure Island appeals to Floridians seeking an old-school beach vibe without sacrificing the modern comforts of the mainland. With the Gulf of Mexico on one side and Boca Ciega Bay on the other, this barrier island — though small — packs plenty into its 3 square miles. There are a surprising number of parks, a lively downtown district with restaurants and bars and a year-round events schedule. It's also just 3 miles from the mainland and about 8 miles from Downtown St. Pete. But the island's main appeal is its wide, white-sand beaches, a short stroll from the many low- and high-rise condo buildings and brightly colored bungalows. "Everything is within a mile of the beach — that's the furthest away you'd be," says Realtor Bruce Erbeck of Re/Max Metro, who has been selling homes since 1995. "That aspect alone kind of brings everybody together at the beach for sunset hour."
Treasure Island residents enjoy waterfront living.
Treasure Island is surrounded by water making it so many homes have waterfront views in Florida.
1/2
Nationally ranked beaches with continuous sea breeze
Though the island is compact, it offers a wide variety of outdoor recreation, including boating, fishing and stand-up paddleboarding — even a 9-hole public golf course manages to squeeze into the Paradise Island neighborhood. But the top-rated beaches are the real draw, whether it's Treasure Island Beach or the less-touristy Sunset Beach on the island's south end. "The beaches are ranked consistently in the top 5 nationally," Erbeck says. "And there's a constant breeze that feels like being in Aruba." Roselli Park is a popular gathering spot in the Isle of Capri neighborhood, with dog park meetups, tennis matches, ball games and shuffleboard showdowns. The centrally located Treasure Island Community Center Park is where many events take place, such as a Friday morning flea market, and it's also a common place for workouts thanks to its outdoor calisthenic exercise equipment.
The beaches in Treasure Island stretch for as far as the eye can see.
Treasure Island neighborhood has miles of beautiful beaches for you take in on a daily basis.
1/2
Old Florida designs blend with modern upgrades
Treasure Island is its own city, distinct from St. Petersburg. It's made up of five areas; some are fingers of waterfront property that were dredged after World War II. Many of the houses on the island were built in this period and back right up to the water, but there are new construction homes as well as contemporary condos. Prices vary dramatically, with smaller bungalows and cottages selling from the mid-$400,000s to $750,000. Midcentury ranch-style homes are priced from around $750,000 to $2 million, while newer, larger houses start at $2 million and can soar to over $5 million if they're set near the beach or on the bay. "With waterfront property, they're not making any more of it," Erbeck says. "It's not the houses that are driving the prices, it's the desirability of being on the water rather than being in a house that's more inland." Condos offer the widest price range, with studios starting at around $200,000 and going into the low millions for larger beachfront units.
Many homes in the Treasure Island neighborhood are waterfront with private docks in Florida.
Beautiful homes with private pools are common in Treasure Island neighborhood in Florida.
1/2
Block parties and master sand sculpting competitions
The island plays host to events year-round. Most prominent is the Sanding Ovations Master's Cup, an international sand sculpting competition taking place in November. In April, the community gathers at Treasure Island Community Center Park for Treasure the Island, an Earth Day celebration promoting an appreciation for the island's community and natural surroundings. But the high watermark of fun happens in mid-spring, when the community converges on 107th Avenue for Rock Around the Clock, an annual block party featuring live music and food vendors. "They close that block down for a weekend and it's a really good time for everybody to come together and have a little party," Erbeck says.
The Treasure Island clock tower is home to the “Rock Around the Clock" event once a year.
Treasure Island Community Park is home to the famous pirate statue.
1/2
Beach bars and local restaurants line Gulf Boulevard
Treasure Island is a popular vacation destination, and its main thoroughfare, Gulf Boulevard, is lined with resorts and hotels, restaurants, beach bars and seasonal snack shacks. During peak tourism months, getting a table at Middle Grounds Grill can be tough, especially when the fresh-caught tuna is in, so reservations are recommended. Boaters can dock at Sea Dog Brewing Company for a cold beer and a lobster roll. Beachfront bars include Caddy's Treasure Island, which also serves breakfast. For everyday essentials, there's a Publix and Walgreen's on the island.
Sea Dog Brewing Company in Treasure Island has indoor and outdoor dining.
Middle Ground is a lovely restaurant in the heart of Treasure Island open in the evenings.
1/2
Causeways, golf carts and bus routes
Residents have more choices than just the Treasure Island Causeway to get on and off the island. Drivers can head north or south to adjacent barrier island communities with causeways of their own that provide mainland connections. But with Gulf Boulevard being the island's only throughway, traffic jams can be frequent in all directions. There are bus stops along the boulevard, but according to Erbeck, most residents either walk or rely on golf carts to get around the island.
Treasure Island causeway will help you get to the mainland & to downtown Saint Petersburg.
Many public bus & trolley stations are in Treasure Island making it easy for you to get around.
1/2
College and career prep at Boca Ciega High
Public school students travel to the mainland to attend school. Azalea Elementary has a Niche score of B and Azalea Middle School has a score of C. The A-minus-rated Boca Ciega High offers multiple ways for students to plan their next steps, whether through dual enrollment credits with local colleges or with the school's College and Career Center.
Boca Ciega High School is an option for Treasure Island's older students.
Azalea Middle School welcomes students in Treasure Island, FL.
1/2
Traffic surges during tourist season
One of the most difficult aspects of living on the island is the congestion and noise during tourist season, typically in winter and early spring. Traffic jams are most common at major intersections, especially where 107th Avenue meets Gulf Boulevard. High water and storm surges caused by hurricanes can also be a threat to islanders. Some waterfront homes on Treasure Island are built to be elevated a few feet off the ground.
Treasure Island is a vacation destination for many because it's filled with everything you need.
Treasure Island causeway is the main road onto the island from the mainland.
1/2
Written By
Tom Jakob
Video By
Jacob Cardwell
Interested in learning more about homes in this area?
Reach out to
Jannette Pena,
an experienced agent in this area.
GreatSchools:
The GreatSchools Rating helps parents compare schools within a state based on a variety of school quality indicators and provides a helpful picture of how effectively each school serves all of its students. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average) and can include test scores, college readiness, academic progress, advanced courses, equity, discipline and attendance data. We also advise parents to visit schools, consider other information on school performance and programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process.
View GreatSchools Rating Methodology
On average, homes in Treasure Island, FL sell after 81 days on the market compared to the national average of 50 days. The median sale price for homes in Treasure Island, FL over the last 12 months is $730,000, down 4% from the median home sale price over the previous 12 months.
RARE 2-BEDROOM OPPORTUNITY IN SUNSET COVE - NO FLOODING OR STORM DAMAGE! Don’t miss your chance to own one of the few 2-bedroom condos in the sought-after Sunset Cove community on gorgeous Sunset Beach—celebrated for its pristine sand and laid-back Florida charm! This fully furnished unit is move-in ready with updated kitchen and bath finishes and newer furniture. Whether you're looking for a
Exceptional Waterfront Retreat with Every Upgrade Imaginable — Treasure Island. This is one you must see in person to fully appreciate. From the moment you arrive, you’ll sense the care and craftsmanship that have gone into every inch of this extraordinary waterfront home. Rarely does a property come to market with such meticulous attention to detail—inside and out. This home gleams and shines
MOTIVATED SELLER!!! Discover the epitome of coastal living with this exceptional 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom townhome nestled in the hidden gem community of The Village of Paradise Island – Phase III. Built for durability and peace of mind, this phase stands out with superior cinder block construction extending from the first-floor slab to the third-floor roof—an upgrade from traditional wood-frame
RARE 2-BEDROOM OPPORTUNITY IN SUNSET COVE - NO FLOODING OR STORM DAMAGE! Don’t miss your chance to own one of the few 2-bedroom condos in the sought-after Sunset Cove community on gorgeous Sunset Beach—celebrated for its pristine sand and laid-back Florida charm! This fully furnished unit is move-in ready with updated kitchen and bath finishes and newer furniture. Whether you're looking for a
Direct Gulf-Front 3BR/3BA NW Corner Unit – Treasure Sands, Treasure IslandRare opportunity to own a spacious northwest corner unit in the highly desirable Treasure Sands Condominium, located directly on one of the widest beaches on Florida’s Gulf Coast. This 10th-floor unit offers 1,790 total sq/ft with 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and 2 private balconies with unobstructed Gulf
BEST VALUE DIRECTLY ON THE GULF! Welcome to the ultimate beach escape—a sprawling 1,650 sq/ft SW corner unit perched on the 10th floor of Treasure Sands, offering unmatched panoramic Gulf views from not one, but TWO private balconies. This is your chance to own one of the largest direct beachfront condos on Treasure Island—and it’s move-in ready!Light, bright, and breezy, this
Modern Coastal Living home for rent in the highly desirable Isle of Capri neighborhood in Treasure Island, FL! This beautifully updated single-family modern-style home offers the perfect blend of comfort, elegance, and beachside living. Property Features: 3 spacious bedrooms with oversized closets 2 fully renovated, sleek bathrooms with glass shower doors and modern vanities Bright, open kitchen
Recently renovated.This 1 bedroom /1 bathroom is a real One of a kind Paradise.Free designated parking by the unit. The Lobby offers an additional private and secure entrance to the apartment , access to the condo can also be obtained via patio doors. Remodeled interior , new water heater , new vanity with back lit mirror and bathtub rain shower, new whirlpool high tech microwave ,dishwasher,
AVAILABLE SEPTEMBER thru JANUARY ONLY!!!!! Welcome to your slice of paradise on Treasure Island! This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom single-family POOL HOME offers the quintessential Florida lifestyle, perfectly situated just two blocks from the pristine white sands of Treasure Island Beach. Step inside this inviting 1,000 sq ft residence and discover a comfortable and functional layout. The home
Walk Score® measures the walkability of any address. Transit Score® measures access to public transit. Bike Score® measures the bikeability of any address. CAP Index provides objective, accurate, and consistent data to help measure, compare, and mitigate crime risks.
Disclaimer: Certain information contained herein is derived from information provided by parties other than Homes.com. Our sources include: Accuweather, Public Records and Neustar. All information provided is deemed reliable, but is not guaranteed to be accurate and should be independently verified.
